What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

You asked me why is the FSM offensive. Its offensive for the same reasons that the N word or boy, or a hangmans noose is offensive to some blacks but not some whites.

; {>

Because of the long history of violence, lynchings and slavery suffered by Christians at the hands of the followers of the FSM? What a convincing analogy you draw.
 
Oh I explained it in detail. Ya all simply told me that you knew better than I what was an insult to Christians and that I was wrong. Funny it still feels like an insult. One more time and I won't reply to any responses because as I said its an insult to me and every Christian I have asked. Its like this; One black guy may not take offense at the word 'boy' or even 'N' depending who is saying it. Another sure will. So I don't use the N word or call either one of them boy. Its just simple common sense. And courtesy. If it ripps your heart out to respect someones religion by not using religious slurs try to respect the person instead.

You asked me why is the FSM offensive. Its offensive for the same reasons that the N word or boy, or a hangmans noose is offensive to some blacks but not some whites.

; {>

Sorry, but that's just complete and utter nonsense. The Flying Spaghetti Monster is a satirical way to critize a certain way of thinking, mainly the special pleading so many Christians exhibit. To compare it to racial slurs completely misses the point.
 
Is it all right if we compare the total lack of evidence for your god with the total lack of evidence for Wotan, Zeus, Huitzilopitchli, the Aten, Ganesh, Amaterasu, Marduk, Ashera, Elion, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera...

I gave you some evidence for my God, most of it would not apply to the ones mentioned. For example the bible does not apply to the deities mentioned. But you should know that by now.

However I replied just in case you are having a difficult time getting the concept down pat. All of us are different, some learn faster than others.

; {>
 
Oh I explained it in detail. Ya all simply told me that you knew better than I what was an insult to Christians and that I was wrong. Funny it still feels like an insult.

Then that's your problem. It's not an insult. If you're so insecure as to believe that any argument against the existence of the Christian god is a direct attack on you - or, indeed, any Christians - then you may need to seek professional help.

One more time and I won't reply to any responses because as I said its an insult to me and every Christian I have asked. Its like this; One black guy may not take offense at the word 'boy' or even 'N' depending who is saying it. Another sure will. So I don't use the N word or call either one of them boy. Its just simple common sense. And courtesy.

False analogy. This is not an insult. It is not a racial slur, or indeed even a religious one. It is a simple explanation of why atheists do not believe in God.

If it ripps your heart out to respect someones religion by not using religious slurs try to respect the person instead.

The person is fine. We're attacking the argument. However, in your case, it seems like there's no difference.

You asked me why is the FSM offensive. Its offensive for the same reasons that the N word or boy, or a hangmans noose is offensive to some blacks but not some whites.

; {>

False analogy, for the reasons given above. But if you're determined to see yourself as a victim of hate speech, no one here can stop you from deluding yourself.

No, its more like going to a Vegas blackjack table and you hitting a 20 and of course betting huge, then the house hits 21 with five cards! Wait it does this a thousand times in a row, every time. (actually the example I read was that the house would hit 21 and you 20 dealing one hand a min for more time than has passed from T-0. Now that may still be a bad reason for suspecting the house is cheating by using some kind of logic game, but trust me the house is cheating!

What? How is this a rebuttal? You are restating the exact same argument that remirol just tore down! Repetition does not equal truth.

Wrong I wasn't using it as an argument from authority and it doesn't violate it if it I did.

Yes it does.

What I was doing was demonstrating that some secular PhDs weren't afraid to admit their true feelings. And I HIGHLY respect that, it adds immeasurably to their credibility.

Their credibility as honest people, certainly. They aren't afraid to say what they believe. But it doesn't add to their scientific credibility, I'm afraid. In fact, it detracts from it. When scientists discover something that they cannot immediately explain, they are supposed to search for the answer, not attribute it to some divine being. Doing so sets scientific progress back by hundreds of years.

Hey I sure would like to play you a game of thousand dollar take out...
Five card stud?

Ha ha ...

Really I would.

Once again, repetition does not equal truth.

More of words of true scientists and real men ;

John O'Keefe (astronomer at NASA): "We are, by astronomical standards, a pampered, cosseted, cherished group of creatures.. .. If the Universe had not been made with the most exacting precision we could never have come into existence. It is my view that these circumstances indicate the universe was created for man to live in."

George Greenstein (astronomer): "As we survey all the evidence, the thought insistently arises that some supernatural agency - or, rather, Agency - must be involved. Is it possible that suddenly, without intending to, we have stumbled upon scientific proof of the existence of a Supreme Being? Was it God who stepped in and so providentially crafted the cosmos for our benefit?" (8)

Argument from authority, totally pointless.

; {>[/QUOTE]
 
I love the idea of god, it makes me feel warm and fuzzy in my tummy. The idea of an all powerful benevolent being hovering above me, looking out for me is a wonderful one.

Only problem is, I live in a world of senseless violence that's all sharp edges and bottomless pits with no evidence in my life or experience that any such being exists.

That's why the FSM crops up in these discussions, because it is the creation of the wishful thinking of men; and the people who use it (well the ones who aren't just being insulting) are inviting a direct comparison of the degree of wishful thinking vs evidence for their construct and the degree of wishful thinking vs evidence for your construct.

As such I think the FSM does an admirable job and should be acknowledged and dealt with and not just dismissed as arrant japery on behalf of the atheists.
 
Why do you not believe in Bacchus, Rev?

I have no evidence for the gods of Greek mythology. I had one semester of a course that was related to GM. If I was going to get in tight with any Greek Gods I don't think a drunkard would be the way to go though!

; {>
 
I gave you some evidence for my God, most of it would not apply to the ones mentioned. For example the bible does not apply to the deities mentioned. But you should know that by now.

However I replied just in case you are having a difficult time getting the concept down pat. All of us are different, some learn faster than others.

; {>

Insulting the intelligence of people here doesn't help your case, RevDisturba. It just makes you appear to be an arrogant boob.

As has been said repeatedly, the Bible is not evidence for the existence of God. Here is the argument you present.

REVDISTURBA: God is real! He gave us the Bible!
LOCAL SKEPTICS: How do you know that God exists?
REVDISTURBA: The Bible says so!
LOCAL SKEPTICS: How do you know that the Bible is true?
REVDISTURBA: God says so!

See the circular logic employed there? Holy texts are not acceptable evidence for the existence of divine beings.
What else ya got?
 
I have no evidence for the gods of Greek mythology. I had one semester of a course that was related to GM. If I was going to get in tight with any Greek Gods I don't think a drunkard would be the way to go though!

; {>

Precisely. No evidence. Just as there is no evidence for the FSM, Shiva, Jesus or Jehova (for whom lovely piece of halibut might be good enough...). Now if only Yrreg would answer such a question, he might see where the athiests among us are coming from.
 
I feel the Penrose calculation, and other such mathematical revelations, that suggest that the universe shouldn’t of turned out the way it did (able to support life) are evidence against a sequence of random events that caused the universe to begin to exist.


Given that we're here discussing this, the probability that this particular universe turned out to be capable of supporting life is 1. Even if it was a highly improbable outcome at the outset, it's just the way it now is. Using this as "evidence" that there is some design behind it is just more circular reasoning.
 
Last edited:
I feel the Penrose calculation, and other such mathematical revelations, that suggest that the universe shouldn’t of turned out the way it did (able to support life) are evidence against a sequence of random events that caused the universe to begin to exist. The figures are so extraordinary as to provoke statements such as thes from scientists
Penrose made certain assumptions in those calculations, including that the Universe is closed and cyclic, and that its collapse can be modeled as a black hole.

Since you reject all of those assumptions, you must also reject the calculation.
 
Hi! Well the universe should be smooth 'plasma like' with no lumps. No chunky objects like planets stars and humans. Nothing solid. Yes the universe is hostile for life in many places.
By "many places", you refer to approximately 99.9999999999999999999999999999999999999% of the Universe being swiftly fatal to anything more advanced than a microbe?

We are extremely lucky that we live where we do,in the burbs of the milky way, of course being a theist I feel its more than luck.
There are so many fallacies tangled up in that one sentence that I hardly know where to start.
 
I have no evidence for the gods of Greek mythology. I had one semester of a course that was related to GM. If I was going to get in tight with any Greek Gods I don't think a drunkard would be the way to go though!

; {>

A genocidal maniac is working ok for you, though?
 
Oh I explained it in detail.
Yes. You are wrong.

Ya all simply told me that you knew better than I what was an insult to Christians and that I was wrong.
Yes. You are wrong.

Funny it still feels like an insult.
That's your problem.

One more time and I won't reply to any responses because as I said its an insult to me and every Christian I have asked.
That's your problem (and theirs).

Its like this; One black guy may not take offense at the word 'boy' or even 'N' depending who is saying it.
False analogy.

Another sure will.
False analogy.

So I don't use the N word or call either one of them boy.
No, but you call those who disagree with you Nazis.

Its just simple common sense.
It's a simple false analogy.

And courtesy.
No. In a debate it is not a courtesy to leave assumptions unexamined.

If it ripps your heart out to respect someones religion by not using religious slurs try to respect the person instead.
They are not slurs, not in any way. They are, in fact, valid arguments.

You asked me why is the FSM offensive. Its offensive for the same reasons that the N word or boy, or a hangmans noose is offensive to some blacks but not some whites.
False analogy.
 
I gave you some evidence for my God, most of it would not apply to the ones mentioned. For example the bible does not apply to the deities mentioned. But you should know that by now.
Funnily enough, the Vedas don't mention your God even once. Nor do the Eddas. He's not spoken of in Saiyuki, or the Kalevala. He's quite absent from tales of the Dreaming and the Book of the Dead.

By your argument, Ganesh, Odin, Buddha, Ilmarinen, the Rainbow Serpent and Ptah are real too.
 
Yes. You are wrong.

Yes. You are wrong.

That's your problem.

That's your problem (and theirs).

False analogy.

False analogy.

No, but you call those who disagree with you Nazis.

It's a simple false analogy.

No. In a debate it is not a courtesy to leave assumptions unexamined.

They are not slurs, not in any way. They are, in fact, valid arguments.

False analogy.

Rev has been taught all these things multiple times already and it was generally understood that his finding it offensive is actually his inability to address it.

some learn faster than others.

; {>

Ironic, isn't it?
 
I cringe when I see Christians playing the victimhood card, especially when they're in the huge majority, as in the US.

Surely, God is big enough to defend himself. If he really, really hates being compared to the FSM, then he could strike down posters with a thunderbolt, rather than getting some Christian poster to whine on his behalf.

If it's on their own behalf that they're concerned, then Christians should be reminded that 'blessed are you when you are persecuted for righteousness' sake ...'. And remember that their martyrdoms hardly compare with those of some of their early co-religionists.

Oh, and they should learn what an analogy is :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I gave you some evidence for my God, most of it would not apply to the ones mentioned.
Where was that?

For example the bible does not apply to the deities mentioned. But you should know that by now.
Actually, Ashera and Elion do apply to the Bible in that they are part of the polytheistic roots of Abrahamic monotheism.
 
I have no evidence for the gods of Greek mythology. I had one semester of a course that was related to GM. If I was going to get in tight with any Greek Gods I don't think a drunkard would be the way to go though!

; {>
How many towns and cities were said to have had every man woman and child put to the sword on the command of Bacchus?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom