What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.


That's probably because you merely do a 'search and find' on the phrase, "I believe in God Almighty!", in which case, you will probably see this post.

Several posters - including me - have accepted your definition of God for the purposes of moving forward. This is where you insert evidence of its existence.

We're waiting...
 
I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

They have taken a most irrevocable vow to their corresponding deity of opposition whatever to the Christian God, to never ever even come to any agreement with theists even just over the concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against.

It is a phenomenon similar to the fear of Dracula for the crucifix.

And in a humorous vein, Dracula also fears garlic.





Yrreg

That is so bizarrely off the mark, innacurate and disingenuous that I wonder if we're even reading the same posts (well, I guess not, since you admit to skipping many of them).

Phase Inverter accepted your definition and tentatively added some rather detailed suggestions for making it compatible with conventional definitions used by Christians. I and many others have accepted your definition as a basis for discussion even though I believe that it is a poor one for reasons I have repeatedly expressed. Nonetheless I, like many others in this thread, have stipulated that this definition would be fine as a basis for discussing whether the entity thus defined actually exists as defined. In other words, if you believe what you posted above, you're just plain wrong.

I will reiterate. I am ready to discuss the existence and attributes of an entity we are calling "God," which entity is defined as the creator of everything that there is (except, of course himself)*. I do not think such a god exists, in part because I think that further inquiry into the attributes necessary for such a god to exist as defined would lead to the conclusion that such a god is impossible. But if you want to discuss the god you have defined, get to it and stop complaining.

If you would rather discuss the psychology of belief versus nonbelief, and how theists and atheists differ emotionally, that's fine too, but it is not the subject of this thread, and never should have come up.

*edit to add: For discussion purposes, the definition need not fill all logical holes, be true, or be possible. You can define "everything" any way you please. The usual sense of "everything" in theistic discussions is the whole physical universe and any non-physical realms that might exist, whether their existence is itself acknowledged or not, and any laws, plans, designs or destinies that are inherent in such things, whether or not they really exist - in other words, I would see no reason for specifying the contents of creation in order to accept the definition of god as the creator of everything.
 
Last edited:
But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

They have taken a most irrevocable vow to their corresponding deity of opposition whatever to the Christian God, to never ever even come to any agreement with theists even just over the concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against.


We understand and accept your definition of God for the purposes of this discussion. Now convince us that such an entity exists.
 
And now yrreg proceeds to ignore this post entirely.
What post?

Didn't you know that Yrreg is an Arepliest. He doesn't believe that anyone replies to him, so he ignores the evidence that they do.

It's because he's angry at repliers.
 
Rev is saying what all Christian theists in these times say. And probably what Christian theists always said:

"By his image he meant that Adam became self aware and had a eternal soul (a gift from God). The full Hebrew version is more revealing than the English translation (s). He made sure to indicate that his body is just that (star) dust and to dust it would return.:

How do you know what he meant? We have only one statement in Genesis, and no significant variation in translations.

It's not just that you think your god made man in his image; the text says "... let us make man in our image, in our likeness..."

So that means that the god-makers, the priests and gurus, imagined the creator as manlike in form.

Now they're trying to sell us that that god was also the "perfect designer".

Ha ha ha ha ha Ha ha ha ha ha Ha ha ha ha ha Ha ha ha ha ha Ha ha ha ha ha Ha ha ha ha ha !
 
Unless it pisses off the Egyptian pantheon.

And let's not forget those pesky Norse gods, either. Thor and Odin were some real short-tempered cats, from what I read, and you wouldn't want an electric hammer up your butt.

The Aztec gods could also get pretty nasty, and don't forget Pele. And Kali just starts out nasty, best I can tell.

I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

They have taken a most irrevocable vow to their corresponding deity of opposition whatever to the Christian God, to never ever even come to any agreement with theists even just over the concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against.

It is a phenomenon similar to the fear of Dracula for the crucifix.

And in a humorous vein, Dracula also fears garlic.

This is simply incoherent.
 
Last edited:
Various posts by Yrreg:

"What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God. Yrreg"

Gerry, it's not that you have a CONCEPT of your god that we deny. It is the real existence of this god that we deny.

What I believe is that there was a religion, Judaism, that existed, and it had one god the Jews called the "Lord". And, like most ethnic groups, it claimed that its god created everything, and could affect the fate of individuals and of nations.

That religion broke up into many sects. Like sects today, each was slightly different from all the others, yet each claimed to teach only absolute truths.

One of Judaism's many prophecies was that a messiah would be born who would lead the Jews out of their oppression and make them the world-dominant nation.

Many men believed they were the Messiah. Or pretended to, so they wouldn't have to work hard for a living.

One of them, Jesus, started a sect claiming that he was the messiah. But he failed to meet the expectations that the Jews had for the Messiah, so they decided he was a blasphemer to have claimed to be the Messiah.

Jesus was killed.

A small group of Jews still believed Jesus was the messiah. But they were harrassed and gaining few followers among the Jews.

But Paul, who had never met Jesus, decided to make Jesusism (Christianity) a religion for all nations. Its promise of bliss eternal and eternal life in return for simply believing the Jesus was in fact the same god as the Lord, sounded like a really good deal. So many gentiles were won over, especially among the slaves and poorest people. The rest we know.

But Jesus was just a man, and the Lord was a creation of the early Jewish mythmakers.

So to answer your question, this is the Christian god we don't believe in. He is "existing" as a mythical and historical figure, but not as a being with power and a personality and the ability to affect anything.

--------------

Later, Yrreg posts:

"You see, atheists, again you try to evade the question, not only try but actually avoiding the issue, instead going into what I call genuine pseudo arguments of bad mouthing God, laughing at God, and insisting you don't know nothing about the concept of God as understood by Christians.'

We don't badmouth your god. We simply don't believe there is anything real behind your statues and colored pictures of the Lord, Jesus and the Holy Dove.

When I say that Spock's mythical planet Vulcan doesn't exist, I'm not badmouthing it. I just think it's imaginary. Like your god.

--------------------------
Gerry also posted:

" ... atheists, you have been saying since shall we say eternity that you lack belief in God or gods, but you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists, and to understand what you read in writings directed against God."

Okay, Gerry, here it is. The definition you've been waiting for.

This is my concept of the god I don't believe in:

"An imaginary being to whom is attributed the power to create the universe and control every aspect of it."

But I also are other gods I don't believe in:

"In the beginning there was an empty darkness. The only thing in this void was Nyx, a bird with black wings. With the wind she laid a golden egg and for ages she sat upon this egg. Finally life began to stir in the egg and out of it rose Eros, the god of love. One half of the shell rose into the air and became the sky and the other became the Earth. Eros named the sky Uranus and the Earth he named Gaia. Then Eros made them fall in love." [The result of their love was all the living things in creation.]

This also is a concept of some gods but I don't believe in them.

I could go on. There are thousands and thousands of gods I don't believe in. I think people made them up, to explain where everything came from to their children, without saying "I don't know," and sounding dumb. People don't like to sound dumb in front of their children. It's just a human trait.
 
Last edited:
Various posts by Yrreg:

"What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God. Yrreg"

Gerry, it's not that you have a CONCEPT of your god that we deny. It is the real existence of this god that we deny.

What I believe is that there was a religion, Judaism, that existed, and it had one god the Jews called the "Lord". And, like most ethnic groups, it claimed that its god created everything, and could affect the fate of individuals and of nations.

That religion broke up into many sects. Like sects today, each was slightly different from all the others, yet each claimed to teach only absolute truths.

One of Judaism's many prophecies was that a messiah would be born who would lead the Jews out of their oppression and make them the world-dominant nation.

Many men believed they were the Messiah. Or pretended to, so they wouldn't have to work hard for a living.

One of them, Jesus, started a sect claiming that he was the messiah. But he failed to meet the expectations that the Jews had for the Messiah, so they decided he was a blasphemer to have claimed to be the Messiah.

Jesus was killed.

A small group of Jews still believed Jesus was the messiah. But they were harrassed and gaining few followers among the Jews.

But Paul, who had never met Jesus, decided to make Jesusism (Christianity) a religion for all nations. Its promise of bliss eternal and eternal life in return for simply believing the Jesus was in fact the same god as the Lord, sounded like a really good deal. So many gentiles were won over, especially among the slaves and poorest people. The rest we know.

But Jesus was just a man, and the Lord was a creation of the early Jewish mythmakers.

So to answer your question, this is the Christian god we don't believe in. He is "existing" as a mythical and historical figure, but not as a being with power and a personality and the ability to affect anything.

--------------

Later, Yrreg posts:

"You see, atheists, again you try to evade the question, not only try but actually avoiding the issue, instead going into what I call genuine pseudo arguments of bad mouthing God, laughing at God, and insisting you don't know nothing about the concept of God as understood by Christians.'

We don't badmouth your god. We simply don't believe there is anything real behind your statues and colored pictures of the Lord, Jesus and the Holy Dove.

When I say that Spock's mythical planet Vulcan doesn't exist, I'm not badmouthing it. I just think it's imaginary. Like your god.

--------------------------
Gerry also posted:

" ... atheists, you have been saying since shall we say eternity that you lack belief in God or gods, but you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists, and to understand what you read in writings directed against God."

Okay, Gerry, here it is. The definition you've been waiting for.

This is my concept of the god I don't believe in:

"An imaginary being to whom is attributed the power to create the universe and control every aspect of it."

But I also are other gods I don't believe in:

"In the beginning there was an empty darkness. The only thing in this void was Nyx, a bird with black wings. With the wind she laid a golden egg and for ages she sat upon this egg. Finally life began to stir in the egg and out of it rose Eros, the god of love. One half of the shell rose into the air and became the sky and the other became the Earth. Eros named the sky Uranus and the Earth he named Gaia. Then Eros made them fall in love." [The result of their love was all the living things in creation.]

This also is a concept of some gods but I don't believe in them.

I could go on. There are thousands and thousands of gods I don't believe in. I think people made them up, to explain where everything came from to their children, without saying "I don't know," and sounding dumb. People don't like to sound dumb in front of their children. It's just a human trait.


Very good post. It's a pity yrreg is unlikely to ever read it.
 
I was fairly sure I would get that ‘its really an analogy’ type answers/rebuttals. So considering the outside chance that some of you may of rationalized yourselves, or been brainwashed by someone that has taught you falsehoods from childbirth and kept you locked in a closet 24/7 I would attempt to clarify what the difference is between making an analogy and making an insult.

I am sure that many of you really mean it when you say that the bible is a fairy tale. I have no doubt when you say the FSM is the same thing as God in your mind. However this isn’t the issue. Again you may really think in your heart that some races look like an ape. Or that the N word is appropriate. Or that calling a black guy boy is ok. Or you may think that flying a rebel flag is your right its about tradition not racist. However much of society has said that its wrong to use most of these terms. You shouldn’t call a gay person a faggot or even a queer right? Why not? The reason is two fold. One is the intent. Second society has said that these words and concepts are wrong hateful and racist and are designed to provoke or to harm.

The favorite comeback is that well I don’t mean it as an insult. That may well be true, however calling a gay person a faggot because you were raised that way is no excuse. Then if a gay person points out your ignorance and tells you that ’faggot’ is an derogatory word that is highly offensive to him and the gay community, and you still use it that can only mean that you are trying to harm or provoke gays.

Its worse in the case of say, racism if a good ole boy calls a black guy a ’boy’. Why? Because traditionally the south has had a confrontational relationship with blacks. The same goes for atheists and Christians. When you are on a site that has topics such as” Religion: The Root of All Evil “ or Studies in Crap (religious issues being the crap) its obvious that a confrontational environment exists. So it sounds a bit of disingenuous when an atheist claims that he was not attempting to provoke by using terms and concepts that the dullest short bus Belleview resident type person would recognize as an insult. I will be indicating some of the more blatant offenders with the hopes of enhanced awareness will, if not diminish the use of said derogatory terms, at least expose the haters for what they are. They will not be able to claim ignorance any longer, and ignorance of the law has never been an excuse.

; }>


I'm sorry.

How, exactly, is referring to the Flying Spaghetti Monster, te Invisible Pink Unicorn, Russel's Teapot, faeries, etc insulting?

Saying that the evidence for the existence of your chosen god is as compelling as the evidence for any of the above entities/objects is not the same as calling an African (or African-elsewhere) individual the n-word. Nor is it the same as calling a homosexual the 6-letter f-word (or its 3-letter short version).

Comparing belief is not the same as using derogatory slang.

In referencing the concept of the FSM, the IPU, or whatever else may be used, we are not calling you names.

There is no insult.

Only your desire to be a victim.





<snip>

But you atheists are not in the quest for God.

<snip>


Correct. At least, the quoted bit is.

Atheists are not on a quest for god.
By and large, we don't care. Couldn't be bothered.
God is unimportant and unnecessary in out lives.



And does anyone else here have the horrible feeling that yrreg is going to latch onto the above as evidence that we reject god out of malice?

I'll dispel that notion now (although te chances of yrreg actually reading more than what he wants to hear are remote):

I general, atheists don't believe in gods because there is no evidence for the existence of gods.

This applies to all god concepts, not just the Christian ones.

We don't beleive, because, without evidence, there is not reason to believe.

We don't believe, because the arguments provided by theistic apologists are, for the most part, inane, absurd, nonsensical, illogical and/or factually wrong.

We don't accept these arguments because the arguments themselves don't warrant acceptance. Not because of any malice or fear.

As a skeptic, I don't accept illogical, absurd or inane arguments for anything. God, in this regard, is not special. I reject homoeopathy, chiropractic, 9/11 truthers, moon-landing hoax arguments, Holocaust denialism, a great may product sales pitches, and the claim that a cat downloaded 1000's of images of child pornography, for the same reasons.
 
I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

Yrreg

Of course you haven't. You never have in the past either, so you have not got a clue what anybody else knows or wishes to discuss (this is a discussion forum after all) and you are just talking to yourself.

I bet you did not even read the posts from another Christian on this thread who started off supporting you, but has since made comments that YOU are not even a Christian!

That's what makes you a self-centrered arrogant a-troll.

norm
 
Last edited:
Quoting from an excellent post:
Later, Yrreg posts:

"You see, atheists, again you try to evade the question, not only try but actually avoiding the issue, instead going into what I call genuine pseudo arguments of bad mouthing God, laughing at God, and insisting you don't know nothing about the concept of God as understood by Christians.'

We don't badmouth your god. We simply don't believe there is anything real behind your statues and colored pictures of the Lord, Jesus and the Holy Dove.

When I say that Spock's mythical planet Vulcan doesn't exist, I'm not badmouthing it. I just think it's imaginary. Like your god.

--------------------------

It seems yrreg can't accept the idea atheists don't 'reject' God from hatred, rebellion or cussedness.
'God' simply doesn't enter the equation.
Or in other words:
'Belief in God' is NOT the default position.
 
"By his image he meant that Adam became self aware and had a eternal soul (a gift from God). The full Hebrew version is more revealing than the English translation (s). He made sure to indicate that his body is just that (star) dust and to dust it would return.
Gen. 2:7, The Lord God formed the man from the soil of the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and the man became a living being.
In the King James Version, the word translated here as being is given as soul. The strict transliteration from the Hebrew is spnl. Of the ten other Bible verses that use that spelling, nine could be understood to mean the physical body. Of those nine, one could be considered being in the balance between life and death, and six are specified as being dead.
So the idea that the "soul" is immortal can not be rightly derived from this verse, in my opinion.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom