Posted by yrreg
If you want me to react to you, just pm me, I am dealing now with bruto.
Now, bruto, you agree with me that the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything is possible in your brain.
Suppose we now go forth and search for this God.
Is that a sensible adventure.
And please don't bring in creator, not now, just keep to my concept of God as worded, scil., the maker of heaven and earth and everything.
That is the trouble with atheists, they keep bringing in things which they need not, but should keep to the terms of the thesis or proposition or the concept as stated:
God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.
I am not sure why you should balk at the word "creator" as a substitute for "maker," but have it your way if it makes you comfortable.
Is searching for such a god a sensible adventure? Yes, I think it is, but with a couple of qualifications.
First of all, if the search is going to be based only on the properties in your definition - that is, on the presumption that what we are looking for is the maker of heaven and earth and everything, then it would see we must start at searching for the answer to the question of whether there is any evidence that "heaven, earth and everything," what most of us are wont to call the universe, can properly be considered to have been "made" by some agency that can be identified.
Second, whether or not the adventure is sensible
at this moment depends rather a lot on whether it has already been undertaken.
As it happens, I
spend spent a good bit of time and energy in my youth trying to connect with that concept of yours, and the adventure ended with no such connection. I'm older now, and other adventures interest me far more.
Therefore, I suggest that if you are in a mood to undertake the adventure, go right ahead. Report your success if you have any, present your evidence, and make your case. But I am no longer in the mood to chase after God.