What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

The problem starts with words written by man, claiming to be God's words.
If we could just get over that silliness, we'd be good to go.

Ummm how could god write it any other way and still be a christian God?

I find it disingenuous that Christians have decided on a particular set of gospels; that the 'word' has been edited immensely according to man's whimsy or agenda

Huh? Its the most accurate copies of the original of any ancient manuscript, what you are parroting is a secular generated lie.

...and that non-christian mono-theists have a whole different set of words, from the same one God, that are at odds with other versions.

Again you should check were that ummm'...material is coming from, its a lie. I don't think its your fault, I mean with a name like quarky how could you be in a conspiracy or anything like that?

If someone tells me that God spoke to them, that's cool, and I'd even ask "What was said?" But when they defer to here-say and rumor as their evidence, I'm not interested.

Again your sc saves you Mr Quarky...







; {>
 
Last edited:
RevDisturba, I don't think your reading comprehension is all it should be.

What "atheist concept"? The one that is like the hobby of not collecting stamps?
That would be a good one. You would have your stamp collecters then some angry people that thinks stamps don't exist. The really funny thing will be when they try to mail a letter!

[Emphasis added.]
Would you like another try to fix your non sequitur?
 
Glad to see you appear to be in a better mood now, Rev. Now we can have a civil conversation again.

I am fine as long as I am not getting poked in the eye with a sharp verbal stick, I have never claimed to be a meek turn the other cheek christian, although I try to be. Hey God loves you and I am trying to! ;)

; }>

ut' ho' I saw bold type as I posted this...time to take Bogie on his sunday walk >>>>> Jfisher<<<<<
 
RevDisturba said:
I find it disingenuous that Christians have decided on a particular set of gospels; that the 'word' has been edited immensely according to man's whimsy or agenda

Huh? Its the most accurate copies of the original of any ancient manuscript, what you are parroting is a secular generated lie.
Are you familiar with how the books which make up the bible were decided on?

...and that non-christian mono-theists have a whole different set of words, from the same one God, that are at odds with other versions.

Again you should check were that ummm'...material is coming from, its a lie.
I'm not sure you understood the point that was being made. Christianity is not the only monotheistic religion; oddly, the others are also under the impression that god has revealed the truth to them in holy words. How does one tell which is correct?

I don't think its your fault, I mean with a name like quarky how could you be in a conspiracy or anything like that?
I'm not really sure why you felt the need to go back and edit that in.
 
That is one of the most misunderstood passages of the new testament

I would agree, but for exactly the opposite reason as you.

...but not too difficult if you had read the prior scripture annd know your bible. Its not litertal and is a parable about your soul and how importat it is, think of the scripture that says if your eye offends you dig it out!

Now, you are just making stuff up. Not literal? Is that code for "we'll just ignore this inconvenient part"? And even it if were a parable, it would still be conveying religious doctrine. But, of course, it is not a parable. It is just a direct statement of doctrine, to be taken literally. A rather straight-forward statement at that.

...
If you want me to clarify it for you after you have read it let me know.

http://www.gnmagazine.org/issues/gn05/jesuschristabolishlaw.htm

Amusingly enough, your link supports my plain English interpretation, not your rather convoluted sideways view. Here's the conclusion that article reaches:

[QUOTE="The Good News" propaganda site]Jesus did exactly what the prophets foretold. He came to expound the full meaning of God's law. He did not introduce new laws and void the old in a rebellion against His Father. He upheld the law of God publicly and in practice.[/QUOTE]
 
RevDisturba, I don't think your reading comprehension is all it should be.



[Emphasis added.]
Would you like another try to fix your non sequitur?

No while I may lack reading comp. you have a problem with definitions. You called a stone cold fact a non sequitur with them thar Oh big fonts! I'd be embarrassed!
BTW what flavor of atheist are you? Check one strong or other (please explain)

; }>
 
Anyway I would rather educate than insult, and only insult after being insulted many many many oh so many times.

; {>

You have not been insulted. You do the insulting. It is one of your specialities, so far as I can see.

I don't know if Wolly is an expert or not. He has not claimed to be one when speaking to me.

True: because the quality of the argument is what matters to him, as he explained

And as I said If he is an expert he is being disingenuous or lacking that part of his education when he tells you and anyone who will listen the falsehood the big bang implies more than one universe.

Another lie

Well you are correct, I should hold myself to the standards I demand of others but I don't. I hold myself to much higher standards that I demand of others!

Oh, I did not realise that telling more lies was a higher standard. I did not realise that insulting people gratuitously was a higher standard. We all have our values, eh? :)

I do practice what I preach as well,

No that is not true. You preach a lack of insult in debate: you do not practice it. You preach against misrepresenting people's arguments: you do not practice that either.
 
I don't use the word 'it' for common courtesy. But what about the Bible?

Yes, what with it? Many people (read: Christians) could care less for what the Bible says, or even means by what it says.


Doesn't the Bible refer to God as exclusively male? Doesn't that make it sacrilegious to refer to God as female? No. God is described in many forms in the bible, none meant to be taken literately, God is a spirit.

Answer one:
Watch, how easy it is to just assert things:
God is described in many forms in the Bible, some is meant literally, some is metaphorical, God is anthropomorphic in shape.

Answer two:
Sure, I do understand that many of the things said in the Bible are not meant literally. BUT ... just dropping something like "This is poetic language" or similar is no get-free-out-of-jail-card so-to-speak. There are reasons why images are chosen. Metaphors and the comparisons they make can and should be explained.

All too often they aren't. It is "this is not literal." And nothing more.


You mentioned calling God it. There is good reason the bible references God as male. For one thing we can say it’s a given that most of the men who scribed their words onto parchment in the distant past considered women inferior. But what many traditional preachers don’t know is that that Hebrew (the old testament was written primarily in Hebrew, with a few small sections written in Aramaic which was essentially a variation of Hebrew) has no concept for “it,” ! The kicker is that most words in Hebrew default to the masculine gender ! Hello Ms!

Ergo, there is no real problem with using "it" or even "she." Is there? :D



That depends on which God we are speaking of.

Yes, that is what I meant by "many of the various Gods".



Personally I feel there is only one non created eternal being that created the universe and it is God. I feel all the other religions are simply attempts to assign attributes to this creator God. I happen to choose Christianity as the most accurate attempt to describe God. None of the religions including Christianity describe God with an accuracy of 100%.

This is your opinion. And there is nothing wrong with it as such of course.

But I do have to wonder what you mean by "the most accurate attempt to describe God."




Think about it. The authors are human, they have to use something to compare their concepts to.


Yes, I tend to think so as well. Once you look at any of such a comparisons you'll find that - of course! - it isn't really true or literal. And then you strip it off. And in the end nothing much is left. We, just like the bibilical authors, don't have the slightest clue what we are talking about.

And then, mind my wonder above at your talking about "the most accurate attempt to describe God."


Its what they were taught, and it doesn’t harm the religion, because the core message is the only important thing.

But the Invisible Pink Unicorn for instance does harm your "core message?" I mean, it does harm your "core message" more than say an average Young Earth Creationist along with his or her Bible choppings? Or, more than people who treat God as their personal wishing well? I am dubious.

Frankly, I see the "core message" you state in the next sentence neither just reflected nor outright stated by many other people.


That is that the bible is a manual for saving ones soul, God wants us to live forever and not end up in the grave (of no self awareness) forever.

Is that just another comparison here that you make for your otherwise undescribably concepts?

God has desires? And really no other options to actualize this desire, apart from a book that you can apparantly only understand when you are really, really good in ancient Hebrew and preferrably have taken courses in advanced theology.

But maybe God doesn't really have desires; not literal desires at least?



Some of its translated material like textual vestiges and some is used to allow us to comprehend difficult and complex ideas. Some have important clues to what the author meant spiritually, again Hebrew is not English and we lose a lot of meaning when translated. I wish everyone could take a course in Hebrew that was bible curious, it would open a lot of eyes, sometimes profoundly so.

Also known as "the anthropomorphic metaphors" describe nothing. ;)



I think you may enjoy studying advanced theology.

I have neither interest in studying advanced theology nor do I see the slightest need to. Several billions of other people didn't need it either to proclaim "I believe in ..." and give a rats behind for either the Bible or advanced theology.



Look at it this way if you didn’t convert to Christianity (I think you would upon full understanding of Gods word) you could use it as ammo in debate.

I have little interest in converting anybody from their beliefs. And, I am still a Christian, that is I am still officially a member of the EKD, with little inclination of changing any of that.
 
Last edited:
Ha ha you seem not to know the process of documentation and cannon that the bible endured to become the number one best seller of history.

1) Ad populum.
2) The part where it was retranslated over and over by various authorities, split into multiple different versions, and recombined as they saw fit? Oh yeah, that's a process of documentation all right. Not a very effective one.

BTW its the most accurate copied document known (ancient document).

1) Source?
2) Of course, that "most accurate" could still be 99% wrong...

Madmen? NO I am afraid you are wrong there as well, john was just seeing the future our present, no wonder it seemed like he was insane,

So you were there and asked him? Or are you just leading off with that old unsupported self-referential assumption, "John wasn't a madman because the Bible is true, so we know what he said in the Bible is true?"
 
BTW its the most accurate copied document known (ancient document).

1) Source?
2) Of course, that "most accurate" could still be 99% wrong...


Of course you are not the first to ask for supporting evidence of his claim. I doubt it will be forthcoming. More interestingly, though, is that RevDisturba as already contradicted his claim by agreeing that there are multiple different versions. Go figure.
 
Rev, I think your disdain for the Flying Spaghetti Monster is misplaced. The Flying Spaghetti Monster is a far more illuminating, more appropriate, and more respectful description of God than the common image of a king on a throne. While it might not have been the intention of the inventor of the FSM, for some theists, the FSM is God for grown-ups.

Grown-ups know (and, in the present day, have the luxury of acknowledging out loud) that real ruling kings are generally venal, vicious, dishonest, self-serving, and most of all, insecure. They require constant shows of veneration because their position is always precarious and they know it. Kings (excepting the ones whose office is primarily symbolic within constitutional government) are among the most monstrous of humans, rather than the most worthy of being exalted. And even the figurehead ones are not exactly paragons of virtue, are they?

Yet most Christians, and Christian scriptures, constantly call God a king. How can they be any more insulting? Maybe if they described Him as being like the most outrageous of pharaohs and Khalifs and Chinese emperors, as so insecure and egotistical that while He sits on a throne, He listens to hosts of His subjects constantly singing His praises...

Oh wait, they do that too.

And it's offensive.

Besides not having the flaws of a king (despite the Bible writers, due to lack of imagination, trying very hard to saddle Him with those), God does not use the methods of a king either. Legions of angels dispatched at need all over the earth to enforce His bidding with their swords are notably absent from the world. No supreme ruler appears on balconies wearing a crown to issue divine proclamations (unless you count the Pope). There is, as of last time we checked, no throne perched on top of a crystal sphere above the earth.

The Flying Spaghetti Monster, by contrast, has no need of minions, sycophants, or a big impressive chair (even a metaphorical one). The Flying Spaghetti Monster, instead, has numerous noodly appendages with which It invisibly influences everything that occurs in the universe, including the hearts and minds of men and women. Be honest, isn't that a lot closer to how you, in your own imagination, visualize God actually operates in the temporal world?

Also, the almighty creator of the world should be almighty tasty. But what do most Christians use to represent the body of God's mortal incarnation in their cannibalistic rites? The blandest stuff available. Another vile insult! Once again the Flying Spaghetti Monster is a better representation. And It still goes great with wine.

Okay, so there's some stuff in the Flying Spaghetti Monster canon that doesn't make a lot of sense, like the part about pirates and global warming. But the difference is, no one pretends that it does make any sense. The pretense that we can understand God is perhaps the biggest insult of all. We cannot understand the Flying Spaghetti Monster and that's that. It's enough to occasionally dress up as pirates in Its honor. Or not do so. Because It doesn't actually care whether we dress up as pirates or not, so we do not have to strain ourselves trying to come up with lame excuses for why It does care (like, it's a king and gets all upset when not flattered). It doesn't even care whether or not we capitalize its pronouns -- and if I'm wrong, it will reach out with one of its noodly appendages and correct me. Hence, It has no need of theologians -- oops, look, It did!

Obviously, monotheism is at a turning point where a Third Testament is needed to explain all this in detail. What a thankless job that will be. I sure hope It doesn't pick...

Aw, hell.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
What a thankless job that will be. I sure hope It doesn't pick...

What it all boils down to is that baring some anti god discovery or on the other hand Jesus coming back (much more likely) I will choose to believe in God while you chose your brand of athiesm (there are several according to scholars ) or whatever it is you believe in or don't.

The stakes are high, higher than life and death and I am a win win situation, and have done my bit for your salvation..

; {>
 
Last edited:
If its a valid case. If you use scripture in context and accurately yes it makes it a christian argument, but it may not be a valid argument.

; {>

Who decides what is accurate or valid and what isn't? Unless the bible is self-evident, it has absolutely no use. Nothing more than any fairy-tale...
 
I see, you are vocal about nothing.

yrreg wrote


  • Quote:
    ...you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists...
    ​

No.


You are entitled to your arbitrary opinion, all in the name of free thought and free speech.


That is the big difference between you and me.

It's like, I maintain that it is only logical from my part that I should know what are alcoholic drinks, in order to maintain a 'lack' of alcoholic drinks in my home and in my person, but you don't subscribe to that idea, just as you don't accept that you have got to know what is God in order to keep a lack of belief in God or gods whatever.



That is why I say you are illogical in that on the one hand you insist that you simply lack a belief in God or gods, but on the other hand you don't want to know what is God or gods which you want to maintain a lack of belief in.

So, what are you lacking a belief in? Nothing you know about?

Which means you are very vocal about lacking a belief of nothing, or lacking a belief in something you know not of.

I see, you are vocal about nothing.




Yrreg
 
You are entitled to your arbitrary opinion, all in the name of free thought and free speech.


That is the big difference between you and me.

It's like, I maintain that it is only logical from my part that I should know what are alcoholic drinks, in order to maintain a 'lack' of alcoholic drinks in my home and in my person, but you don't subscribe to that idea, just as you don't accept that you have got to know what is God in order to keep a lack of belief in God or gods whatever.



That is why I say you are illogical in that on the one hand you insist that you simply lack a belief in God or gods, but on the other hand you don't want to know what is God or gods which you want to maintain a lack of belief in.

So, what are you lacking a belief in? Nothing you know about?

Which means you are very vocal about lacking a belief of nothing, or lacking a belief in something you know not of.

I see, you are vocal about nothing.




Yrreg

You are right, Yrreg. So just as soon as you give us the complete list of everything you do not believe in: with a full description of each concept, as accepted by anyone as fact, we can move on

I would prefer you to start with Vishnu, Brahma and Shiva: but if you would prefer to start with Allah, or some other god you do not accept that will be fine
 
major fail yrreg.

the correct comparison would be you knowing about every type of alcahol in existence.

This is a very improbable task to achieve with new ones being created all the time.

What you probably meant is the effects of consumption of alcahol.

So why cant an atheist do the same deductive reasoning as valid logical proof regarding the non-existence of a deity based on the effects of said entities.
 
Last edited:
You are entitled to your arbitrary opinion, all in the name of free thought and free speech.


That is the big difference between you and me.

You're saying that you are not entitled to your arbitrary opinion in the name of free thought and free speech? Who/what hinders you?

It's like, I maintain that it is only logical from my part that I should know what are alcoholic drinks, in order to maintain a 'lack' of alcoholic drinks in my home and in my person, but you don't subscribe to that idea, just as you don't accept that you have got to know what is God in order to keep a lack of belief in God or gods whatever.

You are asserting that you know all alcoholic drinks. Wanna bet?

That is why I say you are illogical in that on the one hand you insist that you simply lack a belief in God or gods, but on the other hand you don't want to know what is God or gods which you want to maintain a lack of belief in.

yrreg... Most atheists do not maintain that there is no god... Simply that there is no evidence. Does that compute?

So, what are you lacking a belief in? Nothing you know about?

We are lacking a belief in an infinite number of things. Yea, that's right. Infinite. Sorry, but we can't enumerate them all for you. IBM is still running the format on its newly invented infinite capacity hard drive.

Which means you are very vocal about lacking a belief of nothing, or lacking a belief in something you know not of.

I see, you are vocal about nothing.
Yrreg

Nope. You got that wrong. No one is going around shouting their lack of belief in anything. Sorry if people answering your "questions" is too much for you. In that case you might want to avoid questions for others. We already know you never question yourself or your beliefs.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom