What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Because I cannot see how we can have any productive discussion when one party you are of the conviction that everything is appearance.

For you the design in the world is appearance, for me it is reality.


I think he's saying that until you, Bruto, agree that the world is designed in reality, not just in appearance, there can't be any discussion.

That would certainly make it easier for yrreG than producing something like evidence or an argument.
 
I'm constantly amused by the nonsense Yrreg spouts. I'd bet that he could start an argument in an empty house,as my dear old mum used to say.Every time he starts,I feel as if I've wandered into Monty Python's 'Is this the right room for an argument' sketch. Trying to get him to provide any evidence or proof for his sweeping statements is like trying to nail a jellyfish to a wall.Still,I suppose that he's harmless and he provides us with some entertainment.
 
Do you mean by appearance of design as opposed to reality of design?


Take my example of the moon's rotation and orbit and the production of a baby by you, if you ever produced a baby with a person of the opposite sex, they are two examples from me of the certainty of the reality -- as opposed to appearances -- of design in the world.

For you those two examples are not of the real world but of the world of appearance.


So that there is no reality outside of the appearance in both instances of the moon's motion of rotation and orbit and the event of conception and birth of a human baby?






Yrreg

Nonsense. Now you're reading into my language an interpretation that is not there. I see no difference between the world of appearance and the real world. We experience the world as it is, but we do not experience why it is. Sure, I know where babies come from, but this is learned. I experienced a lot, but I did not experience the cause and effect locally, nor have I, or anyone else for that matter, experienced the reason the process works as it does.

You are making a huge leap here, but seem determined to deny that it is a leap at all, and this continues to cause problems in your argument. For millennia, people have used logic, guesswork, inspiration, authority, blundering stupidity and blinding insight to achieve some understanding of the world, without achieving a true consensus. Now you come along and claim that it's all right there to be perceived and experienced; toss the philosophy, fire the theologians, close the colleges, shut down the colliders. If you don't see what Yrreg sees, your brain is broken.
 
You are merely trading on the ambiguities in the way the word design is used, Yrreg.

Design:

I.
1. A plan or scheme conceived in the mind of something to be done: the preliminary conception of an idea that is to be carried into effect by action: a project.

2. Purpose, aim, intention

3. The thing aimed at

4. Contrivance in accordance with a preconceived plan: adaptation of means to ends; prearranged purpose; as,the argument from d.

5. In a bad sense: Crafty contrivance; and instance of this


II.1
a. A preliminary sketch for a work of art; the plan of a building, or part of it, or of a piece of decorative work, after which the structure or texture is to be completed; a delineation or pattern

b. The combination of details which go to make up a work of art; artistic idea as executed; a piece of decorative work, an artistic device

c. The art of picturesque delineation and construction

II.2

a.To plan, plan out

b.To purpose,intend

c. To have in view

d. To intend to go or start

III.1

a. To sketch

b. To trace the outline of, delineate

c. To make the preliminary sketch of; to make the plans and drawings necessary for the constuction of

III.2

To plan and execute; to fashion with artistic skill or decorative device

III.3

a.To draw, sketch

b. To form or fashion a work of art; less widely, to devise artistic patterns

(OED)

When you and and your wife decide to have a baby you "design" to do so in the first sense outlined above: that is, it is your intention/ purpose/aim to have a child. This use of the word "design" is perfectly respectable but it is a little archaic and is seldom used nowadays. People do not go about saying things like "if milk be thy design; with plenteous hand bring Clover grass"; or "he had no design on your pocket". Nor do they say "it is our design to have a baby". What they actually say is things like " we are trying for a baby"; or "we want to have a baby"; or even " we intend to have a baby"

The word design is now much more commonly used in the other senses. It carries the implication that the designer makes the plan for a particular completed work and that work will look like the plan when it is done. There is no way that prospective parents do anything like that. This use of the word design, applied to the making of babies, is so far from what happens as to be laughable.

The incidence of spontaneous abortion runs at about 16%, I think. Is that what prospective parents "design"? Many are born with disabilities and defects. Is that what they "design"? A lot of prospective parents cannot conceive at all. Where is the "design" in that? Before modern medicine a lot of women died in childbirth: is that part of what prospective parents "design"?.

These questions are easily answered: there would be no amniocentesis tests or moves to invent ways to choose the characteristics of any children born if what we get was a product of parental design at present.

Or is it your contention that some other entity does the designing? If so then why did you bring the prospective parents into it in discussing "design"? And while we are on the subject, why is it this designer is so freaking useless as to produce all the problems outlined above? I would sack an architect if 16% of his buildings fell down.

I do not know if your conflation is because your english is limited or because you deliberately obfuscate. But if we are to proceed you need to separate the different meanings of this word: and then, hopefully say which one you are using and also whether you do or don't believe that the world shows evidence of whichever sense of design you choose to adopt

There is only one word for this response: elegant.
 
So that there is no reality outside of the appearance in both instances of the moon's motion of rotation and orbit and the event of conception and birth of a human baby?

Yes there is a reality here: The moon has a motion of rotation and when a woman conceives, the birth of a live human baby is the result in almost all cases. In both examples of the moon and the live birthing, they are as they appear to be because of scientific study. That's the reality.
 
What exactly was this thread about again?

"Maker", "Father", "right hand", "ascend", yum.

I now expect "God" to be a man - as in biological organism - who lives in a spatial place up there somewhere. Either argue for Skydaddy, or clarify.
 
Just tell me what you mean by appearance of design.

Nonsense. Now you're reading into my language an interpretation that is not there. I see no difference between the world of appearance and the real world. We experience the world as it is, but we do not experience why it is. Sure, I know where babies come from, but this is learned. I experienced a lot, but I did not experience the cause and effect locally, nor have I, or anyone else for that matter, experienced the reason the process works as it does.

You are making a huge leap here, but seem determined to deny that it is a leap at all, and this continues to cause problems in your argument. For millennia, people have used logic, guesswork, inspiration, authority, blundering stupidity and blinding insight to achieve some understanding of the world, without achieving a true consensus. Now you come along and claim that it's all right there to be perceived and experienced; toss the philosophy, fire the theologians, close the colleges, shut down the colliders. If you don't see what Yrreg sees, your brain is broken.


Just tell me what you mean by appearance of design.


Is your penis an appearance of design or a reality of design?





Yrreg
 
My wife asked me to stop discussing my penis on line.
But it has its own mind. A stupid mind.
Stupid, stupid, stupid.
 
Just tell me what you mean by appearance of design.

Is your penis an appearance of design or a reality of design?
If penises were designed that they all would be +1 foot in length with multiple hard ridges that could vibrate..... for hours.... or have the ability to grab small items....

Instead we have evolution that strives with minimal effort for: about good enough.
 
Just tell me what you mean by appearance of design.


Is your penis an appearance of design or a reality of design?

Yrreg
Funny you should bring this up....

Have you ever been kicked there? did you ever wonder WHY such an important and sensitive set of organs exist on the outside of body? Why would this be designed as such?
 
Funny you should bring this up....

Have you ever been kicked there? did you ever wonder WHY such an important and sensitive set of organs exist on the outside of body? Why would this be designed as such?


Because God designed yrreg in His own image.
 
Just tell me what you mean by appearance of design.


Is your penis an appearance of design or a reality of design?





Yrreg
The syntax of that sentence defies a direct answer. My penis IS a bodily organ. The properties that it might exhibit (best left unspecified) are not necessarily what it IS. The reality of a tree is the tree itself. It is not woodiness, brownness, etc.; although it may exhibit various properties, it is not, by itself, any one of those properties by itself. Design is a process by which some things become what they are. If one were ignorant, either wilfully or accidentally, of evolution, an observer might see in a penis, as in many other things, the appearance of design - that is, it would appear to the observer to have characteristics that suggest that it was intentionally designed. If the concept of a designing deity is correct and that of natural selection is not, that appearance would correspond to the reality of its having been designed. If it is not, the appearance of design will not correspond to the reality of its evolution. But the object in question is what it is, not its appearance and not our interpretation of its appearance.

I don't know how else to put it. I do know that I would never have thought to put my penis into this conversation, and if you don't mind, I would prefer to withdraw it.
 
I don't know how else to put it. I do know that I would never have thought to put my penis into this conversation, and if you don't mind, I would prefer to withdraw it.

You do know that withdrawal is not an effective method of contraception, right? This discussion could continue to propagate.
 
Funny you should bring this up....

Have you ever been kicked there? did you ever wonder WHY such an important and sensitive set of organs exist on the outside of body? Why would this be designed as such?

It's ok, Radrook has already answered this question elsewhere:

Actually, a break of the pubic bone via a kick is far more serious than a damaged testicle since its jagged edges will pierce nearby internal organs. So placing the testicles on the inside leaves the pubic bone available as a target.

I'm not sure why women don't get the benefit of this 'protection', but apparently your testicles act as excellent armour.
 
Excuse the slight tangent, but at this point I simply have to ask...

Is English yrreg's first language? Second? Is he, perhaps, just sticking a pin into the dictionary and typing out what he hits?

I try my hardest to keep up with his 'arguments' - largely because I derive rather a great deal of entertainment from reading the rest of you beating your heads against the proverbial brick wall for my enjoyment - but he does manage to mask any traces of sense behind a tidal-wave of inappropriate repetition and about three times as much grammar as is good for a body.

I would have addressed this to yrreg directly, but I don't think for a second that he would respond and I'm not about to PM him.

Sorry for the derail and thanks in advance for any response. I really am genuinely interested in the answer.
 
Excuse the slight tangent, but at this point I simply have to ask...

Is English yrreg's first language? Second? Is he, perhaps, just sticking a pin into the dictionary and typing out what he hits?

I try my hardest to keep up with his 'arguments' - largely because I derive rather a great deal of entertainment from reading the rest of you beating your heads against the proverbial brick wall for my enjoyment - but he does manage to mask any traces of sense behind a tidal-wave of inappropriate repetition and about three times as much grammar as is good for a body.

I would have addressed this to yrreg directly, but I don't think for a second that he would respond and I'm not about to PM him.

Sorry for the derail and thanks in advance for any response. I really am genuinely interested in the answer.

I believe this question has been addressed before, but I don't remember in what thread. Yrreg is from the Philippines, and I think English is his second language, but he has mentioned that English is taught in schools there from a fairly early age. I think he generallly does all right as long as he doesn't try too hard to be linguistically clever. I am guessing here that although he is obviously pretty proficient as a reader and writer of English he lacks conversational practice and that is why he sometimes sounds stilted and unidiomatic.

In any case, I'm quite happy to overlook the occasional hiccup in syntax, unless it truly makes it difficult to understand a point. If Yrregs's ideas were as good as his English we'd have little but quibbling left to do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom