What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Ask him for scriptural reference. If you can not defend your beliefs with the bible you are not a christian but rather a false prophet. The bible can be so loosely interpreted that if he or anyone can not make a good case using the bible, its my opinion that it doesn't even loosely conform to anything christian.

; {>

The good Reverent does not seem to realize; THAT is the reason no one uses the Bible to prove the Bible.

That's why they ALL use the Bible to prove the Bible!
 
It's like, I maintain that it is only logical from my part that I should know what are alcoholic drinks, in order to maintain a 'lack' of alcoholic drinks in my home and in my person, but you don't subscribe to that idea, just as you don't accept that you have got to know what is God in order to keep a lack of belief in God or gods whatever.


But where the analogy breaks down is (a) that atheists don't necessarily start randomly believing in things for which there is no evidence, so they don't necessarily have to keep a check on whether these things may be gods, and (b) there is no need to keep non existent entities from entering one's house, since they don't exist.

Even for entities that exist, it isn't necessary to have an exhaustive and comprehensive list of them in order to exclude them. For example, I have a means of preventing small vermin from infesting my house: I keep a cat. This works fine, even if I cannot offhand give the specific name for every species of small mammal that the cat might catch.
 
I was fairly sure I would get that ‘its really an analogy’ type answers/rebuttals. So considering the outside chance that some of you may of rationalized yourselves, or been brainwashed by someone that has taught you falsehoods from childbirth and kept you locked in a closet 24/7 I would attempt to clarify what the difference is between making an analogy and making an insult.
It’s referred to as an analogy because it is. I encourage you to read Elizabeth I’s excellent post on it. I would have said for you to reread it but you obviously didn’t read it to begin with.
I am sure that many of you really mean it when you say that the bible is a fairy tale. I have no doubt when you say the FSM is the same thing as God in your mind.
Jumped up Jeebus Khryst! Are you taking a page from the yrreG book of not paying attention to what anyone says? If you use the word analogy three times in a sentence, it will be yours forever.
However this isn’t the issue. Again you may really think in your heart that some races look like an ape. Or that the N word is appropriate. Or that calling a black guy boy is ok. Or you may think that flying a rebel flag is your right its about tradition not racist. However much of society has said that its wrong to use most of these terms. You shouldn’t call a gay person a faggot or even a queer right? Why not? The reason is two fold. One is the intent. Second society has said that these words and concepts are wrong hateful and racist and are designed to provoke or to harm.
This is not about race, no matter how you spin it. It isn’t anywhere near equivalent. You cheapen the real issues in race relations when you make such an outlandish comparison. You cheapen yourself more.
The favorite comeback is that well I don’t mean it as an insult. That may well be true, however calling a gay person a faggot because you were raised that way is no excuse. Then if a gay person points out your ignorance and tells you that ’faggot’ is an derogatory word that is highly offensive to him and the gay community, and you still use it that can only mean that you are trying to harm or provoke gays.
It isn’t about gender identity issues, sexual preference, or personal lifestyle choices either.
Its worse in the case of say, racism if a good ole boy calls a black guy a ’boy’. Why? Because traditionally the south has had a confrontational relationship with blacks. The same goes for atheists and Christians. When you are on a site that has topics such as” Religion: The Root of All Evil “ or Studies in Crap (religious issues being the crap) its obvious that a confrontational environment exists. So it sounds a bit of disingenuous when an atheist claims that he was not attempting to provoke by using terms and concepts that the dullest short bus Belleview resident type person would recognize as an insult. I will be indicating some of the more blatant offenders with the hopes of enhanced awareness will, if not diminish the use of said derogatory terms, at least expose the haters for what they are. They will not be able to claim ignorance any longer, and ignorance of the law has never been an excuse.

; }>
Your god(s) are like The Flying Spaghetti Monster, ultimately unfalsifiable and unevidenced.
 
Last edited:
It's like, I maintain that it is only logical from my part that I should know what are alcoholic drinks, in order to maintain a 'lack' of alcoholic drinks in my home and in my person

Yrreg

Which particular alcoholic drink do you not partake of? Please define my favorite alcoholic drink so that I know as much as humanly possible that you are not partaking of the right alcoholic drink.

Hint: If you say "all alcoholic beverages", you might be on the road to enlightenment about what atheists lack belief in.
 
Last edited:
You see, atheists, again you try to evade the question, not only try but actually avoiding the issue, instead going into what I call genuine pseudo arguments of bad mouthing God, laughing at God, and insisting you don't know nothing about the concept of God as understood by Christians.

For latecomers, see my opening message, and my message in post #14.


Yes, atheists, you have been saying since shall we say eternity that you lack belief in God or gods, but you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists, and to understand what you read in writings directed against God.




Yrreg

According to your rule, then, I cannot say "There are no tigers under my bed," because I have not counted how many stripes the tigers that are not there might have.
 
Oh, good lord, the king of trolls has returned.

You are entitled to your arbitrary opinion, all in the name of free thought and free speech.

Yes. Yes we are.

That is the big difference between you and me.

You're not? Why? Are the Philippines a dictatorship or something?

It's like, I maintain that it is only logical from my part that I should know what are alcoholic drinks, in order to maintain a 'lack' of alcoholic drinks in my home and in my person, but you don't subscribe to that idea, just as you don't accept that you have got to know what is God in order to keep a lack of belief in God or gods whatever.

As has been said, for this analogy to work you would have to know every alcoholic drink. You don't.
But, in the end, every analogy fails. Beer is not religion. Well, not to me, anyway.


That is why I say you are illogical in that on the one hand you insist that you simply lack a belief in God or gods, but on the other hand you don't want to know what is God or gods which you want to maintain a lack of belief in.

Actually, we do know, yrreg. We've been asking you to define your god so we can show you that, yes, we deny that one, too. But you haven't bothered to define it. You've been asking us to.

So, what are you lacking a belief in? Nothing you know about?

Arrogance. Many of us were raised by very religious families. I know I was. I used to be Christian (well, Catholic, but hey). I know exactly what I'm denying.

Which means you are very vocal about lacking a belief of nothing, or lacking a belief in something you know not of.

Which, from your posts, applies to you. You talk about atheism. You know nothing about atheism.

I see, you are vocal about nothing.

See previous statement.

Yrreg

:spam5 <- yrreg
 
It's like, I maintain that it is only logical from my part that I should know what are alcoholic drinks, in order to maintain a 'lack' of alcoholic drinks in my home and in my person, but you don't subscribe to that idea, just as you don't accept that you have got to know what is God in order to keep a lack of belief in God or gods whatever.


Actually, I can think of a person who needs a list of things that they don't believe in. However, they are not an atheist (at least not nominally).
 
So...either the Olympian gods exist or they don't exist. If they exist I should obviously sacrifice to them regularly and perform all the due sacred rites. If they don't exist, I lose nothing by performing those rites. A sane man, then, will believe in the Olympian gods and honor them in the proper ways.

Right, RevDisturba?
 
I was fairly sure I would get that ‘its really an analogy’ type answers/rebuttals. So considering the outside chance that some of you may of rationalized yourselves, or been brainwashed by someone that has taught you falsehoods from childbirth and kept you locked in a closet 24/7 I would attempt to clarify what the difference is between making an analogy and making an insult.

I am sure that many of you really mean it when you say that the bible is a fairy tale. I have no doubt when you say the FSM is the same thing as God in your mind. However this isn’t the issue. Again you may really think in your heart that some races look like an ape. Or that the N word is appropriate. Or that calling a black guy boy is ok. Or you may think that flying a rebel flag is your right its about tradition not racist. However much of society has said that its wrong to use most of these terms. You shouldn’t call a gay person a faggot or even a queer right? Why not? The reason is two fold. One is the intent. Second society has said that these words and concepts are wrong hateful and racist and are designed to provoke or to harm.

The favorite comeback is that well I don’t mean it as an insult. That may well be true, however calling a gay person a faggot because you were raised that way is no excuse. Then if a gay person points out your ignorance and tells you that ’faggot’ is an derogatory word that is highly offensive to him and the gay community, and you still use it that can only mean that you are trying to harm or provoke gays.

Its worse in the case of say, racism if a good ole boy calls a black guy a ’boy’. Why? Because traditionally the south has had a confrontational relationship with blacks. The same goes for atheists and Christians. When you are on a site that has topics such as” Religion: The Root of All Evil “ or Studies in Crap (religious issues being the crap) its obvious that a confrontational environment exists. So it sounds a bit of disingenuous when an atheist claims that he was not attempting to provoke by using terms and concepts that the dullest short bus Belleview resident type person would recognize as an insult. I will be indicating some of the more blatant offenders with the hopes of enhanced awareness will, if not diminish the use of said derogatory terms, at least expose the haters for what they are. They will not be able to claim ignorance any longer, and ignorance of the law has never been an excuse.

; }>

So... saying that there is no more evidence for god A than for mythical creatures U, V, or W, or for gods X, Y or Z is, in your mind, equivalent to racism or homophobia? That certainly explains a lot about why you write some of the things that you write.

By the way, using the "short-bus" derogatory in the above rant, something that might be taken as very offensive by those among us who have family members who live with mental retardation, makes for some impressive irony.
 
You believe in putting important notice in very fine print, no?

Phase Inverter, you believe in putting important notice in very fine print, no? (Readers, see below.)

Please don't do that, because it is important, so it must be conspicuously visible to readers including most specially people you are interacting with about ideas​

---------------------

yrreg wrote


  • Quote:
    ...you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists...
    ​

No.


You are entitled to your arbitrary opinion, all in the name of free thought and free speech.


That is the big difference between you and me.

It's like, I maintain that it is only logical from my part that I should know what are alcoholic drinks, in order to maintain a 'lack' of alcoholic drinks in my home and in my person, but you don't subscribe to that idea, just as you don't accept that you have got to know what is God in order to keep a lack of belief in God or gods whatever.



That is why I say you are illogical in that on the one hand you insist that you simply lack a belief in God or gods, but on the other hand you don't want to know what is God or gods which you want to maintain a lack of belief in.

So, what are you lacking a belief in? Nothing you know about?

Which means you are very vocal about lacking a belief of nothing, or lacking a belief in something you know not of.

I see, you are vocal about nothing.




Yrreg



Agreed. For the present I will just stick to that line from my list and to your expanded version as well.


Note: You did ask me what I thought the concept of God that the Christians accept as existing was, and I gave it to you. All of it (and I'm sure that my list was incomplete). By isolating one particular aspect of this God, we are no longer discussing the concept of God that Christians alone accept. You have opened up the discussion to any concept of God, that any number of religions accept, that has that one, single trait.


Phase Inverter, you believe in putting important notice in very fine print, no? (Readers, see above.)

Please don't do that, because it is important, so it must be conspicuously visible to readers including most specially people you are interacting with about ideas​


I am not saying anything about what you are alleging that I am saying, what I said is that for the present just keep to my concept of God which also you briefly state in few words.

So, there is no need to put in fine print this notice from you above:

Note: You did ask me what I thought the concept of God that the Christians accept as existing was, and I gave it to you. All of it (and I'm sure that my list was incomplete). By isolating one particular aspect of this God, we are no longer discussing the concept of God that Christians alone accept. You have opened up the discussion to any concept of God, that any number of religions accept, that has that one, single trait.



Why do I want us for the time being to keep to your concept of God and my expanded version? because we have got to keep neat and tidy, otherwise this discussion will get very unmanageable.

And here below is what you and I agree on for the purpose of our discussion on the concept of God:


From you, Phase Inverter:

[God] Is responsible for the creation of the heavens and the earth.​

From me, Yrreg:

That line from you say in very few words what I myself as a rational theist and a Christian understand to be God, namely, the maker of everything including the physical universe, and author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in it.​


Okay? Phase Inverter, no more fine print, yes? no? don't care?

Please inform.




Yrreg
 
Please, everyone, if you have anything pertinent to say, DON'T say it in fine print.

Please, everyone, if you have anything pertinent to say, DON'T say it in fine print.





Yrreg
 
I was fairly sure I would get that ‘its really an analogy’ type answers/rebuttals. So considering the outside chance that some of you may of rationalized yourselves, or been brainwashed by someone that has taught you falsehoods from childbirth and kept you locked in a closet 24/7 I would attempt to clarify what the difference is between making an analogy and making an insult.
Ad hominem, strawman, tu quoque.

I am sure that many of you really mean it when you say that the bible is a fairy tale.
Fairy tale is a reasonable analogy. Really, though, it's myth.

I have no doubt when you say the FSM is the same thing as God in your mind.
Indeed.

However this isn’t the issue.
Yes, it is precisely the issue.

Again you may really think in your heart that some races look like an ape.
False analogy.

Or that the N word is appropriate.
False analogy.

Or that calling a black guy boy is ok.
False analogy.

Or you may think that flying a rebel flag is your right its about tradition not racist.
False analogy.

However much of society has said that its wrong to use most of these terms.
True, and they're right. But completely irrelevant to your position.

You shouldn’t call a gay person a faggot or even a queer right? Why not?
False analogy.

The reason is two fold. One is the intent. Second society has said that these words and concepts are wrong hateful and racist and are designed to provoke or to harm.
False analogy.

Are you done with the nonsense, RevD?

We aren't insulting you. We are just pointing out that your beliefs are completely unsupported by logic or evidence.

The favorite comeback is that well I don’t mean it as an insult.
Strawman.

That may well be true, however calling a gay person a faggot because you were raised that way is no excuse.
False analogy.

Then if a gay person points out your ignorance and tells you that ’faggot’ is an derogatory word that is highly offensive to him and the gay community, and you still use it that can only mean that you are trying to harm or provoke gays.
False analogy.

Its worse in the case of say, racism if a good ole boy calls a black guy a ’boy’.
False analogy.

Why? Because traditionally the south has had a confrontational relationship with blacks.
False analogy.

The same goes for atheists and Christians.
No. Wrong. Completely wrong.

Christians in the United States, according to poll data, tend to despise atheists.

The reverse is not true.

When you are on a site that has topics such as” Religion: The Root of All Evil “ or Studies in Crap (religious issues being the crap) its obvious that a confrontational environment exists.
Well, tough. It's a confrontational environment for all varieties of nonsense.

That's your problem.

So it sounds a bit of disingenuous when an atheist claims that he was not attempting to provoke by using terms and concepts that the dullest short bus Belleview resident type person would recognize as an insult.
No, RevD. We are attacking your arguments, your beliefs. Not you. You are choosing to take it personally. That's your problem.

I will be indicating some of the more blatant offenders with the hopes of enhanced awareness will, if not diminish the use of said derogatory terms, at least expose the haters for what they are.
Tu quoque.

RevD, most of the actual insults are coming from you.

They will not be able to claim ignorance any longer, and ignorance of the law has never been an excuse.
Strawman, false analogy.
 
I don't drink as a rule but if it's free in moderation, and I keep two bottles of...

Which alcoholic beverage do you not drink, yrreG?


I don't drink as a rule but if it's free in moderation.

Free? Yes, free, because people give me also gifts of good brandy and whiskey.

And I keep two bottles of Tanduay Rum 12 years old which I bought for use at home, when I judge that a sip of it can be good for me or my wife or my two kids.


This is an aside to the topic on hand, but I don't mind some nice social exchange, but harsh and unkind remarks owing to God or no God, that is what really depresses me, or people trying by hook and crook to pull a fast dishonest advantage in verbal discourse, that really saddens me about the kind of mind and heart of people resorting to it.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom