What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

20 pages for such an easy question?

What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

this part

"maker of heaven and earth and everything?"

must be

God: belived by some, to be the maker of heaven and earth and everything.
 
So...either the Olympian gods exist or they don't exist. If they exist I should obviously sacrifice to them regularly and perform all the due sacred rites. If they don't exist, I lose nothing by performing those rites. A sane man, then, will believe in the Olympian gods and honor them in the proper ways.

Unless it pisses off the Egyptian pantheon.
 
Last edited:
Unless it pisses off the Egyptian pantheon.

And let's not forget those pesky Norse gods, either. Thor and Odin were some real short-tempered cats, from what I read, and you wouldn't want an electric hammer up your butt.
 
And let's not forget those pesky Norse gods, either. Thor and Odin were some real short-tempered cats, from what I read, and you wouldn't want an electric hammer up your butt.

Pffttt...

Apep could so take Jörmungandr.

Set pwns Loki.

Ptah > Ymir.
 
Yrreg: This post is for yrreg.

Yrreg: This post is for yrreg.

It seems that I was the first poster to actually answer your OP question. I gave you what I thought was the Christian concept of God. See, look at the post:

What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?


To answer your question honestly and without getting off track, the God that the Christians believe exists:

  • Has a name, Yahweh.
  • Is responsible for the creation of the heavens and the earth.
  • Is responsible for the creation of plants, animals, and humans on earth.
  • Is responsible for the creation of angels, and other beings in heaven.
  • Is one, but at the same time three, being(s). One of which was known as logos, but was made flesh and is now called Jesus.
  • Is referred to as being male.
  • Revealed himself to mankind on various occasions in various forms.
  • Directed the recording of these revelations in written form known as the Holy Bible.
  • Demands obedience and worship.
  • Chose one family to live while destroying every other human on earth.
  • Chose one family and it's descendants to be his people.
  • Dictated rules for worship, sacrifice, and behavior.
  • Sent a part of himself, Jesus, as a blood sacrifice to forgive the disobedience of his people.
  • Will punish for eternity all who do not accept or believe that Jesus died for the forgiveness of their disobedience.
  • Will grant eternal life and bliss to all those who do accept and believe that Jesus died for the forgiveness of their disobedience.
  • Will destroy heaven and earth and build a new heaven and earth with Jesus on the throne of the kingdom of God and the twelve disciples as rulers over the twelve tribes of his chosen people.
  • Etc.

Is this the God that you are "humanly certain" exists? Have I left anything out? Is there anything above that is incorrect?

Is this the God that we are going to hear arguments for or against?


You acknowledged my relevant post, but decided to isolate one, single item to focus on. See, here's what you said:

Thanks, Phase Inverter, for being relevant.

Let me just invite you, Phase Inverter, for the present to your words in the following line in your list, the second item:

  • [God] Is responsible for the creation of the heavens and the earth.

That line from you say in very few words what I myself as a rational theist and a Christian understand to be God, namely, the maker of everything including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.

Yes, just keep to that line from your list and also my expanded version of that line, that is the concept of God which I am humanly certain in fact exists.

For the present don't go into anything else, just stick to that line from your list and as I said, which I expand into my own version as stated above.


You asked me to stick to that one, single item and the somewhat expanded version you posted. I agreed to do just that. For the purpose of discussion, of course. See, here's what I said:

Agreed. For the present I will just stick to that line from my list and to your expanded version as well.


Note: You did ask me what I thought the concept of God that the Christians accept as existing was, and I gave it to you. All of it (and I'm sure that my list was incomplete). By isolating one particular aspect of this God, we are no longer discussing the concept of God that Christians alone accept. You have opened up the discussion to any concept of God, that any number of religions accept, that has that one, single trait.


Even though I agreed, for the purpose of discussion, to use the one single line (and your expanded version of it) I really felt that by doing so we are actually moving away from the concept of God that is accepted by Christians as in fact existing. Which was the question you asked in your OP.

Now I have a dilemma. I want to make it known that I have a slight problem with selecting that one, single attribute of the Christian God and ignoring the rest. We can do it, for the purpose of discussion, but at some point the other attributes would have to be brought back. So, how do I make this known (even if just for my own satisfaction) without distracting you from the point - that I agreed with you - and having you go off on a tangent or ignoring the post altogether.

The solution. How about a footnote? Yea, that'll work, a footnote. A note that is for further information, if the reader so desires, yet doesn't distract from the main text. Now I must admit, I didn't invent it. No, I think they've been in use for quite a while.


Phase Inverter, you believe in putting important notice in very fine print, no?


No, I don't.

I see we have now gone off on a tangent.


Please don't do that, because it is important, so it must be conspicuously visible to readers including most specially people you are interacting with about ideas


First, it is not important to the point of the post, which is that I agreed with you to use only one of the attributes from my list. Second, I would hardly call it inconspicuous. Unless you have bad eyesight. Then, may I recommend getting a pair of eyeglasses. I have eyeglasses (see my avatar). Eyeglasses are quite handy to have.


I am not saying anything about what you are alleging that I am saying...


I'm not claiming you said anything. What you said is visible for all to see. I'm simply stating my opinion of what could happen if we start ignoring important aspects of the Christian concept of God.


...what I said is that for the present just keep to my concept of God which also you briefly state in few words.


Hey, that's a good idea. I agree, let's do that.


Why do I want us for the time being to keep to your concept of God and my expanded version? because we have got to keep neat and tidy, otherwise this discussion will get very unmanageable.


I agree. Let's, for the time being, keep to the single item from my list and your expanded version of it. Let's not go off on a tangent, or...what was that word? Oh, yea...tergiversate by going on about font formatting.


Okay? Phase Inverter, no more fine print, yes? no? don't care?

Please inform.


I make use of various types of formatting to make my documents both easy to read and well organized. I shall continue to do so. Do I care? Of course I care. Otherwise I wouldn't bother.
 
Moved the comments about what is the appropriate way to quote someone to AAH (as off-topic). As a note how people chose to quote other Members is up to each Member and not really a matter for the Mod Team unless there is an issue with disruption or "excessive" confusion. Using a different colour for your own responses within a quote is not considered to cause "excessive confusion".

However we would encourage everyone to use the standard "house style" which is to place your responses outside of the quote box. It really does make it easier for everyone else to follow your responses and makes it much easier for other Members to quote your responses.
Posted By: Darat
 
(snipped from the verbiage).....

As I always say, the study of atheists should focus on their psychology of being atheists, emotive motivations for denying God's existence, rather than the intellectual or cognitive grounds for denial.


Yrreg

This statement alone marks almost everything Yrreg has posted here in this thread as intellectually dishonest. He has made it entirely clear that he has no interest in the argument he claims to be hosting, in any objective issues, or any issues regarding the presence or lack of evidence for a creator, nor, in fact, ini any of the problems surrounding his own arguments and his own definitions. He states here, in effect, that all arguments to him must be ad hominem, however deftly he manages to negotiate the technical rules.
 
Having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

They have taken a most irrevocable vow to their corresponding deity of opposition whatever to the Christian God, to never ever even come to any agreement with theists even just over the concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against.

It is a phenomenon similar to the fear of Dracula for the crucifix.

And in a humorous vein, Dracula also fears garlic.





Yrreg
 
I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

They have taken a most irrevocable vow to their corresponding deity of opposition whatever to the Christian God, to never ever even come to any agreement with theists even just over the concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against.

It is a phenomenon similar to the fear of Dracula for the crucifix.

And in a humorous vein, Dracula also fears garlic.





Yrreg

Why do you think I asked you which one alcoholic beverage you didn't drink?
 
This statement alone marks almost everything Yrreg has posted here in this thread as intellectually dishonest. He has made it entirely clear that he has no interest in the argument he claims to be hosting, in any objective issues, or any issues regarding the presence or lack of evidence for a creator, nor, in fact, ini any of the problems surrounding his own arguments and his own definitions. He states here, in effect, that all arguments to him must be ad hominem, however deftly he manages to negotiate the technical rules.

Yep, notice how he only wants to discuss our "emotive" reasons for lacking belief in god(s), and wants nothing to do with any intellectual or logical reasons.
 
I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

They have taken a most irrevocable vow to their corresponding deity of opposition whatever to the Christian God, to never ever even come to any agreement with theists even just over the concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against.

It is a phenomenon similar to the fear of Dracula for the crucifix.

And in a humorous vein, Dracula also fears garlic.





Yrreg

That is lamentable Yrreg. Really, really lamentable.

But I suppose that Phase Inverter, the last in a long line of posters who have been prepared to accept your definition (or something close to it) in order to move the discussion forward, don't exist

Why don't you believe in those posters, Yrreg?
 
But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.
ok.
They have taken a most irrevocable vow to their corresponding deity of opposition whatever to the Christian God, to never ever even come to any agreement with theists even just over the concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against.
Out of curiousity, have you selected which diety you are christianiting against?

It is a phenomenon similar to the fear of Dracula for the crucifix.
I think the phenomenon is similar to you and your use of analogies.
 
I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

This is because you choose not to read the replies given, not because of any act on anyone else's part. That is 'willful ignorance'.

But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

Not really - it's impossibe for your own part, because you refuse to dialogue with anyone.

They have taken a most irrevocable vow to their corresponding deity of opposition whatever to the Christian God, to never ever even come to any agreement with theists even just over the concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against.

Atheism isn't an active event; it is a passive one. There is no reason to agree on any God concept if they don't believe in any God, period. None. None whatsoever. Just as I don't believe in any devils. Not one. No demons whatsoever. I don't have to define which demon I don't believe in; I simply don't believe in Demons, period.

This does not stop conversation on the subject. What does stop conversation on the subject is that you refuse to accept that atheists reject the entire class 'deity' as a whole. That's it. There is no specific Deity concept they are rejecting; they are rejecting the entire concept of Deity as a classification of entities as a whole.

It is a phenomenon similar to the fear of Dracula for the crucifix.

Not really. Crucifices can be shown to exist, after all. You have it rather backwards - it would be more of the folk person's fear of the 'evil eye'.

And in a humorous vein, Dracula also fears garlic.

In some stories. In others, it's werewolves who fear garlic. And in some, neither do.

But since Dracula doesn't exist either...

Or are you now going to attack my avampirism by asking me the specific form of 'vampire' I am rejecting? I reject vampires as a class, just as atheists reject gods as a class.

But if you are at all logically and internally consistent, you must now take offense that I refuse to define WHICH vampire I don't believe in.
 
I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

We are not the ones refusing to read and refusing to discuss, Gerry. That honor is yours alone. If you wish to read and respond to my statements, you are more than welcome; but evasiveness in this manner simply demonstrates your own unwillingness to confront your doubts.
 
In light of the attitude of several members on this forum, I'm changing my reply styles. If it was just because you didn't like the red being inside the quotes, I would say "deal," but I hadn't thought about the fact that it made me difficult to quote. So here you go.

I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

Why not? I took the time to read the two pages that popped up since I went to sleep last night, just to make sure that I wasn't missing anything critical in your argument.


But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

Once again, we hit the Two-Sentence Wall. This is the limit before yrreg devolves into flaming. So I'm ignoring the rest of the post.
However, yrreg, you may find it interesting to note that several members of this site, myself included, would like to hear exactly what you believe we shouldn't be "atheisting against." We want to hear your argument.
 
Here, Yrreg, let me help:

Yrreg:

I believe that God is the creator of all things.

Atheist:

Either it's creators all the way down, or at some point, something didn't need a creator. We know the universe exists; but there's no valid evidence of a creator behind the Universe, much less an endless stack of creators , so I don't believe in your god.

That should be the end of it for you. Atheists don't believe in your god, due to lack of evidence and a simple logical analysis of the idea of a 'prime creator'. Atheists also don't believe in my god, for the same reasons. Unlike you, however, I can accept that fact and move on.
 
I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.
[...]

It is a phenomenon similar to the fear of Dracula for the crucifix.

And in a humorous vein, Dracula also fears garlic.


;)
 
I have not read all the replies to my last message here previous to the present one.

But I am totally convinced that having a constructive dialogue with atheists is impossible from their part.

They have taken a most irrevocable vow to their corresponding deity of opposition whatever to the Christian God, to never ever even come to any agreement with theists even just over the concept of God to which they are 'atheisting' against.

It is a phenomenon similar to the fear of Dracula for the crucifix.

And in a humorous vein, Dracula also fears garlic.





Yrreg

So, you're leaving the forum?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom