What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

That is why it is so frustrating to talk to you guys, because you really don't have any ideas that are relevant except to gripe against Christians.


I am just treating your claims about your God as equally valid as clams about any other god. Until you provide compelling reasons for considering your God to be more valid than any other god we have no reason to consider it to be so.

This is not "griping against Christians"; it is just treating their claims in the same way as the claims of other religions.
 
I still maintain that all atheists' arguments against God must first specify which God they are arguing against...


Yes, but that's either because you are unable to understand that atheists don't believe in any god, or because your argument is dishonest. Your God is not special.
 
Just the same so that you will go forth in life for your remaining years wiser, read now carefully what I am going to say for your benefit.

An elderly couple was crossing the street and a reckless driver hit the man and knocked him down on the road showing no movement, bystanders thought that he was dead; one of them noticed his lips moving very slightly, so he leaned close to the man's face and heard the man saying very weakly, "I am alive."

This man told everyone that the victim is alive, but right away the woman as usual in her habit of contradicting her husband insisted to the audience of bystanders: "Don't take him seriously, ask me."​


Not a very good analogy, but you get the idea or you don't?


Yes, I get the idea: like the old woman in your story you are asking us to ingnore the issues of evidence and rational thought, and you are therefore expecting us to take your word for it that the Christian concept of God is the "correct" one.
 
Thanks for responding, yrreg. Sorry for my delay. I'm visiting relatives out of town and just noticed this post.

[ To read the spoiler, click on the boxed words, Spoiler:Show. ]
CGCF-CU stands for the concept of God in the Christian faith
in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
He is the creator of the universe.​






----------------


First, we have to work on us two concurring on the concepts of universe and of God.

What do you say? namely, whether we have to first work together to come to concurrence on the concept of unverse and of God?

Since God is your term here, I'll let you choose the definition.

I must apologize for missing your post, because I did not read further on after GM whom I invited to tell me what is his information on the CGCF-CU: as I said I am tired of the same people with the same things but not ever daring to examine the CGCF-CU.

Yes, I love to exchange thoughts with you.

So, shall we first work together to come to concurrence on the concept of universe as also of God?

Again, it's your argument, so I'll go with your definitions.

But I fear that eventually you will leave me or take back your words by which we have come to concurrence on some thought.

At this point you will take to irrelevancies and flippancies and bring in penis, masturbation, and spaghetti, unicorn, and sky daddy, etc.

And keep hollering there is no evidence, but you will never either come to concurrence with me (from our common efforts) on what is evidence, what is the target of evidence, and how evidence operates.

Can we agree to have a friendly discussion based on the arguments and evidence, and stay away from personal attacks or questioning each other's integrity? For my part, I have already promised to be fair and reasonable.

However, I don't and can't promise to agree with you. We may end up respectfully disagreeing. But I'm sure we can find some common ground.

No need to argue with me about your eventually running away, and I hope you don't and thus will show yourself to be exceptional for an atheist.

To repeat my question from another post, do I have to claim to be an atheist, or is it enough to say that I am skeptical about supernatural claims?

So, who is going to be first to give his concept of universe and of God, you or I?

Since I am sure God exists I have to present my concept of God, and it is the following:
God is the uncreated creator of the universe.​

Now, since I also know that the universe exists and I am part of the universe and I exist, my concept of the universe is the following:
The universe is the totality of created existence.​

Now, please keep in mind that those are my concepts of universe and of God, let me see what you have and we can work on to come to concurrence on our concepts of universe and of God.



Yrreg

Again, since they are your terms for making your argument, I will let you define what you mean when you use them.

God: uncreated creator of the universe.
universe: the totality of created existence.

Accepting your definitions for the sake of argument*, where does the expedition go from here?


* For my part, I would leave the word "created" out of the definition of universe because it makes assumptions that I don't find in evidence. I know the universe exists, but that knowledge doesn't tell me whether it was created or whether it always existed.
 
How do you know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God"?


Actually, yrreg, I think I understand why you find this question so disturbing.

You have admitted that the only reason you believe in the Christian God rather than any other gods is that you were born into a society in which the infantile fantasies of the Bible are given precedence over those of any other religion:

Tell me how many people today believe in Odin?

Did I say that I reject Odin?

I said that there is no relevancy to discussing Odin today in 2008 c.e.

It's like this. Odin was good enough for some people, Norsemen, in the distant past; it's the name of their God.

If I were to be transfered to their time and clime and I am a Norseman, I would also believe in Odin for a God.


Your God is nothing more than a social construct.

You have no reason for believing in your God other than that it is what you were told to do, and you therefore have no rational answer to my question.
 
On evidence, I have already said it nth times, evidence is any fact man knows leading him to know another fact.

Yes, you have. Even though it's been shown to be wrong, you refuse to move from your illogical position. This is why it's pointless trying to have any kind of reasonable discussion with you. It's the same with all of your preaching.
 
You see, you can't even read correctly, I am inviting you to put forth a question.

But you guys are just full of tripe slogans, like no evidence, burden of proof, who created God, if God created everything, can God make a rock so huge He cannot carry it, Hawking said the universe could and did come from nothing because of the M-theory or the laws of physics, and on and on and on, all showing the most gross ignorance cultivated owing to self-atrophy-ation of brain cells.

You know about a priori knowledge?

It is to the brain what is reflex action to the eye.

When the eye senses something coming toward it, it will start a chain reaction by which it closes the eyelids and the organism with eyes will duck its head.

So also with the brain, when it senses a thought coming to it like that the universe comes from nothing, if it is not already anesthetized by the human subject himself on his self-conditioning, it the brain will right away notice something is askew with that kind of a communication from a fellow human.
Askew, yes. Your communications are
Such is the condition of atheists' brain, self-anesthetized as to become self-bereft of a priori knowledge.



Yrreg

The brain has no a priori knowledge. It is all learned.
 
Thanks everyone for your participation.

I apologize for the harsh words.


Now, I wish for someone to exchange thoughts with -- carefully and relevantlly, and I will wait for Rougarou because he is new here and wants to talk with me starting from both our parts as from a tabula rasa.

He wants to talk about the three questions from me:

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?
We don't know.
He has many questions for me to answer, but I suggest that we first work to concur on what is or should be our concurred on concepts of universe and also of God.



Yrreg

We don't know.
 
Well, let us ask the people who know Brahma, what or who is Brahma.

Wait for me, I will seek fast information in the net.

Here, I found a definition from an instant net dictionary:




Sounds familiar like what I have for my concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely:
God is the uncreated creator of the universe.​


A name without the concept does not convey anything except that for curious people we want to know what the users the name understand by it, so that once we understand the concept represented by the name, we can launch into an expedition to locate the entity or thing represented by the concept which is signified by the name or broadly the word.


So, where do we go from here?

What about seeking to find Brahma or God starting with ourselves which are the nearest things accessible to our search and examination for the existence of God?



Yrreg
We don't know, nor can we know.
 
I still maintain that all atheists' arguments against God must first specify which God they are arguing against, otherwise you atheists are shooting in the dark, and that is very irrational.
You're a Christian so I'll ask you. What is your definition of your god(s) and what are all of its properties? Once we know its properties, we will be able to have a discussion about whether it is real or just imaginary.

Now, if you are arguing against God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, then you have to get it from Christian documents on what is God; and you are not doing yourselves any cognitive credit by bringing in so many gods, goddesses, deities, divinities, etc,, and specially bringing in your passion to denigrate by calling God spaghetti, unicorn, fairy, whatever: that will satisfy your hatred but not your passion for cognition that is not contaminated by hatred.
Why do you continue to bring in the Christian god? Why do you show your hatred of The Flying Spaghetti Monster so vehemently? Is your mind so contaminated by illogic that you are blind to the truth of The Flying Spaghetti Monster?

And that is why you always eschew coming to the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely, as the uncreated creator of the universe.
Evidence for your uncreated creator of the universe? We're still waiting.

<snipped gibberish and insanity>



Yrreg

yrreG, you're showing your hatred for evidence when you don't present any. Don't run away and don't lie about it. Just show evidence that there is an uncreated creator of the universe that isn't The Flying Spaghetti Monster which was destroyed at the instant of creation of the universe.
 
Have the believers yet proven this god of theirs or this heaven of theirs.

NO.

So until that is done, everything else is mute on the subject.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
But you guys are just full of tripe slogans, like no evidence, burden of proof, who created God, if God created everything, can God make a rock so huge He cannot carry it, Hawking said the universe could and did come from nothing because of the M-theory or the laws of physics, and on and on and on, all showing the most gross ignorance cultivated owing to self-atrophy-ation of brain cells.

Yrreg


So according to you, Stephen Hawking is "grossly ignorant"?

And in particular, you are saying Hawking is "grossly ignorant" on M-Theory and Big Bang models?

Hawking is ignorant about science? And in contrast you are so much more knowledgeable about M-Theory and Big Bang cosmology, that you can call Hawking "grossly ignorant"?

Do you know how ridiculously silly that makes you sound?

Going back to page one and your definition of God - someone pointed out to you right from the start, that ordinary dictionaries usually give a definition of God.

But unlike your attempted definition, that dictionary definition included the caution of noting that this "God" was only a proposed "creator of the universe". Your definition entirely omitted the fact that your God is not actually known to exist (indeed a God like that would break all known laws of science), but is in fact only a figure arising from peoples ancient un-evidenced beliefs in the supernatural.

You need to change your definition to include a sentence making clear that the God is only a figure believed by some to exist.
 
Last edited:
I still maintain that all atheists' arguments against God must first specify which God they are arguing against, otherwise you atheists are shooting in the dark, and that is very irrational.
As usual you are completely wrong. Neither you no any other god botherer have shown any evidence or reason to suppose your, or any other, god exists.

Now, if you are arguing against God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, then you have to get it from Christian documents on what is God; and you are not doing yourselves any cognitive credit by bringing in so many gods, goddesses, deities, divinities, etc,, and specially bringing in your passion to denigrate by calling God spaghetti, unicorn, fairy, whatever:
Utterly wrong. Again.

that will satisfy your hatred but not your passion for cognition that is not contaminated by hatred.
Wow............
Pot%2520meet%2520kettle.gif


And that is why you always eschew coming to the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely, as the uncreated creator of the universe.
Start with showing this god of yours actually exists. Stop dodging and evading your responsibility to support your arguments with facts and evidence. Hell even a consistent xian concept of their god would be a start......

There is a very good opening to topple this concept, namely, by showing it is impossible to conceive, therefore it is an invalid concept.
The FSM is very sad for what your'e doing to logic there.
fsm_frown1.gif


Let readers read your arguments how the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe is impossible to conceive wherefore it is an invalid concept, and an invalid concept cannot have a corresponding entity in the actual objective reality of exisitng things: therefore, God does not exist.
How about you shoulder your burden of responsibility and show your god exists?

Otherwise all your arguments are nothing but utterances of hatred.
More pathetic god-botherer whining.
 
You got this one bit right.

The rest of your post is a confused, incoherent mess.
Yep I see a suspension or hissy-fit departure in the near future.

You really don't understand the Flying Spaghetti Monster analogy, do you yrreg?
Or the Invisible Pink Unicorn, or Russel's Teapot.
They appear to be a bit sophisticated for yrreg.

Also, stop being condescending and insulting before you get suspended again.
This is suspect is intentional, conscious or not. Yrreg needs to feel that he's won the argument (or been martyred) and can't face that once again his silly arguments have been shredded. Therefore he needs a justification to himself for his inevitable retreat; either he'll take umbrage at something and flounce off or he'll get himself suspended. This salves his ego.

I am just treating your claims about your God as equally valid as clams about any other god. Until you provide compelling reasons for considering your God to be more valid than any other god we have no reason to consider it to be so.

This is not "griping against Christians"; it is just treating their claims in the same way as the claims of other religions.
But xians are special................... :)

Yes, you have. Even though it's been shown to be wrong, you refuse to move from your illogical position. This is why it's pointless trying to have any kind of reasonable discussion with you. It's the same with all of your preaching.
The discussion isn't going the way it did in his head.
 
But xians are special................... :)


Only in current Christian societies. As he has already conceded, if yrreg had been born as a Viking in the dark ages he would have worshipped Odin, because at that time in that society, Odin worshippers were "special". He has no rational reason for his beliefs; he just goes along with what he perceives as the majority view.
 
You see, you can't even read correctly, I am inviting you to put forth a question.
Why would anyone bother, you haven't answered any of the questions put to you thus far in the thread.

But you guys are just full of tripe slogans,
I think you may mean trite, rather than tripe
like no evidence, burden of proof, who created God, if God created everything, can God make a rock so huge He cannot carry it, Hawking said the universe could and did come from nothing because of the M-theory or the laws of physics, and on and on and on, all showing the most gross ignorance cultivated owing to self-atrophy-ation of brain cells.
But you're the one making the positive claim that God exists so it's your burden of proof. That's the way adult debate works. If you don't like or cannot cope with adult debate with sceptics, you are in the wrong place. If you have presented no evidence that is hardly our fault, and if you cannot see that claiming "everything has a cause except God" is the fallacy of special pleading, then we cannot force you to educate yourself.

Are you seriously claiming that Stephen Hawking is ignorant on matters of physics and cosmology? Do you have any idea how ridiculous that sounds, and how completely it nullifies anything you have to say on matters on which Professor Hawking is an expert?

You know about a priori knowledge?
Yes.

It is to the brain what is reflex action to the eye.
No, it isn't. It is knowledge which is independent of experience - it can be arrived at without examining the properties of the material world. Things like "All bachelors are unmarried" and 2+2=4 are examples of a priori knowledge. However, it is true to say that even when something is considered true a priori, it can be falsified by empirical evidence. Here, yrreg, read this and learn: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/apriori/

<snip an offtopic description of reflex action>

So also with the brain, when it senses a thought coming to it like that the universe comes from nothing, if it is not already anesthetized by the human subject himself on his self-conditioning, it the brain will right away notice something is askew with that kind of a communication from a fellow human.
Nope, this is where you are going wrong. It is your belief that something cannot come from nothing, and because you close your mind to the possibility that you may be wrong, and close your mind to the evidence of experiments which have shown something coming from nothing (particles popping into existence, subatomic events having no cause, for example). You are forgetting, or not understanding, that a priori knowledge can be falsified by empirical evidence.

Such is the condition of atheists' brain, self-anesthetized as to become self-bereft of a priori knowledge.
I foresee cards and suspensions in your future if you continue to be deliberately insulting.

You claim to be here for an exchange of ideas, but exchange goes two ways. You have presented your ideas but not taken on board anything that has been said, as is evidenced by your statement here:
I still maintain that all atheists' arguments against God must first specify which God they are arguing against, otherwise you atheists are shooting in the dark, and that is very irrational.
Every concept of God. Your concept and every other one that has ever been thought of. It's not shooting in the dark. If it is your contention that we have to have a concept of god in order to disbelieve in it, I ask you this. Do you believe elves exist? If not, what concept of elves do you have, that you don't believe in them? What about all the other concepts of elves - do they exist? Are you sure that your concept of elves is the only correct concept of elves?

Is it really so hard for you to understand that it is possible to live a happy, fulfilled, productive, moral and good life without having any God at all?

There are lots of questions in my post, yrreg. This is because in a dialogue (which you claim to want), both sides both ask and answer questions. It would therefore be good for the dialogue for you to commence answering the questions put to you.
 
Last edited:
Maybe it's just me, but I'm still bothered that all three of yrreg's questions to atheists:

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?
all appear to be sentences with the periods replaced by question marks, with articles missing in the first two.


yrreg, those are not questions. It's as much a waste of my time to answer your sentences as it is to answer your questions, since I know you never listen to the answers anyway.

I don't need to specify a particular god to say I don't believe that any gods exist, just as I don't need to specify precisely which fairies I do not believe are currently living in my garden or which specific gremlins are not responsible for losing my socks in the wash.

I'm familiar enough with the concept of the Christian god to know that it's fuzzy and contradictory, to the point where even self-proclaimed christians cannot agree on its attributes, from how it feels about sin or homosexuality, to how it went about "creating the universe" and anything in between. You can't even agree on what's meant by "heaven" so who outside your little cults should care if your particular version of a christian god created your particular version of heaven? We've gone to the christian experts, as you've suggested, and their feedback suggests that everybody believes in a slightly different version of a similar story.

Which christian god concept do you want us to accept so that we can argue about whether or not this particular god created the universe and everything in it, except for himself of course, because nobody needed to create him because MAGIC?
 
You can have the discussion about working together to come to concurrence on the concept of universe and of God (Rougarou), and also where we will get started to launch into the search for God in the universe (Weak Kitten).

I can have many discussions with many people. I require neither your permission nor direction for these things. The fact remains, though, you invited me to have a specific discussion with you, and now that I have accepted your invitation and become invested in a discussion with you, you run away from that discussion.

You fled as soon as it was pointed out that you'd revised your concept of god and that the meaning you attributed to 'evidence' was silly and unworkable. Was that what caused you to hide?

Either way, I remain disappointed with your behavior.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom