What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

False. It is entirely logically consistent for god to be an idiot god, who made things as an accident. Or for god to be nothing but the universe (multiverse) itself. Or for god to be clumsy extradimentional janitor, who accidently spilled his mop water onto the floor which then reacted with a toenail that formed our universe.

There's really no reason at all to assume that what you think god is, is actually what god is (assuming there is a god). I welcome you bringing in evidence that can contradict any of my 3 counter examples.

Given that the god described in scriptures seems to be perpetually concerned with correcting the flaws of his creation, the notion of said god being incompetent seems all the more plausible, even likely. It's an idea that certainly made an impression on many early Christian sects.
 
So, if I can resist the evil that god made and does, than that must make me morally and physically superior to god. Interesting point....

No grasshoppa' that is the wrong path to enlightenment!

You make choices each right choice cleanses you. Each wrong choice soils your soul. Take responsibility for your actions.

; {>
 
Actually in the original Hebrew 'I am who I am' is God and 'it' created the universe. The word 'It' automatically defaults to a masculine entity, but the God of the Hebrews and my god has no form because it is a spirit. It manifests in the temporal universe, the time dependent universe almost exclusively by envoy, by some temporal agent, like Jesus, a man or the bush that fire does not consume, or disembodied voices, dreams and visions.

Whatever; this is just semantics. How do you know that an entity necessarily created the universe, rather than a sequence of random events?

The bible won't bite you and if read with an open mind is fascinating especially if you down load a systran translator and challenge some of the translations. The fun really begins when you use the original script and go from there. Of course if you have been told from childhood that the bible is nonsense, mean, and myth your ability to enjoy the bible might be damaged.
Let's just get this disclaimer out first, shall we? I was raised Episcopalian and served as an acolyte all through high school (a real eye-opener, let me tell you; it's way more of a stage show than most people realise). I didn't really become an explicit atheist until around 22-23 or so.

I find, when these conversations come up, that I actually tend to know far more about the Bible than the people I'm conversing with. I cannot quote chapter-and-verse from it, sadly, but I certainly have read the Bible multiple times -- and the times I read it as an atheist were very revealing to me, especially when taken in context with the times I read it as a believer. (Besides, does it not say that the Devil shall quote Scripture to serve his purposes?)

And what I took from it was that the Bible is a handpicked collection of individual men's writings compiled together into a book, and used by the priesthood in the Dark Ages to drive their flocks; some of those writings obviously by madmen, and some who were simply the temporal equivalent of modern devoted cultists. The contradictions amongst itself are far too significant to be handwaved away, and thus I cannot accept the Bible as divinely inspired... unless the god in question is internally inconsistent and itself mad.

You like to say "original script". Which "original script" are you talking about?
 
Last edited:
No grasshoppa' that is the wrong path to enlightenment!

You make choices each right choice cleanses you. Each wrong choice soils your soul. Take responsibility for your actions.
I do. It seems that it's god who decides to blame others for his mistakes.

God punished adam/eve for eating from the tree which taught them right from wrong. Funny thing is, they couldn't have known it was wrong until they did it. So god punished them for something that only HE knew it was wrong to do.

We could go through multiple examples of this:
God kills nearly everything (including animals) because people were "bad".

God Torture's Job to win a bet.

God makes a new covenant becuase the old one didn't work.

Finally, this new convenant clearly places emphasis on Jesus as the way. We can be outstandingly good, doing everything for our fellow man and go to hell if we don't accept Jesus. This is clearly the "It's not who you are but who you know" version of morality.


If there was a problem with taking responsibility, it isn't mine.
 
You make choices each right choice cleanses you. Each wrong choice soils your soul. Take responsibility for your actions.

; {>

I always find this part the most disgusting. According to this god gave free will: fair enough. He gave each person enough strength to "resist" evil. Fair enough. He knew that some folk would not "resist evil". Fair enough. He allows those people to torture and otherwise harm other people: people who in no way deserve it. He has the power to prevent this. There is no reason whatsoever why he should not prevent it (especially if it is true that the plan is as much a sin as the action: in that case the person has already earned whatever he or she has earned when he or she first thinks seriously about doing these bad things). Nevertheless he lets those go right ahead. And the only excuse he has for this is that he is mysterious. Doesn't look that mysterious to me. Inexcusable, yes. He should take responsibility for his actions, IMO
 
Curious.

When asked which god or gods RevDisturba did not believe in, he responded:

The creator of the universe.


...but then that was contradicted a little later by this:

Again I believe in the creator of the universe.


RevDisturba, you seem confused. Do you really have that much trouble understanding the written word? This does provide insight into your many misinformed posts on cosmology and theology, though.
 
And the only excuse he has for this is that he is mysterious. Doesn't look that mysterious to me. Inexcusable, yes. He should take responsibility for his actions, IMO
"Dad, why didn't you stop my brother from pushing me off the deck? You were standing right next to him!
"I was being Mysterious"
 
Ah, but we can't possibly be proper Christians or we wouldn't be disagreeing with him now, would we?

*sighs* So you are not proper christians: and we are not proper atheists.

Oh Look!! Everyone is out of step except the Rev.
 
"It is time for you, my friend, to stop harping on the fact that atheists are generally hated. The point has been made. No one is contesting the fact. You are simply saying it in an attemt to make us look bad to yourself."

While I agree that this is Rev's motive, I respectfully disagree that 'atheists are generally hated'. I think that the opinion polls might support that in the USA, but the US is not the world. In many European countries atheists are either in a majority, or the population at large simply doesn't care about them. In my own country, the UK, it would be considered very odd to describe atheists as a 'hated minority'.
 
So we seem to be back to the original definition, more or less, which in a Yrreg thread I guess can be considered progress of a sort.

The initial problem still remains, though, that like most definitions of God it's essentially circular, depending on inferences that are themselves inferred from belief in the thing defined, and based not on its attributes or properties, but on a presumption of its actions if it did exist.

IF the universe was designed, it had a designer, and we'll call it God. But what have we really said here?

We define a wrench as "what you reach for when you need a wrench."
 
yrreg said:
As I always say, the study of atheists should focus on their psychology of being atheists, emotive motivations for denying God's existence, rather than the intellectual or cognitive grounds for denial.
I found this a rather good summary of yrreg's problems with understanding atheists. To him, the evidence for god is so overwhelming, he doesn't understand why other people seem not to see it. He sees those people use "intellectual or cognitive grounds" for their denial of that crystal-clear evidence, but surely that can't be right? How can anyone with a modicum of intelligence deny crystal-clear evidence at the end of their nose (or external reproductive organ....which supposedly doesn't exclude women from the conversation.)? Therefore, he sees the atheist's denial as being purely emotional. It's hatred, or jealousy, or selfishness. Yrreg's bottom line: There's something seriously wrong with this person.

Well, yrreg, there's nothing wrong with atheists. Some may have emotional problems, but that's true of everyone, and is not a reason for or a result of their atheism.

First, atheists aren't "denying" god in the way that you think. Theists have posited the existence of a completely unseen being, who has supernatural powers. Some theists have posited the existence of several unseen beings with different supernatural powers. It doesn't matter which one seems to be the strongest or most powerful or most popular - they all have the exact same amount of evidence for their actual existence. ZERO. So when atheists bring up Thor or Odin or FSM, it's not because we're actively denying them too. Do you have an emotional motive for not believing in Thor's existence? Do you have an emotional motive for not believing in FSM's existence? Or is it simply that there is no evidence whatsoever?

Second point above, the reasons atheists have for "denying" god's existence are evidence-based. I would consider those reasons to be intellectual or cognitive, and not emotional, as you claim. I think you'd like to think that your reasons for believing in your god are logical and cognitive, but I would guess they're more emotional. My reasons for NOT believing are not emotional ones, but logic-based. When you speak about the impasse between theists and atheists, I see it as being an impasse between emotional beliefs (theists) and logical ones (atheists). You may disagree, of course.

And so far as evidence for God's existence is concerned people who know God to exist have all the evidence they need, these evidences presented to atheists will never be relevant and sufficient because their kind of evidence is of the dungeoned kind, constricted and perverted kind, and thus only useful to them for a pseudo platform for objections but of no worth whatever to topple the big picture of God as maker of everything.
Do theists generally come to be theists because they're presented with evidence, or because they've been taught that something is true? If there really is some evidence, please present it in a coherent fashion.

Empirical evidence is not dungeoned or perverted. I'm not going to buy a medicine that doesn't have empirical evidence backing up its effectiveness and safety. Other people will buy a medicine because the guy selling it "seemed like a nice guy." Who has the more perverted response?
 
Hey, RevDistuba, you ignored this the first time I tried. Let me try again:

So...either the Olympian gods exist or they don't exist. If they exist I should obviously sacrifice to them regularly and perform all the due sacred rites. If they don't exist, I lose nothing by performing those rites. A sane man, then, will believe in the Olympian gods and honor them in the proper ways.

Right, RevDisturba?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom