Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

strawman.

Why is that a strawman? The Arab states were carved out of the same Ottoman carcass Israel was carved out of. And yet the Arabs didn't take to invading each other, trying to seize each others carved-out lands.

No, they all went after Israel. With genocide on their tongues and in their minds.

And that's why Allah don't like none of em.
 
Why is that a strawman? The Arab states were carved out of the same Ottoman carcass Israel was carved out of. And yet the Arabs didn't take to invading each other, trying to seize each others carved-out lands.

This is flat-out false. There have been quite a number of military conflicts between Arab states, almost all involving territorial disputes. Some of them even involved attempts to conquer another Arab state wholesale.
 
This is flat-out false. There have been quite a number of military conflicts between Arab states, almost all involving territorial disputes. Some of them even involved attempts to conquer another Arab state wholesale.

You are correct. There have been a few Arab-on-Arab dustups since the creation of the state of Israel.

But only 3 attempted genocides. All against one country. All buttressed by claims that the country was occupying "Arab" land.

Unless we count Saddam's experimental WMD attacks on the Kurds as an attempted genocide.

So, all in all, the Arabs have been even more uncivilized than I knew.
 
Last edited:
Now the ruling party's Executive has resigned.

http://bigpondnews.com/articles/Top...pt_ruling_party_executive_resigns_573650.html
The top leadership body of Egypt's ruling party resigned Saturday, including the president's son, but the regime appeared to be digging in its heels, calculating that it can ride out street demonstrations and keep President Hosni Mubarak in office.
The ruling party leaders who resigned included the country's most powerful political figures - and its most unpopular among many Egyptians. The move may have been aimed at convincing protesters in the streets that the regime is sincere in implementing democratic reforms they demand.
But State TV, announcing the resignations, still identified head of state Mubarak as president of the ruling party in a sign he would remain in authority. And Prime Minister Ahmed Shafiq said Saturday that stability was returning to the country, appearing confident that a deal on future reforms can be reached with the multiple opposition movements to defuse


Appeasement seems to be the strategy for Mubarak at the moment. There are also rumours of a crackdown coming, hence the attempts the remove the media.
 
political theories don't kill people. only people kill people.

and following your logic, "Capitalism" has killed millions of people throughout the world as well.


Capitalism isn't a political theory.

You'd be hard-pressed to demonstrate that democracy had killed 100 million people in the last 60 years, even if you counted people who were murdered because they wanted democracy and their evil government didn't want to give it to them.
 
And that's why Allah don't like none of em.

Originally Posted by Toontown
Perhaps they think Allah is punishing them for being a huge pack of little wussies who couldn't even whup a light smattering of Jews..

Originally Posted by Toontown
No wonder Allah doesn't seem to favor them much.


yeah? prove it.

you keep making this ridiculous assertion, so now its time to prove it with evidence.
 
Last edited:
So, what's going on in Egypt? I thought that was the topic of the thread, y'know.
 
PRESIDENT Hosni Mubarak appeared increasingly isolated yesterday as protesters returned to Tahrir Square in force and the US government and some members of the Egyptian military and civilian elite pursued plans to nudge him from power.
The country's newly named vice-president, Omar Suleiman, along with other top military leaders, were discussing steps to limit Mr Mubarak's authority and possibly remove him from the presidential palace in Cairo - although not to strip him of his presidency immediately, Egyptian and US officials said.
A transitional government headed by Mr Suleiman would then negotiate with opposition figures to amend Egypt's constitution and begin a process of democratic changes.
Advertisement: Story continues below
US officials said among the ideas that had been discussed were suggesting to Mr Mubarak that he move to his home at Sharm el-Sheik, the seaside resort, or that he embark on one of his annual medical leaves to Germany for an extended check-up. Such steps would provide him with a graceful exit and effectively remove him from an executive position, going some way towards addressing a central demand of protesters on the streets of Cairo.


http://www.theage.com.au/world/end-of-mubarak-edges-nearer-20110205-1ahpv.html


It appears it is either a case of Mubarak craftily luring people into a false sense of security before he smashes them just as happened in Iran, or he is being edged out bit by bit and he will never be able to claw his way back. Given that the military has already more or less officially declared they will not support violence, and his paramilitary response has fizzled out, unlike that in Iran, he could well be just standing still while events move on past him.
 
Were there simply more radicals in Iran than in Egypt? It sure seemed like the Iranians had an endless supply of armed thugs.
 
Originally Posted by Toontown [qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/helloworld2/buttons/viewpost.gif[/qimg]
Perhaps they think Allah is punishing them for being a huge pack of little wussies who couldn't even whup a light smattering of Jews..

Originally Posted by Toontown [qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/helloworld2/buttons/viewpost.gif[/qimg]
No wonder Allah doesn't seem to favor them much.


yeah? prove it.

you keep making this ridiculous assertion, so now its time to prove it with evidence.

Could this BE any more obvious?

@600 years ago, the Mongols invaded the Persians and Arabs and practically razed the entire region, driving all the way to what is now Israel. The Arabs dubbed Genghis Khan "The Flail of God". You do the math. Back then, even the Arabs understood that Allah didn't like them. Or maybe the Golden Horde was just Tough Love.

Things went downhill for the Arabs from there.

Fast forward to the French genocide of Algeria, etc, etc...

And then, 63 years ago, Allah told the Arabs the light smattering of Jews would be a pushover. Just to be on the safe side, 7 Arab countries gathered their armies for the push. 63 years later, Islamofascists are hovering around the Egyptian uprising, desperately angling for an opportunity to seize Egypt's 500,000 man army for another shot at the pushovers. Other than that, nothing much has changed, except perhaps the number of Jericho missiles in Israel's arsenal, which Iran now appears intent on touching off.

Nowadays, Allah's self-proclaimed messengers recruit gullible, starry-eyed jihadis to make human bombs of themselves and light themselves up, usually in the middle of a large crowd of Arabs, the deaths of whom, it is hoped, will be blamed on the Americans or the Jews, for whatever that's worth. Because He has mansions and virgins for them in heaven. Yeah, right.

He does not like them, Sam I Am.
 
You are correct. There have been a few Arab-on-Arab dustups since the creation of the state of Israel.

So you were wrong.

But only 3 attempted genocides. All against one country. All buttressed by claims that the country was occupying "Arab" land.

And you're still wrong.

Unless we count Saddam's experimental WMD attacks on the Kurds as an attempted genocide.

So, all in all, the Arabs have been even more uncivilized than I knew.

But, even so, you think you are right.

And, you know what? You sound a lot like David Irving:
http://www.haaretz.com/news/david-irving-jews-should-ask-themselves-why-they-are-hated-1.207968

Could this BE any more obvious?

@600 years ago, the Mongols invaded the Persians and Arabs and practically razed the entire region, driving all the way to what is now Israel. The Arabs dubbed Genghis Khan "The Flail of God". You do the math. Back then, even the Arabs understood that Allah didn't like them. Or maybe the Golden Horde was just Tough Love.

Things went downhill for the Arabs from there.

Fast forward to the French genocide of Algeria, etc, etc...

And then, 63 years ago, Allah told the Arabs the light smattering of Jews would be a pushover. Just to be on the safe side, 7 Arab countries gathered their armies for the push. 63 years later, Islamofascists are hovering around the Egyptian uprising, desperately angling for an opportunity to seize Egypt's 500,000 man army for another shot at the pushovers. Other than that, nothing much has changed, except perhaps the number of Jericho missiles in Israel's arsenal, which Iran now appears intent on touching off.

Nowadays, Allah's self-proclaimed messengers recruit gullible, starry-eyed jihadis to make human bombs of themselves and light themselves up, usually in the middle of a large crowd of Arabs, the deaths of whom, it is hoped, will be blamed on the Americans or the Jews, for whatever that's worth. Because He has mansions and virgins for them in heaven. Yeah, right.

He does not like them, Sam I Am.
 
Pipeline Attacked. Israel Concerned

There it starts. Seen something like this coming a mile away.


Egypt's Brotherhood to hold talks with government

Yup. Just as I figured. Radical Jihadist Islam is coming to Egypt. Geeee. I bet they blew the pipeline.


Israel jittery about gas supply from Egypt


This is not the tip of the iceberg. Jordan got cut off also.


Egypt gas pipeline attacked; Israel, Jordan flow hit
How convenient for the Islamic Brotherhood. I guess they figure if they can destabilize Jordan even more then they will be one of the next Dominos to fall.


Next they might screw with the Suez Canal. I seriously hope they don't.
 
Were there simply more radicals in Iran than in Egypt? It sure seemed like the Iranians had an endless supply of armed thugs.

Mubarak has one and a half million at his disposal.

Yup. Just as I figured. Radical Jihadist Islam is coming to Egypt. Geeee. I bet they blew the pipeline.

Easy, tiger.

Has it actually been established that this explosion at a gas-metering station was caused by sabotage?

263894d4e8c8456ab1.jpg


'EMG's Egypt-Israel gas pipeline intact - Ampal'
 
Last edited:
Pipeline Attacked. Israel Concerned

There it starts. Seen something like this coming a mile away.

Egypt's Brotherhood to hold talks with government

Yup. Just as I figured. Radical Jihadist Islam is coming to Egypt. Geeee. I bet they blew the pipeline.

Israel jittery about gas supply from Egypt

This is not the tip of the iceberg. Jordan got cut off also.

Egypt gas pipeline attacked; Israel, Jordan flow hit
How convenient for the Islamic Brotherhood. I guess they figure if they can destabilize Jordan even more then they will be one of the next Dominos to fall.

Next they might screw with the Suez Canal. I seriously hope they don't.

got any evidence of terrorist activity?

thought not. just blaim the evil MOOOOOOOZLIMS.

:)

You know, I find something odd here when I read the things written by some fundamentalist Christians regarding these events, especially those who see all of this as some harbinger of the End Times. On the one hand, they wring their hands in near agony about how all of these horrible things are coming to pass (the End Times are coming! :jaw-dropp), yet wouldn't one expect them to actually be happy because their Savior is supposedly returning to bring them all to Heaven?
 
How is this standoff going to be resolved?

The army is neutral. The revolutionaries are just standing around in the street chanting and throwing rocks. Is Egypt to become the country that stands around in the streets chanting and throwing rocks? That won't work. They'll starve. And the revolutionaries will starve before Mubarak starves.

If Mubarak steps down, what takes his place? I know of no organization capable of governing the country competently and honorably, with the possible exception of the army, which is essentially how Mubarak came to power. Frankly, it looks to me like Mubarak could hold on to power if he's determined to do so.

It could be that the best hope of the Egyptian people is that Mubarak makes good on his promise of free and fair elections. Perhaps, by that time, something non-insane can be organized, and perhaps Mubarak can be pressured to keep his word.

The longer this standoff continues, the greater the probability that the revolution gets hijacked, as per the typical course of events. Lots of bad monkeys are aching to get their paws on Egypt's armed forces, so they can attack Israel again. Plus, they want POWAH like hogs want slop. Power-mongers are always lurking around like hungry hyenas when a country is about to become seizable.

Earth sucks. Beam me up, Scotty. Let's go where no one has gone before. Been here, done this.
 
Mubarak is a general. And I think he will take a very strategic perspective on this.

He knows that once the initial euphoria is gone, the mood will change.

In three weeks time there will be fewer protesters, and they will be exhausted and hungry. food prices have risen ten-fold already. The economy is on it's butt.

He will take his sweet time negotiating with the opposition until he has enough leverage to influence the outcome.

That outcome will probably include concessions to his friends and the assurance that he, his family and his seventy billion dollars will be large left alone after the transition.
 
The thing is that Arab societies aren't like Western societies. The entire apparatus of state in Egypt is a jobs network for loyal Mubarak supporters. From top positions in government ministries and the army right down to schoolteachers, positions aren't earned on merit and experience like they are in Western countries, they are rewards given in return for loyalty. There's a trickle-down effect of the corruption money. Corrupt officials are expected to share the wealth around and keep people happy. This leads to a huge patronage apparatus staffed by people who don't really know what they're doing, and don't care as long as they get their paycheck and a little grease now and then. The system tolerates corruption and incompetence because everyone else is in on it. Regime change would have to include hundreds of thousands of state employees, who are all tied to Mubarak through a network of grease, favors and family connections.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom