What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

I must warn you against this proposed course of action. The FSM does not take kindly to unbelievers.

Seriously, though, Reverend. Loosen up. You may find the FSM, the IPU, and several other things on this site offensive. But that's your business. The FSM is an argument against the existence of your god, nothing more. If our use of this argument offends you, that's your business. No one's going to stop because you don't like it when we make fun of your Big Sky Daddy theory.

Its easy to say loosen up when using these terms or their racial equivalent in the wrong place would get you hospitalized or worse. I am very tolerant and trying to communicate a simple idea that most people know. Ie the difference between a harmless analogy and terms and hate speech. It doesn't offend only me it offends all Christians. If you insist on using gutter terms that's your right here in atheist land, but I wouldn't try it at home.

That kind of hate speech (above) is precisely why atheists like you are the most hated minority in the USA. If the haters could be removed from the ranks of atheists, I am sure that title would evaporate. If you love your atheist brothers you should work towards harmony instead of insisting that the N word and the rebel flag of religious terms are acceptable. Hey maybe you could start a special group of atheists and wear a white sheet for a uniform ?

; }>
 
Last edited:
Yrreg is certainly not a deist. Like many theists, he likes to make arguments for deism -- which is fine as a starting point, but eventually you've got to get around to making the rest of your case.

Among other things, yrreg's god apparently cares whether or not people masturbate. (Unless maybe he'd just confused about what deists mean when they say they believe in a "hands off" god?)

Ask him for scriptural reference. If you can not defend your beliefs with the bible you are not a christian but rather a false prophet. The bible can be so loosely interpreted that if he or anyone can not make a good case using the bible, its my opinion that it doesn't even loosely conform to anything christian.

; {>
 
I was fairly sure I would get that ‘its really an analogy’ type answers/rebuttals. So considering the outside chance that some of you may of rationalized yourselves, or been brainwashed by someone that has taught you falsehoods from childbirth and kept you locked in a closet 24/7 I would attempt to clarify what the difference is between making an analogy and making an insult.

I am sure that many of you really mean it when you say that the bible is a fairy tale. I have no doubt when you say the FSM is the same thing as God in your mind. However this isn’t the issue. Again you may really think in your heart that some races look like an ape. Or that the N word is appropriate. Or that calling a black guy boy is ok. Or you may think that flying a rebel flag is your right its about tradition not racist. However much of society has said that its wrong to use most of these terms. You shouldn’t call a gay person a faggot or even a queer right? Why not? The reason is two fold. One is the intent. Second society has said that these words and concepts are wrong hateful and racist and are designed to provoke or to harm.

The favorite comeback is that well I don’t mean it as an insult. That may well be true, however calling a gay person a faggot because you were raised that way is no excuse. Then if a gay person points out your ignorance and tells you that ’faggot’ is an derogatory word that is highly offensive to him and the gay community, and you still use it that can only mean that you are trying to harm or provoke gays.

Its worse in the case of say, racism if a good ole boy calls a black guy a ’boy’. Why? Because traditionally the south has had a confrontational relationship with blacks. The same goes for atheists and Christians. When you are on a site that has topics such as” Religion: The Root of All Evil “ or Studies in Crap (religious issues being the crap) its obvious that a confrontational environment exists. So it sounds a bit of disingenuous when an atheist claims that he was not attempting to provoke by using terms and concepts that the dullest short bus Belleview resident type person would recognize as an insult. I will be indicating some of the more blatant offenders with the hopes of enhanced awareness will, if not diminish the use of said derogatory terms, at least expose the haters for what they are. They will not be able to claim ignorance any longer, and ignorance of the law has never been an excuse.

; }>


"Help, help, I'm being repressed!"
 
Its easy to say loosen up when using these terms or their racial equivalent in the wrong place would get you hospitalized or worse.

This is not racism. It is a humorous rebuttal to an argument on the existence of gods. We joke that we worship the IPU or the FSM because we have the same amount of evidence for their existence as for the existence of the Christian god. You have no reason to be hatin' on us. You simply are determined to label it as hate speech. And anyway, we're not calling YOU an Invisible Pink Unicorn.

I am very tolerant

Apparently, you're not.

and trying to communicate a simple idea that most people know. Ie the difference between a harmless analogy and terms and hate speech.

It is something that you should learn before you try to teach it.

It doesn't offend only me it offends all Christians.

Baseless statement, no proof. Most Christians I talk to about the FSM actually think it's funny.

If you insist on using gutter terms that's your right here in atheist land, but I wouldn't try it at home.

Again, you are labeling a humorous argument hate speech simply because you don't like losing.

That kind of hate speech (above) is precisely why atheists like you are the most hated minority in the USA.

You, KK, Ethnikos and yrreg are the most hated minority. There's only four of you, so you're a minority, and the hate I generate cannot be matched by the entire American heartland. You and Ethnikos, however, have only recently joined "The List." You can still get out of it if you stop being such a troll and a flamer.

If the haters could be removed from the ranks of atheists, I am sure that title would evaporate.

Flaming, ignored.

If you love your atheist brothers you should work towards harmony instead of insisting that the N word and the rebel flag of religious terms are acceptable.

Again flaming, again ignored.

Hey maybe you could start a special group of atheists and wear a white sheet for a uniform ?

Wait, I thought you CHRISTIANS already had that group going?

; }>

This post is strike one, Reverend. Two more and I permanently consign you to the rank of yrreg-level troll.
 
Its easy to say loosen up when using these terms or their racial equivalent in the wrong place would get you hospitalized or worse.

And a man kissing his boyfriend in the "wrong place," or a woman wearing a miniskirt in the "wrong place," or a Christian wearing a cross in the "wrong place" might get "hospitalized or worse," too. The fact that some people will behave like violent thugs is hardly a guide to what is or should be civil behavior.

I am very tolerant and trying to communicate a simple idea that most people know. Ie the difference between a harmless analogy and terms and hate speech.

I think you'll find that "hate speech" is a very problematic phrase, which is why so many attempts to draft or pass hate speech laws have been unsuccessful. I'm sure some Jews find it offensive when a Christian claims (as some -- not all, I realize -- do) that one can only be saved through Jesus. But that doesn't make that statement "hate speech." Unless you're prepared to water down the definition of "hate speech" to "anything which I claim offends me."

It doesn't offend only me it offends all Christians.

Are you presuming to speak on behalf of all Christians?

If you insist on using gutter terms

(let's remember, the "gutter terms" are things like Flying Spaghetti Monster and Invisible Pink Unicorn. Hide the children!)

that's your right here in atheist land, but I wouldn't try it at home.

Why? Are some of your loving Christian brethren going to put me in the hosptial, "or worse"? If you're going to threaten physical violence, Rev, at least have the balls to do it yourself.
 
Ask him for scriptural reference. If you can not defend your beliefs with the bible you are not a christian but rather a false prophet. The bible can be so loosely interpreted that if he or anyone can not make a good case using the bible, its my opinion that it doesn't even loosely conform to anything christian.

; {>

You can't defend scripture by proving it with other scripture. It's circular logic.
 
Ask him for scriptural reference. If you can not defend your beliefs with the bible you are not a christian but rather a false prophet.


I doubt that he'll be prepared to provide anything that specific. His arguing strategy seems to involve keeping his own claims as vague as possible (for example his definition of god as "the creator of the universe" could apply to any number of possibilities, including the FSM), while asking atheists to provide definitions of the specific god that they don't believe in.
 
How is it possibly an insult when one refers to a fictional character by a nickname?

If I want to call Voldemort "Old Voldie," I'll do so.

I'm not responsible for protecting the imaginary feelings of other people's imaginary friends.

The insults you spoke of, RevD, were ones being directed to actual people. How is referring to your god or any other god as an invisible sky daddy, for instance, an insult to a real person? If you want to believe in a magic man, go right ahead. But don't expect everyone else to treat him/her/it with respect.
 
Ask him for scriptural reference. If you can not defend your beliefs with the bible you are not a christian but rather a false prophet. The bible can be so loosely interpreted that if he or anyone can not make a good case using the bible, its my opinion that it doesn't even loosely conform to anything christian.

; {>

Bolding mine. Thanks for that. I think it made my day.
 
I was fairly sure I would get that ‘its really an analogy’ type answers/rebuttals.

Inevitably, since that is the truth

So considering the outside chance that some of you may of rationalized yourselves, or been brainwashed by someone that has taught you falsehoods from childbirth and kept you locked in a closet 24/7 I would attempt to clarify what the difference is between making an analogy and making an insult.

Yes: I quite see you know what an insult is: you have demonstrated it again and again. I am beginning to get the impression that you cannot help yourself.

Lets have a look at the word "insult", shall we ?

Insult:sb. 1603 1. An act , or the action, of attacking or assailing; attack, assault, onset (lit and fig). arch. b. An open and sudden attack, without preparations. 2. An act, or the action, of insulting (in sense 1 or 2 of vb); injuriously contemptuous speech or action; an affront. 3. The act of leaping upon; "covering".

Insult:V. 1570 1. To manifest arrogant or scornful delight, by speech or behviour; to exult proudly or contemptuously; to vaunt, glory or triumph 2. To assail with scornful abuse or offensive disrespect; to offer indignity to; to affront, outrage 3. To make an attack or assault (lit and fig

OED third edition

Take a look at post #475 in this thread
and compare it with your statement quoted above.

Which one do you think can be taken as an example of the defintion given above? Any idea?
 
Lord Emsworth said:
Hmmm', well most of the time it is "he," and sometimes it "she." Very often though, if you use "it" people will frown upon it.

I don't use the word 'it' for common courtesy. But what about the Bible? Doesn't the Bible refer to God as exclusively male? Doesn't that make it sacrilegious to refer to God as female? No. God is described in many forms in the bible, none meant to be taken literately, God is a spirit. You mentioned calling God it. There is good reason the bible references God as male. For one thing we can say it’s a given that most of the men who scribed their words onto parchment in the distant past considered women inferior. But what many traditional preachers don’t know is that that Hebrew (the old testament was written primarily in Hebrew, with a few small sections written in Aramaic which was essentially a variation of Hebrew) has no concept for “it,” ! The kicker is that most words in Hebrew default to the masculine gender ! Hello Ms!

Well, I don't really have a clue. You see, any of the things that you could assert about the IPU or the FSM to be insulting are clearly there in many of the various Gods as well.

That depends on which God we are speaking of. Personally I feel there is only one non created eternal being that created the universe and it is God. I feel all the other religions are simply attempts to assign attributes to this creator God. I happen to choose Christianity as the most accurate attempt to describe God. None of the religions including Christianity describe God with an accuracy of 100%.

In the case of God the language when talking about it clearly describes something human like. It talks, for instance. It listens, has emotion, there is family, and when you die you'll stand face to face with him, so on and so forth. Almost like a man in the sky. And with the IPU there is something in the form of a horse with a horn attached to its forehead (clover shape hoofs are less important).

Think about it. The authors are human, they have to use something to compare their concepts to. For example the first 12 chapters of Genesis were written primarily by an Yahwist , (putative author of the earliest sources of the Hexateuch, or first six books of the bible) making use of some material provided by the Elohist (E) (he Elohist (E) is one of four sources of the Torah ) both of them so-called by their favored name for God.

Scripture that refer to Yahweh (allahiym) are usually called JE passages. El was the principle god of the Canaanite and the Palestinian pantheon. In the texts his companion AKA as Elath or Eloah, and when combined they were named Elohim, the gods. I could go on but fear that my words would be taken out of context. I will say that if anything the biblical name for God is a combination of male and female concepts.

Now why, if in the case of God this all is just flowery language to describe (almost) nothing at all, why can't people make the same kind of assumption when it comes to IPUs? Why do people insist here of taking it all literally?

Its what they were taught, and it doesn’t harm the religion, because the core message is the only important thing. That is that the bible is a manual for saving ones soul, God wants us to live forever and not end up in the grave (of no self awareness) forever.

And what do the anthropomorphic metaphors even mean? Nothing?

Some of its translated material like textual vestiges and some is used to allow us to comprehend difficult and complex ideas. Some have important clues to what the author meant spiritually, again Hebrew is not English and we lose a lot of meaning when translated. I wish everyone could take a course in Hebrew that was bible curious, it would open a lot of eyes, sometimes profoundly so.

Above I said that I really don't have a clue. Well ... I sometimes do have a hunch that people are so mad, because there is the faint realization that if you strip God of all the blatant garbage, anthropomorphic or otherwise, that then your are practically an atheist.

I think you may enjoy studying advanced theology. Look at it this way if you didn’t convert to Christianity (I think you would upon full understanding of Gods word) you could use it as ammo in debate.

; {>
 
Last edited:
This post is what is so wrong with many armchair biblical experts. There are no quotes only sloppy half copies excerpted from god knows where pulled out of context and order...(I could go on). With all due respect, its worthless except to use as an example of bad..no horrible...no awful debate and even worse theology.

If you want to know the attributes of the Christian God ask or pick one piece of scripture and include the book and verse.

Who should be asked? And why?

Otherwise all you are going to have is a mishmash of dog poo and is good for what dog poo is good for, to dispose of it as quickly as possible.

Listening to some random Christian opinion hardly ameliorates this problem. To the contrary.
 
Take a look at post #475 in this thread
and compare it with your statement quoted above.

Which one do you think can be taken as an example of the defintion given above? Any idea?

The rules don't apply to him, as he is in "atheist land" representing the one and only true god. He's allowed to insult us sinners. His god forgives him. I dare say it commands it.
 
Lord Emsworth said:
Who should be asked?

Ask an expert on the subject


That should be obvious. If you want to know something about theology ask a theologian, a degrees theologian if possible. If you want to ask something about biology ask an expert in biology, such as a person holding a degree in the subject.

Listening to some random Christian opinion hardly ameliorates this problem. To the contrary.

Maybe you didn't notice where I asked the author specify.

; {>
 
Last edited:
You don't understand the old testament, so try reading the new, that is a redo of the old by the man, there you will find the good of God...


Redo, eh? That whole new covenant / old covenant thing? Help me understand this part of the New Testament, then:

Matthew 5 said:
17"Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished."

It seems to be saying the rules and commandments laid out in the Old Testament aren't to be ignored. Of course, that is just the plain English interpretation. I don't have any training in spin-doctology or double-speak.

...and then it continues with my favorite part:

19"Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven."


Sounds like Jesus was laying down some smack on all those Moses-naysayers.
 
Ask an expert on the subject

Ah, you mean like Wollery on astrophyscis?


That should be obvious. If you want to know something about theology ask a theologian, a degrees theologian if possible. If you want to ask something about biology ask an expert in biology, such as a person holding a degree in the subject.

Ah, you mean like Wollery on astrophysics

You know something, RevDisturba: I have mentioned before that it would be good if you held yourself to the same standards you demand of others: I now add it would be helpful if you practised what you preach, as well :)
 
If you want to know something about theology ask a theologian, a degrees theologian if possible. If you want to ask something about biology ask an expert in biology, such as a person holding a degree in the subject.

And if you want to know something about cosmology....
 
Bolding mine. Thanks for that. I think it made my day.

Your welcome.:D If you cant make a case using the bible its not anything Christian. There are many ways to describe an event, but if its not in the bible you might as well be using the satantic bible.

; }>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom