What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

I am just presenting the possibility that there is a punishment for believing in gods, if there is a more powerful god who demands that only he shall be worshipped.
Well maybe I am making the same point as you, that there is no such thing as a generic god. But I am not trying to prove a point here. I am curious if there is an answer because I would like to know it myself. Would a non-generic god give anyone credit for believing in a generic god, if there was such a thing. Based on my background as a Christian, the ready answer would be, no.
Suppose Saturn was kicked out of Greece and went to Rome and gave them a jump start into greatness but eventually he was forgotten in the midst of more visually appealing gods. Could not Rome's downfall be attributed to their lack of faith in their founding deity?

No.
 
Bible reference?
No. In this hypothetical world where the mythological gods are real, or at least where they might be.
Anyway, even if it was written on the golden fleece, or in thirty-foot-high letters of fire on a planet surrounded by souvenir booths, I would require proof that it was actually a message left by Kronos and not simply a document written by people claiming to be his true followers.
What you don't seem to grasp, Ethnikos, is that merely having a holy text doesn't make you right. You have to be able to support that holy text with actual evidence. Otherwise it's just words.
I guess it would be futile to argue the merits of the fleece since we do not have it to examine, so a copy of the fleece would be out of the question.
 
No, it isn't. The Fleece says "Don't worship Kronos."
I might be looking at the wrong myth. In the Jason story the fleece had some way to show who the legitimate king was. It may have come from an older story about it indicating who the legitimate god was. That is a stretch but you could see why it would be important why who owned this artifact would be important.
 
I am just presenting the possibility that there is a punishment for believing in gods, if there is a more powerful god who demands that only he shall be worshipped.

Is there such a God? And what exactly would make him so angry about it...Is he Jealous? Vindictive? Moody? To me it sounds like God is a 17 year old girl on her period.


Well maybe I am making the same point as you, that there is no such thing as a generic god.

So you're an Atheist about generic Gods.


But I am not trying to prove a point here. I am curious if there is an answer because I would like to know it myself.
Probably no answer, but good luck either way

Would a non-generic god give anyone credit for believing in a generic god, if there was such a thing.
Does god give credit to anyone for ANYTHING?

Suppose Saturn was kicked out of Greece and went to Rome and gave them a jump start into greatness but eventually he was forgotten in the midst of more visually appealing gods.

If a non generic god can't be more visually appealing than a generic one...That makes the nongeneric god sound pretty generic now don't it?

Could not Rome's downfall be attributed to their lack of faith in their founding deity?

Rome's downfall was just a LITTLE more complex than that. Waaay more compex than god.
 
Last edited:
I am just presenting the possibility that there is a punishment for believing in gods, if there is a more powerful god who demands that only he shall be worshipped.
Well maybe I am making the same point as you, that there is no such thing as a generic god. But I am not trying to prove a point here. I am curious if there is an answer because I would like to know it myself. Would a non-generic god give anyone credit for believing in a generic god, if there was such a thing. Based on my background as a Christian, the ready answer would be, no.

O.K., but then the rational person needs some evidence that the "more powerful God" is more likely to exist than some other God. Got any?

It's a bit odd, isn't it, that most people--no matter how rational--end up believing in the God that their parents and their community believes in; except in periods of great social upheaval or change. If there's any evidence at all that would persuade me to believe in a Christian God rather than a Hindu pantheon on the Olympic pantheon or Ba'al or what have you, then it seems odd that this evidence makes no headway with otherwise smart and rational Hindus, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists etc. etc. etc. Don't you think?
 
Would a non-generic god give anyone credit for believing in a generic god, if there was such a thing.

When you start basing your thinking on what people or gods "would" do, you're just guessing... at best. What you are likely doing is making up stuff that agrees with what you want to be true.

Forget about "would", it's a guarantee of failure.
 
Maybe one the Greeks did not like and maybe a reason why he went to Rome to find believers.

Reality of the Olympian's existence does not prove that they have the power to thwart the intentions of an agitated Kronos, or Saturn.
But that was not my point anyway. My point is that Saturn, in your scenario, is claiming to be top god, but not necessarily the only god. While (again, in your scenario only) that might be sufficient, if we had evidence of Saturn's chops, to warrant doing as he says, it remains a poor analogy to the question of worshiping a monotheistic god unless clarified, and presupposes that we do, indeed, have evidence that Saturn can back up his threats.
Guessing might be a worthwhile endeavor when it was made known but just not recently reiterated, with the intention of catching us who would only worship Saturn out of fear. Only the true believers would be worthy of Saturn sparing his wrath on.
That doesn't make any sense at all. In your scenario, the only motivation for worshiping Saturn is fear, since we have (again, only in your scenario as posted) no other reason to assume that he's the only god, or even a better god, than the others. For Saturn then to say he'll punish those who base their actions on his threat, and spare only those who did not need it, would be pathological, and for anyone to base his worship on a guess would fail to satisfy him anyway. If this is the best Saturn can come up with, he's going to have a sparse congregation.
 
Last edited:
You know, guys atheists here, I am -- come to think of it -- I am into getting inputs from you about the God, the concept that is, the existence of which theist Christians must believe in or for Yrreg I know from reason to exist as a fact, in order that we can all atheists and theists start looking for that mutually construed God, that being namely that corresponds to the concept that is that can be acceptable to both atheists and theists, all of the best intentions and best honesty in the quest for God.

But you atheists are not in the quest for God.

Just the same, being fellow humans, because you love fellow humans even theists who are diametrically opposite to yourselves, please simply humor us, and we all with your indulgence and collaboration after we have come to a uniform concept of God, we can all go forth and locate that God.

What do you say to that?





Yrreg

I say bollocks.
 
Just the same, being fellow humans, because you love fellow humans even theists who are diametrically opposite to yourselves, please simply humor us, and we all with your indulgence and collaboration after we have come to a uniform concept of God, we can all go forth and locate that God.

What do you say to that?
I say bollocks.

Bollocks indeed! "We can all go forth and locate God?" And why, pray tell, do you feel the need to have atheists shore up your fading faith?
 
Just a short note to let you vampires..err I mean guys know that I have been seriously Ill. I will return in a few days, if not ...

: {>
 
Just a short note to let you vampires..err I mean guys know that I have been seriously Ill. I will return in a few days, if not ...

: {>

Just a short note to let you lowlife... err I mean nice person, know that yes, I know you are seriously ill. And I do hope you get better.
 
Just a short note to let you vampires..err I mean guys know that I have been seriously Ill. I will return in a few days, if not ...

: {>

Well that certainly is very mature of you. Working your way towards ad homs and other types of behavior. I wouldn't be surprised if you ended up like Biblo and Yrreg.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom