Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

Well the stage is set. The military have said this thing is going to end, and the protesters' demands will be met. Mubarak has said he won't leave. It's military coup time.


Agreed. Let's hope they'll get him tonight, or else tomorrow will be very ugly. That Mubarak speech reminded me of Honecker.
 
Guys, a word of caution. Remember Iran. The Iranian revolution was not a victory for democracy and freedom. Iranians were far more modern and worldly that the Egyptians are and the revolution was a giant leap backward, not forward.
 
He really must be delusional. I thought at least he had some semblance of a plan while he was refusing to step down but now it looks like he's just grasping at straws. I don't know what his plan is but he has now cemented his losing position. It's only a matter of how it's going to go down.
 
Mubarak proves he is a grade A ass.
Raise hopes, then dash them. That'll get people of the streets and back to work!

What's next in the playbook?
-- tear gas.
-- internet and phones off
-- police removed from the streets, and prisoners released from prison
-- journalists beaten/arrested
-- condemning the protestors as Israeli/US/Iranian provocateurs
-- appeal via pop star
-- sacking old cabinet/other promises of change

what have I missed?

Appeal to Islam? (It wouldn't be good for him, but it's one thing he hasn't tried).

I'm hoping we see a bloodless coup.
 
Guys, a word of caution. Remember Iran. The Iranian revolution was not a victory for democracy and freedom. Iranians were far more modern and worldly that the Egyptians are and the revolution was a giant leap backward, not forward.

so...we should allow Mubarak to stay as a brutal dictator?

no thank you.
 
Poppy Bush for example.

And we're back at blaming the USA. Good girl. :rolleyes: I was referring to the argument the anti-war crowd used to throw around. It seemed OK to them to let this particularly brutal one stay right where he was.

Actually, Bush senior wanted the Iraqis to revolt against him. That didn't take.
 
Last edited:
And we're back at blaming the USA. Good girl. :rolleyes: I was referring to the argument the anti-war crowd used to throw around. It seemed OK to them to let this particularly brutal one stay right where he was.

Actually, Bush senior wanted the Iraqis to revolt against him. That didn't take.


Maybe that's the trick. If you're a moderately brutal dictator, whose own people are able to eventually throw you off, that's fine. But if you're such a nasty evil monster that your own people are helpless to save themselves, you should be allowed to remain in power.
 
According to some, it was OK to "contain" Hussein and let him stay.

rather then invading Iraq and possibly losing tens of thousands of American troops in the process?

you bet.

and many in the Bush administration agreed with that concept until after 9-11, which changed everything.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Weren't you one of those who wanted to keep "containing" Hussein?

What was your rationale back then?

no no, you're talking about Ms. Condoleeza Rice:

"Saddam Hussein's regime is isolated, his conventional military power has been severely weakened, his people live in poverty and terror, and he has no useful place in international politics. He is therefore determined to develop WMD. Nothing will change until Saddam is gone, so the United States must mobilize whatever resources it can, including support from his opposition, to remove him."

"The containment of Iraq should be aimed ultimately at regime change because as long as Saddam is there no one in the region is safe -- most especially his own people. There are three elements to this policy: one is to try to strengthen the coalition of states that support the sanctions regime; the second is to give better support to opposition forces in accordance with the Iraqi Liberation Act; the third is that is if Saddam gives you a reason to use force against him, then use decisive force, not just a pinprick. And in the long run, you should succeed in creating a Saddam-free Iraq," she said. [9]"



http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Condi_Rice#Statements_About_Iraq
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom