What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

God isn't gender specific.

Hmmm, well most of the time it is "he," and sometimes it "she." Very often though, if you use "it" people will frown upon it.

You see you really do know why such things as the FSM is insulting to Christians or if you dont you do now.

Well, I don't really have a clue. You see, any of the things that you could assert about the IPU or the FSM to be insulting are clearly there in many of the various Gods as well.

In the case of God the language when talking about it clearly describes something human like. It talks, for instance. It listens, has emotion, there is family, and when you die you'll stand face to face with him, so on and so forth. Almost like a man in the sky. And with the IPU there is something in the form of a horse with a horn attached to its forehead (clover shape hoofs are less important).

Now why, if in the case of God this all is just flowery language to describe (almost) nothing at all, why can't people make the same kind of assumption when it comes to IPUs? Why do people insist here of taking it all literally?

And what do the anthropomorphic metaphors even mean? Nothing?

Above I said that I really don't have a clue. Well ... I sometimes do have a hunch that people are so mad, because there is the faint realization that if you strip God of all the blatant garbage, anthropomorphic or otherwise, that then your are practically an atheist.
 
Everything we do is effected by God, from t-0 until the end. The end of the universe or your end, it makes no difference.

Affected or Effected? There's a world of difference. Not that I think either is true, but I'd like to know which you are claiming.
 
God isn't gender specific. I could give you a few atheist names that might give you an idea? Of course I wouldn't know why atheists get angry about the

' You might be a fundy atheist if' Jeff foxworthy type humor sayings either.

But they do. Every time I post them...wonder why, the are just ROTF funny to me...want to hear some of them?

huh do ya huh?

They are ridiculously funny and I really don't know why most atheists get so angry when I post them....

You see you really do know why such things as the FSM is insulting to Christians or if you dont you do now.

; }>

Something like this? By all means go ahead. Should be fun.

Note the moderator's position here.
 
Something like this? By all means go ahead. Should be fun.

Note the moderator's position here.
That is a very old thread, and rules have changed since then; some of the postings in that thread would be moderated today. Also, Tricky was not a moderator at that time, so apart from it being a statement he made 6 years ago, it cannot be held to be a "moderator's position".
 
The best thing to do is to not answer any replies that contain bait words such as the FSM, or associating religious icons with mythical figures, or calling religion myth.
Religious icons are mythical figures.

Religion is myth.

You just happen to believe one particular collection of myths.

That doesn't give it any special standing.

Those kind of comments belong in juvenile hall or to be used amongst school children.
No, they belong in proper history and comparative religion classes.

I see a this forum slightly trending upward towards ethical and debate in good faith and away from the Brownshirt/insultive' quagmire of the past.
Ah, and that wasn't an insult at all.

Either you have no idea what the words you are using actually mean, or you do, and you are making calculated insults of the worst sort.

Wikipedia said:
The Sturmabteilung, abbreviated SA (German for "Storm detachment" or "Assault detachment" or "Assault section", usually translated as "stormtroop(er)s"), functioned as a paramilitary organization of the Nazi Party. It played a key role in Adolf Hitler's rise to power in the 1920s and 1930s.

SA men were often called "brownshirts" for the colour of their uniforms; this distinguished them from the Schutzstaffel (SS), who wore black and brown uniforms (in comparison to Benito Mussolini's blackshirts). Brown-coloured shirts were chosen as the SA uniform because a large batch of them was cheaply available after World War I, having originally been ordered for German troops serving in Africa.

What do you have to say for yourself, RevD?

oops I was making my assessment of this forum getting better by the first few comments on page one, on page two I see the rhetoric and hate speech heating up from the usual suspects, sad!
Yes, from the usual suspects, and yes, very sad.

It seems that we still have a good measure of our unsavory juvenile types eh?
Apparently so.

Well this forum may still yet be a good place to post if the weeds can be pulled.
It's doing just fine, thanks.

The school children of the mentioned offensive insulting people. If I caught my children using those taunts and remarks they would be grounded of a week or worse.
Mote, beam.
 
I Yam what I Yam...You are what you are, and God is 'I AM'. What I want to know is it you are or you R?

Now that should clear it up for sure!

; {>

Wasn't it Popeye who said that? Isn't it nice to amuse ourselves while we're waiting for the Rev and Yrreg to post some evidence for the existence of their god? Ain't seen a shred yet.
 
Yes, atheists, you have been saying since shall we say eternity that you lack belief in God or gods, but you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists, and to understand what you read in writings directed against God.
No, we don't.

That's your job.

You believe in something? It's your job to define it. It's your job to provide evidence that it exists.

Until you do that, we don't have to do a thing.
 
That is a very old thread, and rules have changed since then; some of the postings in that thread would be moderated today.

Sure.

Also, Tricky was not a moderator at that time, so apart from it being a statement he made 6 years ago, it cannot be held to be a "moderator's position".

I didn't mean to imply that it was an official position of Tricky as a moderator. Nonetheless, Tricky is a moderator now and that post goes to show that just for making fun of atheism RevDisturba most probably won't get smacked.
 
I didn't mean to imply that it was an official position of Tricky as a moderator. Nonetheless, Tricky is a moderator now and that post goes to show that just for making fun of atheism RevDisturba most probably won't get smacked.

Why would he? I haven't gotten smacked for making fun of religion. :cs:

The only condition I would place on the good Rev is that he get ready for a storm of return-fire mockery after he posts his stuff.
 
I didn't mean to imply that it was an official position of Tricky as a moderator.
Then why did you say, "Note the moderator's position here." rather than, for example, "See what Tricky said here"? You may not have meant it, but I don't see how it could imply anything else.
Nonetheless, Tricky is a moderator now and that post goes to show that just for making fun of atheism RevDisturba most probably won't get smacked.

What does Tricky being a moderator now have to with what he said 6 years ago?

You may well be right that a posting along those lines won't lead to an infraction, but that would depend, as for all posts, whether it breached the MA. However, a six year old post doesn't say anything about that, for the reasons I already gave.
 
Ha ha you seem not to know the process of documentation and cannon that the bible endured to become the number one best seller of history. BTW its the most accurate copied document known (ancient document). Madmen? NO I am afraid you are wrong there as well, john was just seeing the future our present, no wonder it seemed like he was insane, this secular world is nutty.
You have evidence to support this assertion? Like next week's lottery numbers in clear text in Revelation?

Thought not.

Most of the authors of the bible led normal lives and did not present any insanity or psychosis.
From unusually loquacious shrubbery to the best short-order cook in history, the bible is loaded with nuttiness. It wouldn't be the same without it.

Now the lead swilling nobility of the Romans, they were nutty as can be.
Begging the question.

Nevertheless, the Romans had something in their favour: They actually existed.
 
You don't understand the old testament, so try reading the new, that is a redo of the old by the man, there you will find the good of God...

You mean like:
Luke 12 said:
45But and if that servant say in his heart, My lord delayeth his coming; and shall begin to beat the menservants and maidens, and to eat and drink, and to be drunken;

46The lord of that servant will come in a day when he looketh not for him, and at an hour when he is not aware, and will cut him in sunder, and will appoint him his portion with the unbelievers. 47And that servant, which knew his lord's will, and prepared not himself, neither did according to his will, shall be beaten with many stripes.
Yup, Jesus used beating slaves (it's slave in the original greek) as a parable for why god is just in punishing people to hell.

and, if case you didn't get it the first time arround, Jesus goes a bit further:
Luke 12 said:
51Suppose ye that I am come to give peace on earth? I tell you, Nay; but rather division:

52For from henceforth there shall be five in one house divided, three against two, and two against three. 53The father shall be divided against the son, and the son against the father; the mother against the daughter, and the daughter against the mother; the mother in law against her daughter in law, and the daughter in law against her mother in law.
yup. Jesus encourages the violation of God's own commandment: HOnor thy mother and father. What a card.
if you do not understand how the old testament has to yield to the new read some books on bible synthesis (rather than analytic interpertation)
I understand it just fine. You see, I'm not blinded by dogma to pretend it says something that clearly isn't there.
 
Of course I wouldn't know why atheists get angry about the

' You might be a fundy atheist if' Jeff foxworthy type humor sayings either.

But they do. Every time I post them...wonder why, the are just ROTF funny to me...want to hear some of them?

huh do ya huh?

They are ridiculously funny and I really don't know why most atheists get so angry when I post them....

Lest I forget about this stuff. I am familiar with that "You might be a fundie atheist, if ...."

I am familiar with what it started out as; a handful and some points posted on the old IIDB by a member there, which indeed were (somewhat) funny and (somewhat) true. (I might be able dig it out, but only if you really want me to.)

I am also familiar with that amended version (from *a handful and some* to *150*) from Tektonics. Of course most of the newly added point are not even true to boot, and hence not funny in that sense. One of them asserts that you might be a fundy atheist if you haven't seen The Passion of the Christ, or so I seem to remember (if you must, look up the exact wording). Hysterical.
 
Last edited:
That is an insult, like fundy atheist or calling atheism or the other derogatory names of atheists and atheism, which I wont repeat here, or even calling it for what it is..the most despised minority ever...Its just a way to insult someone, and not worthy of productive debate and a good forum.
Sorry, RevD, you're wrong.

Completely wrong.

The Invisible Pink Unicorn and the Flying Spaghetti Monster are no insult to you unless you choose to make them so.

They address your argument, your beliefs. They point out that your beliefs are founded on nothing. I can understand why you might find this alarming, but that's your problem.
 
What do you know to be the concept of God as accepted by Christians to be in fact existing?

Please take care that we are now into the concept of God accepted by Christians to be in fact existing, we are not now into the issue of the existence of God.


Why do I want to know what you know to be the concept of God, the Christian God that is?

Because then I will know whether you are targeting the correct God, or you are missing altogether your target, and thus you are not being relevant in being atheists.






Yrreg

What overweening arrogance! Many here, myself included, have been brought up Christian, and educated as Christians. We have studied this stuff, probably more thoroughly and more thoughtfully than you have. We know what God you are talking about, and we know what Christians believe, even if you lack the competence either to explain it or to understand it yourself.

So is an irrelevant atheist someone who rejects the wrong gods? Are you suggesting that some putative god hiding behind the door must be considered real until we reject it with exactly the right choice of words?
 
So is an irrelevant atheist someone who rejects the wrong gods? Are you suggesting that some putative god hiding behind the door must be considered real until we reject it with exactly the right choice of words?

We really can't expect anything else from magical thinkers. It's very much like, if you know a demon's true name, you can command him.
 
What overweening arrogance! Many here, myself included, have been brought up Christian, and educated as Christians. We have studied this stuff, probably more thoroughly and more thoughtfully than you have. We know what God you are talking about, and we know what Christians believe, even if you lack the competence either to explain it or to understand it yourself.

So is an irrelevant atheist someone who rejects the wrong gods? Are you suggesting that some putative god hiding behind the door must be considered real until we reject it with exactly the right choice of words?

That's exactly why I believe in Cthulhu. I can't tell him that I don't believe in him, so he won't go away. I mean, I can say "I don't believe in you," but he doesn't speak English, only Ctholhian, and I can't make the right gargling noises and I always forget that I'm supposed to pull out my tongue at the end of the sentence. So he still thinks I believe in him.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom