What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Suppose everyone atheist here, now that you claim you have the correct information of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe, and you do not want to accept that owing to your freedom of choice even against your cognitive brain, tell me what then is the origin fo the universe?


So your God is the God of the gaps. Is that it?
 
Yrreg, my problem isn't with the idea, however unfounded, that a deity created this universe. My problem is that you keep insisting on calling this being the "Christian God". The concept of a "Christian" god has a whole set of other concepts included in it beyond just being "the creator of the universe".

Why don't you call this being Lord Brahma? Or just "unnamed creator deity"?
 
You can't even read correctly, but speak from cue instinct.

Originally Posted by yrreg
To everyone atheist just give me one question the most grievously you imagine to be an objection against God's existence, don't go far and wide, and I will answer it -- but I tell you I have already answered them all the nth times in this forum.

​

No.

The burden of proof is on you, not on atheists.


You see, you can't even read correctly, I am inviting you to put forth a question.

But you guys are just full of tripe slogans, like no evidence, burden of proof, who created God, if God created everything, can God make a rock so huge He cannot carry it, Hawking said the universe could and did come from nothing because of the M-theory or the laws of physics, and on and on and on, all showing the most gross ignorance cultivated owing to self-atrophy-ation of brain cells.

You know about a priori knowledge?

It is to the brain what is reflex action to the eye.

When the eye senses something coming toward it, it will start a chain reaction by which it closes the eyelids and the organism with eyes will duck its head.

So also with the brain, when it senses a thought coming to it like that the universe comes from nothing, if it is not already anesthetized by the human subject himself on his self-conditioning, it the brain will right away notice something is askew with that kind of a communication from a fellow human.


Such is the condition of atheists' brain, self-anesthetized as to become self-bereft of a priori knowledge.



Yrreg
 
You see, you can't even read correctly, I am inviting you to put forth a question.

But you guys are just full of tripe slogans, like no evidence, burden of proof, who created God, if God created everything, can God make a rock so huge He cannot carry it, Hawking said the universe could and did come from nothing because of the M-theory or the laws of physics, and on and on and on, all showing the most gross ignorance cultivated owing to self-atrophy-ation of brain cells.

You know about a priori knowledge?

It is to the brain what is reflex action to the eye.

When the eye senses something coming toward it, it will start a chain reaction by which it closes the eyelids and the organism with eyes will duck its head.

So also with the brain, when it senses a thought coming to it like that the universe comes from nothing, if it is not already anesthetized by the human subject himself on his self-conditioning, it the brain will right away notice something is askew with that kind of a communication from a fellow human.


Such is the condition of atheists' brain, self-anesthetized as to become self-bereft of a priori knowledge.



Yrreg


So you don't understand the concept of burden of proof.

You are making the claim that God exists. It is up to you to prove it.
 
On evidence, I have already said it nth times, evidence is any fact man knows leading him to know another fact.

Excellent. We can proceed from there. I can accept the first part, although it is open to a quibble about whether the evidence itself is fact. Let us just leave that, though, since it would unnecessarily complicate the discussion without advancing it.

It is the second part with which I must take exception. Evidence can mislead. The Michelson-Morely experiment, for example, provides evidence for the Earth being stationary with respect to the aether. However, this conclusion is not fact; it is contradicted by other experimental results.

Your view of the meaning of evidence is not serviceable. Evidence lends credence to a conclusion, but the conclusion may not be fact. Would you not agree that evidence can mislead? May I now add a second bullet to our progress, thusly:
  1. Creator of the heavens and Earth are the necessary and sufficient characteristics of the Christian god.
  2. Evidence is that which lends credence to some conclusion.

...
Okay, every atheist with brain power, think hard what is the origin of the universe.

Why do you load this with so much venom and vitriol? It is almost as if you were trying to chase people away rather than engage. Yes, I see you are contemptuous of those with beliefs not in line with your own, but please try to maintain a civil discussion. Only then can we make sincere progress together.

As for the origin of the universe, my answer is simple: I do not know.

Has the universe always existed? Maybe. It would be consistent with the notion of time being part of the universe and therefore meaningless to speak of a time before it existed.

Did the universe create itself? Possibly.

Did god create the universe? Well, certainly within the construct you have proposed, and I have accepted under your authority as a Christian, for your lord, if the universe were in any sense whatsoever created, even from itself, then buried in there somewhere would be something that would fit your criterion for god. I don't see the utility in this, however, since it robs your concept of god of any substantive meaning.

...
I will not anymore entertain any other question except this one on what is the origin of the universe if you don't want to admit God as the uncreated creator of the universe.

Oh, dear! Yrreg, you have moved the goal posts. If you are unwilling to hold a fixed position on your concepts, then how can we have a meaningful discussion of them? May I trust to you hold to his particular version of the concept of your Christian god without further revision? I hope so. Is this now our common ground:
  1. The uncreated creator of the heavens and Earth are the necessary and sufficient characteristics of Yrreg's Christian god.
  2. Evidence is that which lends credence to some conclusion.
 
But you guys are just full of tripe slogans,

Unlike you, of course. ("Tergiversating, hissing, correct concept of god, CGF-CU, fundamental concept....")

like no evidence, burden of proof, who created God,

Why is "what created the universe" an ok question, but "what created God" isn't?

if God created everything, can God make a rock so huge He cannot carry it,

Again, why are those questions nonsensical, but "what created the universe" isn't?

Hawking said the universe could and did come from nothing because of the M-theory or the laws of physics,

That's funny. You were all in favor of quoting famous academics when you were doing your little victory lap over a senile Anthony Flew's "conversion."

and on and on and on, all showing the most gross ignorance cultivated owing to self-atrophy-ation of brain cells.

Such is the condition of atheists' brain, self-anesthetized as to become self-bereft of a priori knowledge.

Ah, I see you're back in full swing insulting us all again. Please, tell us more about how we just offer "tripe slogans" as opposed to your high quality intellectual discourse.
 
Now, you want me to give equal attention to other gods, spaghetti, unicorn, etc,

I will do that as soon as you understand them to be uncreated creator of the universe, even though you are into unsavory epithets against them.



Yrreg

Oh good. You understand that The Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe and was destroyed in its making.

Are you able to understand that? You may answer yes or no.
 
Another instance of not reading correctly and lack of practical intelligence.

Originally Posted by yrreg
You ask how do people get to know the correct concept of God?

Logical, ask the people who know, and they will tell you that God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe is the uncreated creator of the universe, I said that already nth times.
​

How do we know which people are "the people who know," as opposed to people who may be mistaken or misinformed?



The concept of God is presented by Christians who claim to know God exists, but keep in mind that they are talking about their God .

So, since you want to know the correct concept of God with Christians, logically you have to go to them.

Now, if you have other folks who claim to know God also, then you go to these latter folks also in order to know what is their correct concept of God.

Yrreg said:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8277192&postcount=1516

Originally Posted by Mojo

[...]

Here they are again:

How do you know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God"?

Why should all these other supernatural entities be rejected in favour of your own personal concept of "God"?

Perhaps this time you can attempt to address these questions instead of once more running away from them.
​

That is why it is so frustrating to talk to you guys, because you really don't have any ideas that are relevant except to gripe against Christians.

You ask how do people get to know the correct concept of God?

Logical, ask the people who know, and they will tell you that God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe is the uncreated creator of the universe, I said that already nth times.

Now, you don't want to accept that from Christians, then give them your or what you think is the correct concept, and if it is not what Christians consider to be the uncreated creator of the universe, then you just attack that God which is for you the correct God.

Now, you want me to give equal attention to other gods, spaghetti, unicorn, etc,

I will do that as soon as you understand them to be uncreated creator of the universe, even though you are into unsavory epithets against them.


-------------------
Edited by Lisa Simpson: 
Edited to remove incivility.


Just the same so that you will go forth in life for your remaining years wiser, read now carefully what I am going to say for your benefit.

An elderly couple was crossing the street and a reckless driver hit the man and knocked him down on the road showing no movement, bystanders thought that he was dead; one of them noticed his lips moving very slightly, so he leaned close to the man's face and heard the man saying very weakly, "I am alive."

This man told everyone that the victim is alive, but right away the woman as usual in her habit of contradicting her husband insisted to the audience of bystanders: "Don't take him seriously, ask me."​


Not a very good analogy, but you get the idea or you don't?

My nose! I give up.




Yrreg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Not that I know of.

It states that false gods are man-made, and that worshiping them is worshipping what is created rather than the Creator.

It demonstrates their impotence repeatedly, as though they are not real.

But there is not a definite, direct statement on this point that I know of.

Thank you for the response. :) I had thought that perhaps I inadverdently offended you.

It makes sense that the creators of christianity would write as such, or even if the bible were 'inspired' by its god, that it would not want other gods in the way.

Chemosh was written of as being 'real,' iirc. "Do you not accept the things thy god Chemosh hath given you?" or something like that. But I could, perhaps, have missed a later part saying that maybe not because Chemosh is/was not real?

I do wish the bible specifically stated with clarity the reality of ALL other gods, at least in the new testament. Tho I suppose in the end it doesn't matter, because interpretations and belief/disbelief will still abound.

I may PM you, if that's all right. :)
 
You are not reading fully and remembering my words.

Yrreg, my problem isn't with the idea, however unfounded, that a deity created this universe. My problem is that you keep insisting on calling this being the "Christian God". The concept of a "Christian" god has a whole set of other concepts included in it beyond just being "the creator of the universe".

Why don't you call this being Lord Brahma? Or just "unnamed creator deity"?


You are not reading fully and remembering my words.


I have also said that God is the flying spaghetti monster if you want to call Him that, provided that He is the uncreated creator of the universe.

And I said also that God is the random mutation combined with natural selection provided that He thus created the universe.

You want to call God Brahma, and no irreverence intended, abracadabra, all right with me as long as you understand those labels to represent the uncreated creator of the universe.

Unnamed creator deity is also all right with me, provided this deity is in concept the uncreated creator of the universe.


I see in you a most naive mind, as with all atheists who are vocal but forget to think carefully, like Hawking telling his idolatrous fans that the universe could and did come from nothing because there is the M-theory and of course the laws of physics.


Tell you want, WK, you think about how the concept of an uncreated creator of the universe is an invalid concept, but first work on what is a concept and how it is valid or invalid.

That will open your mind to the vast expanse of concepts and realities and how man's mind works from realities to concepts and from concepts back to realities.


But I can understand because that is the easier or the easiest thing to do, swallow what to you appears to be smart, like no evidence, burden of proof, spaghetti, many gods you just add another one in addition to the ones denied by Christians to exist, and all those nonsensical utterances of atheists.

Now, you will ask me what is sense and nonsense, and I will welcome you to engage in examining what is sense and what is nonsense.

And right away I will tell you that atheists are all always into nonsense, and theists are the people who make sense.




Yrreg
 
But I can understand because that is the easier or the easiest thing to do, swallow what to you appears to be smart, like no evidence, burden of proof, spaghetti, many gods you just add another one in addition to the ones denied by Christians to exist, and all those nonsensical utterances of atheists.


Why do you dismiss concepts you don't understand, instead of making an honest attempt at understanding?

Your arrogance is impressive. And sad.
 
[* Nonsense snipped. *] And right away I will tell you that atheists are all always into nonsense, and theists are the people who make sense.


I asked this of another god believer, but he/she apparently didn't have the courage or honesty necessary to answer it. Do you, yrreg?...

Is there an objective method for separating the voices in your head that might be a symptom of psychosis or schizophrenia from the voices in your head that allegedly come from some supernatural being? Is there a way to objectively sort the figments of your imagination that you attribute to gods from those that are just daydreams or idle fantasies?​
 
But, I'm perfectly fine accepting Brahma as the creator of the universe. I have no problem envisioning that.

So, Brahma is the uncreated creator of the universe. Awesome. Now where do we go from there?
 
I am waiting for Rougarou, hope he returns soon.

Thanks everyone for your participation.

I apologize for the harsh words.


Now, I wish for someone to exchange thoughts with -- carefully and relevantlly, and I will wait for Rougarou because he is new here and wants to talk with me starting from both our parts as from a tabula rasa.

He wants to talk about the three questions from me:

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?

He has many questions for me to answer, but I suggest that we first work to concur on what is or should be our concurred on concepts of universe and also of God.



Yrreg
 
Thanks everyone for your participation.

I apologize for the harsh words.


Now, I wish for someone to exchange thoughts with -- carefully and relevantlly, and I will wait for Rougarou because he is new here and wants to talk with me starting from both our parts as from a tabula rasa.

He wants to talk about the three questions from me:

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?

He has many questions for me to answer, but I suggest that we first work to concur on what is or should be our concurred on concepts of universe and also of God.



Yrreg


You can always PM Rougarou if you want to hold a private conversation.

Are you going to answer any of the other questions asked of you here?
 
Well, let us ask the people who know Brahma, what or who is Brahma.

But, I'm perfectly fine accepting Brahma as the creator of the universe. I have no problem envisioning that.

So, Brahma is the uncreated creator of the universe. Awesome. Now where do we go from there?


Well, let us ask the people who know Brahma, what or who is Brahma.

Wait for me, I will seek fast information in the net.

Here, I found a definition from an instant net dictionary:

http://education.yahoo.com/reference/dictionary/entry/Brahma



Brahma

NOUN:
Hinduism
The creator god, conceived chiefly as a member of the triad including also Vishnu and Shiva.
Variant of Brahman.
Variant of Brahman.
ETYMOLOGY:
Sanskrit brahm, from brahma, prayer


Sounds familiar like what I have for my concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely:
God is the uncreated creator of the universe.​


A name without the concept does not convey anything except that for curious people we want to know what the users the name understand by it, so that once we understand the concept represented by the name, we can launch into an expedition to locate the entity or thing represented by the concept which is signified by the name or broadly the word.


So, where do we go from here?

What about seeking to find Brahma or God starting with ourselves which are the nearest things accessible to our search and examination for the existence of God?



Yrreg
 
But wouldn't the best place to look for the creator of the universe be in the shape of that universe itself? We as individuals are just one tiny aspect of the universe, wouldn't it would be like trying to understand an elephant from just looking at a single molar?
 
If we just want to pm each other there is no need for a forum.



Now, do you want to ask a question or you just want me to answer all questions here which you claim that I have not answered?



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom