Okay, so you are not happy with my expanded definition of God, so let me just go back to my previous most brief in three words concept of God:
Maker of everything.
Happy now?
Sure, whatever. Now GIVE US SOME EFFING EVIDENCE.
What next?
Ah yes, I said concept of God from Christians, now I am not bringing in Christians.
I am still having the Christian God in mind, but if you want me to exclude the Christian God, I want to tell you that you are being petty to no advantage to yourselves except to be petty.
We don't want you to exclude anything. Bring on whatever you've got. No-holds-barred cage match! Tag-team of yrreg and RevDisturba, the Crusaders for Christ, take on a horde of JREF atheists! Don't miss it!
You see in the concept of God from Christians, there is the most important core, and that is maker of everything.
You want me to denounce the attributes Christians assign to God like omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence.
No need to denounce and renounce them unless I want be illogical, because those attributes follow from the core concept of maker of everything by way of necessary inference.
You want to show that those attributes cannot be in God because God will be internally inconsistent, but you are not really conversant about the nature of God as God Himself is in Himself and knows Himself.
We don't want you to drop anything in your definition. Go ahead and throw in anything you want. Hell, you could say that he's a fish if you wanted. Just give us some evidence for the way you think.
In other words in you knowledge of God you want to see that there is internal inconsistency between the attributes of God among themselves and also with the core concept of God as maker of everything, that is in your knowledge that is willy nilly limited and imperfect.
Flaming. Rest of the post is ignored.
You cannot claim to be all knowing as to know the nature of God as it is in God Himself, not as known to you in your limited and imperfect brain.
Anyway, you want me to also wrap up myself in inconsistency the way you want yourselves to do so, to justify your being atheists.
That is not to my mind an honest valuation of God, but a dishonest one, dishonest intellectually.
And I will not be dishonest intellectually; what I can say is that in the imperfect and thus limited consideration of our puny knowledge we might seem to see inconsistency among the attributes men assign to God and in regard to God's core concept of maker of everything, but the reality is that God is the maker of everything and on that basis there can be no genuinely inconsistency among the attributes men assign to Him among themselves the attributes, and in regard to God's core concept of maker of everything.
Now, I want you to admit that those attributes of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence are assigned to God on the basis of man's own knowledge of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence, which in all objective factuality man really don't have the kind of knowledge by which man can know God as God knows Himself, that is why I say that man knows God only imperfectly and in a limited degree.
Okay, I'm back. Again, the definition doesn't matter as long as you can give us some evidence.
Withal man's thinking of God from his exposure to the world that he has access to though imperfect and limited is still sufficient for him to come to the certainty of God as the maker of everything.
As I always say, the study of atheists should focus on their psychology of being atheists, emotive motivations for denying God's existence, rather than the intellectual or cognitive grounds for denial.
And so far as evidence for God's existence is concerned people who know God to exist have all the evidence they need, these evidences presented to atheists will never be relevant and sufficient because their kind of evidence is of the dungeoned kind, constricted and perverted kind, and thus only useful to them for a pseudo platform for objections but of no worth whatever to topple the big picture of God as maker of everything.
What is also very useful for understanding the psychology of atheists and thus their kind of consequential cognitivity, is to discern what are the worldview impasses between theists on the one side and atheists from the other side, and unearth the grounds of those impasses.
Briefly put, the most foundational impasse between theists and atheists is for theists there is God maker of everything, for atheists there is only matter in randomness.
And then also for theists there is the whole totality of existence which includes the physical universe, whereas for atheists there is only the physical universe which atheists consider to be everything that is of empirical access to themselves -- but then that empirical universe they know also that man can only have an imperfect and limited access to.
Well that was pointless. Why did I read that?
Yrreg