Dear Bruto, I hope you are not one to lack in magnanimity unlike pusillanimous souls here who would swoon in fits of anger at the mention of brain peculiarity on their part.
You say about my description of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything:
The problem with your definition is not that it is impossible. It is that it is incomplete. I do not think you have considered just what a definition is. A definition defines, and in so doing, it does not only state what it applies to, but what it does not apply to. It is in that latter area that your definition falls short.
Let's attend to this particular text from you:
"A definition defines, and in so doing, it does not only state what it applies to, but what it does not apply to. It is in that latter area that your definition falls short."
To be diplomatic I will just say that you have a peculiar idea that dictionaries have the job of restricting people from applying a word to objects they don't include in their definitions.
I for my own part definitely maintain something altogether distinctly different from your idea of the job of dictionaries, namely, that if they do at least imply what objects their definitions apply to, they don't in effect restrict their definitions to only those objects.
I will just seriously suggest to you to think: whether your employment of dictionaries in that respect is doing yourself a service or a disservice, and giving credit to the authors of dictionaries.
Yrreg
*See my post
here, in a past thread.
Nobby nobs has said it more artfully that I can, perhaps, but I will just say that you are quite wrong about what you presume I believe about dictionaries. Dictionaries help us to understand the meaning of words as we use them in discourse with each other. It is thus that we can make sure that when we use a word it accomplishes the job of clear communication. If we define a word in our own peculiar way, communication is impeded.
Let me see if I can try once more to express what I mean as if I were speaking to someone who cares about meaning and has a willingness to understand something other than what he already thinks (I realize it's a long shot, but here goes....)
Let us define God, in a way that is incontrovertible, if there is a god at all.
I define God as "something creative"
Now if there is a god at all, this statement is entirely true, and cannot be denied.
But is it a good definition? I don't think so. I think it is a very stupid definition.
Why is it a stupid definition? Because it does not DEFINE. It omits what we need to know to distinguish the thing we are speaking of from other things that are not it.
I could define a dog as "an animal," and would be 100 percent correct, yet the definition would be a bad one, worthless in fact, because other things that are not dogs are animals too.
You see, a statement, even if it is true, is not necessarily a good definition if it does not establish some difference between what it refers to and what it does not.
Now let us look at the definition of god as the creator of everything (including heaven and earth, in case we cannot comprehend what the word "everything" might include). Is that a good definition? Does it distinguish the god belonging to one faith from the god belonging to others? Does it impute any actual characteristics, properties, or attributes to the god in question? It does not. Does it exclude possible forces other than those generally reckoned to be divine? It does not.
So, if you define God as you have, you have perhaps defined the concept of "first cause," which in most theologies is one of the several attributes of God, just as being an animal is one of the several attributes of a dog. You have not, however, come up with a very good definition of God.
And I continue to wonder why you bother with this discussion, since if you chose, you could almost certainly provide a better and fuller definition, or reference one, which would resolve much of this debate even if it did not convince anyone that the god in question actually exists.