What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

I say that:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.
First important word in that definition of God, the word maker.

Wrong. First important word is "everything". Did god make itself?
 
I am still having the Christian God in mind, but if you want me to exclude the Christian God, I want to tell you that you are being petty to no advantage to yourselves except to be petty.

We don't want you to exclude any god(s). Round 'em all up and we'll lack belief in them all collectively.

You see in the concept of God from Christians, there is the most important core, and that is maker of everything.

You want me to denounce the attributes Christians assign to God like omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence.

Nope. We don't care what you include or exclude from your definition of god(s), just so long as you declare what attributes you believe it has.

No need to denounce and renounce them unless I want be illogical, because those attributes follow from the core concept of maker of everything by way of necessary inference.

You want to show that those attributes cannot be in God because God will be internally inconsistent, but you are not really conversant about the nature of God as God Himself is in Himself and knows Himself.

You should think about that logically for a change and draw conclusions.

In other words in you knowledge of God you want to see that there is internal inconsistency between the attributes of God among themselves and also with the core concept of God as maker of everything, that is in your knowledge that is willy nilly limited and imperfect.

Christians define their God to possess inconsistent attributes. Not our fault.

You cannot claim to be all knowing as to know the nature of God as it is in God Himself, not as known to you in your limited and imperfect brain.

Show me the post where someone claimed to be all knowing.

Anyway, you want me to also wrap up myself in inconsistency the way you want yourselves to do so, to justify your being atheists.

Nobody wants you to, you just do it. It's the nature of the god(s) you believe in.

That is not to my mind an honest valuation of God, but a dishonest one, dishonest intellectually.

And I will not be dishonest intellectually;

Maybe not deliberately.

what I can say is that in the imperfect and thus limited consideration of our puny knowledge we might seem to see inconsistency among the attributes men assign to God and in regard to God's core concept of maker of everything, but the reality is that God is the maker of everything and on that basis there can be no genuinely inconsistency among the attributes men assign to Him among themselves the attributes, and in regard to God's core concept of maker of everything.

yrreG, it is real inconsistency in the magical being that theists believe in.

Now, I want you to admit that those attributes of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence are assigned to God on the basis of man's own knowledge of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence, which in all objective factuality man really don't have the kind of knowledge by which man can know God as God knows Himself, that is why I say that man knows God only imperfectly and in a limited degree.

Which god(s)? Some god(s) are defined as having omniscience, omnipotence, or omnibenevolence. You will admit that these are mutually exclusive and then you will have your answer.

Withal man's thinking of God from his exposure to the world that he has access to though imperfect and limited is still sufficient for him to come to the certainty belief of God as the maker of everything.

Fixed.

As I always say, the study of atheists should focus on their psychology of being atheists, emotive motivations for denying God's existence, rather than the intellectual or cognitive grounds for denial.

So that you won't have to focus on internally consistent god(s).

And so far as evidence for God's existence is concerned people who know God to exist have all the evidence they need, these evidences presented to atheists will never be relevant and sufficient because their kind of evidence is of the dungeoned kind, constricted and perverted kind, and thus only useful to them for a pseudo platform for objections but of no worth whatever to topple the big picture of God as maker of everything.

Or, these evidence will never be presented at all.

What is also very useful for understanding the psychology of atheists and thus their kind of consequential cognitivity, is to discern what are the worldview impasses between theists on the one side and atheists from the other side, and unearth the grounds of those impasses.

I'm guessing locical thinking vs. dogma.

Briefly put, the most foundational impasse between theists and atheists is for theists there is God maker of everything, for atheists there is only matter in randomness.

Ah, I was right.

And then also for theists there is the whole totality of existence which includes the physical universe, whereas for atheists there is only the physical universe which atheists consider to be everything that is of empirical access to themselves -- but then that empirical universe they know also that man can only have an imperfect and limited access to.




Yrreg
 
please give us your list of the gods you do not believe in,and your reasons why.
 
You want me to denounce the attributes Christians assign to God like omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence.

No need to denounce and renounce them unless I want be illogical, because those attributes follow from the core concept of maker of everything by way of necessary inference.
False. It is entirely logically consistent for god to be an idiot god, who made things as an accident. Or for god to be nothing but the universe (multiverse) itself. Or for god to be clumsy extradimentional janitor, who accidently spilled his mop water onto the floor which then reacted with a toenail that formed our universe.

There's really no reason at all to assume that what you think god is, is actually what god is (assuming there is a god). I welcome you bringing in evidence that can contradict any of my 3 counter examples.
 
six7s said:
So... your 'argument' (for want of a better, less grandiose term) is wrong, right?

Which one my friend? (so far)...

Although there are many atheists actively participating on this forum, this is NOT an atheist site - see the thread entitled The JREF is not an atheist organization

Well of course its not an atheist site in name, but its atheist secular in practice. I do a general search of the site and a few of its members before I join. I know the drill but most of the active posters are atheist apologetic. I have not been to the other areas of the board but intend to. I have only noticed one christian here and he seemed strangely aloof or something. I like the site its just a few members that seem intent on christian basing that nearly ruin it for me anyway.

Now you're getting closer... this site overtly aims to promote critical thinking>>>>Brevity snip<<<<Care to try it?


Critical thinking and christian hobbled debate is what atheist moderators and secular/atheist & christian hostile active members end up with. Its business, that's all. If most of your members are secular or atheists you don't bite the hand that feeds you eh?

I will say that the last week to ten days that there has been a remarkable change for the better at the moderator level. I am starting to think that my moderator is on vacation. (she must love me because she gave me her undivided attention at first!).

So yes its getting better and I am getting some maneuvering room at last....

; {>
 
Last edited:
Is that the same god who stated he created evil?

Do you often worship things which do evil?

God created everything including what you call evil, however he gave you the ability to resist being evil. We have a choice.

; {>
 
please give us your list of the gods you do not believe in,and your reasons why.

Its much easier to tell you the one I do believe in, and that is the God that created the universe (as I said).

What are you beliefs ?

; {>
 
God created everything including what you call evil, however he gave you the ability to resist being evil. We have a choice.

So god intentionally caused large numbers of his creations to suffer extensively (under the thumbs of those who are 'evil'), even though he could have prevented it?

And yet this is a "compassionate, merciful god"? This story does not hang together, sorry.
 
How do you know some_one_ created it, rather than some_thing_?

Actually in the original Hebrew 'I am who I am' is God and 'it' created the universe. The word 'It' automatically defaults to a masculine entity, but the God of the Hebrews and my god has no form because it is a spirit. It manifests in the temporal universe, the time dependent universe almost exclusively by envoy, by some temporal agent, like Jesus, a man or the bush that fire does not consume, or disembodied voices, dreams and visions.

The bible won't bite you and if read with an open mind is fascinating especially if you down load a systran translator and challenge some of the translations. The fun really begins when you use the original script and go from there. Of course if you have been told from childhood that the bible is nonsense, mean, and myth your ability to enjoy the bible might be damaged.

BTW what are your beliefs?

; {>
 
Last edited:
Geez, I leave the thread for one night and look what happens! I'm completely lost! Lots of yrreg and RevDisturba posts to tear up... man... good thing I've got a free half-hour still. *sings* Well, I've been away for a long time / and it looks like a mess around here!

You know, guys atheists here, I am -- come to think of it -- I am into getting inputs from you about the God, the concept that is, the existence of which theist Christians must believe in or for Yrreg I know from reason to exist as a fact, in order that we can all atheists and theists start looking for that mutually construed God, that being namely that corresponds to the concept that is that can be acceptable to both atheists and theists, all of the best intentions and best honesty in the quest for God.

If you bring that sentence in for a fitting I can have it shortened by Thursday.

But you atheists are not in the quest for God.

You're right. We're not. Yet you keep trying to get us to join in.

Just the same, being fellow humans, because you love fellow humans even theists who are diametrically opposite to yourselves,

Yes. We do. Though it seems hard for you and the good Reverend to comprehend, we don't hate either one of you. I'm sure that you, yrreg, are a fine person in real life, and that RevD is the same. But here in the Religion and Philosophy forums, there ain't enough room for you two.

please simply humor us, and we all with your indulgence and collaboration after we have come to a uniform concept of God, we can all go forth and locate that God.

What do you say to that?

I say fine. Give us a definition of God, then present your proof. Just don't make us go through this whole rigamarole of going through the definition word by word.


Yrreg

There are two kinds of men, and also women, or mankind, those in need of God and those not in need of God.

Uhh... sure. Whatever.

I am of the kind that is in need of God.

Obviously. This explains a lot.

Now, needing God or not needing God, I am inviting atheists who don't need God, just the same to join with theists or just join me, Yrreg a rational theist Christian, to come to a uniform concept of God, so that we can then proceed together to look for the entity that corresponds to our mutually worked out construct of God, in all the nooks and crannies of the whole totality of existence including the physical universe.

Can do. But I've got a better idea. You tell us what god you're looking for, and then we'll deny it. Happy?
What you don't seem to understand is that it doesn't matter what god you come up with. We want hard evidence for it. You haven't given any. If you actually came up with some, then maybe you could make some headway.




Yrreg

If I weren't I am sure Milligan would want their degree back. Yes I knew that even before my first year at seminary. You see I think for some big events God took the universe off auto pilot and tweaks it a bit, case study was Constantine's conversion to Christianity.

So your god intervenes in the world periodically. Can you give us any specific examples that can be definitively shown to be divine intervention?

In Hoc Signo Vinces, Constantine did, which allowed us to, and I am happy to say that we are still at the helm with everyone's best interests at heart.I am not as in your face as my more traditional brethren are, and do the absolute minimum to make sure anyone who wants to know the good news does.

:eye-poppi
Excuse me? You seem to be every bit as in-your-face, shout-about-Jeeesusss as yrreg.


There are many ways to discern truth my friend. A tiny group of Christians that were hated as much as your group is today, and they rose above all the other religions is not evidence but a hint.

It is time for you, my friend, to stop harping on the fact that atheists are generally hated. The point has been made. No one is contesting the fact. You are simply saying it in an attemt to make us look bad to yourself.

Fulfilled Bible prophesy is another, but atheist doctrine makes it VERY difficult for an atheist realize that the bible is an accurate book.

Give us one example of a fulfilled prophecy in the Bible that does not concern scripture.

Then there are the many other evidences that that I use because they are so in your face obvious.

Show them to us anyway. We'd like to know. Generally, the more obvious the evidence is, the stronger it is. For example, showing that a building is made of brick is a lot easier if you show someone a brick from that building.

If you don't like a big thick book of theology get a popular book like a case for the creator and ignore what the secular critics have said (they have to say its a lie etc) and attempt to read it with an open mind. If you would have already of read it you would know what many of my evidences are, but not all.

Actually, many of us have read plenty of books like that. I personally spend a lot of my free time reading those kinds of books. I find them both funny and useful for the arguments I use on this site. But the arguments inside tend to boil down to the same things you have been spouting, e.g. nonsense.

Sometimes I go back and what I think is my words for grammar and spelling using the WP, and accidentally edit the entire thing by mistake. If I change the wording of an author I do my best to put emphis mine etc, everyone makes mistakes, eh?

Thanks for your reply.

; {>

You are too negativistic, too pessimistic, too independent of God.

You're implying that we shouldn't be independent of your god at all? That we should let him control our lives in the entirety?
Oh wait. You're yrreg. That's exactly what you're saying.


You will never be of any benefit to mankind.

Flaming.

Look back to what atheists communists sought to bring about an atheist utopia, which came to nothing in very brief historical time.

Look back to the French Revolution leaders, all atheists like you guys here, they ended up killing each other, like the Russian atheists revolutionaries of very recent years, they came to nothing.


At no time in the history of mankind had atheists ever had all the resources of government to bring about utopia to the half of mankind they enslaved, and they failed miserably to uplift mankind even just on material needs.

Look at North Korea today.
What an atheist paradise, eh?


Of course, you will insist that the ills of the atheist regimes during the cold war years were not due to atheists as atheists but due to atheists as communists totalitarians.

So their being atheists and humanists and rationalists, and everything good and terrific for mankind did not succeed to keep them away from being despotic totalitarians who murdered more peoples ever in the whole history of mankind, than any other adherents of any worldviews or visions for mankind.

Wherefore, being atheists does not spell any reassuring hope for mankind to get ahead to better conditions for everyone, quite the opposite.

This entire post is one giant flame. Reported.

Yrreg

False prophets that were not following anything in the bible, they preached false doctrine. The bible warns about these people. Just compare what they are saying with scripture. They may sprinkle scripture in with thiere own peverted adgenda but if it doesnt correlate with the bible dont drink the koolaid.

The problem is that the Bible itself don't jive, mah good man.
; {>

When you use words that are obvious religious slurs the world over (except in dirty little corners where anything goes) and act like you can't understand the correlation of religious insults with racial and sexual identification smears and taunts, while feigning ignorance or ? then it is you that is beyond help not I. The person that uses religious and racial slurs etc as a matter of conversation or debate are lacking in several areas of human compassion and maturity.

The person that sees racial slurs in humorous debate and light mockery has some serious insecurity issues. Please seek help.
; {>

Okay, let us get going into the concept of God, without bringing in spaghetti.

Okay, then. Down to brass tacks.

I say that:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.

Whatever. Evidence, please?

First important word in that definition of God, the word maker.


Do you atheists have any trouble with the word maker, just that word, please for now, don't go into the invisible pink unicorn, and above all keep that spaghetti in the kitchen, we are into serious business, finding out if anyone conversant with English is having any trouble with word maker.

Oh good lord. Just give us your evidence.

Yrreg

You are blind as well and a meddler I have already responded to Wolly if you want to keep calling me a liar after I have explained myself (twice) that's a reportable offense.

It's not a reportable offense if the person is actually a liar and has been repeatedly exposed for it.

BTW what form of atheism are you? If you don't mind sharing?

What do you mean, what form? There's no schisms in atheism. You're just an atheist.
; {>

To be logically systematic hence productive, work on definitions first.

We have a definition. Now give us your evidence.

You keep saying that God is a leprechaun, Santa, invisible pink unicorn, flying spaghetti monster, celestial teapot, etc.

:notm
We say that there is as much evidence for the IPU and FSM as for your god.


That is what I call bad-mouthing God instead to getting to be serious about exactly what you have for a concept of God against which you are 'atheisting' in calling yourselves atheists.

We are serious about it. We just don't feel the need to show respect to a nonexistent celestial being.

That is your routine avoidance strategy, and the reason why I always get the impression and now the certainty that either you atheists don't really know what you are atheisting against, or you just want to skirt the need to do logical thinking, fearing that logic will bring you to God.

We know exactly what we are "atheisting" against. It's gods. We don't believe in them. ANY OF THEM. Period.

Anyway, as I said, definitions have got to be agreed on first before we come to the proof of existence or evidence presentation.

Perhaps. But we have a definition. Just go ahead and work your magic.

Otherwise you will go on and on and on and on and on and on with spaghetti and feeling so smart that you have what? hoodwinked yourselves into a comfortable posture of perpetually atheisting, but in fact betraying yourselves as what? shallow thinkers.

Flaming again. Rest of the post is hereby ignored.

Why shallow thinkers? Because only shallow thinkers resort to name-calling or bad-mouthing God, instead of analyzing the concept of God prior to attempts at proofs against His existence.

In which case you atheists are not thinkers at all, but name-callers.





Yrreg

Okay, so you are not happy with my expanded definition of God, so let me just go back to my previous most brief in three words concept of God:

Maker of everything.​

Happy now?

Sure, whatever. Now GIVE US SOME EFFING EVIDENCE.

What next?


Ah yes, I said concept of God from Christians, now I am not bringing in Christians.


I am still having the Christian God in mind, but if you want me to exclude the Christian God, I want to tell you that you are being petty to no advantage to yourselves except to be petty.

We don't want you to exclude anything. Bring on whatever you've got. No-holds-barred cage match! Tag-team of yrreg and RevDisturba, the Crusaders for Christ, take on a horde of JREF atheists! Don't miss it!

You see in the concept of God from Christians, there is the most important core, and that is maker of everything.

You want me to denounce the attributes Christians assign to God like omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence.

No need to denounce and renounce them unless I want be illogical, because those attributes follow from the core concept of maker of everything by way of necessary inference.

You want to show that those attributes cannot be in God because God will be internally inconsistent, but you are not really conversant about the nature of God as God Himself is in Himself and knows Himself.

We don't want you to drop anything in your definition. Go ahead and throw in anything you want. Hell, you could say that he's a fish if you wanted. Just give us some evidence for the way you think.

In other words in you knowledge of God you want to see that there is internal inconsistency between the attributes of God among themselves and also with the core concept of God as maker of everything, that is in your knowledge that is willy nilly limited and imperfect.

Flaming. Rest of the post is ignored.

You cannot claim to be all knowing as to know the nature of God as it is in God Himself, not as known to you in your limited and imperfect brain.


Anyway, you want me to also wrap up myself in inconsistency the way you want yourselves to do so, to justify your being atheists.

That is not to my mind an honest valuation of God, but a dishonest one, dishonest intellectually.

And I will not be dishonest intellectually; what I can say is that in the imperfect and thus limited consideration of our puny knowledge we might seem to see inconsistency among the attributes men assign to God and in regard to God's core concept of maker of everything, but the reality is that God is the maker of everything and on that basis there can be no genuinely inconsistency among the attributes men assign to Him among themselves the attributes, and in regard to God's core concept of maker of everything.

Now, I want you to admit that those attributes of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence are assigned to God on the basis of man's own knowledge of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence, which in all objective factuality man really don't have the kind of knowledge by which man can know God as God knows Himself, that is why I say that man knows God only imperfectly and in a limited degree.

Okay, I'm back. Again, the definition doesn't matter as long as you can give us some evidence.

Withal man's thinking of God from his exposure to the world that he has access to though imperfect and limited is still sufficient for him to come to the certainty of God as the maker of everything.




As I always say, the study of atheists should focus on their psychology of being atheists, emotive motivations for denying God's existence, rather than the intellectual or cognitive grounds for denial.

And so far as evidence for God's existence is concerned people who know God to exist have all the evidence they need, these evidences presented to atheists will never be relevant and sufficient because their kind of evidence is of the dungeoned kind, constricted and perverted kind, and thus only useful to them for a pseudo platform for objections but of no worth whatever to topple the big picture of God as maker of everything.

What is also very useful for understanding the psychology of atheists and thus their kind of consequential cognitivity, is to discern what are the worldview impasses between theists on the one side and atheists from the other side, and unearth the grounds of those impasses.

Briefly put, the most foundational impasse between theists and atheists is for theists there is God maker of everything, for atheists there is only matter in randomness.

And then also for theists there is the whole totality of existence which includes the physical universe, whereas for atheists there is only the physical universe which atheists consider to be everything that is of empirical access to themselves -- but then that empirical universe they know also that man can only have an imperfect and limited access to.

Well that was pointless. Why did I read that?


Yrreg

Which one my friend? (so far)...



Oh I saw much more than that. I do a general search of the site and a few of its members before I join. I know the drill but most of the active posters are atheist apologetic.

Wrong. We don't apologize for anything. We are the way we are; if you don't like it, tough noogies. We don't need to justify our non-belief. the burden of proof is on you.

I have not been to the other areas of the board but intend to. I have only noticed one christian here and he seemed strangely aloof or something. I like the site its just a few members that seem intent on christian basing that nearly ruin it for me anyway.

There are plenty of other Christians on the board. They just don't post in R&P. The ones that post in R&P are you, yrreg, Ethnikos, kurious_kathy and Christian dude.

Critical thinking and christian hobbled debate. I will say that the last week to ten days that there has been a remarkable change at the moderator level. I am starting to think that my moderator (she must love me because she gave me her undivided attention at first!). So yes its getting better!

; {>

Blah. Done.
 
God created everything including what you call evil, however he gave you the ability to resist being evil. We have a choice.

; {>
So, if I can resist the evil that god made and does, than that must make me morally and physically superior to god. Interesting point....
 
Which one my friend? (so far)...
Does it make any difference?

Well of course its not an atheist site in name, but its atheist secular in practice.
Equivocation.

I do a general search of the site and a few of its members before I join. I know the drill but most of the active posters are atheist apologetic.
Strawman.

I have not been to the other areas of the board but intend to.
That is an excellent idea.

Seriously.

Because what you will find is that exactly the same skepticism applied in this section of the forum to matters philosophical and religious, being applied to pseudoscience and the supernatural and conspiracy theories, among other fields.

Not so much the politics forum, though.

I have only noticed one christian here and he seemed strangely aloof or something.
More than one of the people disagreeing with you have identified themselves as Christians.

I like the site its just a few members that seem intent on christian basing that nearly ruin it for me anyway.
No.

Critical thinking and christian hobbled debate.
The only person hobbling you, is you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom