What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Yrreg, you are not making any sense. I am not sure what the problem is this time but once again you are insulting people and I am particularly annoyed to see you insult Bruto in this way. He has been unfailingly courteous and patient in his dealings with you and he has tried to seriously engage with you in face of real problems with both your argument and your english.

But for what it is worth I think the problem lies here:

Yrreg said:
Even mathematicians tell us that there are ultimate premises taken for granted by all mathematicians if they would do mathematics and get something done seriously.

That is true and I do not think anyone would deny it.

But you are behaving as if "design" was just such a premise. It is not.

That assumption seems to be so strong in you that you do not even see how it is distorting your thinking: but it is rendering you incapable of grasping what is being said. (or you might just be trolling - I am inclined to that view but it is not certain)

Nobody is denying the existence of the material world. There are no posts in this thread which suggest that. Nobody has said the penis is not real.

But you seem to assume that acceptance of the reality of the penis entails acceptance of the idea it was designed: you can only do so if you believe that design is an "ultimate premise", and that is what is at issue.

Design is not an "ultimate premise": it is a conclusion. I thought you had already conceded that, because you have talked about using your reason to arrive at your conclusion. I now see that you meant your conclusion is the existence of god and that this is based on the assumption of design.

We cannot reach true conclusions if we found on false premises. Atheists do not accept that your premise is correct. You cannot insist that we accept it as an "ultimate premise", because we have no need for it in order to "get something done". Instead you must show why it is to be treated in that way. And you cannot demonstrate that by showing we cannot get to the existence of god without it: that may be true, but it does not seem to be anything more than begging the question.

So you need to do what I said earlier: you need to state explicitly what you mean when you talk of "design", because the term is used in different ways: then you need to show why the definition you have adopted is necessary to explain the material world as we experience it. After that you need to show how that premise, combined with which facts, leads logically to the existence of God.

I will be generous: I give you 50 words. If you cannot do this in 50 words or less then you do not know what you are talking about :p
 
This is some impasse but very crucially critical against exchange of thoughts.

Since Yrreg has introduced the subject of the purported design of penises, it occurs to me to cite this rather entertaining article. Yessiree, step right up to the design bar and get your barbs, hooks, daggers and corkscrews!

http://www.sciencenews.org/view/feature/id/40385/title/A_Most_Private_Evolution


This is some impasse but very crucially critical against exchange of thoughts.

I am talking about what you add to the meaning of the word design with the prefix phrase "appearance of," if you mean it is not to be understood as "just," so that "appearance of penis'design" does not mean "just appearance" of penis' design."


In which case you need not add that prefix phrase.


If you believe you have to, then I will tend to conclude that you want to be devious in your words, which deviousness from your part in your words certainly stymies viable communication among men.





Yrreg
 
Yrreg, allow me to try to explain what is meant by the term "appearance of design", so that the exchange of views may be continued fruitfully.

Let us take two objects as examples, an abacus, and a snowflake. The abacus was design by a human for the purpose of counting and doing mathematics. The snowflake came about without any design, due to the way water crystallises as it cools slowly.

However, a snowflake has an intricate structure, which to many people would indicate a design, yet there was no design.

So, both the abacus and the snowflake look as if they have been designed, but only the abacus was "actually" designed. They both have the "appearance" of design, but in the case of the snowflake this "appearance" is misleading, because it wasn't actually designed.

Many things have the "appearance" of design, and some of them were, in fact, designed, but many of them weren't. Hence it is most useful when talking about design in this context to ensure that until proof of design can be made available for any individual object we talk about its appearance of design.
 
Read Other Posts!

Dear Gerry,

Read other posts: They will help your brain come out of that land of confusion it's currently mired in.
 
Yrreg said:
Even mathematicians tell us that there are ultimate premises taken for granted by all mathematicians if they would do mathematics and get something done seriously.
That is true and I do not think anyone would deny it.

I'd deny it. Nothing is taken for granted by all mathematicians. There are whole fields of mathematics that have been created by throwing out all axioms and starting again with some new ones. Sometimes it leads to nonsense and dead ends, other times you end up with interesting and important discoveries. In addition, even within a field axioms are never taken for granted. All of mathematics accepts that it is based on a set of assumptions and that they may not necessarily apply in all situations.

I have no idea what Yrreg was actually trying to say, but it appears he knows as little about mathematics as he does about everything else.
 
Yrreg, considering how many words you use, I'm surprised you are having trouble with the simple word "appearance". If it will help, here are some other ways to say "appearance of design".

It seems to be designed.
It has the guise of being designed.
It has the semblence of design.
It looks like it may have been designed.
It has an air of design about it.


Note that none of these statements are equivalent to "It was designed.".
 
If God is the maker of everything, who made God?

That to me is a question that is irrational and illogical, but just the same suppose you tell me what is wrong with my answer below:



If God is the maker of everything, who made God?

He made Himself and then made Himself again and again and again and again all in a circle endlessly.​


That is why He does not have to make Himself unless He wants to repeat endlessly the making of Himself around and around in a circle.


But He has read about the principle of frugality and can stop making Himself in a circle of making Himself again and again and again, except turning His making of Himself on repeatedly for the benefit of people who keep asking if God makes everything who made God?





Yrreg
 
That to me is a question that is irrational and illogical, but just the same suppose you tell me what is wrong with my answer below:



If God is the maker of everything, who made God?

He made Himself and then made Himself again and again and again and again all in a circle endlessly.​







Yrreg

So it is elephants all the way down
 
So are you positing a god which has always existed? Or one which is outside time? Or something else? I am not sure I understand your position.
 
That is why He does not have to make Himself unless He wants to repeat endlessly the making of Himself around and around in a circle.

Let me put the question this way : How did god begin?

It makes no sense to answer that god began himself, because if he was there to begin himself then it was not a beginning. There must be some other answer.

So how did god begin?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom