What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Thanks, Phase Inverter, for being relevant.

Let me just invite you, Phase Inverter, for the present to your words in the following line in your list, the second item:

  • [God] Is responsible for the creation of the heavens and the earth.

That line from you say in very few words what I myself as a rational theist and a Christian understand to be God, namely, the maker of everything including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.

Yes, just keep to that line from your list and also my expanded version of that line, that is the concept of God which I am humanly certain in fact exists.

For the present don't go into anything else, just stick to that line from your list and as I said, which I expand into my own version as stated above.



Agreed. For the present I will just stick to that line from my list and to your expanded version as well.


Note: You did ask me what I thought the concept of God that the Christians accept as existing was, and I gave it to you. All of it (and I'm sure that my list was incomplete). By isolating one particular aspect of this God, we are no longer discussing the concept of God that Christians alone accept. You have opened up the discussion to any concept of God, that any number of religions accept, that has that one, single trait.
 
The bible is clear on what God is.


According to the bible, God:

  • Speaks to humans: Then the Lord God called to the man, and said to him, "Where are you?"

  • Has hands: "when I stretch out My hand on Egypt and bring out the sons of Israel from their midst."

  • Has a face: And he said, "Thou canst not see my face: for there shall no man see me, and live."

  • Can be seen: for I have seen God face to face, and my life is preserved.

  • Has a mouth: By the word of the Lord the heavens were made, and by the breath of His mouth all their host.

  • Has eyes and ears: The eyes of the Lord are toward the righteous, and His ears are open to their cry.

  • Has arms: Thou Thyself didst crush Rahab like one who is slain; Thou didst scatter Thine enemies with Thy mighty arm.

  • Has wings: Be gracious to me, O God, be gracious to me, for my soul takes refuge in Thee; and in the shadow of Thy wings I will take refuge, until destruction passes by.

  • Has a heart: And the Lord was sorry that He had made man on the earth, and He was grieved in His heart.

  • Has backparts: "And I will take away mine hand, and thou shalt see my back parts"

  • Walks: And they heard the voice of the LORD God walking in the garden in the cool of the day.

  • Is jealous: "for I, the Lord your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children, on the third and the fourth generations of those who hate Me."

  • Changes his mind: So the Lord changed His mind about the harm which He said He would do to His people.

  • Rests: And by the seventh day God completed His work which He had done; and He rested on the seventh day from all His work which He had done.

  • Is regretful: And the Lord was sorry that He had made man on the earth, and He was grieved in His heart.

  • Is forgetful: "When the bow is in the cloud, then I will look upon it, to remember the everlasting covenant between God and every living creature of all flesh that is on the earth."

  • Etc.
 
That's exactly why I believe in Cthulhu. I can't tell him that I don't believe in him, so he won't go away. I mean, I can say "I don't believe in you," but he doesn't speak English, only Ctholhian, and I can't make the right gargling noises and I always forget that I'm supposed to pull out my tongue at the end of the sentence. So he still thinks I believe in him.
Yeah, you have to be careful with that:

Phnglui mgwlnafthth Cthulhu rlyey wghnagl fthagn.

In his flat in Bromley, drunk Cthulhu waits knitting? I think a few subtle typos may have crept into into that one.

That explains why this shoggoth I summoned is only 3mm tall.

-- Peter da Silva and Peter Gutmann, asr
 
Yeah, you have to be careful with that:

Phnglui mgwlnafthth Cthulhu rlyey wghnagl fthagn.

In his flat in Bromley, drunk Cthulhu waits knitting? I think a few subtle typos may have crept into into that one.

That explains why this shoggoth I summoned is only 3mm tall.

-- Peter da Silva and Peter Gutmann, asr

:D
 
Agreed. For the present I will just stick to that line from my list and to your expanded version as well.


Note: You did ask me what I thought the concept of God that the Christians accept as existing was, and I gave it to you. All of it (and I'm sure that my list was incomplete). By isolating one particular aspect of this God, we are no longer discussing the concept of God that Christians alone accept. You have opened up the discussion to any concept of God, that any number of religions accept, that has that one, single trait.

Well, now that we have a (somewhat-) defined "god-qualifications-list" to work with, we can get down to some serious denial.

I deny that the god set out by this list exists.
 
Then why did you say, "Note the moderator's position here." rather than, for example, "See what Tricky said here"? You may not have meant it, but I don't see how it could imply anything else.

I had no way of knowing that Tricky was not a moderator back then. I made a false assumption. Also, Rev was asking a mod's permission to post some stuff. If I had said "See what Tricky said here" it wouldn't have addressed Rev's question. Besides, even if I did, I'm almost certain that there would have been someone to point it out to me that Tricky was not a moderator back then and either way, it's the MA that counts.

What does Tricky being a moderator now have to with what he said 6 years ago?

Nothing. Nor did I imply that it does. I assumed he still means what he said back then. And I can't find anything in the MA that says anything about mockery in itself...

You may well be right that a posting along those lines won't lead to an infraction, but that would depend, as for all posts, whether it breached the MA. However, a six year old post doesn't say anything about that, for the reasons I already gave.

Yes.
 
Just to restate, this is the list of characteristics of God that yrreg has agreed to use for this argument.

  • Has a name, Yahweh.
  • Is responsible for the creation of the heavens and the earth.
  • Is responsible for the creation of plants, animals, and humans on earth.
  • Is responsible for the creation of angels, and other beings in heaven.
  • Is one, but at the same time three, being(s). One of which was known as logos, but was made flesh and is now called Jesus.
  • Is referred to as being male.
  • Revealed himself to mankind on various occasions in various forms.
  • Directed the recording of these revelations in written form known as the Holy Bible.
  • Demands obedience and worship.
  • Chose one family to live while destroying every other human on earth.
  • Chose one family and it's descendants to be his people.
  • Dictated rules for worship, sacrifice, and behavior.
  • Sent a part of himself, Jesus, as a blood sacrifice to forgive the disobedience of his people.
  • Will punish for eternity all who do not accept or believe that Jesus died for the forgiveness of their disobedience.
  • Will grant eternal life and bliss to all those who do accept and believe that Jesus died for the forgiveness of their disobedience.
  • Will destroy heaven and earth and build a new heaven and earth with Jesus on the throne of the kingdom of God and the twelve disciples as rulers over the twelve tribes of his chosen people.

Now. Do any of the atheists here feel uncomfortable denying the existence of a being with the above characteristics? I don't.
 
Last edited:
You know, this argument won't make any progress at all unless everyone agrees not to post another thing until Yrreg makes some attempt to outline his case for the existence of his God.

It seems to me that the ball is in his court at this point. He has to offer proof of the existence of a creator-God. Until he does, nobody should post another thing.
 
IIRC he only agreed to the second.


Yes, that's how I read it as well.

I also agreed to keep the discussion going by limiting "the concept of God that is accepted by Christians as in fact existing" to just that single item from the list, and yrreg's expansion of said item.


However, in reference to this,

...you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists, and to understand what you read in writings directed against God.


I think my full list is a pretty accurate concept of the Christian God and is therefore sufficient justification for me calling myself an atheist.

But, that's irrelevant. We can still have a discussion about the existence of God based on yrreg's single, quintessential concept of the Christian God. It should be quite interesting, if said discussion actually occurs.
 
Okay, everybody silent! Wait, who's making that post? Oh, it's me. Who's doing that? Oh, it's me again.

There's nothing paradoxical about making a suggestion to a group of people that they cease engaging in a particular argument until their interlocutor expounds the basis for his position. There is a paradox in saying something like "anyone who posts in this thread is a douchebag" but that's not my point.

I think Yrreg is a troll (and a remarkably low-effort one) who gets an extraordinary number of perfectly well-meaning members of this site to dance to his tune and expend an enormous amount of mental energy and time providing argument and analysis which--as far as I can tell--he simply ignores.

I am suggesting that every single person interested in the issues Yrreg raises simply agrees to refuse to proceed any further in the debate until he shows that he is not simply trolling and actually participates in an argument. I am further suggesting that the step he be required to take in order to show good faith is to produce an argument for a the existence of his God. That, at least, will give people something to argue with.

No one has to agree, of course; but it would, I think, be an effective way of dealing with this kind of trolling.
 
I know exactly what you meant. I just tend to never take things seriously. I was joking; actually, I was kind of quoting from the movie Madagascar.
Anyway, back to silence.
 
I was taking up for him, he seems to have a more difficult time than I do expressing himself. Yrreg seems to be a deist, or maybe a theist that likes to argue.

; {>

Yrreg is certainly not a deist. Like many theists, he likes to make arguments for deism -- which is fine as a starting point, but eventually you've got to get around to making the rest of your case.

Among other things, yrreg's god apparently cares whether or not people masturbate. (Unless maybe he'd just confused about what deists mean when they say they believe in a "hands off" god?)
 
Yrreg is certainly not a deist. Like many theists, he likes to make arguments for deism -- which is fine as a starting point, but eventually you've got to get around to making the rest of your case.

Among other things, yrreg's god apparently cares whether or not people masturbate. (Unless maybe he'd just confused about what deists mean when they say they believe in a "hands off" god?)

Shh!

We're hunting yrregs. If we stay quiet, that one in the bushes over there will come out for a drink. Then you can hit him with the tranquilizer, and I can get him in the net.
 
I was fairly sure I would get that ‘its really an analogy’ type answers/rebuttals. So considering the outside chance that some of you may of rationalized yourselves, or been brainwashed by someone that has taught you falsehoods from childbirth and kept you locked in a closet 24/7 I would attempt to clarify what the difference is between making an analogy and making an insult.

I am sure that many of you really mean it when you say that the bible is a fairy tale. I have no doubt when you say the FSM is the same thing as God in your mind. However this isn’t the issue. Again you may really think in your heart that some races look like an ape. Or that the N word is appropriate. Or that calling a black guy boy is ok. Or you may think that flying a rebel flag is your right its about tradition not racist. However much of society has said that its wrong to use most of these terms. You shouldn’t call a gay person a faggot or even a queer right? Why not? The reason is two fold. One is the intent. Second society has said that these words and concepts are wrong hateful and racist and are designed to provoke or to harm.

The favorite comeback is that well I don’t mean it as an insult. That may well be true, however calling a gay person a faggot because you were raised that way is no excuse. Then if a gay person points out your ignorance and tells you that ’faggot’ is an derogatory word that is highly offensive to him and the gay community, and you still use it that can only mean that you are trying to harm or provoke gays.

Its worse in the case of say, racism if a good ole boy calls a black guy a ’boy’. Why? Because traditionally the south has had a confrontational relationship with blacks. The same goes for atheists and Christians. When you are on a site that has topics such as” Religion: The Root of All Evil “ or Studies in Crap (religious issues being the crap) its obvious that a confrontational environment exists. So it sounds a bit of disingenuous when an atheist claims that he was not attempting to provoke by using terms and concepts that the dullest short bus Belleview resident type person would recognize as an insult. I will be indicating some of the more blatant offenders with the hopes of enhanced awareness will, if not diminish the use of said derogatory terms, at least expose the haters for what they are. They will not be able to claim ignorance any longer, and ignorance of the law has never been an excuse.

; }>
 
I was fairly sure I would get that ‘its really an analogy’ type answers/rebuttals. So considering the outside chance that some of you may of rationalized yourselves, or been brainwashed by someone that has taught you falsehoods from childbirth and kept you locked in a closet 24/7 I would attempt to clarify what the difference is between making an analogy and making an insult.

I am sure that many of you really mean it when you say that the bible is a fairy tale. I have no doubt when you say the FSM is the same thing as God in your mind. However this isn’t the issue. Again you may really think in your heart that some races look like an ape. Or that the N word is appropriate. Or that calling a black guy boy is ok. Or you may think that flying a rebel flag is your right its about tradition not racist. However much of society has said that its wrong to use most of these terms. You shouldn’t call a gay person a faggot or even a queer right? Why not? The reason is two fold. One is the intent. Second society has said that these words and concepts are wrong hateful and racist and are designed to provoke or to harm.

The favorite comeback is that well I don’t mean it as an insult. That may well be true, however calling a gay person a faggot because you were raised that way is no excuse. Then if a gay person points out your ignorance and tells you that ’faggot’ is an derogatory word that is highly offensive to him and the gay community, and you still use it that can only mean that you are trying to harm or provoke gays.

Its worse in the case of say, racism if a good ole boy calls a black guy a ’boy’. Why? Because traditionally the south has had a confrontational relationship with blacks. The same goes for atheists and Christians. When you are on a site that has topics such as” Religion: The Root of All Evil “ or Studies in Crap (religious issues being the crap) its obvious that a confrontational environment exists. So it sounds a bit of disingenuous when an atheist claims that he was not attempting to provoke by using terms and concepts that the dullest short bus Belleview resident type person would recognize as an insult. I will be indicating some of the more blatant offenders with the hopes of enhanced awareness will, if not diminish the use of said derogatory terms, at least expose the haters for what they are. They will not be able to claim ignorance any longer, and ignorance of the law has never been an excuse.

; }>

I must warn you against this proposed course of action. The FSM does not take kindly to unbelievers.

Seriously, though, Reverend. Loosen up. You may find the FSM, the IPU, and several other things on this site offensive. But that's your business. The FSM is an argument against the existence of your god, nothing more. If our use of this argument offends you, that's your business. No one's going to stop because you don't like it when we make fun of your Big Sky Daddy theory.
 
According to the bible, God:>>>>for mercy and brevity<<<<
[*]Is forgetful: "When the bow is in the cloud, then I will look upon it, to remember the everlasting covenant between God and every living creature of all flesh that is on the earth."[*]Etc.
[/LIST]

This post is what is so wrong with many armchair biblical experts. There are no quotes only sloppy half copies excerpted from god knows where pulled out of context and order...(I could go on). With all due respect, its worthless except to use as an example of bad..no horrible...no awful debate and even worse theology.

If you want to know the attributes of the Christian God ask or pick one piece of scripture and include the book and verse. Otherwise all you are going to have is a mishmash of dog poo and is good for what dog poo is good for, to dispose of it as quickly as possible.

; {>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom