Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

You're getting off track (if you want we can come back to this). If the bulk of land that was allocated to the Jews was an infertile (inhospitable) desert, would it be fair to leave it out of the equation? Palestinians were not living in the Negev in any significant numbers either, btw.

If the land isn't important enough to count, why not give it to the Palestinians?
 
Ooh! So brave! ;)


Says the gutless wonder ... :p

As to "keeping up" I think I'll watch ESPN for a couple of days and check back to see what has developed.

For Wildcat: not much of an attack, Cooper still has his teeth. :( The least they could have done is laid upon him a proper arse whipping.
 
If the land isn't important enough to count, why not give it to the Palestinians?

Because numbers make people complacent, especially if they're in a person or groups favor. That doesn't change the fact that the Negev was more or less useless, regardless of ownership.
 
"Mubarak’s fortune, including his wife’s and son’s, is estimated to be …$40 Billion + $5 Billion + $17 Billion= $62 Billion. We Americans have been paying this man for 30 years, for a total of $60 Billion. Was it for infrastructure, job creation…you know, all those vital ingredients? Or was it to create another king, a dictator, or as Escobar puts it, a Pharaoh with a $Billions fortune?"

http://www.boilingfrogspost.com/201...ng-the-real-issues-fudging-the-real-culprits/

Sorry, the 30 years times 2 billion per year wasn't checks sent to Mubarak. It was money mostly spent in the US, on the DoD side, for stuff to provide him in military aid, agri aid, and such. It is of interest to note that the Egyptians have about 1000 M1 tanks (that's real expensive) and dozens of UH-60 helicopoters, also expensive, which top the list of a lot of stuff made in America, and paid for by US tax dollars under that aid program.

I am partly familiar with the helicopter side of that, and it's been a few years.

JJane, when you spit out the kind of ignorance you quoted, you do us all a favor and remind us of the uselessness of your position.

That said, I am sure President M did as most officials in that region of the world do, and gotten his little bit of baksheesh, or his "a lot a bit" of bakshees. It's how things are done. *shrugs*

Please continue shooting yourself in the foot, JJane, it is most amusing.
 
For Wildcat: not much of an attack, Cooper still has his teeth. :( The least they could have done is laid upon him a proper arse whipping.

He seemed more 'harmed' by his crew getting attacked, of which several women were involved.
 
I don't appreciate you mischaracterising my political satire in that demagogic manner..

and yet, in the next sentence, you blatantly misrepresent my statement, in regards to why the Arabs invaded the new state of Israel:

Yeah, that was almost as funny as you claiming the Arabs only tried to exterminate the Jews out of a noble concern for the rights of religious/ethnic minorities inside the Jewish state.

irony, huh?
 
nice one dude.

:)

let's see em' evade this one.

There's nothing to evade, it was a silly question. Jewish or Palestinian, it doesn't matter who got the Negev - it's useless, and counting it towards your 'total' land mass (especially if it's used against you) is pointless since it has no value.

If you want, you could dig around for the total wealth produced from the Negev and use it to support an argument that Jewish ownership of it reduced the standard of living for the Palestinians.
 
There's nothing to evade, it was a silly question. Jewish or Palestinian, it doesn't matter who got the Negev - it's useless, and counting it towards your 'total' land mass (especially if it's used against you) is pointless since it has no value.

good...so give it to the Palestinians.
 
good...so give it to the Palestinians.

Sure, why not. Stick 'em in a giant desert and see what they can scrape off the rocks. It's only fair.

You still have not addressed the main issue (which you brought up) about the value of the Negev and it's relation to the total land allotted to Israel. Do you think the Negev should count towards that 60% despite having 0 value to anyone? The Palestinians were not using it or living there in any significant number, the Israelis have only recently begun to develop it (at a snails pace) and the income it provided was next to nothing.
 
Sure, why not. Stick 'em in a giant desert and see what they can scrape off the rocks. It's only fair.

how humanitarian of you.

I said give them the Negev, not force them there. But your desires are clear.
 
Sorry, the 30 years times 2 billion per year wasn't checks sent to Mubarak. It was money mostly spent in the US, on the DoD side, for stuff to provide him in military aid, agri aid, and such. It is of interest to note that the Egyptians have about 1000 M1 tanks (that's real expensive) and dozens of UH-60 helicopoters, also expensive, which top the list of a lot of stuff made in America, and paid for by US tax dollars under that aid program.

I am partly familiar with the helicopter side of that, and it's been a few years.

JJane, when you spit out the kind of ignorance you quoted, you do us all a favor and remind us of the uselessness of your position.

That said, I am sure President M did as most officials in that region of the world do, and gotten his little bit of baksheesh, or his "a lot a bit" of bakshees. It's how things are done. *shrugs*

Please continue shooting yourself in the foot, JJane, it is most amusing.

I notice a strong correlation between reactionary political beliefs and a need to aggressively personalize issues.
 
Last edited:
how humanitarian of you.

I said give them the Negev, not force them there. But your desires are clear.

You were talking about evading?

Address my question or don't. If you don't feel up to it, I'll just remind you every time you bring up this supposed 'skewed' land allocation.
 
I notice a strong correlation between reactionary political beliefs and a need to aggressively personalize issues.

Read much?

You might note that the aggressive and deliberately inflammatory language began with the person whom I asked that question of. Or didn't you bother to read the exchange for comprehension?

I note a strong correlation between your myopia and a lack of understanding.

Pay close attention.
UWdude. said:
That is because American are useless, cowardly sheep, who ironically think they should be the world's shepherd.
I suggest you familiarize yourself with the term Anonymous Coward. The Endless September provided us with a limitless supply of them.
 
Last edited:
and yet, in the next sentence, you blatantly misrepresent my statement, in regards to why the Arabs invaded the new state of Israel:

But your positions evolve so quickly, like the Andromeda Strain. How's a muther to keep up with your ever-changing positions?

Your earlier position was to the effect that the Arabs were only concerned about the ethnic/religious minorities in Israel because, you said, they were the only minorities being oppressed in the whole of the Arab world. Are you now suggesting the Arabs had other reasons for their own massive armored oppression of the Jewish minority? Or has your position changed again?
 
Last edited:
Read much?

You might note that the aggressive and deliberately inflammatory language began with the person whom I asked that question of. Or didn't you bother to read the exchange for comprehension?

I note a strong correlation between your myopia and a lack of understanding.

Pay close attention.

I suggest you familiarize yourself with the term Anonymous Coward. The Endless September provided us with a limitless supply of them.

I'm not UWdude.
 
Is this the right thread to recognise that what could have been Red China at Tiananmen Square was averted by the Egyptian military? Two days ago, there was a strong probability that the media blackouts were a preface to mass slaughter.

Are any of you people even interested in this?
 
Your earlier position was to the effect that the Arabs were only concerned about the ethnic/religious minorities in Israel because, you said, they were the only minorities being oppressed in the whole of the Arab world. Are you now suggesting the Arabs had other reasons for their own massive armored oppression of the Jewish minority? Or has your position changed again?

strawman.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom