What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

I cringe when I see Christians playing the victimhood card, especially when they're in the huge majority, as in the US.

Surely, God is big enough to defend himself. If he really, really hates being compared to the FSM, then he could strike down posters with a thunderbolt, rather than getting some Christian poster to whine on his behalf.

If it's on their own behalf that they're concerned, then Christians should be reminded that 'blessed are you when you are persecuted for righteousness' sake ...'. And remember that their martyrdoms hardly compare with those of some of their early co-religionists.

Oh, and they should learn what an analogy is :rolleyes:
Haven't you heard? Rev hopes to be there when his god gives me what for.
 
Surely, God is big enough to defend himself. If he really, really hates being compared to the FSM, then he could strike down posters with a thunderbolt, rather than getting some Christian poster to whine on his behalf.

Maybe he has - but Hell has really good wi-fi connections? ;)

Mind you, it IS Hell, so all the PCs are running Vista. :cool:
 
Oh I explained it in detail. Ya all simply told me that you knew better than I what was an insult to Christians and that I was wrong. Funny it still feels like an insult. One more time and I won't reply to any responses because as I said its an insult to me and every Christian I have asked. Its like this; One black guy may not take offense at the word 'boy' or even 'N' depending who is saying it. Another sure will. So I don't use the N word or call either one of them boy. Its just simple common sense. And courtesy. If it ripps your heart out to respect someones religion by not using religious slurs try to respect the person instead.

You asked me why is the FSM offensive. Its offensive for the same reasons that the N word or boy, or a hangmans noose is offensive to some blacks but not some whites.

; {>

It really is hard to get that last nail in all by yourself. But by all means, feel free to continue the effort to explain how an analogy that illustrates a logical flaw in theistic claims regarding gods is equivalent to expressions of racism.
 
No, its more like going to a Vegas blackjack table and you hitting a 20 and of course betting huge, then the house hits 21 with five cards! Wait it does this a thousand times in a row, every time.

Stop right there -- as soon as you say "thousand times in a row", it's a bad analogy. We are currently the only planet we know of in the universe that contains life in any form, so we only have a single instance of 'success' to compare to.

The analogy is correct up to that point, however... and by definition, it is possible for the house to get five-card-Charlie! It would happen rarely, of course, but it would happen.

The point is that those times when the house does not hit five-card-Charlie... or in this case, when conditions do not produce life... there's nobody around to see it. There is no possible way for us to make observations that does not include the rare occurrence having happened, so we cannot conclude that our existence is not merely the result of a rare occurence simply because we exist.

Wrong I wasn't using it as an argument from authority and it doesn't violate it if it I did. What I was doing was demonstrating that some secular PhDs weren't afraid to admit their true feelings.
The part where it's an argument from authority is the part where the PhDs are drawing conclusions about a field (religion) they are not an expert in, and you are holding their conclusions up as de facto true because of their expertise in the field they are an expert in. I don't care if physics PhDs are atheist, theist, or agnostic; that PhD grants them no paticular credentials to speak with regard to religion any more accurately than I do.

More of words of true scientists and real men
More arguments from authority. Sorry, these are not meaningful as support.
 
Hi! Well the universe should be smooth 'plasma like' with no lumps. No chunky objects like planets stars and humans. Nothing solid.
Citation please.

Yes the universe is hostile for life in many places. We are extremely lucky that we live where we do,in the burbs of the milky way, of course being a theist I feel its more than luck.
This is a good example of reverse reasoning. As in were lucky to live here as this in the only place we know off that supports life......... madness
 
How immensely lucky we must be to have the right type of God. Just imagine a Supreme Being that favors a universe, a creation that to us and our minds would be nothing but a totally inconceivable mess.
 
Hey, RevDistuba, you keep ignoring this question. Let me try again:

So...either the Olympian gods exist or they don't exist. If they exist I should obviously sacrifice to them regularly and perform all the due sacred rites. If they don't exist, I lose nothing by performing those rites. A sane man, then, will believe in the Olympian gods and honor them in the proper ways.

Right, RevDisturba?
 
Hey, RevDistuba, you keep ignoring this question. Let me try again:

So...either the Olympian gods exist or they don't exist. If they exist I should obviously sacrifice to them regularly and perform all the due sacred rites. If they don't exist, I lose nothing by performing those rites. A sane man, then, will believe in the Olympian gods and honor them in the proper ways.

Right, RevDisturba?

Wanna bet?

...

Sorry, couldn't resist.
 
I gave you some evidence for my God, most of it would not apply to the ones mentioned. For example the bible does not apply to the deities mentioned. But you should know that by now.
So you do beleive that the bible is THE TRUTH and that it contains no errors, presuming one knows how to read it?
 
Oh I explained it in detail. Ya all simply told me that you knew better than I what was an insult to Christians and that I was wrong. Funny it still feels like an insult. One more time and I won't reply to any responses because as I said its an insult to me and every Christian I have asked. Its like this; One black guy may not take offense at the word 'boy' or even 'N' depending who is saying it. Another sure will. So I don't use the N word or call either one of them boy. Its just simple common sense. And courtesy. If it ripps your heart out to respect someones religion by not using religious slurs try to respect the person instead.

You asked me why is the FSM offensive. Its offensive for the same reasons that the N word or boy, or a hangmans noose is offensive to some blacks but not some whites.

; {>

So, if you are talking to Muslims, do you say Allah, instead of God? Afterall, it would be highly insulting to them to imply that there is anyother god than Allah or to imply that Mohammed isn't his prophet.

I'm just wondering how far your sensibilities extend.
 
There have been multiple references to the FSM; therefore, Rev Disturbia will no longer respond.

Thank you.
 
No, its more like going to a Vegas blackjack table and you hitting a 20 and of course betting huge, then the house hits 21 with five cards! Wait it does this a thousand times in a row, every time. (actually the example I read was that the house would hit 21 and you 20 dealing one hand a min for more time than has passed from T-0. Now that may still be a bad reason for suspecting the house is cheating by using some kind of logic game, but trust me the house is cheating!
Sounds to me like a variation on the Watchmaker Argument - look at the fine-tuning, what are the chances? we can't think how this could happen - so it must be designed. Basically the same old Argument From Incredulity & Ignorance. The God of the Gaps writ large, ID, etc.

Latest News: God has retreated to the very edge of the beginning of the universe and is hanging on by His holy fingertips.
 
Do any of them even dare consider the idea that all of this was created as a result of God's death? No, of course not.
 
Rev quotes various science guys:

Roger Penrose (mathematician and author): "I would say the universe has a purpose. It's not there just somehow by chance."

Entirely subjective opinion. Where's the evidence?

Tony Rothman (physicist): "When confronted with the order and beauty of the universe and the strange coincidences of nature, it's very tempting to take the leap of faith from science into religion. I am sure many physicists want to. I only wish they would admit it."

This is not the product of a scientific mind. (Lots of guys in science should be elsewhere.)

1. order of the universe What about the chaos of the universe?

2. beauty of the universe Beauty is subjective. It makes sense that omnivores like us would derive pleasure from contemplating a vista of rivers, forests, fields, homes, mountains, oceans -- a magnificent habitat! Even the beauty of the night sky, the sun, the planets -- which give us a notion of vastness -- can please our senses.

3. "I am sure many physicists want to [take the leap from science into religion]. I only wish they would admit it."

Upon what evidence is his certainty based? How does Rothman know these 'many physicists' have something they haven't 'admitted'?

Ellis (British astrophysicist):

"Amazing fine tuning occurs in the laws that make this [complexity] possible."

Begs the question. Implies a designer mind.

The physical world behaves as it behaves. That which is, is -- and that which is not, is not. [According to Parmenides. :-) ]

As for our place in it, evolution theory handles this one quite nicely. We adapted to the environment such as it was. If we hadn't adapted, we wouldn't be here.

[The theistic mind models the scenario otherwise: We were placed here; the 'complexity' was placed here beforehand, to accommodate us. Ellis reveals his theistic bias in the way -- the only way, apparently -- that he imagines the sequence.]

Ellis continues: "Realization of the complexity of what is accomplished makes it very difficult not to use the word 'miraculous' without taking a stand as to the ontological status of the word."

The word 'accomplished' begs the question. We only know what our senses and their extensions, the instruments we created, show us.

"Miraculous"? Why not use the word 'natural'?

"I‘m not saying that the universe is forbidden to use natural processes etc. However I feel that special process ie metaphysical processes etc are a rational and reasonable choice at this point in time."

What on earth is that supposed to mean? The universe "forbidden to use natural processes"? From where does this absurd dualism, natural vs miraculous, come? We see one face presented to us: the face of the universe as seen through our eyes and our instruments.

As for probability, since we don't know how many planets there are in our galaxy, or were, let alone in the universe, or the multiverse, it is very difficult for us to assess the probability of any sequence of events.

As Mojo said, above, "Even if it was a highly improbable outcome at the outset, it's just the way it now is."

We can't calculate the odds.
 
Last edited:
You've yet to explain how references to the FSM are offensive.

Because he says they are. Geeze...:cool:

Not surprising. He accused me of directing hateful speech toward Yrreg, so I asked him if he would be so kind as to indicate a single comment that I'd made regarding Yrreg that could reasonably be described as hateful. He has not responded.

To me, either - only he just accused me of racial, cultural and religious slurs.
 
The posts with references to the FSM and other slurs that are offensive will be answered last, if ever.


The only reason you find references to the FSM offensive is because you know the FSM is a parody of religion. I assume you would not be offended by a Muslim referencing Allah or an Indian referencing Vishnu or a Hare Krishna referencing Krishna.

You could easily do away with references to the FSM by showing that the FSM is a strawman.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom