What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

That was an wrong impression held by atheist apologists. If my argument was correct it would give strong evidence for a creator.
So... your 'argument' (for want of a better, less grandiose term) is wrong, right?


So of course in an atheist site you would get that impression.

Although there are many atheists actively participating on this forum, this is NOT an atheist site - see the thread entitled The JREF is not an atheist organization

Its a given, but I thought I would attempt to present the truth for those that may be fence sitting and can think critically.
Now you're getting closer... this site overtly aims to promote critical thinking
jrefheadertext.gif

​
Care to try it?
 
Give it up bud, these people (I should say the handful of the usual suspects) have no real desire to debate the issues they live for the argument not the debate. I do wish the real atheists would post. Hey what about a head count?

Strong atheists or other?

Have I already said that?

The fear of being exposed settles in ~

; {>
You're mistaken, I think. Many of us for a very long time in this and other Yrreg threads have demonstrated a willingness to accept Yrreg's working definition of God, despite its obvious flaws, which have been pointed out many times as well (see above earlier tonight, in which an attempt was made to get Yrreg to include exclusivity and eternity in his definition - ideas which most Christian theists would accept without argument).

Yrreg seems to be under the impression that if one only agreed to his definition of God and understood it, atheism would be impossible. Perhaps he has in mind a home-brewed ontological proof. Unfortunately, we may never find out, since he is unable to present his case with clarity. Yrreg has so far been unable to provide a convincing argument for the existence of the God he has defined, and tends to fall back into insult and digression when he fails. Whether the fault is in his definition, his argument, his own understanding of what he asserts, the simple non-existence of the god in question, or all of the above, is really immaterial. His argument, such as it is, has not been successful because it has not been well made.
 
You don't like the word author; okay, change that to maker; okay now?

One of the problem words for me is "author" as it implies intelligence. You haven't shown any evidence of intelligence for your putative maker yet. You haven't shown evidence that there is a maker either, but I'm skipping that for the moment.


You don't like the word author; okay, change that to maker; okay now?


So, now my concept of God is as follows:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the maker [in place of author] of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


Next, the word everything, does any atheists have any trouble with understanding the word everything?




Yrreg
 
I'm generally what one would classify as a strong atheist. It may be impossible to disprove the existence of any particular god, but I don't think there's any good reason to think one exists, anymore than there's reason to believe there really is a teacup orbiting the sun. I believe that all god beliefs (across cultures and throughout history) are man-made constructs, used in an effort to explain things that could not be explained otherwise, and also in an effort to effect or maintain a power base.

I don't believe it's a sensible position to believe that one god belief is somehow true, while believing that all the others are false/imaginary, or that one interpretation is closer to the true nature of god than any others. I'm most familiar with the old/new testament Abrahamic god of the bible, and find it utterly ridiculous to think that an all-powerful being would show his "best self" to a small sect of middle eastern goatherders.

Careful, SC - talking about that orbiting teacup is "hate speech". It is, in fact, a "religious slur," "gutter talk," and...I forget what else. :rolleyes:
 
You don't like the word author; okay, change that to maker; okay now?


So, now my concept of God is as follows:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the maker [in place of author] of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


Next, the word everything, does any atheists have any trouble with understanding the word everything?




Yrreg

Great, now address Dunstan's concerns.

Why are you asking anyone to agree to a definition of your god(s)? Define it however you like and then defend it or provide evidence for it.
 
So, now my concept of God is as follows:

God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the maker [in place of author] of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.

Fine. Now all you have to do is demonstrate a logical reason to believe that such a thing exists.
 
Great, now address Dunstan's concerns.

Why are you asking anyone to agree to a definition of your god(s)? Define it however you like and then defend it or provide evidence for it.

I get the impression, although I could be mistaken, that Gerry thinks that definition is his proof. I think his strategy is leading to something like this:

"Something made everything, so whatever that something was is what I call 'God'. Oh, and did I mention that it happens to be the Catholic God."
 
Okay, let us get going into the concept of God, without bringing in spaghetti.



I say that:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


First important word in that definition of God, the word maker.


Do you atheists have any trouble with the word maker, just that word, please for now, don't go into the invisible pink unicorn, and above all keep that spaghetti in the kitchen, we are into serious business, finding out if anyone conversant with English is having any trouble with word maker.

Yeah, I do not find the word maker to be unproblematic. To quote what I already said in post #46:
Maker: Means what? Normally if I am faced with the word maker I will assume that if refers to a human being. But I doubt that this is the case here. So, if what I would perceive as the literal meaning does not apply, I would have to opt for understanding it as a metaphor. There is nothing wrong with that per se, it is only that there are software packages, like File Maker, which use the word "maker" as well.

So, without further specification I have no clue how to imagine that "maker" in question, let alone imagining how what the making is like.

Come to think of it I do think "maker" suggests something along the lines of intentionality and purpose. Now do you, or don't you want any of that? Would a software package, or a piece of machinery (as in "coffeemaker") fit the bill or should there be more to it?

And if so, what?
 
You don't like the word author; okay, change that to maker; okay now?
Yrreg, we all understand the words you're using. I can't speak for anyone else here, but to me there's no difference whether you use the word "maker" or "author." What matters is that there's absolutely no evidence that the universe requires a maker/author.

So, now my concept of God is as follows:

God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the maker [in place of author] of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.
If God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, does that mean that your God is also the maker of himself/itself, or is god not part of the whole totality of existence, as you see it?

Next, the word everything, does any atheists have any trouble with understanding the word everything?
I think a more specific definition would help here. See above. Does "everything" include god? Does "everything" include imaginary concepts, like "heaven?" Does "everything" include the dinner I ate tonight?

Careful, SC - talking about that orbiting teacup is "hate speech". It is, in fact, a "religious slur," "gutter talk," and...I forget what else. :rolleyes:
My bad. *sigh* I guess I'm just really angry at god, and that makes me so hateful. :rolleyes:
 
I hold females in the greatest of honor, because they are the mothers of mankind.

No true atheist fallacy? Do you not see how offensive and insulting you are? Because the atheists here won't supply the definitions of your particular magical sky daddies, we're somehow afraid of debate? Why do you think your god is so special anyway? What exactly differentiates him from every other god belief throughout history? The evidence for your god, whatever your god may be, is no better and no worse than the evidence from your neighbor's god. In all cases, it's non-existant.

Btw, I've been an atheist my entire life. Is that real enough for you or yrreg? (I know yrreg doesn't count me, as I'm female.)


I hold females in the greatest of honor, because they are the mothers of mankind.


Now, will you just join me in finding out what is wrong with my concept of God:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the maker [in place of author] of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.

The second important word there is everything.

Do you have any trouble with the word everything, it means everything as everything is understood by anyone with any reading comprehension of English as to read newspapers in English intelligently.




Yrreg
 
Now, will you just join me in finding out what is wrong with my concept of God


This continues to be an exercise in simplicity: What is wrong with your concept of god? Nothing, except it, your god, does not exist. Sky Daddy is a figment of your imagination. If that's not a problem for you, it is not a problem for me, either.
 
Now, will you just join me in finding out what is wrong with my concept of God:

  • God is the maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe, and the maker [in place of author] of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.


I am okay with your concept of God. However, there is no evidence such an entity exists.


The second important word there is everything.

Do you have any trouble with the word everything, it means everything as everything is understood by anyone with any reading comprehension of English as to read newspapers in English intelligently.


The word 'everything' would include God. This creates a paradox. An entity cannot create itself. Therefore, God, as defined by you, does not exist. We can leave it at that or you can take another stab at a definition.
 
If I weren't I am sure Milligan would want their degree back. Yes I knew that even before my first year at seminary. You see I think for some big events God took the universe off auto pilot and tweaks it a bit
Special pleading.

case study was Constantine's conversion to Christianity.
God had to directly intervene in the laws of physics to convert one guy?

I am not as in your face as my more traditional brethren are, and do the absolute minimum to make sure anyone who wants to know the good news does.
Does that include insulting everyone who disagrees with you, or is that a bonus just for us?

There are many ways to discern truth my friend.
Wrong.

A tiny group of Christians that were hated as much as your group is today, and they rose above all the other religions is not evidence but a hint.
Well, you're half right. It's certainly not evidence.

Fulfilled Bible prophesy is another
What fulfilled Bible prophesy?

but atheist doctrine makes it VERY difficult for an atheist realize that the bible is an accurate book.
One, what atheist doctrine?

Two, the Bible is no more accurate than the Iliad and the Odyssey. And those are far more entertaining.

Then there are the many other evidences that that I use because they are so in your face obvious.
Such as?

If you don't like a big thick book of theology get a popular book like a case for the creator and ignore what the secular critics have said (they have to say its a lie etc) and attempt to read it with an open mind. If you would have already of read it you would know what many of my evidences are, but not all.
Strawman, ad hominem, begging the question, lousy grammar.

So, RevD, what are these "evidences" of yours?
 
delete...I accidentally responded to pixie post...I am saving the personal content and triage them for last, and may post it again later.
What personal content?

RevD, it appears that you have identified yourself so closely with your beliefs that you mistake arguments against the latter for person insults. And in your responses you mistake personal insults for arguments.

Neither approach is terribly productive.
 
False prophets that were not following anything in the bible, they preached false doctrine. The bible warns about these people. Just compare what they are saying with scripture.
Why?

The Bible doesn't mention Marduk or Tiamat, so it's clearly wrong.

They may sprinkle scripture in with thiere own peverted adgenda but if it doesnt correlate with the bible dont drink the koolaid.
So we should only drink the koolaid when it does correlate with the Bible? That's good to know.
 
When you use words that are obvious religious slurs the world over (except in dirty little corners where anything goes) and act like you can't understand the correlation of religious insults with racial and sexual identification smears and taunts, while feigning ignorance or ? then it is you that is beyond help not I.
Nope.

Beliefs are fair game. Always. Anyone can - and should - examine their beliefs and adjust them to suit the facts.

None of this is true for race (which is not a valid scientific concept with respect to homo sap. anyway).


The person that uses religious and racial slurs etc as a matter of conversation or debate are lacking in several areas of human compassion and maturity.
Fail.

We're not using "religious slurs". We're attacking your argument. If you don't like that, get a better argument.
 
Well I know I lied if I said that!
You did say that.

Because I know your stance is the opposite of that.
Right.

If I said that I lied by mistake and it would not serve me in anyway to say it.
What?

So it was a typo and I am only sorry for that.
A typo? A typo?!

No, RevD, this is no typo:

I don't know if Wolly is an expert or not. He has not claimed to be one when speaking to me. And as I said If he is an expert he is being disingenuous or lacking that part of his education when he tells you and anyone who will listen the falsehood the big bang implies more than one universe.
That's a strawman and an ad hominem attack.

I am well aware that we are at an impasse in that area.
No impasse. You're just wrong.
 
Well lets have a look ;

Originally Posted by RevDisturba View Post
"And as I said If he is an expert he is being disingenuous or lacking that part of his education when he tells you and anyone who will listen the falsehood the big bang implies more than one universe."

Yes an error, It should of read thusly;


Originally Posted by RevDisturba View Post
"And as I said If he is an expert he is being disingenuous or lacking that part of his education when he tells you and anyone who will listen the falsehood THAT the big bang DOESN'T IMPLY more than one universe."
If you keep piling on the negatives, you might eventually arrive at something that isn't not true.

What it should of said is in bold
Should HAVE said.

In other words your telling us that the big bang does not imply just one universe.
Exactly right. It doesn't imply anything of the sort.

I claim that the big bang implies only one universe.
Yes, you claim that. You are completely wrong.

So yes its a typo and I am sorry for the misunderstanding, I am responding to a lot of people and generating a huge amont of font, compared to most of you guys.
A huge amount of font?
 
To be logically systematic hence productive, work on definitions first.

Please don't spend the next 20 pages on the individual definitions of the words in your sentence. I don't think the bandwidth could handle it.

Let's get to the proof of the existence of the above entity. We're still waiting.


To be logically systematic hence productive, work on definitions first.

You keep saying that God is a leprechaun, Santa, invisible pink unicorn, flying spaghetti monster, celestial teapot, etc.

That is what I call bad-mouthing God instead to getting to be serious about exactly what you have for a concept of God against which you are 'atheisting' in calling yourselves atheists.

That is your routine avoidance strategy, and the reason why I always get the impression and now the certainty that either you atheists don't really know what you are atheisting against, or you just want to skirt the need to do logical thinking, fearing that logic will bring you to God.

Anyway, as I said, definitions have got to be agreed on first before we come to the proof of existence or evidence presentation.

Otherwise you will go on and on and on and on and on and on with spaghetti and feeling so smart that you have what? hoodwinked yourselves into a comfortable posture of perpetually atheisting, but in fact betraying yourselves as what? shallow thinkers.

Why shallow thinkers? Because only shallow thinkers resort to name-calling or bad-mouthing God, instead of analyzing the concept of God prior to attempts at proofs against His existence.

In which case you atheists are not thinkers at all, but name-callers.





Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom