What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Not sure how that got introduced into the conversation. You'll have to take it up with yrreG. It's his contention that the fact that he (yrreG) has a nose and a penis is evidence that his (yrreG's) god(s) jumpstarted the universe. He (yrreG) hasn't quite got around to his (yrreG's) god(s)'s form or formlessness.


I was taking up for him, he seems to have a more difficult time than I do expressing himself. Yrreg seems to be a deist, or maybe a theist that likes to argue.

; {>
 
You don't understand the old testament, so try reading the new, that is a redo of the old by the man, there you will find the good of God...

No. The New Testament is barely better than the Old. Even Jesus preaches tough love.

; {>

if you do not understand how the old testament has to yield to the new read some books on bible synthesis (rather than analytic interpertation)

In other words, read Christian apologetics spewing frantically to cover up the fact that their god is a total a-hole?
 
I was taking up for him, he seems to have a more difficult time than I do expressing himself. Yrreg seems to be a deist, or maybe a theist that likes to argue.

; {>

A pity he never addresses anyone's point then. I'd guess he more likes to hear the sound of his own voice.

Sure would be nice if someone could address those points, like using the Invisible Pink Unicorn as an analogy for god(s).
 
Alternately, there I will find the ravings of madmen, cherry-picked and carefully edited and interpreted over a thousand years to suit a particular definition of god.

Ha ha you seem not to know the process of documentation and cannon that the bible endured to become the number one best seller of history. BTW its the most accurate copied document known (ancient document). Madmen? NO I am afraid you are wrong there as well, john was just seeing the future our present, no wonder it seemed like he was insane, this secular world is nutty. Most of the authors of the bible led normal lives and did not present any insanity or psychosis. Now the lead swilling nobility of the Romans, they were nutty as can be.

; {>
 
And God saith unto Moses, 'I AM THAT WHICH I AM;' He saith also, 'Thus dost thou say to the sons of Israel, I AM hath sent me unto you.'

I hope that clears everything up.

Yes, your God thing apparantly is capable of producing speech sounds. And it appears to be male.

But that is old news.


I'll probably never understand what people find so offensive about comparisons of God to the Invisible Pink Unicorn et al.
 
Last edited:
A pity he never addresses anyone's point then. I'd guess he more likes to hear the sound of his own voice.

Sure would be nice if someone could address those points, like using the Invisible Pink Unicorn as an analogy for god(s).

That is an insult, like fundy atheist or calling atheism or the other derogatory names of atheists and atheism, which I wont repeat here, or even calling it for what it is..the most despised minority ever...Its just a way to insult someone, and not worthy of productive debate and a good forum.

; }>
 
yrreg wrote
...you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists...

No.
 
Yes, your God thing apparantly is capable of producing speech sounds. And it appears to be male.

But that is old news.


I'll probably never understand what people find so offensive about comparisons of God to the Invisible Pink Unicorn et al.

God isn't gender specific. I could give you a few atheist names that might give you an idea? Of course I wouldn't know why atheists get angry about the

' You might be a fundy atheist if' Jeff foxworthy type humor sayings either.

But they do. Every time I post them...wonder why, the are just ROTF funny to me...want to hear some of them?

huh do ya huh?

They are ridiculously funny and I really don't know why most atheists get so angry when I post them....

You see you really do know why such things as the FSM is insulting to Christians or if you dont you do now.

; }>
 
Last edited:
God isn't gender specific. I could give you a few atheist names that might give you an idea? Of course I wouldnt know why atheists get angry about the

' You might be a fundy atheist if' Jeff foxworthy type humor sayings either.

But they do. Every time I post them...wonder why, the are just ROTF funny to me...want to hear some of them?

huh do ya huh?

; }>
Go ahead, doesn't bother me in the slightest. Why should it?
 
Go ahead, doesn't bother me in the slightest. Why should it?

I will have to get an ok from a moderator (for obvious reasons), but I may pick out some mild ones...If they really dont care I will post some in every reply I make for a week or two... there are about a hundred and fifty of them...

What about it Lord Emsworth..Lisa?

; }>
 
Last edited:
Ha ha you seem not to know the process of documentation and cannon that the bible endured to become the number one best seller of history.

Actually, most of the people here know the Bible extremely well. Know thine enemy and all that.

BTW its the most accurate copied document known (ancient document).

Source please? And just because it's the most accurate doesn't mean that it's accurate. I mean, everything else could just have been a horrible translation.

Madmen? NO I am afraid you are wrong there as well, john was just seeing the future our present, no wonder it seemed like he was insane, this secular world is nutty.

:dig:
Urgh. I can see we're not going to get anywhere here, so I won't discuss this topic. But here's my take on it: What's simpler: John saw the future, or John was hallucinating and/or crazy?


Most of the authors of the bible led normal lives and did not present any insanity or psychosis.

Source.

Now the lead swilling nobility of the Romans, they were nutty as can be.

Corrupt, yes. Nutty? I don't know.
; {>

That is an insult, like fundy atheist or calling atheism or the other derogatory names of atheists and atheism, which I wont repeat here, or even calling it for what it is..the most despised minority ever...Its just a way to insult someone, and not worthy of productive debate and a good forum.

It's not an insult. It's a statement of fact. If you'd ever actually read any yrreG threads, you'd understand. He literally doesn't respond to posts. He continues as if no one has spoken.
And, secondly, atheists are the SECOND-most despised minority in America. You, yrreG, Ethnikos and kurious_kathy form the most despised.


; }>

God isn't gender specific.

Then why say "He"? And capitalize it, as well?

I could give you a few atheist names that might give you an idea?

What?

Of course I wouldnt know why atheists get angry about the

' You might be a fundy atheist if' Jeff foxworthy type humor sayings either.

We don't. As a rule, we don't care if you mock us. After all, Cthulhu knows we do it to you as well. But we do care when you use that mocking as a basis for your argument. It's called argument ad hominem, and it's frowned upon here.

But they do. Every time I post them...wonder why, the are just ROTF funny to me...want to hear some of them?

huh do ya huh?

Sure, shoot.

; }>

Okay. There's two kinds of Christians on this board now:
- KK and yrreG; the flat-out trolls.
- RevD and Ethnikos; slightly less trollish, but still really, really annoying. At least they respond to posts.
 
The bible does not say God is human in form or that he as a form at all.

Yes, the Bible does say that. Somewhere in the first few chapters of Ezekiel IIRC. It also talks. It has a son, who takes his body with him when ascending to the sky.

But of course, I don't understand any of that stuff.
 
yrreg wrote
...you have got to know what is the concept of God or gods you lack belief in, in order to be logical in calling yourselves atheists...

No.


Yrreg's comment is like the "argument" I recently saw put forward by an apologist for homoeopathy, who said that I can't say that homoeopathy doesn't work because I "have no clue HOW it may NOT work".
 
That is an insult, like fundy atheist or calling atheism or the other derogatory names of atheists and atheism, which I wont repeat here, or even calling it for what it is..the most despised minority ever...Its just a way to insult someone, and not worthy of productive debate and a good forum.

Try to understand this:

No one is calling your God the Invisible Pink Unicorn, or the Flying Spaghetti Monster, or the Invisible Teapot in Orbit around Saturn, or the Invisible Dragon Living in My Garage, or Santa Claus, or the Tooth Fairy, or an elf, or a leprechaun, or the fairies at the bottom of the garden.

No one referring to any of those concepts is "insulting" your God.

What they are saying is that all of those concepts have just as much evidence for their existence, and are just as unfalsifiable, as your God. The argument for the existence of the Invisible Pink Unicorn can take exactly the same form, and go through exactly the same steps, as the argument for your God, and the same on down the line.

Think of it this way - the Bible describes God as appearing as a burning bush, a bright light, a disembodied voice, and a mortal man, right? But you would say (I think) that God is actually none of these things. Those who compare the arguments for the existence of God to the arguments for the existence of the Flying Spaghetti Monster are not calling God names - they are saying that the arguments in favor of one have just as much force as the arguments for the existence of the other.

"Prove to me that the Invisible Teapot in Orbit around Saturn does not exist," is not the same as saying, "Nanny-nanny boo-boo, you put your foot in poo-poo." It is actually shorthand for a quite nuanced statement about belief, evidence, and the relationship between the two.

Until you can show why your argument for the existence of God is any different than the argument for the existence of the Invisible Pink Unicorn, your argument will be relegated to the category of irrelevance by those who demand evidence.
 
That is an insult, like fundy atheist or calling atheism or the other derogatory names of atheists and atheism, which I wont repeat here, or even calling it for what it is..the most despised minority ever...Its just a way to insult someone, and not worthy of productive debate and a good forum.

; }>

No it isn't. It isn't said to be insulting and there is no reason for theists to read it as being insulting. It is used for the purpose of making theists think.

If you prefer, we could use The Flying Spaghetti Monster or the Invisible Dragon in the garage. Or we could use aether.

Here, to make it fair, I'll use an analogy to refer to atheists: Atheism is a belief system like not stamp collecting is a hobby.
 
You don't understand the old testament, so try reading the new, that is a redo of the old by the man, there you will find the good of God...

So God was evil, but then he reformed? Really, if God is perfect then why does he need to alter his earlier covenant?

Old Testament: Slaughter everyone! The men, the women, the old, the children...

New Testament: Uh, never mind that genocidal stuff. I was really out of my head. But it's still OK to enslave people.
 
Try to understand this:

No one is calling your God the Invisible Pink Unicorn, or the Flying Spaghetti Monster, or the Invisible Teapot in Orbit around Saturn, or the Invisible Dragon Living in My Garage, or Santa Claus, or the Tooth Fairy, or an elf, or a leprechaun, or the fairies at the bottom of the garden.

No one referring to any of those concepts is "insulting" your God.

What they are saying is that all of those concepts have just as much evidence for their existence, and are just as unfalsifiable, as your God. The argument for the existence of the Invisible Pink Unicorn can take exactly the same form, and go through exactly the same steps, as the argument for your God, and the same on down the line.

Think of it this way - the Bible describes God as appearing as a burning bush, a bright light, a disembodied voice, and a mortal man, right? But you would say (I think) that God is actually none of these things. Those who compare the arguments for the existence of God to the arguments for the existence of the Flying Spaghetti Monster are not calling God names - they are saying that the arguments in favor of one have just as much force as the arguments for the existence of the other.

"Prove to me that the Invisible Teapot in Orbit around Saturn does not exist," is not the same as saying, "Nanny-nanny boo-boo, you put your foot in poo-poo." It is actually shorthand for a quite nuanced statement about belief, evidence, and the relationship between the two.

Until you can show why your argument for the existence of God is any different than the argument for the existence of the Invisible Pink Unicorn, your argument will be relegated to the category of irrelevance by those who demand evidence.

Rev, this post clearly drives home an important point. Please don't ignore it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom