What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

The point is that those times when the house does not hit five-card-Charlie... or in this case, when conditions do not produce life... there's nobody around to see it. There is no possible way for us to make observations that does not include the rare occurrence having happened, so we cannot conclude that our existence is not merely the result of a rare occurence simply because we exist.
Gee, that's quite too many negatives to make it clear enough. I'd suggest rewriting it with less negativity.

No pun intended ;)
 
..................................NOTICE........................................... ......................................

I am going to triage the replies to my post beginning ummmm' NOW. The posts with references to the FSM and other slurs that are offensive will be answered last, if ever. It will give me more time to post in the sites that are interested in real debate instead of promoting disharmony between religion and science by using ....pseudo skepticism. And it will give me more time to answer the resident members here at JREF that are interested in real debate while applying real skepticism, and critical thinking.



There is just as much evidence for the Flying Spaghetti Monster and the Invisible Pink Unicorn as there is for your god.

The FSM and IPU can be defended with arguents identical to the ones you use to defend your god.

Now that I've gravely offended you, report me. Go on, do it.
If you don't, you are admitting that your claim to offense is unfounded.



Oh I explained it in detail. Ya all simply told me that you knew better than I what was an insult to Christians and that I was wrong. Funny it still feels like an insult. One more time and I won't reply to any responses because as I said its an insult to me and every Christian I have asked. Its like this; One black guy may not take offense at the word 'boy' or even 'N' depending who is saying it. Another sure will. So I don't use the N word or call either one of them boy. Its just simple common sense. And courtesy. If it ripps your heart out to respect someones religion by not using religious slurs try to respect the person instead.

You asked me why is the FSM offensive. Its offensive for the same reasons that the N word or boy, or a hangmans noose is offensive to some blacks but not some whites.

; {>



I was not aware that drawing reference to the Flying Spaghetti Monster was on par with referring to a group of people by use of racial epithet.

For one thing, we are not using the term "Pastafarian" to refer to Christians.
No more than we would use the terms Hindu, Sikh, Zoroastrian or Raelian to refer to Christians.
No more than we would describe the above belief systems in reference to the Christian belief system.
As a point of comparison? Yes.
As a synonym? No.

We address purported belief.

Or is it also offensive to refer to those religious ideas?

Does the concept of people having different beliefs offend you?
Or is it just the ideas which satirize religious belief that offend you?

If satire and parody offend you, I suggest you refrain from reading Kurt Vonnegut or Jonathan Swift.





Short version: I, for one, refuse to pander to your invented sensitivities.
 
Last edited:
Rev quotes various science guys:

Roger Penrose (mathematician and author): "I would say the universe has a purpose. It's not there just somehow by chance."

Entirely subjective opinion. Where's the evidence?
This one isn't subjective, actually. But it's based on specific models of universe formation and collapse, and of universal entropy.

I've noted that at the same time RevD latches on to Penrose's calculations, he rejects the models that Penrose used as the basis for those calculations.

~CAN(HAVE(CAKE) ^ EAT(CAKE))

(Sorry, too lazy to Latex.)
 
Your point being?
There was the claim that God gave Adam an immortal soul, and that is described in the Genesis creation account. I was just trying to point out that Christians who pay attention to the Bible may not agree.
I think you're just trying to show off.
I was trying to support Rev's statement but I think he took it as a rebuttal.
I was already studying this so it was a ready additional comment I could throw in since Rev brought up the subject. There seems to be a confusion with some people about whether there are more than one god and what their relationship is between each other. I think the old Jehovah was the same as who we know as Jesus. We know Jesus as the Son of God, and that is appropriate. But what Rev was saying was that God is Spirit so if there is someone having a form and is representing himself as God, it may be true enough but in a way that is not especially easy to explain.
 
Hey, RevDistuba, you keep ignoring this question. Let me try again:

So...either the Olympian gods exist or they don't exist. If they exist I should obviously sacrifice to them regularly and perform all the due sacred rites. If they don't exist, I lose nothing by performing those rites. A sane man, then, will believe in the Olympian gods and honor them in the proper ways.

Right, RevDisturba?

What if Saturn told you, "Thou shalt not worship any Olympian Gods."? "I am a jealous god and I insist that by worshipping me, you disavow the demands upon you by any other god besides me." "If you worship the other gods, I will cause earthquakes to destroy your houses and volcanoes to choke you with ash."

Would you continue to serve the other gods and call upon yourself the wrath of Saturn, or would you give into his demands and stop worshipping any Olympian god?
 
What if Saturn told you, "Thou shalt not worship any Olympian Gods."? "I am a jealous god and I insist that by worshipping me, you disavow the demands upon you by any other god besides me." "If you worship the other gods, I will cause earthquakes to destroy your houses and volcanoes to choke you with ash."

Would you continue to serve the other gods and call upon yourself the wrath of Saturn, or would you give into his demands and stop worshipping any Olympian god?
Then we'd be dealing with a different question, wouldn't we?

One such question would remain, whether the other gods are real. Saturn's threat does nothing to clarify the question. If they are real, then Saturn's threat is just the beginning of a faith auction or a war of the gods. If they're not real, then there's little for a god of any kind of worth to be jealous of: he'd do a lot better simply to explain the truth and earn his worship than to bluster about earthquakes and volcanoes and hope we don't call his bluff.

But if there were a Saturn, and if Saturn did actually operate by such revelations, and if that were the content of it, then one would not be guessing and basing one's worship on a cost-benefit wager. But if all the above occurred, I'd still wonder why the "real" god is not only a passive aggressive jerk, but an inefficient bumbler, and be inclined not to worship any gods at all.
 
What if Saturn told you, "Thou shalt not worship any Olympian Gods."? "I am a jealous god and I insist that by worshipping me, you disavow the demands upon you by any other god besides me." "If you worship the other gods, I will cause earthquakes to destroy your houses and volcanoes to choke you with ash."

Would you continue to serve the other gods and call upon yourself the wrath of Saturn, or would you give into his demands and stop worshipping any Olympian god?


Well, I guess if Kronos reveals himself to me (you must be one of those upstart Romans to call him by the barbarian name "Saturn") and makes such a command, I'd be a fool to disobey him. There's no future in saying "no" to gods (and precious little in saying "yes"). But then we're no longer in the terms of, um, Paskal's wager are we (you know my buddy Paskal, right? Xenophon's layabout son)? It only makes whatever sense it makes in world of silent gods.
 
What if Saturn told you, "Thou shalt not worship any Olympian Gods."? "I am a jealous god and I insist that by worshipping me, you disavow the demands upon you by any other god besides me." "If you worship the other gods, I will cause earthquakes to destroy your houses and volcanoes to choke you with ash."

Would you continue to serve the other gods and call upon yourself the wrath of Saturn, or would you give into his demands and stop worshipping any Olympian god?

False analogy. We do not have any situation even close to this in the real world. Yoink was making a point similar to the FSM argument.
 
Well, I guess if Kronos reveals himself to me (you must be one of those upstart Romans to call him by the barbarian name "Saturn") and makes such a command, I'd be a fool to disobey him. There's no future in saying "no" to gods (and precious little in saying "yes"). But then we're no longer in the terms of, um, Paskal's wager are we (you know my buddy Paskal, right? Xenophon's layabout son)? It only makes whatever sense it makes in world of silent gods.
Silent God? What if Kronos said, "I am going to be silent for a certain amount of time, and when I wake up, I will bring judgment on those who worship the Olympians."? Would you not worry that the reason he was silent had nothing to with whether he exists or not, or if he was able to fulfil his threats?
 
Silent God? What if Kronos said, "I am going to be silent for a certain amount of time, and when I wake up, I will bring judgment on those who worship the Olympians."? Would you not worry that the reason he was silent had nothing to with whether he exists or not, or if he was able to fulfil his threats?


There would need to be evidence that Kronos actually said that, and not simply some people claiming he said that.
 
Then we'd be dealing with a different question, wouldn't we?
Maybe one the Greeks did not like and maybe a reason why he went to Rome to find believers.

One such question would remain, whether the other gods are real. Saturn's threat does nothing to clarify the question. If they are real, then Saturn's threat is just the beginning of a faith auction or a war of the gods. If they're not real, then there's little for a god of any kind of worth to be jealous of: he'd do a lot better simply to explain the truth and earn his worship than to bluster about earthquakes and volcanoes and hope we don't call his bluff.
Reality of the Olympian's existence does not prove that they have the power to thwart the intentions of an agitated Kronos, or Saturn.
But if there were a Saturn, and if Saturn did actually operate by such revelations, and if that were the content of it, then one would not be guessing and basing one's worship on a cost-benefit wager. But if all the above occurred, I'd still wonder why the "real" god is not only a passive aggressive jerk, but an inefficient bumbler, and be inclined not to worship any gods at all.
Guessing might be a worthwhile endeavor when it was made known but just not recently reiterated, with the intention of catching us who would only worship Saturn out of fear. Only the true believers would be worthy of Saturn sparing his wrath on.
 
Silent God? What if Kronos said, "I am going to be silent for a certain amount of time, and when I wake up, I will bring judgment on those who worship the Olympians."? Would you not worry that the reason he was silent had nothing to with whether he exists or not, or if he was able to fulfil his threats?

Er, if he "said" that, then he wasn't "silent" was he?

Was this some sort of trick question?
 
False analogy. We do not have any situation even close to this in the real world. Yoink was making a point similar to the FSM argument.
Probably. Sorry about subjecting people to a hypothetical but for some reason, I might have a personal concern about missing something. This is something that has been bugging me for a long time, this Kronos character and how much different than some other god, who I should probably not mention, he is.
 
Er, if he "said" that, then he wasn't "silent" was he?

Was this some sort of trick question?

It's not a trick question. Let's say that, for the sake of the discussion, that Kronos revealed a certain amount of information about his intentions and then went into a state of hibernation, to eventually return to see how things were going. So though we have a god who is silent, we have an explanation for why he is silent and it should not be taken as evidence that he does not exist.
 
It's not a trick question. Let's say that, for the sake of the discussion, that Kronos revealed a certain amount of information about his intentions and then went into a state of hibernation, to eventually return to see how things were going. So though we have a god who is silent, we have an explanation for why he is silent and it should not be taken as evidence that he does not exist.

Then, again--assuming that we are quite certain that he made these statements--we're not in a Pascal's Wager situation.

For Pascal's Wager to work (and, of course, it doesn't work, because there is no such thing as a 'generic' god to believe in--which was my point) you have to concede that there is no evidence for the existence of God, but then say it still makes more sense to believe than not to believe because there are penalties for not believing and no penalty (and, indeed, a reward) for believing.
 
It's not a trick question. Let's say that, for the sake of the discussion, that Kronos revealed a certain amount of information about his intentions and then went into a state of hibernation, to eventually return to see how things were going. So though we have a god who is silent, we have an explanation for why he is silent and it should not be taken as evidence that he does not exist.

But this is also a false analogy.

In your hypothetical situation, we know for sure that Kronos is going to wake up. He told us, specifically, that he was going to. In the real world, we have no direct contact with your proposed god. We have only the writings of a few people from thousands of years previously. In addition, it has been proven that these writings have been altered on several occasions. And it has also been proven that many of the sections of the writing are downright lies, or, if they aren't lies, are unintentionally wrong.
 
There would need to be evidence that Kronos actually said that, and not simply some people claiming he said that.

Yes, of course! The sceptical mind at work.
Maybe it is written on the golden fleece at the end of the world?
 
Yes, of course! The sceptical mind at work.
Maybe it is written on the golden fleece at the end of the world?

Bible reference?

Anyway, even if it was written on the golden fleece, or in thirty-foot-high letters of fire on a planet surrounded by souvenir booths, I would require proof that it was actually a message left by Kronos and not simply a document written by people claiming to be his true followers.
What you don't seem to grasp, Ethnikos, is that merely having a holy text doesn't make you right. You have to be able to support that holy text with actual evidence. Otherwise it's just words.
 
Then, again--assuming that we are quite certain that he made these statements--we're not in a Pascal's Wager situation.

For Pascal's Wager to work (and, of course, it doesn't work, because there is no such thing as a 'generic' god to believe in--which was my point) you have to concede that there is no evidence for the existence of God, but then say it still makes more sense to believe than not to believe because there are penalties for not believing and no penalty (and, indeed, a reward) for believing.
I am just presenting the possibility that there is a punishment for believing in gods, if there is a more powerful god who demands that only he shall be worshipped.
Well maybe I am making the same point as you, that there is no such thing as a generic god. But I am not trying to prove a point here. I am curious if there is an answer because I would like to know it myself. Would a non-generic god give anyone credit for believing in a generic god, if there was such a thing. Based on my background as a Christian, the ready answer would be, no.
Suppose Saturn was kicked out of Greece and went to Rome and gave them a jump start into greatness but eventually he was forgotten in the midst of more visually appealing gods. Could not Rome's downfall be attributed to their lack of faith in their founding deity?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom