What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

They have taken a most irrevocable vow to their corresponding deity of opposition whatever to the Christian God, to never ever even come to any agreement with theists even just over the concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against.


Yrreg, people have repeatedly told you which gods atheists don't believe in: all of them. And you have repeatedly been told that atheists are not opposed to gods - they merely don't believe in them. Asking them to specify a particular "concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against" is therefore a waste of the bandwidth of this forum, and suggests that you have a lack of reading comprehension.

You, on the other hand, claim to believe in a god. You should therefore, if your claim is true, be able to define the particular god you believe in. If you are prepared to do that, we can then, perhaps, discuss the evidence for the existence of this particular god.

As a believer in a particular god, do you consider yourself to be opposed to all other gods?
 
Actually in the original Hebrew 'I am who I am' is God and 'it' created the universe. The word 'It' automatically defaults to a masculine entity, but the God of the Hebrews and my god has no form because it is a spirit. It manifests in the temporal universe, the time dependent universe almost exclusively by envoy, by some temporal agent, like Jesus, a man or the bush that fire does not consume, or disembodied voices, dreams and visions.
Isaiah 40:18 "To whom then will you liken God? Or what likeness will you compare with Him?"
The Hebrew for god in this verse, is 'el, which basically means god.
In the verses of Genesis that tell about man being made in God's likeness, the word for god is 'elohiym, which is a word that can be used to designate something that is not actually the God.
1 Samuel 3:3 "and the lamp of God had not yet been extinguished. Samuel was lying down in the temple of the Lord as well; the ark of God was also there."
Here the word for God is 'elohiym and for Lord is Y@hovah. So you have a lamp and an ark of 'elohiym, but the whole temple is of a specific god, Y@hovah. The more specific something is in the physical sense, the less specific it seems to be in the spiritual. At least that is how it looks to me. So, in the more specific Genesis description of what can be reversed to imply that God can be seen as being similar to man, the least specific version for god is used.
 
Last edited:
Whatever; this is just semantics. How do you know that an entity necessarily created the universe, rather than a sequence of random events?

I feel the Penrose calculation, and other such mathematical revelations, that suggest that the universe shouldn’t of turned out the way it did (able to support life) are evidence against a sequence of random events that caused the universe to begin to exist. The figures are so extraordinary as to provoke statements such as thes from scientists ;

Roger Penrose (mathematician and author): "I would say the universe has a purpose. It's not there just somehow by chance." (11)

Tony Rothman (physicist): "When confronted with the order and beauty of the universe and the strange coincidences of nature, it's very tempting to take the leap of faith from science into religion. I am sure many physicists want to. I only wish they would admit it." (12)

Ellis (British astrophysicist): "Amazing fine tuning occurs in the laws that make this [complexity] possible. Realization of the complexity of what is accomplished makes it very difficult not to use the word 'miraculous' without taking a stand as to the ontological status of the word."

I‘m not saying that the universe is forbidden to use natural processes etc. However I feel that special process ie metaphysical processes etc are a rational and reasonable choice at this point in time.

; {>
 
..................................NOTICE........................................... ......................................

I am going to triage the replies to my post beginning ummmm' NOW. The posts with references to the FSM and other slurs that are offensive will be answered last, if ever. It will give me more time to post in the sites that are interested in real debate instead of promoting disharmony between religion and science by using ....pseudo skepticism. And it will give me more time to answer the resident members here at JREF that are interested in real debate while applying real skepticism, and critical thinking.

I would like to thank those of you that did participate in good insult free debate from the start. However, your name escapes me just about now. Or if not completely insult free, there were some of you that had the common sense to use just enough flame to keep it interesting. Most of all thanks to those that changed your style to meet me in the middle. I'm not going anywhere (I hope), Just slowing down and answering the posts/replies from those of you that want debate instead of exchanging insults and other toxic endeavors.

; {>

; }>
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I feel the Penrose calculation, and other such mathematical revelations, that suggest that the universe shouldn’t of turned out the way it did (able to support life) are evidence against a sequence of random events that caused the universe to begin to exist.
Two points:
1. How else should it have turned out?
2. So far as we know the universe is very hostile to life.
 
shouldn't have

Whatever. :o Trust me, when I slap most of the replies up on the WP they light up with bright red highlights and little ziggley lines indicating bad grammer' and spellin' errors...I ain't wrried bout it most of the times'

But thanks for your considerations' :o

; {>
 
Good luck if you can see the difference between this colour and white!" they wrote.

"Suggestions for the name are welcome. As long as it is not 'beige'!"


It is magnolia :(.

I wonder if it smells of coffee, too

God is an estate agent, it seems
 
Two points:
1. How else should it have turned out?
2. So far as we know the universe is very hostile to life.

Hi! Well the universe should be smooth 'plasma like' with no lumps. No chunky objects like planets stars and humans. Nothing solid. Yes the universe is hostile for life in many places. We are extremely lucky that we live where we do,in the burbs of the milky way, of course being a theist I feel its more than luck.

; }>
 
I feel the Penrose calculation, and other such mathematical revelations, that suggest that the universe shouldn’t of turned out the way it did (able to support life) are evidence against a sequence of random events that caused the universe to begin to exist.

This is a variant of the standard argument "Of course we must have been created -- the odds are so far against any given planet supporting life that for life to be here, we must have been put here on purpose!"

And, like that other argument, it falls over when you consider that in all cases where the odds did _not_ hit the small chance to produce life on a planet, there is no life there to notice it. In other words, the only way we could ask the question in the first place is de facto as part of the case where the odds turned out in favor of producing life -- so using our own unlikely existence as evidence that there must be a creator is inaccurate.

The figures are so extraordinary as to provoke statements such as thes from scientists *snipped*

ad authoritam, sorry. Scientists are experts in their _scientific_ field, but the fact that some draw religious conclusions about the evidence holds no weight as to the existence of any given god.
 
..................................NOTICE...........................................

I am going to triage the replies to my post beginning ummmm' NOW. The posts with references to the FSM and other slurs that are offensive will be answered last, if ever. It will give me more time to post in the sites that are interested in real debate instead of promoting disharmony between religion and ....pseudo skepticism. And it will give me more time to answer the resident members here at JREF that are interested in real debate while applying real skepticism, and critical thinking.

I would like to thank those of you that did participate in good insult free debate from the start. However, your name escapes me just about now. Or if not completely insult free, there were some of you that had the common sense to use just enough flame to keep it interesting. Most of all thanks to those that changed your style to meet me in the middle. I'm not going where (I hope) Just slowing down and answering the post form those of you that want debate instead of exchanging insults and other toxic endeavors.

; {>

; }>

Is it all right if we compare the total lack of evidence for your god with the total lack of evidence for Wotan, Zeus, Huitzilopitchli, the Aten, Ganesh, Amaterasu, Marduk, Ashera, Elion, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You've yet to explain how references to the FSM are offensive.

Not surprising. He accused me of directing hateful speech toward Yrreg, so I asked him if he would be so kind as to indicate a single comment that I'd made regarding Yrreg that could reasonably be described as hateful. He has not responded.
 
You've yet to explain how references to the FSM are offensive.

Oh I explained it in detail. Ya all simply told me that you knew better than I what was an insult to Christians and that I was wrong. Funny it still feels like an insult. One more time and I won't reply to any responses because as I said its an insult to me and every Christian I have asked. Its like this; One black guy may not take offense at the word 'boy' or even 'N' depending who is saying it. Another sure will. So I don't use the N word or call either one of them boy. Its just simple common sense. And courtesy. If it ripps your heart out to respect someones religion by not using religious slurs try to respect the person instead.

You asked me why is the FSM offensive. Its offensive for the same reasons that the N word or boy, or a hangmans noose is offensive to some blacks but not some whites.

; {>
 
This is a variant of the standard argument "Of course we must have been created -- the odds are so far against any given planet supporting life that for life to be here, we must have been put here on purpose!"

And, like that other argument, it falls over when you consider that in all cases where the odds did _not_ hit the small chance to produce life on a planet, there is no life there to notice it. In other words, the only way we could ask the question in the first place is de facto as part of the case where the odds turned out in favor of producing life -- so using our own unlikely existence as evidence that there must be a creator is inaccurate.

No, its more like going to a Vegas blackjack table and you hitting a 20 and of course betting huge, then the house hits 21 with five cards! Wait it does this a thousand times in a row, every time. (actually the example I read was that the house would hit 21 and you 20 dealing one hand a min for more time than has passed from T-0. Now that may still be a bad reason for suspecting the house is cheating by using some kind of logic game, but trust me the house is cheating!

ad authoritam, sorry. Scientists are experts in their _scientific_ field, but the fact that some draw religious conclusions about the evidence holds no weight as to the existence of any given god.

Wrong I wasn't using it as an argument from authority and it doesn't violate it if it I did. What I was doing was demonstrating that some secular PhDs weren't afraid to admit their true feelings. And I HIGHLY respect that, it adds immeasurably to their credibility.

Hey I sure would like to play you a game of thousand dollar take out...
Five card stud?

Ha ha ...

Really I would.

More of words of true scientists and real men ;

John O'Keefe (astronomer at NASA): "We are, by astronomical standards, a pampered, cosseted, cherished group of creatures.. .. If the Universe had not been made with the most exacting precision we could never have come into existence. It is my view that these circumstances indicate the universe was created for man to live in."

George Greenstein (astronomer): "As we survey all the evidence, the thought insistently arises that some supernatural agency - or, rather, Agency - must be involved. Is it possible that suddenly, without intending to, we have stumbled upon scientific proof of the existence of a Supreme Being? Was it God who stepped in and so providentially crafted the cosmos for our benefit?" (8)

; {>
 
Last edited:
Gen. 2:7, The Lord God formed the man from the soil of the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and the man became a living being.
In the King James Version, the word translated here as being is given as soul. The strict transliteration from the Hebrew is spnl. Of the ten other Bible verses that use that spelling, nine could be understood to mean the physical body. Of those nine, one could be considered being in the balance between life and death, and six are specified as being dead.
So the idea that the "soul" is immortal can not be rightly derived from this verse, in my opinion.

Your point being?

Isaiah 40:18 "To whom then will you liken God? Or what likeness will you compare with Him?"
The Hebrew for god in this verse, is 'el, which basically means god.
In the verses of Genesis that tell about man being made in God's likeness, the word for god is 'elohiym, which is a word that can be used to designate something that is not actually the God.
1 Samuel 3:3 "and the lamp of God had not yet been extinguished. Samuel was lying down in the temple of the Lord as well; the ark of God was also there."
Here the word for God is 'elohiym and for Lord is Y@hovah. So you have a lamp and an ark of 'elohiym, but the whole temple is of a specific god, Y@hovah. The more specific something is in the physical sense, the less specific it seems to be in the spiritual. At least that is how it looks to me. So, in the more specific Genesis description of what can be reversed to imply that God can be seen as being similar to man, the least specific version for god is used.

See above comment. I think you're just trying to show off.

I feel the Penrose calculation, and other such mathematical revelations, that suggest that the universe shouldn’t of turned out the way it did (able to support life) are evidence against a sequence of random events that caused the universe to begin to exist.

How else should it have turned out?

The figures are so extraordinary as to provoke statements such as thes from scientists ;

Roger Penrose (mathematician and author): "I would say the universe has a purpose. It's not there just somehow by chance." (11)

Tony Rothman (physicist): "When confronted with the order and beauty of the universe and the strange coincidences of nature, it's very tempting to take the leap of faith from science into religion. I am sure many physicists want to. I only wish they would admit it." (12)

Ellis (British astrophysicist): "Amazing fine tuning occurs in the laws that make this [complexity] possible. Realization of the complexity of what is accomplished makes it very difficult not to use the word 'miraculous' without taking a stand as to the ontological status of the word."

Argument from authority.

I‘m not saying that the universe is forbidden to use natural processes etc. However I feel that special process ie metaphysical processes etc are a rational and reasonable choice at this point in time.

; {>

You're the only one, then.
See, Rev, the thing you fail to understand is this:
The odds against the universe turning out in this exact way are astronomical, yes. But the odds against it turning out any other way are equally astronomical. It had to turn out some way. If it had turned out another way instead, all the little Garblefreejans would be sitting on the Jaxon Remdi Educational Foundation website forums right now and talking about how unlikely it is that the universe came to contain Garblefreejan life.

..................................NOTICE...........................................

I am going to triage the replies to my post beginning ummmm' NOW. The posts with references to the FSM and other slurs that are offensive will be answered last, if ever.

NOTICE: This post contains a reference to the FSM, but only a very slight one. And it's a direct reply to that part of your post, not used as an argument. So I'd be much obliged if you would at least read it.

If you are determined to see the Flying Spaghetti Monster as an insult to your religion, that's your choice. But understand what it looks like from our side. You have come here claiming to want free, unhindered, civilized debate. But right off the bat you have ruled out our ability to use one of our most potent arguments on the grounds that it offends you. Well, I personally don't mind not referencing the FSM or the IPU since I didn't use them in the first place anyway, but you're being unnecessarily difficult and I wouldn't be surprised if several of the other members of the forum leave the thread right now. It would be their right.

It will give me more time to post in the sites that are interested in real debate instead of promoting disharmony between religion and science by using ....pseudo skepticism.

You would be hard-pressed to find a site more interested in real debate than the JREF. I would be interested in looking at these sites, though. Could you give links?
No one here is "promoting disharmony". You have simply defined "promoting disharmony" as "disagreeing with RevDisturba or Yrreg". We are simply providing rebuttals to your arguments. If you don't like being on the losing side of a debate, I suggest that you leave, because you're not going to win this one.

And it will give me more time to answer the resident members here at JREF that are interested in real debate while applying real skepticism, and critical thinking.

Now you've gone and insulted everyone here. Oh dear.
My good Reverend, I must say that, for someone as apparently worried about insults as yourself, you make an awful lot of them.

I would like to thank those of you that did participate in good insult free debate from the start. However, your name escapes me just about now. Or if not completely insult free, there were some of you that had the common sense to use just enough flame to keep it interesting. Most of all thanks to those that changed your style to meet me in the middle. I'm not going anywhere (I hope), Just slowing down and answering the posts/replies from those of you that want debate instead of exchanging insults and other toxic endeavors.

It appears that RevD suffers from the same Compulsive Flaming Disorder as Yrreg. Is there any known cure?

Hi! Well the universe should be smooth 'plasma like' with no lumps. No chunky objects like planets stars and humans. Nothing solid.

In the beginning, yes. When the Big Bang had just happened and everything was speeding away from everything else.
But there are only so many directions that you can take from a central point, and there's lots of matter in our universe. This matter had limited choices as to which way to go when the single point that it had existed in prior to the Bang exploded. After the Bang, the matter which took similar paths was drawn together, via a force known as gravity. Perhaps you've heard of it?

Yes the universe is hostile for life in many places. We are extremely lucky that we live where we do,in the burbs of the milky way, of course being a theist I feel its more than luck.

; }>

Okay, here's what I'm getting as your argument.
POINT ONE: Most of the universe is incapable of supporting life.
POINT TWO: Earth is a very small place in the universe capable of supporting life.
POINT THREE: Life exists on Earth.
CONCLUSION: We are extremely lucky that life formed on Earth. So lucky, in fact, that it's impossible that it happened on its own. Someone must have made sure that life formed on Earth as opposed to somewhere else.

:drool:

The argument works fine up until the conclusion. You say that we're lucky that life formed on Earth. I say that it's impossible for it to have formed anywhere else (well, there may be other Earth-type planets, but whatever - you know what I mean). Therefore, if life was going to form at all, it had to have been on Earth. Therefore, not such a huge defiance of the odds after all.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom