What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Will you be inclined at least for review tell people what is the intelligent...

I have a pretty good idea, but I don't think you're going to get me there unarmed.

Your examples smack of "argument from design," which has been a dead end and a failure not only for science but for intelligent theology for enough centuries that I, at least, have no desire to revisit it.

I might add too, that your examples above of "making" leave some questions that could lead us back into the quagmire of definition, requiring that we define the terms by which you have defined God.

I have, for example, "made" some babies in the colloquial sense of the word, but it would take a wild and hubristic stretch of the imagination to suggest that I "made" them in any sense that matches the way I have made buildings, furniture, machines, and the like. The part I played in the making of those babies (now adults, by the way), is often referred to with another term, a four letter Anglo-saxon term, beginning with the letter "f," which forum rules prevent me from spelling out. Now there may be some people who would consider this also the best word to describe the effect of God on the universe, of discourse if not of reality, but I suspect that this is not the direction in which you wish to head.


Will you be inclined at least for review tell people what is the intelligent design argument?




I was not thinking of the intelligent design argument, not that I can directly link what I have in mind with the intelligent design argument.

Now that you bring up the ID argument and state that you find it for yourself and others like you to be meaningless, then for the time being, suppose you tell me what it is?


We are now in the process of eliminating the kinds of makers who do not qualify for the concept of the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


So that readers will know what you understand by the ID argument please just tell us in your own words however many you need what is the intelligent design argument.



I will tell you later what I have in mind for an argument from the existence of men as makers of things and being very clever about being makers.


You will notice that we are now attempting to come to a concurrence on exactly what is the intelligent design argument which you in effect find it meaningless or in other words unacceptable to yourself and others like yourself.

At least we have so far concurred on the possibility of the concept in our brain of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.



I will tell you right away that I am not trying to corner you into a haha gotcha situation.

The most useful finding we might come to in this exchange is that we have very clear boundaries of the impasse between you and me, in this matter of the existence of God understood as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.





Yrreg
 
Yrreg if you are not proposing intelligent design and Bruto is not what would be the point of outlining it. Why not just get on with whatever you are trying to do?
 
I agree with Fiona. If ID is not yrreg's point, it would only be a derail here.

I think since yrreg has stated that he is not making an intelligent design claim, all discussion on the topic should be removed.
 
Will you be inclined at least for review tell people what is the intelligent design argument?




I was not thinking of the intelligent design argument, not that I can directly link what I have in mind with the intelligent design argument.

Now that you bring up the ID argument and state that you find it for yourself and others like you to be meaningless, then for the time being, suppose you tell me what it is?


We are now in the process of eliminating the kinds of makers who do not qualify for the concept of the maker of heaven and earth and everything.


So that readers will know what you understand by the ID argument please just tell us in your own words however many you need what is the intelligent design argument.



I will tell you later what I have in mind for an argument from the existence of men as makers of things and being very clever about being makers.


You will notice that we are now attempting to come to a concurrence on exactly what is the intelligent design argument which you in effect find it meaningless or in other words unacceptable to yourself and others like yourself.

At least we have so far concurred on the possibility of the concept in our brain of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.



I will tell you right away that I am not trying to corner you into a haha gotcha situation.

The most useful finding we might come to in this exchange is that we have very clear boundaries of the impasse between you and me, in this matter of the existence of God understood as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.





Yrreg

I did not quite use the term "intelligent design." I used the term "argument from design." In brief, it is the assertion that since the world shows the appearance of design, there must be a designer, a fallacy in that it skips the premise that the appearance of design necessarily requires a designer. Now of course you could say, technically, that since you have not used the word "design," and have avoided any contention in your definition that God exhibits intelligence or intention, you have not broached the argument from design, but it does sound from what you've said so far, and the analogies you've suggested so far, that you are using the appearance of design (or of manufacture or of making, if you prefer) as an argument for the assumption of a designer (or maker, if you prefer).

Nor did I say the argument was meaningless: only fallacious.

Of course if you have some other argument, and agree that the argument from design is no good, you'd do better to present yours on its own merits, rather than getting sidetracked into something neither of us would care to spend time on.
 
Actually, yrreg reminds me of god, because I get the same responses from him as I used to get when I used to pray.
 
On appearance of design, and sidetracking.

I did not quite use the term "intelligent design." I used the term "argument from design." In brief, it is the assertion that since the world shows the appearance of design, there must be a designer, a fallacy in that it skips the premise that the appearance of design necessarily requires a designer. Now of course you could say, technically, that since you have not used the word "design," and have avoided any contention in your definition that God exhibits intelligence or intention, you have not broached the argument from design, but it does sound from what you've said so far, and the analogies you've suggested so far, that you are using the appearance of design (or of manufacture or of making, if you prefer) as an argument for the assumption of a designer (or maker, if you prefer).

Nor did I say the argument was meaningless: only fallacious.

Of course if you have some other argument, and agree that the argument from design is no good, you'd do better to present yours on its own merits, rather than getting sidetracked into something neither of us would care to spend time on.



In brief, it is the assertion that since the world shows the appearance of design, there must be a designer, a fallacy in that it skips the premise that the appearance of design necessarily requires a designer.​

That could be an instance of impasse between you and me, that you are of the conviction that the world shows the appearance of design, while I am of the human certainty that the world has the reality of design.


Of course if you have some other argument, and agree that the argument from design is no good, you'd do better to present yours on its own merits, rather than getting sidetracked into something neither of us would care to spend time on. ​


I never say that I find the argument from design to be no good.

And I did not bring up the argument from design, you are the one, wherefore you should not say that I am sidetracking into something neither of us would care to spend time on.


Please for the sake of maintaining a neat and tidy discussion, abstain from bringing in a lot of code words like "appearance of design," on which and by which you have already inured a psychological position in your brain and nerves of negation against God.




Yrreg
 
I don't think the universe has even the appearance of design.

To state that it does, it is first necessary to define the observable difference between a designed characteristic, and a non-designed characteristic. And I don't think anyone can do that.

So, debating the subject is a nonsense.

Although I concede that other people, who aren't me, may say, 'Hey, look at the universe, it is so totally designed.'
 
In brief, it is the assertion that since the world shows the appearance of design, there must be a designer, a fallacy in that it skips the premise that the appearance of design necessarily requires a designer.​

That could be an instance of impasse between you and me, that you are of the conviction that the world shows the appearance of design, while I am of the human certainty that the world has the reality of design.


Of course if you have some other argument, and agree that the argument from design is no good, you'd do better to present yours on its own merits, rather than getting sidetracked into something neither of us would care to spend time on. ​


I never say that I find the argument from design to be no good.

And I did not bring up the argument from design, you are the one, wherefore you should not say that I am sidetracking into something neither of us would care to spend time on.


Please for the sake of maintaining a neat and tidy discussion, abstain from bringing in a lot of code words like "appearance of design," on which and by which you have already inured a psychological position in your brain and nerves of negation against God.




Yrreg

What???
 
Please for the sake of maintaining a neat and tidy discussion, abstain from bringing in a lot of code words like "appearance of design," on which and by which you have already inured a psychological position in your brain and nerves of negation against God.



This sentence should be taken out back and shot. It's a traitor to the English language!



Honestly, Yrreg, what are you on about?
 
First we have a concept of something, then we go forth and look for it. 2

Start reading from the line below, bypassing the long citation:
[ Start here, if you are short of time. ]​

------------------------------


Posted by bruto
Posted by yrreg
If you want me to react to you, just pm me, I am dealing now with bruto.

Now, bruto, you agree with me that the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything is possible in your brain.


Suppose we now go forth and search for this God.



Is that a sensible adventure.



And please don't bring in creator, not now, just keep to my concept of God as worded, scil., the maker of heaven and earth and everything.



That is the trouble with atheists, they keep bringing in things which they need not, but should keep to the terms of the thesis or proposition or the concept as stated:


God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.​
I am not sure why you should balk at the word "creator" as a substitute for "maker," but have it your way if it makes you comfortable.

Is searching for such a god a sensible adventure? Yes, I think it is, but with a couple of qualifications.

First of all, if the search is going to be based only on the properties in your definition - that is, on the presumption that what we are looking for is the maker of heaven and earth and everything, then it would see we must start at searching for the answer to the question of whether there is any evidence that "heaven, earth and everything," what most of us are wont to call the universe, can properly be considered to have been "made" by some agency that can be identified.

Second, whether or not the adventure is sensible at this moment depends rather a lot on whether it has already been undertaken.

As it happens, I spend spent a good bit of time and energy in my youth trying to connect with that concept of yours, and the adventure ended with no such connection. I'm older now, and other adventures interest me far more.

Therefore, I suggest that if you are in a mood to undertake the adventure, go right ahead. Report your success if you have any, present your evidence, and make your case. But I am no longer in the mood to chase after God.​



You say:

As it happens, I spend spent a good bit of time and energy in my youth trying to connect with that concept of yours, and the adventure ended with no such connection. I'm older now, and other adventures interest me far more.
​


First we have a concept of something, then we go forth and look for it.

You spent a good bit of time and energy in your youth trying to connect with that concept of God, and the adventure ended with no such connection.

You did not find something that corresponds to the concept of maker of heaven and earth and everything.

That is really most disappointing on your part.



In my case I will first render the concept even more simple, telling myself that I am looking for a maker of everything.


A maker of something is easy to locate, for example maker of shoes, maker of cheese, maker of car batteries, one can find all such kinds of makers easily.

A maker of babies also, you are I would like to assume are one with your spouse, I am certainly one with my wife.


A brief reflection should tell you that of all makers of things that we know to have been made, humans are the ones doing all the making which we call artifacts: from spaceships which go into distant space and return to earth, to great gigantic dams to produce energy from water, control water flow, and also irrigate dry plains for agricultural pursuits.

Should I mention other artifacts of humans in all fields of human endeavors which make life more safe, last longer, and more comfortable, and enable humans themselves to come to greater and greater knowledge of the universe?

As regards knowledge you are aware that with man's brain and the instrumentation he has contrived man has multiplied with greater and greater acceleration the quantity and quality and certainty of his knowledge of the universe outside man and also within man himself.



At this point, I ask you, do you know where I am leading to?



Yrreg


[ Start here, if you are short of time. ]​


At this point, I ask you, do you know where I am leading to?


But you jumped right away to the argument from design by which you betray your prejudgment that design in the world is only an appearance.

Is that your conviction?

In which case as I have said already, for me the design in the world is a reality of which I have certainty about insofar as I have a brain that works as it should work.

That is an instance of impasse between you and me, and are you going to continue bringing up everything that you do not like to be appearances?


Because I cannot see how we can have any productive discussion when one party you are of the conviction that everything is appearance.

I was asking you whether you got what I was leading to, but you did not get what I was leading to.

Let that pass for the present.


Now we do have some very important matter to settle.

For you the design in the world is appearance, for me it is reality.

What other things in the world for you is appearance aside from the design in the world.

Or is everything that is design in the world for is you appearance, like the design of the moon's rotation and orbit?

And also the conception of a baby if you ever made a baby with a person of the opposite sex, that is not design but at most an appearance of design -- because the design in the world is appearance only.



About what I am leading to, I guess it is now on the shelf unless and until we can get to know what are for you appearances in the world and what are not.





Yrreg
 
I was not thinking of the intelligent design argument, not that I can directly link what I have in mind with the intelligent design argument.

That could be an instance of impasse between you and me, that you are of the conviction that the world shows the appearance of design, while I am of the human certainty that the world has the reality of design.

Egon: There's one important thing I forgot to tell you.
Peter: What?
Egon: Don't cross the logic streams.
Peter: Why?
Egon: It would be bad.
Peter: I'm Fuzzy on this whole good bad thing. What do you mean, "bad?"
Egon: Try to imagine all of rationality as you know it stopping instantaneously and every irony meter in your universe exploding at the speed of light.
Joobz: Total Argument Reversal
Peter: Right. That's bad. Okay. All right. Important safety tip.
 
Well, Joobz, I don't think there is any need to get excited: it is all perfectly clear. The world is designed: just not intelligently. Relax :)
 
Well, Joobz, I don't think there is any need to get excited: it is all perfectly clear. The world is designed: just not intelligently. Relax :)
Same applies to Yrreg's argument.
 
In brief, it is the assertion that since the world shows the appearance of design, there must be a designer, a fallacy in that it skips the premise that the appearance of design necessarily requires a designer.​

That could be an instance of impasse between you and me, that you are of the conviction that the world shows the appearance of design, while I am of the human certainty that the world has the reality of design.
Yes indeed, I believe that is an impasse, because I do not share your certainty and if your certainty is not inferred from the appearance of design, then I don't know what it could be based on other than the authority of holy writ or divine inspiration. You certainly were not present at the creation. I suspect that further discussion is going to turn on your idiosyncratic take on empiricism
Of course if you have some other argument, and agree that the argument from design is no good, you'd do better to present yours on its own merits, rather than getting sidetracked into something neither of us would care to spend time on. ​


I never say that I find the argument from design to be no good.

And I did not bring up the argument from design, you are the one, wherefore you should not say that I am sidetracking into something neither of us would care to spend time on.


Please for the sake of maintaining a neat and tidy discussion, abstain from bringing in a lot of code words like "appearance of design," on which and by which you have already inured a psychological position in your brain and nerves of negation against God.

Yrreg
I'm not even quite sure what that last sentence of yours means, and suggest a vocabulary check. But "appearance of design" is not code, even if it is often used by those who assert that the world has no designer. It simply means that to many people the world shows a kind of order and organization that we associate, rightly or wrongly, with intentional design.
 
Do you mean by appearance of design as opposed to reality of design?

Posted by bruto
In brief, it is the assertion that since the world shows the appearance of design, there must be a designer, a fallacy in that it skips the premise that the appearance of design necessarily requires a designer.

Posted by Yrreg
That could be an instance of impasse between you and me, that you are of the conviction that the world shows the appearance of design, while I am of the human certainty that the world has the reality of design.

​


Yes indeed, I believe that is an impasse, because I do not share your certainty and if your certainty is not inferred from the appearance of design, then I don't know what it could be based on other than the authority of holy writ or divine inspiration. You certainly were not present at the creation. I suspect that further discussion is going to turn on your idiosyncratic take on empiricism I'm not even quite sure what that last sentence of yours means, and suggest a vocabulary check. But "appearance of design" is not code, even if it is often used by those who assert that the world has no designer. It simply means that to many people the world shows a kind of order and organization that we associate, rightly or wrongly, with intentional design.


Do you mean by appearance of design as opposed to reality of design?


Take my example of the moon's rotation and orbit and the production of a baby by you, if you ever produced a baby with a person of the opposite sex, they are two examples from me of the certainty of the reality -- as opposed to appearances -- of design in the world.

For you those two examples are not of the real world but of the world of appearance.


So that there is no reality outside of the appearance in both instances of the moon's motion of rotation and orbit and the event of conception and birth of a human baby?






Yrreg
 
You are merely trading on the ambiguities in the way the word design is used, Yrreg.

Design:

I.
1. A plan or scheme conceived in the mind of something to be done: the preliminary conception of an idea that is to be carried into effect by action: a project.

2. Purpose, aim, intention

3. The thing aimed at

4. Contrivance in accordance with a preconceived plan: adaptation of means to ends; prearranged purpose; as,the argument from d.

5. In a bad sense: Crafty contrivance; and instance of this


II.1
a. A preliminary sketch for a work of art; the plan of a building, or part of it, or of a piece of decorative work, after which the structure or texture is to be completed; a delineation or pattern

b. The combination of details which go to make up a work of art; artistic idea as executed; a piece of decorative work, an artistic device

c. The art of picturesque delineation and construction

II.2

a.To plan, plan out

b.To purpose,intend

c. To have in view

d. To intend to go or start

III.1

a. To sketch

b. To trace the outline of, delineate

c. To make the preliminary sketch of; to make the plans and drawings necessary for the constuction of

III.2

To plan and execute; to fashion with artistic skill or decorative device

III.3

a.To draw, sketch

b. To form or fashion a work of art; less widely, to devise artistic patterns

(OED)

When you and and your wife decide to have a baby you "design" to do so in the first sense outlined above: that is, it is your intention/ purpose/aim to have a child. This use of the word "design" is perfectly respectable but it is a little archaic and is seldom used nowadays. People do not go about saying things like "if milk be thy design; with plenteous hand bring Clover grass"; or "he had no design on your pocket". Nor do they say "it is our design to have a baby". What they actually say is things like " we are trying for a baby"; or "we want to have a baby"; or even " we intend to have a baby"

The word design is now much more commonly used in the other senses. It carries the implication that the designer makes the plan for a particular completed work and that work will look like the plan when it is done. There is no way that prospective parents do anything like that. This use of the word design, applied to the making of babies, is so far from what happens as to be laughable.

The incidence of spontaneous abortion runs at about 16%, I think. Is that what prospective parents "design"? Many are born with disabilities and defects. Is that what they "design"? A lot of prospective parents cannot conceive at all. Where is the "design" in that? Before modern medicine a lot of women died in childbirth: is that part of what prospective parents "design"?.

These questions are easily answered: there would be no amniocentesis tests or moves to invent ways to choose the characteristics of any children born if what we get was a product of parental design at present.

Or is it your contention that some other entity does the designing? If so then why did you bring the prospective parents into it in discussing "design"? And while we are on the subject, why is it this designer is so freaking useless as to produce all the problems outlined above? I would sack an architect if 16% of his buildings fell down.

I do not know if your conflation is because your english is limited or because you deliberately obfuscate. But if we are to proceed you need to separate the different meanings of this word: and then, hopefully say which one you are using and also whether you do or don't believe that the world shows evidence of whichever sense of design you choose to adopt
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom