What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

The rules don't apply to him, as he is in "atheist land" representing the one and only true god. He's allowed to insult us sinners. His god forgives him. I dare say it commands it.

This is atheist land and I am not allowed to insult or even remotely insult atheists or the atheist concept. We are all sinners. And you are correct I am representing what I personally think is the one true god. If you want to worship whatever that is your right and I respect anyone's beliefs,Levay satanists, wiccan pagan etc, too bad the concept of respect isn't reciprocal.

; {>
 
And if you want to know something about cosmology....

I am an serious amateur astronomer, but not an expert in astronomy or cosmology. But you still can ask me, some people get an degree from their life experience and other studies.

; {>
 
According to the bible, God:

  • <SNIP>


This post is what is so wrong with many armchair biblical experts.


The concept of having to have special knowledge or special training to correctly interpret the bible, and that those who do often present contradictory interpretations, doesn't say much for its status as a divine revelation to mankind.



There are no quotes only sloppy half copies...


I beg to differ, all the above are direct quotes.



...excerpted from god knows where...


I stated my source at the top of my post: The Bible.



...pulled out of context and order...(I could go on).


It was listed in order of the physical features attributed to God followed by things like actions and emotions. It was not listed in order of appearance in the text, but I don't see how that would make any difference.

As for context. An apologists typical first reaction is to claim that it's taken out of context. The context in this case is easily determined, however, most of the passages mention these features of God in passing. The context in which they are mentioned doesn't change the fact.



With all due respect, its worthless except to use as an example of bad..no horrible...no awful debate and even worse theology.


Someone commented that yrregs god has no other attributes other than being the creator. You indicated that the Bible is clear on what God is.

When I read the word clear I take it to mean:

Not obscured; Free from impediment, obstruction, or hindrance; Open; Plain or evident to the mind; Unmistakable; Easily perceptible; Distinct; Free from doubt or confusion; Certain; Free from qualification or limitation; Absolute.​

I presented passages that clearly indicate some of the features of God. I didn't think that I was arguing against your position at all. In fact, my post appears to support your position, that the Bible is clear on what God is.

As for theology. I'll leave that to the theologians.


If you want to know the attributes of the Christian God ask or pick one piece of scripture...


I know all about the Christian God, I used to be a Christian. If you want to discuss Christian scripture, I'm fine with that. Pick any of the passages I listed and we can discuss it.


...and include the book and verse. Otherwise all you are going to have is a mishmash of dog poo and is good for what dog poo is good for, to dispose of it as quickly as possible.


Chapter/verse numbers, as we know them, are a quite late arrival. People have discussed scripture for centuries without them. I disagree that this results in a "mishmash of dog poo."
 
Your welcome.:D If you cant make a case using the bible its not anything Christian.
; }>

How about if you can make a case using the bible? Does that make it christian?

In hopes of winning the MDC I'll predict the gist of the answer :D
"If you can make a case using a bible that cannot be considered christian, then you are not using the bible right".
 
Fiona said:
Ah, you mean like Wollery on astrophyscis?

I don't know if Wolly is an expert or not. He has not claimed to be one when speaking to me. And as I said If he is an expert he is being disingenuous or lacking that part of his education when he tells you and anyone who will listen the falsehood the big bang implies more than one universe.

You know something, RevDisturba: I have mentioned before that it would be good if you held yourself to the same standards you demand of others: I now add it would be helpful if you practised what you preach, as well :)

Well you are correct, I should hold myself to the standards I demand of others but I don't. I hold myself to much higher standards that I demand of others! I do practice what I preach as well, come on down to hillbilly land and see for yourself (or check the public records of carter county TN for my humanitarian mission 2004-2009) and church records.

; {>
 
Last edited:
How about if you can make a case using the bible? Does that make it christian?

In hopes of winning the MDC I'll predict the gist of the answer :D
"If you can make a case using a bible that cannot be considered christian, then you are not using the bible right".

If its a valid case. If you use scripture in context and accurately yes it makes it a christian argument, but it may not be a valid argument.

; {>
 
What "atheist concept"? The one that is like the hobby of not collecting stamps?

That would be a good one. You would have your stamp collecters then some angry people that thinks stamps don't exist. The really funny thing will be when they try to mail a letter!

That come back has seen its day and it wasn't a good one when it was overused. No its the lack of belief. I can build a cult on anything including a lack of belief. Or nothingness. ]

Then you have all the flavors of atheists that some say do exist and some (atheists) say don't exist....

eh?

; {> : }> : {>
 
Last edited:
Phase Inverter; said:
The concept of having to have special knowledge or special training to correctly interpret the bible, and that those who do often present contradictory interpretations, doesn't say much for its status as a divine revelation to mankind.

I am going to review your reply again Mr Phase Inverter. I have made huge blunders in the past because I am a bit touchy, and if I have misread the intent of your post or have the material facts of your post wrong I will correct and or apologize, fair enough?

; {>
 
I don't know if Wolly is an expert or not. He has not claimed to be one when speaking to me. And as I said If he is an expert he is being disingenuous or lacking that part of his education when he tells you and anyone who will listen the falsehood the big bang implies more than one universe.

I don't suppose you can point to a post where wollery or anyone else actually says that?

You can't, because that is not what the argument was. The big bang does not imply more than one universe; it also doesn't imply only one, either.
 
jsfisher said:
Redo, eh? That whole new covenant / old covenant thing? Help me understand this part of the New Testament, then:

Originally Posted by Matthew 5
17"Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished."

That is one of the most misunderstood passages of the new testament but not too difficult if you had read the prior scripture annd know your bible. Its not litertal and is a parable about your soul and how importat it is, think of the scripture that says if your eye offends you dig it out!...

Anyway~

Its a prime example of why we must use scripture to define scripture and how the new and old testament is meant to be used together. Instead of filling up the page with biblical font I will out of respect refer you to a site that explains exactly what this passage means. It is shorter than I could make but still a fairly long explanation. If you want me to clarify it for you after you have read it let me know.

http://www.gnmagazine.org/issues/gn05/jesuschristabolishlaw.htm

; {>
 
I feel like it doesn't make much difference whether a person believes in God or doesn't. It could remain a personal, secret matter for a lifetime, without ever being a divisive issue.

The problem starts with words written by man, claiming to be God's words.
If we could just get over that silliness, we'd be good to go.

I find it disingenuous that Christians have decided on a particular set of gospels; that the 'word' has been edited immensely according to man's whimsy or agenda...and that non-christian mono-theists have a whole different set of words, from the same one God, that are at odds with other versions.

If someone tells me that God spoke to them, that's cool, and I'd even ask "What was said?" But when they defer to here-say and rumor as their evidence, I'm not interested.
 
I don't suppose you can point to a post where wollery or anyone else actually says that?

You can't, because that is not what the argument was. The big bang does not imply more than one universe; it also doesn't imply only one, either.

DaH-na dah-na dahna dahnadahnada na <<<< that was supposed to be Jaws music

Gawd.....just when you thought it was safe in another thread...

; {>
 
This is atheist land and I am not allowed to insult or even remotely insult atheists or the atheist concept.

Yet you do so anyway. Your posts generally devolve into flaming if your arguments are debunked.

We are all sinners.

Bare assertion. I challenge you to prove it. And sin only exists if you subscribe to religion.

And you are correct I am representing what I personally think is the one true god. If you want to worship whatever that is your right and I respect anyone's beliefs,Levay satanists, wiccan pagan etc,

Good for you. Just so long as we worship something, eh? I look at it this way: theists don't care if you play their little game by different rules, just so long as you play. But when they see us atheists standing in the corner and refusing to pick up the dice, they get mad. Because seeing us denying that the game is important makes them feel like they're wasting their time, but they don't want to quit and learn a new game either.
Bad analogy. I like board games; there's no way I wouldn't be playing.


too bad the concept of respect isn't reciprocal.


It is. No one has flamed you, no one has responded to your vitriolic posts in turn. Your beliefs get mocked, but you mock ours as well. You are simply determined to be able to tell yourself that we are all horrible nasty small-minded people who hate you, since then you no longer have to question your beliefs if we don't listen.

; {>

Your welcome.:D If you cant make a case using the bible its not anything Christian.

Well, duh.

There are many ways to describe an event, but if its not in the bible you might as well be using the satantic bible.

There's a Satanic Bible now?

; }>

I don't use the word 'it' for common courtesy. But what about the Bible? Doesn't the Bible refer to God as exclusively male?

It does, yeah.

Doesn't that make it sacrilegious to refer to God as female? No. God is described in many forms in the bible, none meant to be taken literately, God is a spirit.

Bare assertion.

You mentioned calling God it. There is good reason the bible references God as male. For one thing we can say it’s a given that most of the men who scribed their words onto parchment in the distant past considered women inferior.

Bare assertion. They may have believed women inferior, but you can't prove that this is the reason they referred to their god as male.

But what many traditional preachers don’t know is that that Hebrew (the old testament was written primarily in Hebrew, with a few small sections written in Aramaic which was essentially a variation of Hebrew) has no concept for “it,” ! The kicker is that most words in Hebrew default to the masculine gender ! Hello Ms!

...Yay?

That depends on which God we are speaking of. Personally I feel there is only one non created eternal being that created the universe and it is God. I feel all the other religions are simply attempts to assign attributes to this creator God. I happen to choose Christianity as the most accurate attempt to describe God. None of the religions including Christianity describe God with an accuracy of 100%.

This still doesn't change the fact that the FSM argument works. We have as much evidence for the FSM as for your god. So why should we worship Yaweh over His Noodlyness?

Think about it. The authors are human, they have to use something to compare their concepts to. For example the first 12 chapters of Genesis were written primarily by an Yahwist , (putative author of the earliest sources of the Hexateuch, or first six books of the bible) making use of some material provided by the Elohist (E) (he Elohist (E) is one of four sources of the Torah ) both of them so-called by their favored name for God.

This actually makes sense. I mean, they were describing a god that doesn't exist, but this really does make sense as to why they would give it human attributes. But still, this book is supposed to be the absolute authority on your god. If parts of it are unreliable - especially if those are the parts which describe that god's characteristics - shouldn't you be worried?

Scripture that refer to Yahweh (allahiym) are usually called JE passages. El was the principle god of the Canaanite and the Palestinian pantheon. In the texts his companion AKA as Elath or Eloah, and when combined they were named Elohim, the gods. I could go on but fear that my words would be taken out of context. I will say that if anything the biblical name for God is a combination of male and female concepts.



Its what they were taught, and it doesn’t harm the religion, because the core message is the only important thing. That is that the bible is a manual for saving ones soul, God wants us to live forever and not end up in the grave (of no self awareness) forever.

So the IPU argument doesn't hurt your belief in your god? Hmm. I wonder why you're so angry about it, then?

Some of its translated material like textual vestiges and some is used to allow us to comprehend difficult and complex ideas. Some have important clues to what the author meant spiritually, again Hebrew is not English and we lose a lot of meaning when translated. I wish everyone could take a course in Hebrew that was bible curious, it would open a lot of eyes, sometimes profoundly so.

In other words, nothing. Like he said.

I think you may enjoy studying advanced theology. Look at it this way if you didn’t convert to Christianity (I think you would upon full understanding of Gods word) you could use it as ammo in debate.

Somehow I doubt that taking a theology class would convert me. But why would we need any more ammo for a debate? We're doing fine so far.

; {>

Glad to see you appear to be in a better mood now, Rev. Now we can have a civil conversation again.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom