What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

You refuse to accept the good things that come through it.


There is no evidence that the "good things that come through it" are available exclusively to those who believe in invisible magical beings. From my observation, all those good things can be had without being encumbered by delusions of the existence of gods.

That I can't figure out, but we accept reality and the supernatural/spiritual nature of life because we have witnessed these things one way or another.


Is there an objective method for separating the voices in your head that might be a symptom of psychosis or schizophrenia from the voices in your head that allegedly come from some supernatural being? Is there a way to objectively sort the figments of your imagination that you attribute to gods from those that are just daydreams or idle fantasies?

Reality as you accept it is a fleeting thing.


Fleeting as it might be, my reality began around the time of my birth and will end at my death. And I've got news for you: Your reality is exactly as fleeting. I share mine with several billion other people, objectively, out here in the open. I have the strength and courage to live life without the guidance, judgement, support, or threats from imaginary friends. I'm not swayed by hollow promises of reward from any gods, nor am I fearful of their retribution. I take responsibility for the good and the bad in my life. I'm not so weak that I have to blame invisible entities for the bad or give them credit for the good. I don't have to make up magical **** in my head in order to fully appreciate my reality. I experience it with a freedom that no devoutly religious person could begin to understand.
 
First, we have to work on concurring on concepts of universe and God.

[ To read the spoiler, click on the boxed words, Spoiler:Show. ]
CGCF-CU stands for the concept of God in the Christian faith
in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
He is the creator of the universe.​


Originally Posted by yrreg
Now, you will say that history proves I have left this forum time and again.

I have not run away but left it in order to be busy with more productive undertakings.

Then I come back again and also now when I have the inspiration to put aside some time to see whether they are atheists here who are like Antony Flew, but so far it is the same people who are always into irrelevancies.


Okay, let us take the expedition to search for God in the universe, by us you atheists and I a theist working on the answers to these questions:

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?

​

---------------------

Hi, Yrreg. Since you and I have never had a discussion here, I'm not the "same people," and I will not "run away."

To answer your questions:
I don't know if the universe has always existed, and I think the question depends upon what you mean by "always existed." If the universe explodes in a Big Bang, expands, contracts, and explodes again over and over forever, does that count as always existing? Or is each explosion a separate universe?

Does the universe create itself? Since I don't know if it always existed, this question is irrelevant, I think. Still, what do you mean by "create"? Does the Big Bang count as the universe creating itself?

God created the universe? Are these questions meant to be sequential or independent? If I don't know whether the universe always existed or not, how could I speculate on who or what may have created it? That aside, I think you would need to define God and demonstrate God's existence before you could logically present Him/Her/It as an explanation for the creation of the universe. Agreed?

Disclaimer: I've not read the rest of the thread, so if you've already answered these questions, please point me to the post. Thanks.



----------------


First, we have to work on us two concurring on the concepts of universe and of God.

What do you say? namely, whether we have to first work together to come to concurrence on the concept of unverse and of God?


I must apologize for missing your post, because I did not read further on after GM whom I invited to tell me what is his information on the CGCF-CU: as I said I am tired of the same people with the same things but not ever daring to examine the CGCF-CU.

Yes, I love to exchange thoughts with you.

So, shall we first work together to come to concurrence on the concept of universe as also of God?


But I fear that eventually you will leave me or take back your words by which we have come to concurrence on some thought.

At this point you will take to irrelevancies and flippancies and bring in penis, masturbation, and spaghetti, unicorn, and sky daddy, etc.

And keep hollering there is no evidence, but you will never either come to concurrence with me (from our common efforts) on what is evidence, what is the target of evidence, and how evidence operates.

No need to argue with me about your eventually running away, and I hope you don't and thus will show yourself to be exceptional for an atheist.


So, who is going to be first to give his concept of universe and of God, you or I?

Since I am sure God exists I have to present my concept of God, and it is the following:
God is the uncreated creator of the universe.​

Now, since I also know that the universe exists and I am part of the universe and I exist, my concept of the universe is the following:
The universe is the totality of created existence.​

Now, please keep in mind that those are my concepts of universe and of God, let me see what you have and we can work on to come to concurrence on our concepts of universe and of God.



Yrreg
 
I expect people to agree on concepts and procedures, otherwise it is all hollering.

[ Useless already answered nth times prattle. ]


This is an open discussion thread, yrreG. You don't get to set the rules.


I expect people interactng with me to first agree on concepts and on procedures, otherwise it is all hollering, and since you are many here and I am only all alone, you will win the hollering contest.



Yrreg
 
If you are happy with your characterization of your lord, I'm happy with it, too.

Any God that is the creator of the universe is The GOD.

That's very vague. Surely you have more attributes for the Christian god that distinguish it from all pretenders, surely. Would the Almighty SingularityTM fit your concept? (As it stands, it would.)

Now you want to add more things to God creator of the universe, you are welcome, but just make sure that they are not incompatible with God creator of the universe, because that is what He is fundamentally in relation to the universe.

Me? No. It is not my object of worship, so its is not my place to add anything. If you are happy with such a vague characterization of your lord, so be it.

So, you will say that God is supposed to be good, merciful, intelligent, etc., but He is not according to your evaluation:

Me? Again, no. You are erecting a strawman. Again, if you are happy with your very limited characterization of your lord, so be it.

...however, first get an authorization from someone with power to authorize you to evaluate, judge God in regard to goodness, mercy, intelligence, etc.

Ok, this genuinely confuses me. Why would I need authorization to form an opinion? No matter. You seem happy with creator of the heavens and the Earth as the only distinguishing characteristics of your object of worship. I can accept that. So, what's next?

Shall we consider the meaning of the term, evidence, next? Ok, great. What do you consider the term to mean?

Progress so far:
  1. Creator of the heavens and Earth are the necessary and sufficient characteristics of the Christian god.
 
According to Orphic tradition the uncreated creators of the universe are Nyx, the night mother, and her husband Protogonos, the lord of light. The two of them arose from Chaos and created the day and the night and all things which exist within them.

According to Hindu tradition this isn't even the first world to exist. However all worlds were made by the uncreated creator Lord Brahma, he who is everything. Tales vary as to exactly how he accomplished this feat but all agree that the world was created out of him and he is the world.

According to Mayan tradition the world was created by the uncreated creator Heart of Sky, the Maker and Modeler. He created the world by speaking it into existence.

I could spend years listing all of the creation myths and deities that have existed in this world. As an outsider I have no reason to view any one of them as better or worse than any other.

Now I give you a simple question yrreg. Why do you insist that your Christian god should be accepted as the only creator deity?
 
Perhaps you want to debate with the authors of the Declaration of Independence?

[ To read the spoiler, click on the boxed words, Spoiler:Show. ]
CGCF-CU stands for the concept of God in the Christian faith
in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
He is the creator of the universe.​



Originally Posted by yrreg
Don't send a post telling people to look up a later post coming next.

Just write the post when you have your thought already made up, and send it.
​
Sorry, I meant this:

In answer to your trichotomy

Universe has always existed?
Universe created itself?
God created the universe?

Originally Posted by arthwollipot
None of the above. The universe began through a purely natural process. It was not created by some third party, it did not "create itself" (whatever that might mean) and it hasn't always been around. This is consistent with all the evidence that humans in their ingenuity have been able to gather.

​



Perhaps you might care to debate with the authors of the Declaration of Independence:

"When in the Course of human Events, it becomes necessary for one People to dissolve the Political Bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the Powers of the Earth, the separate and equal Station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent Respect to the Opinions of Mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the Separation."
-Declaration of Independence (1776)​


So?


You see, when you think about it honestly and completely and ultimately, God is the creator of everything that is not God, including the reason for the independence of a people.



Yrreg
 
Perhaps you might care to debate with the authors of the Declaration of Independence:

"When in the Course of human Events, it becomes necessary for one People to dissolve the Political Bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the Powers of the Earth, the separate and equal Station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent Respect to the Opinions of Mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the Separation."
-Declaration of Independence (1776)​


I'm sorry, but this is one of the stupidest arguments for the existence of God I've heard in a while.
 
Does the bible (assuming it has credibility) ever specifically and without a doubt state that ALL other gods are imaginary? I mean 'imaginary' in that they never did and never will exist in any meaningful way.

Not that I know of.

It states that false gods are man-made, and that worshiping them is worshipping what is created rather than the Creator.

It demonstrates their impotence repeatedly, as though they are not real.

But there is not a definite, direct statement on this point that I know of.
 
Just for fun, you only have to say penis, to reveal your heart and mind.

Anyone read the Discovery article I linked about the theory of the cyclical, always-existing universe? I know Yrreg has not and will not. Anyone else?


Just for fun, you only have to say penis, to reveal your heart and mind.



Just for comic relief.



But do engage in some real original personal thinking.


Instead of shouting penis.


You read a lot of prattle, but nothing genuinely critical and insightful, and nothing of the history of ideas, which could have stirred your brain cells to do some original personal thinking.

Okay, how do yo get out of a maze? And how long?


The man will shout again, penis!



Just for fun only, so don't run to the moderators.




Yrreg
 
Just for fun, you only have to say penis, to reveal your heart and mind.



Just for comic relief.



But do engage in some real original personal thinking.


Instead of shouting penis.


You read a lot of prattle, but nothing genuinely critical and insightful, and nothing of the history of ideas, which could have stirred your brain cells to do some original personal thinking.

Okay, how do yo get out of a maze? And how long?


The man will shout again, penis!



Just for fun only, so don't run to the moderators.




Yrreg



What? :confused:
 
Are you the guy who left God for guiltless masturbation?

[ To read the spoiler, click on the boxed words, Spoiler:Show. ]
CGCF-CU stands for the concept of God in the Christian faith
in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
He is the creator of the universe.​


Originally Posted by yrreg
Irrelevant post, into ignorance again, so I will not bother with you.


Just the same, irrelevant analogy, the existence of the universe is not somebody having stolen something.


Try again, do another analogy.


At the same time, give serious attention to figure out what it is to explain something.


​

In other words, you haven't the slightest comprehension of what I was getting at. I wasn't offering an analogy for the existence of the universe, I was offering an analogy for your simple-minded assumption that one has to offer a specific gnostic claim about the nature of the universe in order to reject your claim. I was attempting to explain to you that it is better to admit that we can't yet know something than to make up an answer. The reason I used a simple analogy was because it is clear that you have difficulty understanding the concept of the null hypothesis. I tried to explain it to you as I would to a child, or an uneducated person who doesn't know enough to mix warm and cold water to get the desired temperature for drinking.


The lady doth protest too much, methinks.



Go, examine the CGCF-CU.



Ah, everyone atheist tells readers that you were just being funny with guiltless masturbation.


That is what is called after the fact.



Yrreg
 
What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?
Redundant - everything includes heaven and earth.
Incoherent - everything includes God.

Oh, have we moved on?
 
How to know the correct concept of God, ask the people who know.

[ To read the spoiler, click on the boxed words, Spoiler:Show. ]
CGCF-CU stands for the concept of God in the Christian faith
in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
He is the creator of the universe.​




[...]

Here they are again:

How do you know that the Christian concept of God is "the correct concept of God"?

Why should all these other supernatural entities be rejected in favour of your own personal concept of "God"?


Perhaps this time you can attempt to address these questions instead of once more running away from them.


That is why it is so frustrating to talk to you guys, because you really don't have any ideas that are relevant except to gripe against Christians.

You ask how do people get to know the correct concept of God?

Logical, ask the people who know, and they will tell you that God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe is the uncreated creator of the universe, I said that already nth times.

Now, you don't want to accept that from Christians, then give them your or what you think is the correct concept, and if it is not what Christians consider to be the uncreated creator of the universe, then you just attack that God which is for you the correct God.

Now, you want me to give equal attention to other gods, spaghetti, unicorn, etc,

I will do that as soon as you understand them to be uncreated creator of the universe, even though you are into unsavory epithets against them.



You guys atheists never come to the ideas which are relevant in the question of God and the universe.

And you keep on repeating what you think are most grievous objections against God, but they are all so silly if you have an honest and independent and averagely keen intelligence to think from the smallest to the biggest pictures of existence.



To everyone atheist just give me one question the most grievously you imagine to be an objection against God's existence, don't go far and wide, and I will answer it -- but I tell you I have already answered them all the nth times in this forum.


Your really don't read anything about the history of ideas of God, but you swallow every gastro-esophageal reflux of your also ignorant mentors who will talk about nothing being the origin of the universe and you also get so excited that finally nothing is the source of the universe, without even doing anything of serious thinking except that the guys who say so claim to be scientists and to be talking scientifically.


My nose!


Now, Mojo, from the words and thoughts you exude to this post I will know again that you are really one ignorant dude in this forum, you got your ideas third fourth fifth nth hand from also ignorant dudes who just gripe against Christians but will not do any serious thinking except perhaps only dissecting some frogs and say that everything came from the primeval soup whatever by the magic of random mutation and natural selection, but forget to remember the Declaration of Independence pronouncing about everything ultimately coming from Nature's God.




Yrreg
 
To everyone atheist just give me one question the most grievously you imagine to be an objection against God's existence, don't go far and wide, and I will answer it -- but I tell you I have already answered them all the nth times in this forum.


No.

The burden of proof is on you, not on atheists.
 
I have already said it nth times, evidence is any fact man knows leading him to...

[...]

Shall we consider the meaning of the term, evidence, next? Ok, great. What do you consider the term to mean?

[...]


On evidence, I have already said it nth times, evidence is any fact man knows leading him to know another fact.


On God, read this spoiler:

[ To read the spoiler, click on the boxed words, Spoiler:Show. ]
CGCF-CU stands for the concept of God in the Christian faith
in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
He is the uncreated creator of the universe.​



I want to talk with Rougarou because he is a new man here, and I do not expect him to have read my posts here from way back.



Suppose everyone atheist here, now that you claim you have the correct information of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe is that God is the uncreated creator of the universe, and you do not want to accept that owing to your freedom of choice even against your cognitive brain, tell me what then is the origin fo the universe?


Okay, every atheist with brain power, think hard what is the origin of the universe.

But first give your concept of the universe, now that you claim to have the correct information of God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.


I will not anymore entertain any other question except this one on what is the origin of the universe if you don't want to admit God as the uncreated creator of the universe.




Yrreg
 
You ask how do people get to know the correct concept of God?

Logical, ask the people who know, and they will tell you that God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe is the uncreated creator of the universe, I said that already nth times.

How do we know which people are "the people who know," as opposed to people who may be mistaken or misinformed?
 
Your move on with nothning as origin of the universe and cognitively self-assured.

Redundant - everything includes heaven and earth.
Incoherent - everything includes God.

Oh, have we moved on?



You move on with nothing as the origin of the universe.

Me, I am staying put and with reasons that God is the uncreated creator of the universe.

Now, you go and tell your fellow atheists and all you atheists drink a toast together that you have found the truth.

No need anymore to buy books from fellow ignorant atheist mentors who write so many words just to say declaratively from ipse dixit that God is a flying spaghetti monster because just as God is not accepted by you to be the uncreated creator of the universe He deserves to be put by you in the same category as flying spaghetti monsters, and you all feel oh so very rational.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom