Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

The thing is that Arab societies aren't like Western societies. The entire apparatus of state in Egypt is a jobs network for loyal Mubarak supporters. From top positions in government ministries and the army right down to schoolteachers, positions aren't earned on merit and experience like they are in Western countries, they are rewards given in return for loyalty. There's a trickle-down effect of the corruption money. Corrupt officials are expected to share the wealth around and keep people happy. This leads to a huge patronage apparatus staffed by people who don't really know what they're doing, and don't care as long as they get their paycheck and a little grease now and then. The system tolerates corruption and incompetence because everyone else is in on it. Regime change would have to include hundreds of thousands of state employees, who are all tied to Mubarak through a network of grease, favors and family connections.

Largely correct, with the addition that western (American) money is at the top of the financial trickle-down pyramid. I think Egypt crossed the Rubicon. It is certainly possible that this uprising will calm down for the moment and that the people will go back to work, whatever that may mean in Egypt. But there is no way that the old sitution will be restored indefinitely. The current regime relies on American financial support and will vanish if the subsidies will be halted, as they will with the increased financial difficulties of the US. The next uprising will not be peaceful anymore. Egypt has only one grass roots institution for the survival of the poorest, that's the Muslim Brotherhood. They will be the really big winners if the current powers that be will refuse to share power now. But they will not share power. That means they will be removed from power the hard way in the not too distant future, meaning that Egypt will be lost for the West.
 
Last edited:
Already, there are dark reports of demonstrators who dared to return home and disappeared. The Egyptian writer Mohamed Fadel Fahmy, who is involved in the committee discussions, is fearful for himself. "We're safe as long as we have the square," he said to me yesterday, urging me to publish his name as a symbol of the freedom he demands. "If we lose the square, Mubarak will arrest all the opposition groups – and there will be police rule as never before. That's why we are fighting for our lives."

The state security police now have long lists of names of protesters who have given television interviews or been quoted in newspapers, Facebook postings and tweets.

The protesters have identified growing divisions between the Egyptian army and the thugs of the interior ministry, whose guards exchanged fire with soldiers three days ago as they continued to occupy the building in which basement torture chambers remain undamaged by the street fighting. These were the same rooms of horror to which America's "renditioned" prisoners were sent for "special" treatment at the hands of Mubarak's more sadistic torturers – another favour which bound the Egyptian regime to the United States as a "trusted" ally.


'Robert Fisk: Exhausted, scared and trapped, protesters put forward plan for future'
 
That's nonsense. Syria and Iran don't get subsidies and they haven't vanished.

I was talking about vanishing American friendly governments, not about countries as such.
These 2 governments you mention are not very American government friendly.

I leave it to you as an exercise to figure out why that might be.
 
Mubarak has one and a half million at his disposal.



Easy, tiger.

Has it actually been established that this explosion at a gas-metering station was caused by sabotage?

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/263894d4e8c8456ab1.jpg[/qimg]

'EMG's Egypt-Israel gas pipeline intact - Ampal'

Even if there was some sort of "leak" gas lines don't just explode for no reason. I have worked in the oil field for many years and we have fixed leaks before.

They just don't explode.

Shoot we have even had to bleed off gasy wells next to major roads before sending gas clouds over the highway. Cars pass through them and their RPMs jump a bit (you can hear it) but even then there was no explosion.

got any evidence of terrorist activity?

thought not. just blaim the evil MOOOOOOOZLIMS.

:)


Who else was it Coptic Christians? Catholics? Hindous? Budhists? Or some of the rioters who are Muslim Brotherhood sympathizers who despise Israel?

I am not blaming all Muslims like you try to make it seem like. I have friends and have worked for some really nice and good Muslim people before.

It is the radicals and trust me there are plenty over there.

Who are the ones that practice female genitalia mutilation in Egypt? Tell me who you think it is? I guarantee it is the radicals.


You know, I find something odd here when I read the things written by some fundamentalist Christians regarding these events, especially those who see all of this as some harbinger of the End Times. On the one hand, they wring their hands in near agony about how all of these horrible things are coming to pass (the End Times are coming! :jaw-dropp), yet wouldn't one expect them to actually be happy because their Savior is supposedly returning to bring them all to Heaven?

Who is saying anything about end times? Are all of our watches going to stop working or something?

The Earth is going to go on for ever and ever.

I find it something odd how only 10yrs after 911 people forget what happened and who was responsible for creating the entities and ideology that was responsible for it.

It's like you all have ADD or something.
 
I find it something odd how only 10yrs after 911 people forget what happened and who was responsible for creating the entities and ideology that was responsible for it.

It's like you all have ADD or something.

I didn't. Conservatives just celebrated the 100th anniversary of his birth.
 
He only enabled them and financed the cause.
Not the Arabs.

Anyway, it was Jimmy Carter who started aiding the mujahedeen, a year and a half before Reagan took office. So do you blame Carter for 9/11? He's still alive you know, you can write him an angry letter!
 
Not the Arabs.

Anyway, it was Jimmy Carter who started aiding the mujahedeen, a year and a half before Reagan took office. So do you blame Carter for 9/11? He's still alive you know, you can write him an angry letter!

There you go. Both of them are responsible. However
Under Reagan, U.S. support for the mujahideen evolved into an official U.S. foreign policy, known as the Reagan Doctrine, which included U.S. support for anti-Soviet movements in Afghanistan, Angola, Nicaragua, and elsewhere.[16] Ronald Reagan praised mujahideen as "freedom fighters".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mujahideen
 
Last edited:
Mubarak is a general. And I think he will take a very strategic perspective on this.

He knows that once the initial euphoria is gone, the mood will change.

In three weeks time there will be fewer protesters, and they will be exhausted and hungry. food prices have risen ten-fold already. The economy is on it's butt.

He will take his sweet time negotiating with the opposition until he has enough leverage to influence the outcome.

That outcome will probably include concessions to his friends and the assurance that he, his family and his seventy billion dollars will be large left alone after the transition.

Hungry people are getting hungrier. The 'cavalry charge' about a week ago of camels and horses was apparently tourist operators. They are losing a lot of money. The crowds are getting smaller, and Mubarak appears to be doing everything to give the appearance he is losing his grip, while doing all he can to hold on. The army isn't helping him, but they haven't overthrown him, either. If they had wanted to, he would have been gone in the first few days. Journalists are still being harassed, as if Mubarak is trying to make sure than when the crackdown comes, it won't look too bad.
 
I won't fault Reagan for aiding the Mujahedeen as it was the smart thing to do. The fault was what we did after they were done kicking the USSR out.
 
Hungry people are getting hungrier. The 'cavalry charge' about a week ago of camels and horses was apparently tourist operators. They are losing a lot of money. The crowds are getting smaller, and Mubarak appears to be doing everything to give the appearance he is losing his grip, while doing all he can to hold on. The army isn't helping him, but they haven't overthrown him, either. If they had wanted to, he would have been gone in the first few days. Journalists are still being harassed, as if Mubarak is trying to make sure than when the crackdown comes, it won't look too bad.

That would explain the camels.
I thought that was a bit bizarre, even for Egypt.
 
Yeah, very smart! Almost as smart selling arms to Iran to fund terrorists in South America!. Great guy!

'Egypt: Exchanging a Dictator for a Torturer'


I won't defend the Iran-Contra clusterbuck.

But arming the Afghans was a good idea compared to just letting the USSR muscle it's way into the area. Not to mention it bogged the USSR down in a very costly war that might have hastened it's demise.
 
So, what's the latest from Egypt? I mean, besides the fact that Reagan's 100-year-old zombie corpse has been resurrected for a cage match with the still-living but not-long-for-this-world Carter? Isn't that match taking place in Cairo?
 
I won't defend the Iran-Contra clusterbuck.

But arming the Afghans was a good idea compared to just letting the USSR muscle it's way into the area.

Why? Some time ago you mocked me for claiming that Afghanistan had any strategic importance whatsoever.

Not to mention it bogged the USSR down in a very costly war that might have hastened it's demise.

Do you think 911 was worth it?

So, what's the latest from Egypt? I mean, besides the fact that Reagan's 100-year-old zombie corpse has been resurrected for a cage match with the still-living but not-long-for-this-world Carter? Isn't that match taking place in Cairo?

Do you have access to the internet?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom