What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

No, I am not hiding anything of The Apostles' Creed, not even that part about father almighty.


What I am doing is to bring your attention to the quintessence of God as far as we humans can know of Him with our reason and intelligence.


The rest is a matter of faith, on the script of men claiming to be commissioned by God to teach about God.




You see, first I want to see if you can at least see the possibility of the concept of God as maker of heaven and earth and everything.


Then for people here although atheists who can still with their brain harbor the possibility of the concept of God as maker of heaven and earth and everything, I will invite them to join me in the search of anything which can satisfy that description of God.


What's in it for me?


It is fun, and I hope will be fun for you also.


And of course intellectually rewarding.


About God being psychologically comforting for people who take Him for a father, I confess I do that myself; but remember that is a script I take the presumption to make up for God, on the ground that I know Him from reason and intelligence to be maker of heaven and earth and everything.


Do you feel that for yourself it demeans you? That is your privilege founded upon your free thought and free choice.





Yrreg

Bold = the part I still have a problem with. This is not an issue of ability to hold a concept, or of understanding.

In my case, this comes back, as it has all along, to a fundamental disagreement with regard to what you consider to be "knowing" as opposed to faith.

I doubt we will ever agree on this, but as far as I am concerned, all the properties of God, whether or not they are included in your definition, are matters of faith and reason, not of experience, and separating out that one part of the definition as a special exception to this starts you down the wrong path once again.

By the way, I will add that the last couple of responses I have had from you have been much more to the point, as well as polite, and however much we may never meet on opinion, I appreciate the effort.
 
Yes, and tomorrow, we're going to teach you to use the big boy's potty.
Not to derail, but last night my 2 year old son attempted to use the potty for the first time. It was so cute that it was hard not laughing, but I didn't want to give him some sort of complex. He wanted to use the urinal thing we got him, but he had already peed in his diaper. So he ended up basically humping the contraption.
 
First time I had to use it, my dad sat next to me reading me my favourite comic.

I reckon the experience screwed us both up for decades.
 
No, I am not hiding anything of The Apostles' Creed, not even that part about father almighty.


What I am doing is to bring your attention to the quintessence of God as far as we humans can know of Him with our reason and intelligence.

What preponderance of evidence are you going to present that persuades your belief in God?
 
From the point of view of most adherents of the religions professing the Apostle's Creed, applying "maker of heaven and earth" as the definition of God (as opposed to just one line item on His resume) is inadequate to the point of sacrilege.

Most protestant religious practices, for example, are primarily concerned with achieving salvation through God's grace. As far as the doctrines of salvation are concerned, who created heaven and earth is hardly relevant at all. Had God not created the world but instead acquired dominion over it by defeating the great Uullm, the true creator of heaven and earth, in a Baby Back Ribs Battle in Kitchen Stadium, the practical import would be negligible. Two chapters out of 1,189 in the King James Bible would be different, and the phrase "the defeater of Uullm" would be swapped for "the maker of heaven and earth" in the Apostle's Creed. The parts of Christianity regarding how God wants people to behave would not be affected at all.

By focusing on God's role as creator of heaven and earth, are you rejecting those other doctrines (saints, the virgin birth, judgment, salvation, Christ, etc.) or are you just disregarding them? If you're rejecting them, then you are indeed getting into the realm of deism. On the other hand if you believe in them, why define God in such a way as to disregard them?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Sounds Fine.

Ok.
To me, God is a dog seen in a mirror.
Perhaps we should provide evidence for our differing definitions? You start.

It's important to remember that the modern domesticated God as we know it was descended from its wild ancestor Flow.
 
The distinction between knowing and believing.

Posted by yrreg
No, I am not hiding anything of The Apostles' Creed, not even that part about father almighty.


What I am doing is to bring your attention to the quintessence of God as far as we humans can know of Him with our reason and intelligence.


The rest is a matter of faith, on the script of men claiming to be commissioned by God to teach about God.




You see, first I want to see if you can at least see the possibility of the concept of God as maker of heaven and earth and everything.


Then for people here although atheists who can still with their brain harbor the possibility of the concept of God as maker of heaven and earth and everything, I will invite them to join me in the search of anything which can satisfy that description of God.


What's in it for me?


It is fun, and I hope will be fun for you also.


And of course intellectually rewarding.


About God being psychologically comforting for people who take Him for a father, I confess I do that myself; but remember that is a script I take the presumption to make up for God, on the ground that I know Him from reason and intelligence to be maker of heaven and earth and everything.


Do you feel that for yourself it demeans you? That is your privilege founded upon your free thought and free choice.

​

Bold = the part I still have a problem with. This is not an issue of ability to hold a concept, or of understanding.

In my case, this comes back, as it has all along, to a fundamental disagreement with regard to what you consider to be "knowing" as opposed to faith.

I doubt we will ever agree on this, but as far as I am concerned, all the properties of God, whether or not they are included in your definition, are matters of faith and reason, not of experience, and separating out that one part of the definition as a special exception to this starts you down the wrong path once again.

By the way, I will add that the last couple of responses I have had from you have been much more to the point, as well as polite, and however much we may never meet on opinion, I appreciate the effort.


Before anything else, bruto, you do agree with me that the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything is a possible concept in the brain of man.


This possibility of the concept is a matter of knowing.

Do you also accept that statement immediately preceding above?



So that our exchange will be neat and tidy, suppose you just tell me what you see to be from my post referred to by you, one thing that is from me a matter of knowing and one thing just one thing that is from me a matter of believing.


Just one thing each, then we can exchange thoughts further on what is knowing and what is believing, and hope to not be bogged down into definitions.





Yrreg
 
It's important to remember that the modern domesticated God as we know it was descended from its wild ancestor Flow.
Is the wild Flow a relative of the modern-day Flew? I hear that this God fellow was last spotted somewhere in the vicinity of his brain.

Just one thing each, then we can exchange thoughts further on what is knowing and what is believing, and hope to not be bogged down into definitions.
Yrreg
But...but...getting bogged down in definitions is the hallmark of every yrreg thread! I thought this one was actually beginning to get somewhere. Oh well.
 
Sorry, yrreg but you're replying selectively and actively ignoring important questions addressed to you

Here's my definition of yrreg:

A troll


*End of transmission*
 
Before anything else, bruto, you do agree with me that the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything is a possible concept in the brain of man.
That seems reasonable even if we can carp about the way it is phrased. We can have a concept of a creator. The concept may or may not be clear, coherent, correct or rational, but we can have it. As it stands now, since there is nothing other than the act of creation itself as an attribute, the concept is pretty basic, and could even be considered second-hand, in that the meat of the concept is really that the universe is created, and from it we derive the concept that something did it. Nonetheless, it's a concept, and yes, you can have it in your brain. It's all yours!
This possibility of the concept is a matter of knowing.
If you mean we can know that the concept is possible, yes. If you mean that we can know that we have the concept ourselves, yes. Beyond that, if the referenced sentence has any other meaning, I do not see what it could be. What is not a matter of knowing is the subject of the concept. I can have a concept of something that is not true. I can even have a concept of something that is practically or logically impossible. To experience the thought is not to experience the thing thought of.
Do you also accept that statement immediately preceding above?
as qualified above....
So that our exchange will be neat and tidy, suppose you just tell me what you see to be from my post referred to by you, one thing that is from me a matter of knowing and one thing just one thing that is from me a matter of believing.
If I am getting this right (your sentence structure is a bit odd), I would say it this way. We both know you have a concept of a creator, which you call "God," and that this concept is in general agreement with what other people mean when they use the term "God." You believe that such a god exists, and you believe that you know it, but you have yet to convince anyone that you know it, or to provide a convincing argument for how you come to believe that you know it.

I hope that is clear enough, and addresses what you mean.
Just one thing each, then we can exchange thoughts further on what is knowing and what is believing, and hope to not be bogged down into definitions.
Yrreg
Indeed, I think this, and not the issue of definitions, is where we will find a disagreement that may prove unbridgeable, but let's see what happens.
 
Just pm me if you really want me to react to your thoughts, okay?

Otherwise, don't waste the time of readers and the forum's bandwidth.

No offense intended, just speaking out my brain's honest and direct thoughts.

So why are you bothering with this thread if you just want to exchange private emails?
 
I can agree with your concept of God Yrreg, except the maker of everything. I haven't seen that claim made by anyone except those like you who believe in this God.

The existence of God can't really be tested, but the belief in God can be. So Yrreg, can you provide evidence that persuades you to believe in your God?
 
That's not being exact and specific; please be exact and specific.



That is why I am very exasperated in exchange of ideas with you guys, you tend to tergiversate and/or prevaricate and even calumniate, instead of being exact and specific in reacting to the issue.





Yrreg


"everything" is simply wrong.

For a start, my thoughts exist - IT didn't make them.

Also, IT can't actually make anything. If IT is already 'the' everything [which faithers seem to believe] then how can IT make 'anything' else! That would be more than the 'everything' IT was! WHICH means IT wasn't everything to begin with.

So your use of the term 'everything' is wrong!:jaw-dropp
 
Playing devil's advocate here for a minute, I think the "everything" that Yrreg is referring to is the Universe. That's a pretty useful definition, since we cannot measure anything outside the Universe, and indeed, it defines the limits of our knowledge.

Of course, the maker of the Universe is the Big Bang, which I suspect isn't what Yrreg means, but there you go, vive la difference and all that.
 
Man is the measure of everything even God, wherefore man defines God.

Of course, now that we are so concerned about whether He does exist or not, then we start with the concept itself of God in our brain.

Here is my concept of God in my brain:
The maker of heaven and and earth and everything.
​
And here is my idea of what a definition is good or useful for to man, as understood by man, who is himself the measuring entity of everything that is of concern to man.

I was ok with this so far.


This bit...

At this point of the thread I like to invite people to concentrate on the word God as at least referring to a possible entity inside the brain of humans at least some, which word God refers to the concept again in the brain of at least some people connoting:
The maker of heaven and earth and everything.
​

..started me scratching my head.

This part...

If you have trouble with everything, it means everything that man knows now and can know in the future and also they thought they knew in the past but now know better.

...I kind of understood, but didn't know where he was going with it.

Then this...

So if you are a man or a woman or anything in between provided still human with a genetically human brain,* everything means everything you know now or in the future.

..made me smile.

This...

Some people know more things than others of course, but everyone knows everything he does know.

made me laugh.

However, this...

If you are again and still having trouble with knowing everything, then just pretend that you don't know something of the everything that you know, then that should still be all right in regard to the everything that you now know, whereas you actually know one more than everything you now know with the pretended ignorance of one thing of the everything you know without pretending to not know the one thing you do know without the said pretension*.

...made me get up and walk away from the computer because I couldn't breathe I was laughing too hard and oh god it hurts what the hell is he talking about I can't stop laughing...must...breathe...ok..better...calming down...calming down...back to the computer...breathe...calm....

Please, for the love of viable communication,

Nope. Lost it again.
 
If you are again and still having trouble with knowing everything, then just pretend that you don't know something of the everything that you know, then that should still be all right in regard to the everything that you now know, whereas you actually know one more than everything you now know with the pretended ignorance of one thing of the everything you know without pretending to not know the one thing you do know without the said pretension.

...made me get up and walk away from the computer because I couldn't breathe I was laughing too hard and oh god it hurts what the hell is he talking about I can't stop laughing...must...breathe...ok..better...calming down...calming down...back to the computer...breathe...calm....

Yrreg must have channeled into Donald Rumsfeld's brain to come up with that word salad.

Here is Rumfeld's; The Unknown

As we know,There are known knowns. There are things we know we know. We also know
There are known unknowns.
That is to say We know there are some things We do not know.
But there are also unknown unknowns, The ones we don't know We don't know.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
If you want me to react to you, just pm me, I am dealing now with bruto.

If you want me to react to you, just pm me, I am dealing now with bruto.​


Now, bruto, you agree with me that the concept of God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything is possible in your brain.


Suppose we now go forth and search for this God.



Is that a sensible adventure.



And please don't bring in creator, not now, just keep to my concept of God as worded, scil., the maker of heaven and earth and everything.



That is the trouble with atheists, they keep bringing in things which they need not, but should keep to the terms of the thesis or proposition or the concept as stated:


God as the maker of heaven and earth and everything.​





Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom