What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Hmmm – that leaves me feeling nasty and uncharitable. I think I tend to assume that anyone who’ going to launch into a dictionary with that much fervour must have English as their first (or very close second) language. This is, I don’t doubt, the appalling legacy of being edumucated in Thatcher’s Britain. I speak English and Geordie (thanks to my mother), but nothing else to any degree of proficiency. (et le sange et conduit l’autobus)

Let me take a moment to blink in the startling light of day and say a huge hats-off to anyone holding forth in a non-native language – especially in a forum like this one. I apologise for my post-imperialistic presumptions and I’ll try to do better,

Having said that, yrreg, please understand that your grammar and sentence structure are problematic, certainly to me and I’m sure to others, even if Bruto doesn’t find any difficulty. Long and obscure words are all very fine and well – I am a great fan myself – but their use is a hindrance when they effectively obscure your meaning.

That said, I’ll slop off back to the side-lines and think about what I’ve done.

(PS: Drafted in a shifty 5 minutes at work, please excuse anything I’ve missed…)
 
No, bruto, no, I will not leave your penis alone, and not yourself either.

Posted by yrreg
Just tell me what you mean by appearance of design.


Is your penis an appearance of design or a reality of design?

​

The syntax of that sentence defies a direct answer. My penis IS a bodily organ. The properties that it might exhibit (best left unspecified) are not necessarily what it IS. The reality of a tree is the tree itself. It is not woodiness, brownness, etc.; although it may exhibit various properties, it is not, by itself, any one of those properties by itself. Design is a process by which some things become what they are. If one were ignorant, either wilfully or accidentally, of evolution, an observer might see in a penis, as in many other things, the appearance of design - that is, it would appear to the observer to have characteristics that suggest that it was intentionally designed. If the concept of a designing deity is correct and that of natural selection is not, that appearance would correspond to the reality of its having been designed. If it is not, the appearance of design will not correspond to the reality of its evolution. But the object in question is what it is, not its appearance and not our interpretation of its appearance.

I don't know how else to put it. I do know that I would never have thought to put my penis into this conversation, and if you don't mind, I would prefer to withdraw it.


I don't know how else to put it. I do know that I would never have thought to put my penis into this conversation, and if you don't mind, I would prefer to withdraw it. -- bruto​

No, bruto, no, I will not leave your penis alone, much less yourself, and you can refer to my penis also.

And if any woman atheist is around, then I am also referring to your vagina which such thing I have seen and touched and examined, and know it is a reality of design, and not an appearance of design as to be useless except for looking at.

[ Thanks to moderators here and to the usual squealing posters here about my ad hominem vocabulary, that you have not squealed so far about my use of the word penis and my reference to the reality of penis in bruto, which penis of bruto is not appearance but all reality, and which he certainly makes good use of to urinate and to copulate, and not only to engage in an appearance of urination and copulation. ]​



Addressing bruto:

You have not answered my question:

Just tell me what you mean by appearance of design. ​

What you are trying to do is to parade a lot of pseudo and pretentious and murky learning: you are engaged in evasion pure and simple or muddling up the water, and hoping to convince people you have a point; but no, nothing, except the appearance of pseudo learning to people who do not possess the skill of critical reading and examination, or critical thinking.


Okay, be simple and candid and brief:

If you genuinely know what is the meaning of your phrase, “appearance of design,” for example, “appearance of the design of your penis,” as opposed to the reality of the design of your penis, just tell me in not more than ten words what is the meaning of appearance of design as distinct and opposed to the reality of design.

That will establish you to be a person of learning, genuine and solid, instead of parading pseudo learning without anything of substance but for the appearance.



Addressing all posters here, if you know what bruto means by appearance of design, just tell me what in not more than ten words.


I can do it in just three words what he means by appearance of design.

He instead keeps going around and around, without ever speaking clearly and definitively, hoping to intimidate by disgorging a lot of pompously sounding deep but mirage words.


Here, do it this way:

By appearance of design bruto means (start counting your words here): 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 [ or less ].​



As a matter of fact, I need only one word to tell people what he means by appearance of design, and if he does not agree with me that is what he means, then he does not know what he is talking about: not what is appearance and not what is design.



I am getting to know more and more what atheist bigots have inside their brain for what I call first operating premises of pseudo thinking, and one of them is "appearance of design."


That is why for bruto his penis is an appearance of penis.

And that is not attacking bruto but his argument, erh, thinking, erh, pseudo thinking.


For people who want to insist on appearance of design when everyone knows what is design and it is not appearance, there is no other way to hopefully -- if they be still of workable brain -- than to refer to their penis or vagina, and ask them if these are realities of design or appearances of design.





Yrreg

PS

Thank you Terry.

A big thank-you to Terry for all the work he does behind the scenes to keep this Forum running and for the Forum's smoothest ever server migration!

Now, if you can just tell me why I can't just highlight a line of text in my edit box and click on a formatting feature like B I and U and presto it is done, whereas now I have to spell out the code word before and after the line.

And tell me, more important, how to restore that feature when I am engaged in writing in this forum of JREF website.​
 
I don't know how else to put it. I do know that I would never have thought to put my penis into this conversation, and if you don't mind, I would prefer to withdraw it. -- bruto​

No, bruto, no, I will not leave your penis alone, much less yourself, and you can refer to my penis also.

And if any woman atheist is around, then I am also referring to your vagina which such thing I have seen and touched and examined, and know it is a reality of design, and not an appearance of design as to be useless except for looking at.

[ Thanks to moderators here and to the usual squealing posters here about my ad hominem vocabulary, that you have not squealed so far about my use of the word penis and my reference to the reality of penis in bruto, which penis of bruto is not appearance but all reality, and which he certainly makes good use of to urinate and to copulate, and not only to engage in an appearance of urination and copulation. ]​



Addressing bruto:

You have not answered my question:

Just tell me what you mean by appearance of design. ​

What you are trying to do is to parade a lot of pseudo and pretentious and murky learning: you are engaged in evasion pure and simple or muddling up the water, and hoping to convince people you have a point; but no, nothing, except the appearance of pseudo learning to people who do not possess the skill of critical reading and examination, or critical thinking.


Okay, be simple and candid and brief:

If you genuinely know what is the meaning of your phrase, “appearance of design,” for example, “appearance of the design of your penis,” as opposed to the reality of the design of your penis, just tell me in not more than ten words what is the meaning of appearance of design as distinct and opposed to the reality of design.

That will establish you to be a person of learning, genuine and solid, instead of parading pseudo learning without anything of substance but for the appearance.



Addressing all posters here, if you know what bruto means by appearance of design, just tell me what in not more than ten words.


I can do it in just three words what he means by appearance of design.

He instead keeps going around and around, without ever speaking clearly and definitively, hoping to intimidate by disgorging a lot of pompously sounding deep but mirage words.


Here, do it this way:

By appearance of design bruto means (start counting your words here): 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 [ or less ].​



As a matter of fact, I need only one word to tell people what he means by appearance of design, and if he does not agree with me that is what he means, then he does not know what he is talking about: not what is appearance and not what is design.



I am getting to know more and more what atheist bigots have inside their brain for what I call first operating premises of pseudo thinking, and one of them is "appearance of design."


That is why for bruto his penis is an appearance of penis.

And that is not attacking bruto but his argument, erh, thinking, erh, pseudo thinking.


For people who want to insist on appearance of design when everyone knows what is design and it is not appearance, there is no other way to hopefully -- if they be still of workable brain -- than to refer to their penis or vagina, and ask them if these are realities of design or appearances of design.





Yrreg

PS

Thank you Terry.

A big thank-you to Terry for all the work he does behind the scenes to keep this Forum running and for the Forum's smoothest ever server migration!

Now, if you can just tell me why I can't just highlight a line of text in my edit box and click on a formatting feature like B I and U and presto it is done, whereas now I have to spell out the code word before and after the line.

And tell me, more important, how to restore that feature when I am engaged in writing in this forum of JREF website.​

This is the appearance of an argument.
 
I don't know how else to put it. I do know that I would never have thought to put my penis into this conversation, and if you don't mind, I would prefer to withdraw it. -- bruto​

No, bruto, no, I will not leave your penis alone, much less yourself, and you can refer to my penis also.

And if any woman atheist is around, then I am also referring to your vagina which such thing I have seen and touched and examined, and know it is a reality of design, and not an appearance of design as to be useless except for looking at.

[ Thanks to moderators here and to the usual squealing posters here about my ad hominem vocabulary, that you have not squealed so far about my use of the word penis and my reference to the reality of penis in bruto, which penis of bruto is not appearance but all reality, and which he certainly makes good use of to urinate and to copulate, and not only to engage in an appearance of urination and copulation. ]​



Addressing bruto:

You have not answered my question:

Just tell me what you mean by appearance of design. ​

What you are trying to do is to parade a lot of pseudo and pretentious and murky learning: you are engaged in evasion pure and simple or muddling up the water, and hoping to convince people you have a point; but no, nothing, except the appearance of pseudo learning to people who do not possess the skill of critical reading and examination, or critical thinking.


Okay, be simple and candid and brief:

If you genuinely know what is the meaning of your phrase, “appearance of design,” for example, “appearance of the design of your penis,” as opposed to the reality of the design of your penis, just tell me in not more than ten words what is the meaning of appearance of design as distinct and opposed to the reality of design.

That will establish you to be a person of learning, genuine and solid, instead of parading pseudo learning without anything of substance but for the appearance.



Addressing all posters here, if you know what bruto means by appearance of design, just tell me what in not more than ten words.


I can do it in just three words what he means by appearance of design.

He instead keeps going around and around, without ever speaking clearly and definitively, hoping to intimidate by disgorging a lot of pompously sounding deep but mirage words.


Here, do it this way:

By appearance of design bruto means (start counting your words here): 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 [ or less ].​



As a matter of fact, I need only one word to tell people what he means by appearance of design, and if he does not agree with me that is what he means, then he does not know what he is talking about: not what is appearance and not what is design.



I am getting to know more and more what atheist bigots have inside their brain for what I call first operating premises of pseudo thinking, and one of them is "appearance of design."


That is why for bruto his penis is an appearance of penis.

And that is not attacking bruto but his argument, erh, thinking, erh, pseudo thinking.


For people who want to insist on appearance of design when everyone knows what is design and it is not appearance, there is no other way to hopefully -- if they be still of workable brain -- than to refer to their penis or vagina, and ask them if these are realities of design or appearances of design.





Yrreg

PS

Thank you Terry.

A big thank-you to Terry for all the work he does behind the scenes to keep this Forum running and for the Forum's smoothest ever server migration!

Now, if you can just tell me why I can't just highlight a line of text in my edit box and click on a formatting feature like B I and U and presto it is done, whereas now I have to spell out the code word before and after the line.

And tell me, more important, how to restore that feature when I am engaged in writing in this forum of JREF website.​

I have explained what I mean by the appearance of design, and if you do not understand it, I'm afraid I cannot think of any better way to do so. Everything that exists that we can perceive has peceptible characteristics (an appearance), and we interpret what we perceive according to our experience, our intelligence and our expectations.

Your continual conflation of appearance with substance baffles me. When I say that something has a certain appearance, this does not mean that the thing is simply the appearance.

Separate note with regard to formatting: Are you using Firefox? I had a similar problem a while back after one of the database upgrades. I don't know whether it was a cookie or cache problem or what, but I went back to the editing preferences and turned off the advanced features. The basic formatting features then began working as they should, and when I returned to the advanced features, all the formatting features remained correct, and the problem has not recurred. It might help to erase the cookies. If you have Firefox (or any of a number of cookie management programs) you can go into the tools menu and deal with cookies individually, so if you have many sites with remembered passwords and preferences you don't have to clobber the whole lot of them.
 
No, bruto, no, I will not leave your penis alone, much less yourself, and you can refer to my penis also.

This would worry me.

[ Thanks to moderators here and to the usual squealing posters here about my ad hominem vocabulary, that you have not squealed so far about my use of the word penis

There is nothing wrong with the word penis as far as the forum goes. Your obsession with it is another matter. Refering to others here as "the usual squealing posters" is an ad hom.

Addressing all posters here, if you know what bruto means by appearance of design, just tell me what in not more than ten words.

You used 990 words.

I can do it in just three words what he means by appearance of design.

I look forward to your three word posts in the future. Won't you think of the bandwidth?

He instead keeps going around and around, without ever speaking clearly and definitively, hoping to intimidate by disgorging a lot of pompously sounding deep but mirage words.

Ok, you have to be joking here. You have described yourself to a 'T'.

I am getting to know more and more what atheist bigots

Ad hom

have inside their brain for what I call first operating premises of pseudo thinking

Ad hom

And that is not attacking bruto but his argument, erh, thinking, erh, pseudo thinking.

Ad hom
 
What you are trying to do is to parade a lot of pseudo and pretentious and murky learning: you are engaged in evasion pure and simple or muddling up the water, and hoping to convince people you have a point; but no, nothing, except the appearance of pseudo learning to people who do not possess the skill of critical reading and examination, or critical thinking.


Okay, be simple and candid and brief:

...

He instead keeps going around and around, without ever speaking clearly and definitively, hoping to intimidate by disgorging a lot of pompously sounding deep but mirage words.


:id:

Oh well, there goes another one.
 
Addressing all posters here, if you know what bruto means by appearance of design, just tell me what in not more than ten words.

It the apparition in your brain of resemblance of design.
 
No, bruto, no, I will not leave your penis alone, much less yourself, and you can refer to my penis also.

And if any woman atheist is around, then I am also referring to your vagina which such thing I have seen and touched and examined, and know it is a reality of design, and not an appearance of design as to be useless except for looking at.

[ Thanks to moderators here and to the usual squealing posters here about my ad hominem vocabulary, that you have not squealed so far about my use of the word penis and my reference to the reality of penis in bruto, which penis of bruto is not appearance but all reality, and which he certainly makes good use of to urinate and to copulate, and not only to engage in an appearance of urination and copulation. ]​

This has the appearance of a touched nerve and subsequent rant.
 
Addressing all posters here, if you know what bruto means by appearance of design, just tell me what in not more than ten words.

How about eight words?

2282161686_fb5b82559c.jpg
 
God told you to stop tergiversating and wasting bandwidth?

I think I mean more like listening intently for a response, and only getting static.

Then I think it's probably the bloody excitement pounding in my ears.
 
You mean that there is nothing certain about designs at all?

I have explained what I mean by the appearance of design, and if you do not understand it, I'm afraid I cannot think of any better way to do so. Everything that exists that we can perceive has peceptible characteristics (an appearance), and we interpret what we perceive according to our experience, our intelligence and our expectations.

Your continual conflation of appearance with substance baffles me. When I say that something has a certain appearance, this does not mean that the thing is simply the appearance.

Separate note with regard to formatting: Are you using Firefox? I had a similar problem a while back after one of the database upgrades. I don't know whether it was a cookie or cache problem or what, but I went back to the editing preferences and turned off the advanced features. The basic formatting features then began working as they should, and when I returned to the advanced features, all the formatting features remained correct, and the problem has not recurred. It might help to erase the cookies. If you have Firefox (or any of a number of cookie management programs) you can go into the tools menu and deal with cookies individually, so if you have many sites with remembered passwords and preferences you don't have to clobber the whole lot of them.

========= end of quote =========


Your continual conflation of appearance with substance baffles me. When I say that something has a certain appearance, this does not mean that the thing is simply the appearance. -- bruto​

In the case of your penis and my penis, do we have to check all the time whether there is only the appearance of the design of penis or there is genuinely the reality of the design of penis as everyone knows to be penis?

You mean that there is nothing certain about designs at all?

And do we thus according to your concern maintain there is no reality that is reliable in the world of man and in man's knowledge and conduct of life except appearances, which at most can only lead the brain to the corresponding realities, but which realities whether they be and which and what they are can never be resolved for the kind of certainty, which is sufficient for our knowledge of the world of realities and for the conduct of life?

Why do you have to enslave, yes, enslave, your brain to that kind of a brainframe?

What kind of allegiance are you paying to what entity or perverse standard of knowledge and certainty?


Just so that you don't have to consider at all the evidence that is all around us for the existence of God as maker of everything in the last analysis and at the end of the day?


Your brainframe is understandable only in the posit of a brain satan holding you in thralldom.


And you know why your kind of a satanic [ pardon the mythology* there but you cannot understand otherwise ] brainframe is altogether no less self-eviscerating, therefore of no worth whatsoever.


Even mathematicians tell us that there are ultimate premises taken for granted by all mathematicians if they would do mathematics and get something done seriously.





Yrreg


*Satan according to the ancients of wisdom is the enemy of mankind and the father of lies.
 
I want yrreg to get DOC, Radrook, Malerin, Beth, plumjam, Stone Island, and some of the other Christians and religious folks to come in here and agree with his definition of his god. Then I'd say he's onto something. But without the support of other Christians, he's done nothing with this thread but show he is an utter failure, incapable of supporting his position. Although I must say there's one thing he hasn't failed at. He has met my expectations perfectly.
 
Your brainframe is understandable only in the posit of a brain satan holding you in thralldom.
And you know why your kind of a satanic [ pardon the mythology* there but you cannot understand otherwise ] brainframe is altogether no less self-eviscerating, therefore of no worth whatsoever.
Even mathematicians tell us that there are ultimate premises taken for granted by all mathematicians if they would do mathematics and get something done seriously.
Yrreg


*Satan according to the ancients of wisdom is the enemy of mankind and the father of lies.

But we're not angry with each other?
 
Yrreg, it seemed for a few posts as if we had begun to communicate in some degree, but that last post of yours, which I will not bother to quote, has descended back into the incoherence and insult I had hoped to avoid. I really have no answer for it. You appear utterly incapable of understanding what I thought were fairly simple and reasonable concepts, and in addition incapable of maintaining a civil exchange of ideas without distortion and mis-characterization. I realize it was a vain and futile hope that you might finally have become interested in either understanding the point of view of others or in clarifying your own, but if I decide to go on with this it will be some other time. I have better things to do tonight. Good luck.
 
I think what we may have here is just a little boy who has just found out that he can say "penis" as much as he wants to.

It'll get boring for him after a while if we just ignore him.
 
Why do you have to enslave, yes, enslave, your brain to that kind of a brainframe?

What makes you so certain of enslavement? What do you possess in your brainframe that can verify bruto is limited with his evaluations?

What kind of allegiance are you paying to what entity or perverse standard of knowledge and certainty?

Why do you imply bruto's arguments to be suspected as an allegiance to a perverse standard of knowledge and certainty? Who claims them to be perverse? Why are they perverse?
 
My regrets if you take offense, but we have to see whether we can concur.

Yrreg, it seemed for a few posts as if we had begun to communicate in some degree, but that last post of yours, which I will not bother to quote, has descended back into the incoherence and insult I had hoped to avoid. I really have no answer for it. You appear utterly incapable of understanding what I thought were fairly simple and reasonable concepts, and in addition incapable of maintaining a civil exchange of ideas without distortion and mis-characterization. I realize it was a vain and futile hope that you might finally have become interested in either understanding the point of view of others or in clarifying your own, but if I decide to go on with this it will be some other time. I have better things to do tonight. Good luck.


My regrets if you take offense, but we have to see whether we can concur.


Tell me, is there design in the penis or just the appearance of design?


You say:

[...]

Your continual conflation of appearance with substance baffles me. When I say that something has a certain appearance, this does not mean that the thing is simply the appearance.

[...]


Do you mean with these words:

When I say that something has a certain appearance, this does not mean that the thing is simply the appearance. ​

That when you say "appearance of design" and I bring up the penis as a design, you don't mean that the penis is simply an appearance of design?


In which case, you really don't have to use the phrase appearance of design, unless you really mean by appearance mirage.




Simply use the phrase "no design" in every instance where you feel that it is just an "appearance of design"; because if you don't mean by "appearance of design" that the design is not simply an appearance, why bother appending design with the qualifier "appearance of"?


Take the injunction of Occam to heart, in this case be thrifty with words, just say design.





Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom