What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

But wouldn't the best place to look for the creator of the universe be in the shape of that universe itself? We as individuals are just one tiny aspect of the universe, wouldn't it would be like trying to understand an elephant from just looking at a single molar?


I like for you to suggest a starting point if you don't think that we are not enough of a starting point.


Yrreg
 
I hate to say this, but from my own limited observation I would say that for quantity alone: there has been no comparable amount of records of human thinking on God and the universe, from since the invention of writing, with the volumes of writings made and still preserved and still increasing today, in what I call the Western tradition of which a most sizable part is Christendom.

So, if you want to know about an idea and what mankind has thought about it and still thinks about it, you can look up the Western tradition, specifically Christendom.


Forgive me if you think that I am a chavinist in this respect of volumes of written records of man's thinking from since the invention of writing.

The fact is that when you examine an idea in Hinduism, Buddhism, Taoism, etc. isms outside the Western tradition and Christendom, it is profitable to look up the Western and Christian studies of that idea.

And from my own part, I always seek to find what is common in other traditions even though earlier with what I call the Western tradition and Christendom.



Yrreg
 
I have also said that God is the flying spaghetti monster if you want to call Him that, provided that He is the uncreated creator of the universe.


Yrreg

Yes, it has been noted that you finally agree that The Flying Spaghetti Monster (note that it is capitalized), created the universe and was destroyed in its making. Now you are finally thinking that this is logical because there has been no evidence of anything supernatural. Certainly not in this thread.
 
Just for fun, you only have to say penis, to reveal your heart and mind.



Just for comic relief.



But do engage in some real original personal thinking.


Instead of shouting penis.


You read a lot of prattle, but nothing genuinely critical and insightful, and nothing of the history of ideas, which could have stirred your brain cells to do some original personal thinking.

Okay, how do yo get out of a maze? And how long?


The man will shout again, penis!



Just for fun only, so don't run to the moderators.




Yrreg

Penis therefore god.

Again
 
Originally Posted by yrreg
I am waiting for Rougarou and Weak Kitten.


Yrreg

​

Ah, so you have run away from our discussion. I am disappointed in your behavior.


You can have the discussion about working together to come to concurrence on the concept of universe and of God (Rougarou), and also where we will get started to launch into the search for God in the universe (Weak Kitten).



Yrreg
 
The behavior isn't really surprising though. When one has the mentality of a child one usually behaves like a child.

True. I must commend you all, tho, that you seem able to make sense of his posts. I can only make sense out of some of them. If I'm correct, he is attempting to engage with only one person, and that person must agree firstly to his concepts of 'god' and then come to an agreement that matches his own?

I... think. :boggled:
 
All your arguments are nothing but utterances of hatred.

[ To read the spoiler, click on the boxed words, Spoiler:Show. ]
CGCF-CU stands for the concept of God in the Christian faith
in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
He is the uncreated creator of the universe.​




I still maintain that all atheists' arguments against God must first specify which God they are arguing against, otherwise you atheists are shooting in the dark, and that is very irrational.

Now, if you are arguing against God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, then you have to get it from Christian documents on what is God; and you are not doing yourselves any cognitive credit by bringing in so many gods, goddesses, deities, divinities, etc,, and specially bringing in your passion to denigrate by calling God spaghetti, unicorn, fairy, whatever: that will satisfy your hatred but not your passion for cognition that is not contaminated by hatred.

And that is why you always eschew coming to the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely, as the uncreated creator of the universe.

There is a very good opening to topple this concept, namely, by showing it is impossible to conceive, therefore it is an invalid concept.


Let readers read your arguments how the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe is impossible to conceive wherefore it is an invalid concept, and an invalid concept cannot have a corresponding entity in the actual objective reality of exisitng things: therefore, God does not exist.

Otherwise all your arguments are nothing but utterances of hatred.



Yrreg
 
[ To read the spoiler, click on the boxed words, Spoiler:Show. ]
CGCF-CU stands for the concept of God in the Christian faith
in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
He is the uncreated creator of the universe.​




I still maintain that all atheists' arguments against God must first specify which God they are arguing against, otherwise you atheists are shooting in the dark, and that is very irrational.

Now, if you are arguing against God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, then you have to get it from Christian documents on what is God; and you are not doing yourselves any cognitive credit by bringing in so many gods, goddesses, deities, divinities, etc,, and specially bringing in your passion to denigrate by calling God spaghetti, unicorn, fairy, whatever: that will satisfy your hatred but not your passion for cognition that is not contaminated by hatred.

And that is why you always eschew coming to the concept of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, namely, as the uncreated creator of the universe.

There is a very good opening to topple this concept, namely, by showing it is impossible to conceive, therefore it is an invalid concept.


Let readers read your arguments how the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe is impossible to conceive wherefore it is an invalid concept, and an invalid concept cannot have a corresponding entity in the actual objective reality of exisitng things: therefore, God does not exist.

Otherwise all your arguments are nothing but utterances of hatred.



Yrreg

Foolish, foolish foolish conclusion.

Disagreement with an inarticulate premise and illogical conclusion does not constitute hatred.

ETA - okay, I'm probably wasting my time here, but here goes:

Fundamental premise of atheism: there is a lack of evidence of any god, therefore there is no god to believe in.

You claim there is a god, more specifically a Christian god. You attempt to claim that something must have created the universe, therefore it was god.

Instant fail.

First, there must be a basis for claiming that a specific *something* created the universe. Secondly, that the universe was created and therefore needed a something to do it. Thirdly, that the agent of that creation was a god as defined in whatever religion it is that you're espousing.

The existence of the universe does not in itself establish that there are any gods, until evidence for all three points is sufficient to establish that god or gods exist AND created the universe.

Your explanation is awaited.
 
Last edited:
You really don't understand the Flying Spaghetti Monster analogy, do you yrreg?
Or the Invisible Pink Unicorn, or Russel's Teapot.

Maybe you should do some "real original personal thinking" on what those analogies mean, rather than immediately disregarding them as ignorance and flippancy.

Also, stop being condescending and insulting before you get suspended again.
 
The concept of God is presented by Christians who claim to know God exists, but keep in mind that they are talking about their God .

So, since you want to know the correct concept of God with Christians, logically you have to go to them.

There is a flaw in your logic. You are assuming -- or asserting without proof -- that Christians know "the correct concept of God."

Unless, of course, the only thing you mean by "correct" is "what they are claiming" rather than "what is true." But then you are asserting a mere triviality, that in order to know what Christians claim, we must ask Christians. And that triviality is not disputed by anyone here. But knowing what people claim, while it is a useful beginning, does not get us very far. All of us here are quite familiar with the claims of Christians.

We must know what evidence they offer in support of that claim. And that, of course, is where you always fail, because instead of offering any, you ask questions like "well, did the universe create itself?" If we are being very charitable to you -- despite your lack of charity to us, I might add -- that is at best the tired old claim that "the universe exists, and it must have a creator," to which posters here have responded extensively.

Now, if you have other folks who claim to know God also, then you go to these latter folks also in order to know what is their correct concept of God.

Excellent! While we are gathering these "correct concepts of God," I trust we will go to some atheists, who will inform us that their "correct concept of God" is "a fictional character invented by humans."

Of course, we would also have to speak to those who claim that the "correct concept of God" is Zeus, or a flying spaghetti monster, or Thor... but you seem to object vociferously to doing so.

And more importantly, once we have gathered all these different concepts, from the Christian god to Zeus to the fictional character, how shall we determine which is correct?
[/QUOTE]

I still maintain that all atheists' arguments against God must first specify which God they are arguing against,

"Whaddya got?"
 
I expect people interactng with me to first agree on concepts and on procedures, otherwise it is all hollering...

I do hope you'll answer my question : why is 'morality' a proof of the judeo-christian god?
 
[ To read the spoiler, click on the boxed words, Spoiler:Show. ]
CGCF-CU stands for the concept of God in the Christian faith
in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
He is the creator of the universe.​


Mojo said:
[...]

Here they are again:

How do you know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God"?

Why should all these other supernatural entities be rejected in favour of your own personal concept of "God"?


Perhaps this time you can attempt to address these questions instead of once more running away from them.




That is why it is so frustrating to talk to you guys, because you really don't have any ideas that are relevant except to gripe against Christians.

You ask how do people get to know the correct concept of God?

Logical, ask the people who know, and they will tell you that God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe is the uncreated creator of the universe, I said that already nth times.


You are basically saying that we should reject all concepts of "god" other than yours because you say so. Given the muddled thinking you have exhibited on this forum, people are not likely to regard your personal authority as a good reason to do this.

And you have still failed to answer the first question: How do you know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God"?

"Just take my word for it" is not an answer to this question.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom