What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

This continues to be an exercise in simplicity: What is wrong with your concept of god? Nothing, except it, your god, does not exist. Sky Daddy is a figment of your imagination. If that's not a problem for you, it is not a problem for me, either.
It is, however, a problem for countless people whose friends and relatives have been tortured and/or killed in the name of woo :mad:
 
That was an wrong impression held by atheist apologists.
No. Your logic is flawed and all your premises are false.

If my argument was correct it would give strong evidence for a creator.
Actually, as presented it would give evidence for a gaping non-sequitur. You never did address that problem.

So of course in an atheist site you would get that impression.
Strawman, ad hominem.

Its a given, but I thought I would attempt to present the truth for those that may be fence sitting and can think critically.
Ad hominem, begging the question.
 
I hold females in the greatest of honor, because they are the mothers of mankind.


Now, will you just join me in finding out what is wrong with my concept of God:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the maker [in place of author] of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.

The second important word there is everything.

Do you have any trouble with the word everything, it means everything as everything is understood by anyone with any reading comprehension of English as to read newspapers in English intelligently.




Yrreg
Now, of course, you've changed your definition from what you originally put forth, and your latest version has a serious, fatal flaw. You have inserted the conclusion that a "scheme of intelligent order" prevails in the universe. Such a tendentious definition should be shunned and rejected by any person intending an honest discourse on the subject of God, whether for or against.
 
That is what I call bad-mouthing God instead to getting to be serious about exactly what you have for a concept of God against which you are 'atheisting' in calling yourselves atheists.

That is your routine avoidance strategy, and the reason why I always get the impression and now the certainty that either you atheists don't really know what you are atheisting against, or you just want to skirt the need to do logical thinking, fearing that logic will bring you to God.

There's a reason why the word "atheisting" does not exist.

We don't "atheist" "against" anything. We simply don't believe in any of the gods that people have tried to convince us to believe in.

It's really that simple. You've been told this countless times, so for you to continually ignore it looks like a "routine avoidance strategy" on your part, if not outright ... tergiversating.

Anyway, as I said, definitions have got to be agreed on first before we come to the proof of existence or evidence presentation.

But the problem is you keep trying to smuggle disputed facts into your definition. What does it mean if I "agree" to your definition that god is "maker of everything"? Would you take that to mean that I am agreeing that there is a "maker of everything"? That would be in very bad faith on your part, but given your penchant for shouting "HAHA GOTCHA" in threads, people have come to expect a certain amount of game-playing on your part.

All that we really need to establish is a definition for what your propose to prove. You don't need us to "agree" to it.

I will agree to this: "Yrreg claims that there is an entity called god, which yrreg claims made everything [except, presumably, himself]."

Otherwise you will go on and on and on and on and on and on with spaghetti and feeling so smart that you have what? hoodwinked yourselves into a comfortable posture of perpetually atheisting, but in fact betraying yourselves as what? shallow thinkers.

Why shallow thinkers? Because only shallow thinkers resort to name-calling or bad-mouthing God, instead of analyzing the concept of God prior to attempts at proofs against His existence.

In which case you atheists are not thinkers at all, but name-callers.

Name-calling? Is that like repeatedly calling people "shallow thinkers"?
 
You keep saying that God is a leprechaun, Santa, invisible pink unicorn, flying spaghetti monster, celestial teapot, etc.
Please find one post which does this. You won't find one.

Nobody thinks that your god is the same thing as a leprechaun or Santa or a teapot. The evidence for your god's existence is the same as the evidence of any of the other entities' existence. It's not the same thing. If you've had as much practice taking IQ tests as you claim, you would know this.

That is your routine avoidance strategy, and the reason why I always get the impression and now the certainty that either you atheists don't really know what you are atheisting against, or you just want to skirt the need to do logical thinking, fearing that logic will bring you to God.
First we were sour-graping and now we're atheisting? Are there any other nouns that you want to verb?

Also, atheists don't fear that logic will bring them to god. For many atheists, logic has brought them away from god. There's no logical reason to posit the existence of any god, let alone one that possesses such human attributes as jealousy, hatred, vengence, love, justice, or intelligence.

Anyway, as I said, definitions have got to be agreed on first before we come to the proof of existence or evidence presentation.
Then define what you mean by god being the maker of everything in existence. Does this include himself or not? Is he part of everything, or does he get a special pass? If he didn't make himself, where did he come from?

Otherwise you will go on and on and on and on and on and on with spaghetti and feeling so smart that you have what? hoodwinked yourselves into a comfortable posture of perpetually atheisting, but in fact betraying yourselves as what? shallow thinkers.
The people being hoodwinked are the ones who have given their time, money, self-worth or dignity (among other things) to the purveyors of magical thinking.

Why shallow thinkers? Because only shallow thinkers resort to name-calling or bad-mouthing God, instead of analyzing the concept of God prior to attempts at proofs against His existence.
Saying that there's as much proof for god's existence as their is for the existence of a flying spaghetti monster is NOT bad-mouthing god. It's simply true. There's no evidence for either. 0 = 0
 
Damn I hate this God character. I hate him, I hate him, I hate him! I mean, he's such a revolting psychopath, how can anyone not hate him?

But you know who's even worse? Sauron. The way he lied to those nice Elves and turned them into Orcs really pisses me off!
 
God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the maker [in place of author] of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


How do you know it wasn't a team of 300 gods making everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe?
 
Okay, so you are not happy with my expanded definition of God, so let me just go...

Okay, so you are not happy with my expanded definition of God, so let me just go back to my previous most brief in three words concept of God:

Maker of everything.​

Happy now?


What next?


Ah yes, I said concept of God from Christians, now I am not bringing in Christians.


I am still having the Christian God in mind, but if you want me to exclude the Christian God, I want to tell you that you are being petty to no advantage to yourselves except to be petty.

You see in the concept of God from Christians, there is the most important core, and that is maker of everything.

You want me to denounce the attributes Christians assign to God like omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence.

No need to denounce and renounce them unless I want be illogical, because those attributes follow from the core concept of maker of everything by way of necessary inference.

You want to show that those attributes cannot be in God because God will be internally inconsistent, but you are not really conversant about the nature of God as God Himself is in Himself and knows Himself.

In other words in you knowledge of God you want to see that there is internal inconsistency between the attributes of God among themselves and also with the core concept of God as maker of everything, that is in your knowledge that is willy nilly limited and imperfect.

You cannot claim to be all knowing as to know the nature of God as it is in God Himself, not as known to you in your limited and imperfect brain.


Anyway, you want me to also wrap up myself in inconsistency the way you want yourselves to do so, to justify your being atheists.

That is not to my mind an honest valuation of God, but a dishonest one, dishonest intellectually.

And I will not be dishonest intellectually; what I can say is that in the imperfect and thus limited consideration of our puny knowledge we might seem to see inconsistency among the attributes men assign to God and in regard to God's core concept of maker of everything, but the reality is that God is the maker of everything and on that basis there can be no genuinely inconsistency among the attributes men assign to Him among themselves the attributes, and in regard to God's core concept of maker of everything.

Now, I want you to admit that those attributes of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence are assigned to God on the basis of man's own knowledge of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence, which in all objective factuality man really don't have the kind of knowledge by which man can know God as God knows Himself, that is why I say that man knows God only imperfectly and in a limited degree.

Withal man's thinking of God from his exposure to the world that he has access to though imperfect and limited is still sufficient for him to come to the certainty of God as the maker of everything.




As I always say, the study of atheists should focus on their psychology of being atheists, emotive motivations for denying God's existence, rather than the intellectual or cognitive grounds for denial.

And so far as evidence for God's existence is concerned people who know God to exist have all the evidence they need, these evidences presented to atheists will never be relevant and sufficient because their kind of evidence is of the dungeoned kind, constricted and perverted kind, and thus only useful to them for a pseudo platform for objections but of no worth whatever to topple the big picture of God as maker of everything.

What is also very useful for understanding the psychology of atheists and thus their kind of consequential cognitivity, is to discern what are the worldview impasses between theists on the one side and atheists from the other side, and unearth the grounds of those impasses.

Briefly put, the most foundational impasse between theists and atheists is for theists there is God maker of everything, for atheists there is only matter in randomness.

And then also for theists there is the whole totality of existence which includes the physical universe, whereas for atheists there is only the physical universe which atheists consider to be everything that is of empirical access to themselves -- but then that empirical universe they know also that man can only have an imperfect and limited access to.




Yrreg
 
You want me to denounce the attributes Christians assign to God like omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence.

No need to denounce and renounce them unless I want be illogical, because those attributes follow from the core concept of maker of everything by way of necessary inference.


Omnipotence, omniscience and omnibenevolence do not logically follow from the definition "maker of everything".

It is conceivable that God made everything, but cannot undo what has been done. Therefore, it is possible to be "maker of everything", but not be omnipotent.

It is conceivable that God made everything, but doesn't know what I am thinking at this moment in time. Therefore, it is possible to be "maker of everything", but not be omniscient.

It is conceivable that God made everything, but has a nasty streak. In fact, the Bible seems to support this type of god. Therefore, it is possible to be "maker of everything", but not be omnibenevolent.

To scale it down to our level, if a man and woman create a child and smack the child when it is naughty, they cannot unsmack it, they cannot read the child's thoughts and they can be downright evil to the child. However, they still created said child.
 
Now, will you just join me in finding out what is wrong with my concept of God:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the maker [in place of author] of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.
He doesn't exist. Or at least there is no evidence that he does.
 
I'm generally what one would classify as a strong atheist. It may be impossible to disprove the existence of any particular god, but I don't think there's any good reason to think one exists, anymore than there's reason to believe there really is a teacup orbiting the sun.

Splitter! It's the celestial teapot you're supposed to not believe in. Have you been missing the weekly atheist meetings?
 
I hold females in the greatest of honor, because they are the mothers of mankind.


Now, will you just join me in finding out what is wrong with my concept of God:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the maker [in place of author] of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.

The second important word there is everything.

Do you have any trouble with the word everything, it means everything as everything is understood by anyone with any reading comprehension of English as to read newspapers in English intelligently.



Yrreg
Yreeg using the word intelligently,how ironic.Yrreg my lad,there is no "maker of everything",so what are you banging on about? Give it a rest and go and do something useful.
 
Okay, so you are not happy with my expanded definition of God, so let me just go back to my previous most brief in three words concept of God:
Maker of everything.​
Happy now?


What next?


Ah yes, I said concept of God from Christians, now I am not bringing in Christians.


I am still having the Christian God in mind, but if you want me to exclude the Christian God, I want to tell you that you are being petty to no advantage to yourselves except to be petty.

You see in the concept of God from Christians, there is the most important core, and that is maker of everything.

You want me to denounce the attributes Christians assign to God like omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence.

No need to denounce and renounce them unless I want be illogical, because those attributes follow from the core concept of maker of everything by way of necessary inference.

You want to show that those attributes cannot be in God because God will be internally inconsistent, but you are not really conversant about the nature of God as God Himself is in Himself and knows Himself.

In other words in you knowledge of God you want to see that there is internal inconsistency between the attributes of God among themselves and also with the core concept of God as maker of everything, that is in your knowledge that is willy nilly limited and imperfect.

You cannot claim to be all knowing as to know the nature of God as it is in God Himself, not as known to you in your limited and imperfect brain.


Anyway, you want me to also wrap up myself in inconsistency the way you want yourselves to do so, to justify your being atheists.

That is not to my mind an honest valuation of God, but a dishonest one, dishonest intellectually.

And I will not be dishonest intellectually; what I can say is that in the imperfect and thus limited consideration of our puny knowledge we might seem to see inconsistency among the attributes men assign to God and in regard to God's core concept of maker of everything, but the reality is that God is the maker of everything and on that basis there can be no genuinely inconsistency among the attributes men assign to Him among themselves the attributes, and in regard to God's core concept of maker of everything.

Now, I want you to admit that those attributes of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence are assigned to God on the basis of man's own knowledge of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence, which in all objective factuality man really don't have the kind of knowledge by which man can know God as God knows Himself, that is why I say that man knows God only imperfectly and in a limited degree.

Withal man's thinking of God from his exposure to the world that he has access to though imperfect and limited is still sufficient for him to come to the certainty of God as the maker of everything.




As I always say, the study of atheists should focus on their psychology of being atheists, emotive motivations for denying God's existence, rather than the intellectual or cognitive grounds for denial.

And so far as evidence for God's existence is concerned people who know God to exist have all the evidence they need, these evidences presented to atheists will never be relevant and sufficient because their kind of evidence is of the dungeoned kind, constricted and perverted kind, and thus only useful to them for a pseudo platform for objections but of no worth whatever to topple the big picture of God as maker of everything.

What is also very useful for understanding the psychology of atheists and thus their kind of consequential cognitivity, is to discern what are the worldview impasses between theists on the one side and atheists from the other side, and unearth the grounds of those impasses.

Briefly put, the most foundational impasse between theists and atheists is for theists there is God maker of everything, for atheists there is only matter in randomness.

And then also for theists there is the whole totality of existence which includes the physical universe, whereas for atheists there is only the physical universe which atheists consider to be everything that is of empirical access to themselves -- but then that empirical universe they know also that man can only have an imperfect and limited access to.




Yrreg

Athiests believe that there is no *********** god!,that's all we have in common. Why do you seem unable to grasp this simple point?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I believe it is impossible to know whether a god exists. Since, it is impossible to know whether a god exists, I don't believe in any particular one. For the same reason, I don't believe in:

  • Flying Spaghetti Monsters
  • Invisible Pink Unicorns
  • Time-travelling Chimpanzees
  • Leprechauns
  • Fairies

Some would call me an atheist, while others would call me an agnostic. I don't particularly care which label you use.

By the way, why don't you believe in fairies?

Well Rev?
 
please, everyone, if you have anything pertinent to say, don't say it in fine print.





Yrreg

please give us your list of the gods you do not believe in,and your reasons why.
 
Last edited:
...And so far as evidence for God's existence is concerned people who know God to exist have all the evidence they need, these evidences presented to atheists will never be relevant and sufficient because their kind of evidence is of the dungeoned kind, constricted and perverted kind, and thus only useful to them for a pseudo platform for objections but of no worth whatever to topple the big picture of God as maker of everything. ...Yrreg

Perverted?
And this from yrreg, who brought us the 'penis as proof of God' argument?
 
.
Men like Jim Jones, or Marshall Applewhite , or Prophet Yahweh, or.... the list of deluded people claiming to be THE outlet for the divine truth is endless.
L. Ron Hubbard, Joseph Smith, Muhammed, Mary Baker Eddy....
False prophets that were not following anything in the bible, they preached false doctrine. The bible warns about these people. Just compare what they are saying with scripture. They may sprinkle scripture in with thiere own peverted adgenda but if it doesnt correlate with the bible dont drink the koolaid.


How do you know that the authors of the Bible were not false prophets?
 
.
Men like Jim Jones, or Marshall Applewhite , or Prophet Yahweh, or.... the list of deluded people claiming to be THE outlet for the divine truth is endless.
L. Ron Hubbard, Joseph Smith, Muhammed, Mary Baker Eddy....

Okay, let us get going into the concept of God, without bringing in spaghetti.



I say that:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


First important word in that definition of God, the word maker.


Do you atheists have any trouble with the word maker, just that word, please for now, don't go into the invisible pink unicorn, and above all keep that spaghetti in the kitchen, we are into serious business, finding out if anyone conversant with English is having any trouble with word maker.




Yrreg


You are highlighting the problem with your definition: it doesn't[/i] exclude the Flying Spaghetti Monster (or any number of alternative deities). If you insist of a definition of God that fits the FSM, you can't object to the FSM being brought into the conversation.

I'm not saying that your God is a Flying Spaghetti Monster, and I don't believe that the FSM exists. I'm merely pointing out a problem with your definition.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom