yrreg said:
As I always say, the study of atheists should focus on their psychology of being atheists, emotive motivations for denying God's existence, rather than the intellectual or cognitive grounds for denial.
I found this a rather good summary of yrreg's problems with understanding atheists. To him, the evidence for god is so overwhelming, he doesn't understand why other people seem not to see it. He sees those people use "intellectual or cognitive grounds" for their denial of that crystal-clear evidence, but surely that can't be right? How can anyone with a modicum of intelligence deny crystal-clear evidence at the end of their nose (or external reproductive organ....which supposedly doesn't exclude women from the conversation.)? Therefore, he sees the atheist's denial as being purely emotional. It's hatred, or jealousy, or selfishness. Yrreg's bottom line: There's something seriously wrong with this person.
Well, yrreg, there's nothing wrong with atheists. Some may have emotional problems, but that's true of everyone, and is not a reason for or a result of their atheism.
First, atheists aren't "denying" god in the way that you think. Theists have posited the existence of a completely unseen being, who has supernatural powers. Some theists have posited the existence of several unseen beings with different supernatural powers. It doesn't matter which one seems to be the strongest or most powerful or most popular - they all have the exact same amount of evidence for their actual existence. ZERO. So when atheists bring up Thor or Odin or FSM, it's not because we're actively denying them too. Do you have an emotional motive for not believing in Thor's existence? Do you have an emotional motive for not believing in FSM's existence? Or is it simply that there is no evidence whatsoever?
Second point above, the reasons atheists have for "denying" god's existence are
evidence-based. I would consider those reasons to be intellectual or cognitive, and not emotional, as you claim. I think you'd like to think that your reasons for believing in your god are logical and cognitive, but I would guess they're more emotional. My reasons for NOT believing are not emotional ones, but logic-based. When you speak about the impasse between theists and atheists, I see it as being an impasse between emotional beliefs (theists) and logical ones (atheists). You may disagree, of course.
And so far as evidence for God's existence is concerned people who know God to exist have all the evidence they need, these evidences presented to atheists will never be relevant and sufficient because their kind of evidence is of the dungeoned kind, constricted and perverted kind, and thus only useful to them for a pseudo platform for objections but of no worth whatever to topple the big picture of God as maker of everything.
Do theists generally come to be theists because they're presented with evidence, or because they've been taught that something is true? If there really is some evidence, please present it in a coherent fashion.
Empirical evidence is not dungeoned or perverted. I'm not going to buy a medicine that doesn't have empirical evidence backing up its effectiveness and safety. Other people will buy a medicine because the guy selling it "seemed like a nice guy." Who has the more perverted response?