What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

It is good to see you back, dafydd. To embedden a youtube, use the tags [ yt] and [ /yt], (without the spaces) and in between the tags just put the bit after the v= in the youtube address.

 
It is good to see you back, dafydd. To embedden a youtube, use the tags [ yt] and [ /yt], (without the spaces) and in between the tags just put the bit after the v= in the youtube address.


Thank you, and thank you.
 
Good, Rougarou and Weak Kitten have returned.

[ To read the spoiler, click on the boxed words, Spoiler:Show. ]
CGCF-CU stands for the concept of God in the Christian faith
in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
He is the uncreated creator of the universe.​





Yes, Rougarou has returned, and also Weak Kitten; so I will deal with them, and you guys can continue working on your own how the concept of God is an invalid concept, and also what it is to prove something to not exist or a concept to be invalid.

And please forgive me, I will not spend time to read your latest posts here; if you really are not running away, please just put forth your sharpened thought in few pithy clear concise words, and I will attend to you next time around.



Yrreg
 
Since you don't know as to choose a point to start, I will not deal with you.

Sorry I took so long to respond, I had stuff I needed to do.

Anyway, I guess my answer is, I don't know.

I just know that humans are not always reliable. They can be confused, or remember incorrectly, or even be genuinely sick in the head. You can't trust the word of a single human or group of humans. Sometimes, you can't even trust your own personal perceptions.

To really understand the universe you need a way of filtering out all the information that might be faulty so that the truth can really be understood. A way that can get around all biases and misunderstandings, including your own. Something that will let others check your truth and tell you whether you are confused or have actually found something important. A way that will let you check the truth of others and determine for your self whether they are correct or not.


Since you don't know as to choose a point to start, I will not deal with you.

No need to downgrade our capability to know, so I will not give it any attention whatsoever on that score, because that is removing the ground below our feet, namely, the first principle of human knowing, scil., we can and do know things like the nose in our face, and also that you have a brain.



When you have chosen where you and I can and will start at some point in the universe to launch into the search for God, then pm me.


Remember I was suggesting that we start the search with ourselves but you said that is too trivial to take when the universe is such a most vast territory.

Now, are you going into the useless wrangle that I did not say that and you said something else, and on and on and on... in that direction: that is what you atheist guys are good at, wrangling over what you said and what I said.




Yrreg
 
And please forgive me, I will not spend time to read your latest posts here

Yrreg,
Is this how you treat people in real life, with such dishonesty? You invited me into a discussion. I assumed your invitation was in earnest, and accepted it, but now I see you were being insincere. You have abandoned the discussion.

Why did you run away?

Why are you compelled to hide from me? You have nothing to fear from me, so please reconsider and come out from hiding to continue our discussion.
 
You are asking me two questions, one of them is about my assumptions...

[...]

Again, since they are your terms for making your argument, I will let you define what you mean when you use them.

God: uncreated creator of the universe.
universe: the totality of created existence.

Accepting your definitions for the sake of argument*, where does the expedition go from here?


* For my part, I would leave the word "created" out of the definition of universe because it makes assumptions that I don't find in evidence. I know the universe exists, but that knowledge doesn't tell me whether it was created or whether it always existed.




You have two questions the way I read you:

Q1. Where do we go from the concepts of God and the universe which you accept from me [ wherefore we do now have a concurrence on the concepts, good! ].

Q2. You want to know what are my assumptions in saying in our now concurred on concept of the universe, namely, the totality of created existence.


I think we must now first deal with Q2, what are my assumptions in saying that the universe is the totality of created [ by God ] existence.

Now, please don't think that I am being evasive, suppose you tell me what you understand by an assumption.


The road to concurrence on anything at all among humans is a long one and tortuous one, but with sincerity and dedication and with total application as we do have a brain, concurrence will be achieved on everything that does matter to the humans who want answers to questions, like is there a God uncreated creator of the universe?

So, again, to the work of concurrence, what is an assumption, you are the one bringing up that term, or you want to withdraw that term?


I am so glad that I don't have to deal with all posters here but you only for the present, until you also leave me -- and then I will see if someone will be available to take your place.




Yrreg
 
You have two questions the way I read you:

Q1. Where do we go from the concepts of God and the universe which you accept from me [ wherefore we do now have a concurrence on the concepts, good! ].

Q2. You want to know what are my assumptions in saying in our now concurred on concept of the universe, namely, the totality of created existence.


I think we must now first deal with Q2, what are my assumptions in saying that the universe is the totality of created [ by God ] existence.

Now, please don't think that I am being evasive, suppose you tell me what you understand by an assumption.


The road to concurrence on anything at all among humans is a long one and tortuous one, but with sincerity and dedication and with total application as we do have a brain, concurrence will be achieved on everything that does matter to the humans who want answers to questions, like is there a God uncreated creator of the universe?

So, again, to the work of concurrence, what is an assumption, you are the one bringing up that term, or you want to withdraw that term?


I am so glad that I don't have to deal with all posters here but you only for the present, until you also leave me -- and then I will see if someone will be available to take your place.

Yrreg

Should we go hire an interpreter?
 
I am so glad that I don't have to deal with all posters here but you only for the present, until you also leave me -- and then I will see if someone will be available to take your place.

I assume this means when he asks a question that you can't answer, you'll run away from him too.

Run Away Yrreg.
 
I see we've again reached the point where Gerry becomes frustrated by his inability to make people respond according to his preconceived script.
 
Many of these threads do seem like walking into a play you didn't get your copy of script for.

There's obviously some sort of act we're supposed to be following that we aren't.
 
I am so glad that I don't have to deal with all posters here but you only for the present, until you also leave me -- and then I will see if someone will be available to take your place.
Yrreg


In other words, "If I can find someone else to sort of follow the script I've decided I want to follow in this thread, instead of having any kind of real discussion in which I learn anything."
 
...you guys can continue working on your own how the concept of God is an invalid concept...

Actually, I think many have already come to that conclusion, yrreG.
And have moved on.

I gather you have no immediate plans to deal with my question.
No worries.
My question is-how does 'morality' prove the existence of the judeo-christian god?




... what are my assumptions in saying that the universe is the totality of created [ by God ] existence.

Now, please don't think that I am being evasive, suppose you tell me what you understand by an assumption....
I am so glad that I don't have to deal with all posters here but you only for the present, until you also leave me -- and then I will see if someone will be available to take your place. .../QUOTE]

Interesting how yrreG seeks to turn this into a 'debate' format.
 
Q2. You want to know what are my assumptions in saying in our now concurred on concept of the universe, namely, the totality of created existence.


I think we must now first deal with Q2, what are my assumptions in saying that the universe is the totality of created [ by God ] existence.

Ok. Your assumption is wrong as there is no proof of your belief. If you need a yes man, then hire one.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom