What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

You can run but you cannot hide, except throw up a smoke screen of useless words.

Well, as usual you guys all run away from the issue at hand.

I am asking you to examine the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe, that it is an invalid concept.

Okay, again, stick to the instant issue, show how that concept is invalid.

At the same time, give also equal if not more importance to think about what it is to prove something to not exist or in our instant concern to be invalid as a concept.

I will come back towmorrow morning, meantime I am also going to look up what it is to prove something to not exist in the actual objective reality of existing things, and also more close to our instant concern, to prove that something is an invalid concept.

Don't write so many words in order to just run away from the instant concern; if you have a well-sharpened thought you can say it in few pithy clear plain words, otherwise you are running away and putting up a smoke screen to hide in: still you know in your heart of hearts and mind of minds that you can run but you cannot hide, however much you do hope to throw up a smoke screen like legendary but Hollywood ninjas to hide in.


Okay, no more running, show how the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe is an invalid concept, and also what it is to prove a concept to be invalid.


Wait, I almost forget, I have to check whether Rougorou is still running away and also Weak Kitten is still running away, or still staying away.

.........

No, no they have not returned.

Rougarou wanted me to answer to his many questions about God and universe, but I asked him for us two to first work together to come to concurrence on our concepts of universe and God, and he just disappeared from that point to the present.

With Weak Kitten, she said that my proposal to launch an expedition to search for God in the universe by starting with ourselves is too trivial for a starting point when the universe is such a huge place; so I asked her to suggest where she wants us to for a starting point to launch into the search for God in the universe, and she has disappeared from that point in time and in space to the present.


Okay guys, get busy and productive, work on why is the concept of God as uncreated creator of the universe is invalid, and also how to prove a concept to be invalid.

Else go away and stay in bed, don't write here: because unless we come to concurrence on concepts and procedures you are wasting the time and trouble of readers here, and also your own time and trouble, just stay in bed.


I will be back tomorrow morning to check whether you guys are now into the issue at hand or still running away, erh, hiding, and throwing up a huge smoke screen of irrelevant words.


But just one last request, put your already sharpened thought if any at all in few pithy relevant clear plain words, otherwise you have a very vague thought when you have to say so many words for a smoke screen to say nothing relevant to the issue at hand.



Yrreg
 
Well, as usual you guys all run away from the issue at hand.

I am asking you to examine the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe, that it is an invalid concept.
Again? You neither acknowledge or respond to the many people who have already explained why your logic is invalid.

Your argument (which is a simple repackaging of the Kalam cosmological argument) boils down to:

1. Everything which exists must have a cause (this is untrue)
2. The universe exists
3. God caused it (this does not follow logically)

Even if, for the sake of argument, we agreed that the first premise is correct, there is no logical reason why the cause must be God. If you want to argue for the existence of God, you need to first show evidence for God. Only once you have established the existence of God can you move on to demonstrate the properties of the God.

In the alternative, you claim that God created "heaven and earth and everything", but that God did not require a creator. This is special pleading, which is a logical fallacy. You are on the one hand positing that everything needs a creator, and on the other hand that God does not need a creator. If God is not part of everything, then God does not exist.

Furthermore, as has been explained, there is no evidence for the existence of heaven, but if there was it would be part of "everything", and the earth is also part of "everything" so your phrase is needlessly repetitious. The phrase "God created everything" will suffice, although as before, you have no evidence that God created anything at all, nor that God exists.

Okay, again, stick to the instant issue, show how that concept is invalid.

At the same time, give also equal if not more importance to think about what it is to prove something to not exist or in our instant concern to be invalid as a concept.
Your English isn't really able to cope with that sentence, but I think you mean how can a person prove that something exists or doesn't exist. As has been explained to you before, the person making the positive claim (there is a God) has the burden of proof. It is not possible to prove a negative except by demonstrating the absence of evidence for the positive claim. Since you have not adduced any evidence, the null hypothesis is that no God exists. If you or any other theist comes up with empirical evidence for God, we'll revise our stance and believe in God. But nobody has come up with evidence in the last 2000 years, so we won't hold our breaths waiting.

I will come back towmorrow morning, meantime I am also going to look up what it is to prove something to not exist in the actual objective reality of existing things, and also more close to our instant concern, to prove that something is an invalid concept.
You don't need to keep repeating yourself.

Don't write so many words in order to just run away from the instant concern; if you have a well-sharpened thought you can say it in few pithy clear plain words, otherwise you are running away and putting up a smoke screen to hide in: still you know in your heart of hearts and mind of minds that you can run but you cannot hide, however much you do hope to throw up a smoke screen like legendary but Hollywood ninjas to hide in.
Have you no self-awareness whatsoever? Your posts are overly verbose and your sentences tangled. Take your own advice to improve your own posts before requiring other people to do what you seem incapable of doing.


Okay, no more running, show how the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe is an invalid concept, and also what it is to prove a concept to be invalid.
Didn't you say this earlier in this same post? Why yes, yes you did. You just instructed everyone not to write so many words, and yet you have repeated yourself three times in the space of one post.

Wait, I almost forget, I have to check whether Rougorou is still running away and also Weak Kitten is still running away, or still staying away.

.........

No, no they have not returned.

Rougarou wanted me to answer to his many questions about God and universe, but I asked him for us two to first work together to come to concurrence on our concepts of universe and God, and he just disappeared from that point to the present.

With Weak Kitten, she said that my proposal to launch an expedition to search for God in the universe by starting with ourselves is too trivial for a starting point when the universe is such a huge place; so I asked her to suggest where she wants us to for a starting point to launch into the search for God in the universe, and she has disappeared from that point in time and in space to the present.
People do have lives outside this message board; neither Rougorou nor Weak Kitten is at your beck and call.


Okay guys, get busy and productive, work on why is the concept of God as uncreated creator of the universe is invalid, and also how to prove a concept to be invalid.
For the love of everything you hold dear, that's a fourth repetition of the same thing! There is no need to keep repeating yourself, a written medium means people can read more than once should they wish.

Else go away and stay in bed, don't write here: because unless we come to concurrence on concepts and procedures you are wasting the time and trouble of readers here, and also your own time and trouble, just stay in bed.
I just checked, and you are not in charge. It would be more polite if you did not try to set rules on who can post on this or any other thread, nor what and how often they post.


I will be back tomorrow morning to check whether you guys are now into the issue at hand or still running away, erh, hiding, and throwing up a huge smoke screen of irrelevant words.
Yes, we know, you already said that earlier in the post.

But just one last request, put your already sharpened thought if any at all in few pithy relevant clear plain words, otherwise you have a very vague thought when you have to say so many words for a smoke screen to say nothing relevant to the issue at hand.
Oh, if only you would take your own advice.

In short, and in the pithy words you require of others but are incapable or unwilling to do others the courtesy of using:

There is no evidence for your concept of God. Please provide some.
 
Well, as usual you guys all run away from the issue at hand.

Really? I've kept up my side of the discussion, but it seems you haven't. So, that would mean you have run away. Why did you run away?

Perhaps you will reconsider. Here, I can remind you where we were:
  1. The uncreated creator of the heavens and Earth are the necessary and sufficient characteristics of Yrreg's Christian god.
  2. Evidence is that which lends credence to some conclusion.

Now, what are your views on these two?
 
Last edited:
I still maintain that all atheists' arguments against God must first specify which God they are arguing against, otherwise you atheists are shooting in the dark, and that is very irrational.

How can I choose between thousands of non-existent beings?
 
I like for you to suggest a starting point if you don't think that we are not enough of a starting point.


Yrreg

Sorry I took so long to respond, I had stuff I needed to do.

Anyway, I guess my answer is, I don't know.

I just know that humans are not always reliable. They can be confused, or remember incorrectly, or even be genuinely sick in the head. You can't trust the word of a single human or group of humans. Sometimes, you can't even trust your own personal perceptions.

To really understand the universe you need a way of filtering out all the information that might be faulty so that the truth can really be understood. A way that can get around all biases and misunderstandings, including your own. Something that will let others check your truth and tell you whether you are confused or have actually found something important. A way that will let you check the truth of others and determine for your self whether they are correct or not.
 
Yrreg is simply incapable of understanding basic concepts, and doesn't even appear to try to.

Waste of time.

Pithy enough for you, Yrreg?
 
<snipped everything that was idiotic>

You are really mad that you've run away so many times and it is pointed out to you, aren't you?

So, any evidence of your uncaused god(s) yet? Don't run away and don't lie this time like you lied about not drinking.
 
*Sigh* Yet another tawdry attempt to dictate what we should think.

As usual, the argument is unjustifiably smug, long on words, short on meaning, and attempts to shift the burden of proof.

Please try again - here's a reminder:


Foolish, foolish foolish conclusion.

Disagreement with an inarticulate premise and illogical conclusion does not constitute hatred.

ETA - okay, I'm probably wasting my time here, but here goes:

Fundamental premise of atheism: there is a lack of evidence of any god, therefore there is no god to believe in.

You claim there is a god, more specifically a Christian god. You attempt to claim that something must have created the universe, therefore it was god.

Instant fail.

First, there must be a basis for claiming that a specific *something* created the universe. Secondly, that the universe was created and therefore needed a something to do it. Thirdly, that the agent of that creation was a god as defined in whatever religion it is that you're espousing.

The existence of the universe does not in itself establish that there are any gods, until evidence for all three points is sufficient to establish that god or gods exist AND created the universe.

Your explanation is awaited.
 
<snip>
Wait, I almost forget, I have to check whether Rougorou is still running away and also Weak Kitten is still running away, or still staying away.

.........

No, no they have not returned.

Rougarou wanted me to answer to his many questions about God and universe, but I asked him for us two to first work together to come to concurrence on our concepts of universe and God, and he just disappeared from that point to the present.



Yrreg

I answered your post in detail here where I even accepted your definitions for the sake of the argument.
 
Oh, yrreG.
You really HAVE missed the boat here!

Rougarou
Originally Posted by yrreg

...Rougarou wanted me to answer to his many questions about God and universe, but I asked him for us two to first work together to come to concurrence on our concepts of universe and God, and he just disappeared from that point to the present.

I answered your post in detail here where I even accepted your definitions for the sake of the argument.

:rolleyes:


...
I don't need to specify a particular god to say I don't believe that any gods exist, just as I don't need to specify precisely which fairies I do not believe are currently living in my garden or which specific gremlins are not responsible for losing my socks in the wash. ...Which christian god concept do you want us to accept so that we can argue about whether or not this particular god created the universe and everything in it, except for himself of course, because nobody needed to create him because MAGIC?

I don't think that will be answered by yrreG, just as I doubt they will answer my question about "morality" as a proof of the existence of the judeo-christian god.
 
Last edited:
I am asking you to examine the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe, that it is an invalid concept.

Okay, again, stick to the instant issue, show how that concept is invalid.


How does this God appear with "no cause"?

Claiming that a God exists without any "cause", is exactly the same as admitting you have no explanation in the first place.

Against that, at least since the work of Einstein and the pioneers of QM, modern physics and cosmology have been able to produce increasingly refined explanations of how our universe came into existence via. a process called the "Big Bang" ...

... that is a genuine explanation in which science provides answers to all of those unexplained questions. That is - our most recent explanations of how the universe came into existence, do not rely on any unexplained "first cause" or any unanswered questions ...

... science and scientists do not refuse to answer questions about how and why the Big Bang occurred. On the contrary they give a highly detailed explanation, right down to the most precise mathematical description.

In contrast to that, what you and theists like William Lane-Craig want to do, is to refuse to provide any answer to how, why or where this figure called "God" from .... you are totally refusing to answer that absolutely central question, and instead just claiming that you don’t need an answer because you going to use the following six words " God is our unexplained First Cause " ... well, that's exactly the same as saying you can't explain it lol :D.

IOW - by your own admission, you literally have no explanation :rolleyes:.
 
Last edited:
Well, as usual you guys all run away from the issue at hand.

I am asking you to examine the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe, that it is an invalid concept.

Okay, again, stick to the instant issue, show how that concept is invalid.

At the same time, give also equal if not more importance to think about what it is to prove something to not exist or in our instant concern to be invalid as a concept.

I will come back towmorrow morning, meantime I am also going to look up what it is to prove something to not exist in the actual objective reality of existing things, and also more close to our instant concern, to prove that something is an invalid concept.

Don't write so many words in order to just run away from the instant concern; if you have a well-sharpened thought you can say it in few pithy clear plain words, otherwise you are running away and putting up a smoke screen to hide in: still you know in your heart of hearts and mind of minds that you can run but you cannot hide, however much you do hope to throw up a smoke screen like legendary but Hollywood ninjas to hide in.


Okay, no more running, show how the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe is an invalid concept, and also what it is to prove a concept to be invalid.


Wait, I almost forget, I have to check whether Rougorou is still running away and also Weak Kitten is still running away, or still staying away.

.........

No, no they have not returned.

Rougarou wanted me to answer to his many questions about God and universe, but I asked him for us two to first work together to come to concurrence on our concepts of universe and God, and he just disappeared from that point to the present.

With Weak Kitten, she said that my proposal to launch an expedition to search for God in the universe by starting with ourselves is too trivial for a starting point when the universe is such a huge place; so I asked her to suggest where she wants us to for a starting point to launch into the search for God in the universe, and she has disappeared from that point in time and in space to the present.


Okay guys, get busy and productive, work on why is the concept of God as uncreated creator of the universe is invalid, and also how to prove a concept to be invalid.

Else go away and stay in bed, don't write here: because unless we come to concurrence on concepts and procedures you are wasting the time and trouble of readers here, and also your own time and trouble, just stay in bed.


I will be back tomorrow morning to check whether you guys are now into the issue at hand or still running away, erh, hiding, and throwing up a huge smoke screen of irrelevant words.


But just one last request, put your already sharpened thought if any at all in few pithy relevant clear plain words, otherwise you have a very vague thought when you have to say so many words for a smoke screen to say nothing relevant to the issue at hand.



Yrreg


You can run but you cannot hide, except throw up a smoke screen of useless words.
 
All of them.

All of them.

All of them.

All of them.

All of them.

...

Is that clear enough for you, yrreg?

Please, don't take me wrong, but I think this would be losing our time.

Yrregular thinking characterizes by:

  • Treating atheists as people who decided to reject "G"od, the one and only threesomic of choice. In Yrregular thinking an atheist -as other assorted non.theists- is depicted like an inferior creature shouting "Nah, nah, nah! I can't hear you! I can't hear you!" to "G"od.
  • Casting anything into existence just by "conceptualizing" it, with conceptualizing meaning just imagining a notion and holding it as a pretty stable signal in one's cerebral convolutions.
  • Easily losing the trail of any reasoning:
    • as notions (stable signals) get stuck at the upper functions of the brain and -like stars at dawn- only the shiniest ones still get noticed.
    • as obsessive-compulsive structures in the mind translate into "airtight compartments" that prevent laws of logic to erode any "given" notion. The walls of those compartments are made of such a resilient material that had the Titanic's been made of that it wouldn't have sunk.
So, debating with those yrregular thinkers is just like trying to convince an unknown barky dog that it must stop barking and snarling just by using our best dog-like reasoning: they'd stop barking when you accidentally come upon a solution.

Or the dog dies. One can also expect that the barky dog run and get hit by a car. At least, dogs live shorter than people -an then they go to the puppy's heaven, the most marvellous place-.
 
Well, as usual you guys all run away from the issue at hand.

I am asking you to examine the concept of God as the uncreated creator of the universe, that it is an invalid concept.



Yrreg

The existence of the universe does not prove the existence of a god or God.

It goes like this
-I define "Cosmic Peanut Butter Sandwich" to be "the creator of the universe"
-I then demonstrate the existence of the Universe
-Therefore the existence of the Universe proves the existence of the Cosmic Peanut Butter Sandwich.

This is a tautology and a fallacy of construction.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom