Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

Nope. I commented on Hama, which was brought up by another poster.

The entire Arab opposition to Israel, the impetus for the 3 wars Israel fought with the Arab states, is anti-semitism. If the same bit of land had been acquired by Arab or Muslim diaspora none of the Arab states would have given a damn. But because it was Jews, that was simply unacceptable.

Jews are supposed to live "under the wing" of Islam as Dhimmi, and the refusal of the Jews in Israel to submit to that is what pissed off the Arab states so much it was worth fighting 3 wars over.

so if you land was occupied, and your family hearded into camps, by white christians, you'd find that acceptable?

Jews not being muslims of course makes things worse, but Arabs fought the Turks before, for the same reason: They were foreign invaders.
 
Evidence?

or did you once again pull the claims out of your rear end?
You think?
In the immediate aftermath of trilateral invasion during the Suez Crisis of 1956, on November 23 by Britain France and Israel, a proclamation was issued stating that 'all Jews are Zionists and enemies of the state', and it promised that they would be soon expelled. Some 25,000 Jews, almost half of the Jewish community left, mainly for Europe, the United States and South America, and Israel, after being forced to sign declarations that they were leaving voluntarily, and agreed with the confiscation of their assets. Some 1,000 more Jews were imprisoned. Similar measures were enacted against British and French nationals in retaliation for the invasion. In Joel Beinin's summary: "Between 1919 and 1956, the entire Egyptian Jewish community, like the Cicurel firm, was transformed from a national asset into a fifth column."[19]

After the 1967 war, more confiscations took place. Rami Mangoubi, who lived in Cairo at the time, states that nearly all Egyptian Jewish men between the ages of 17 and 60 were either thrown out of the country immediately, or taken to the detention centres of Abou Za'abal and Tura, where they were incarcerated and tortured for more than three years.[26] The eventual result was the almost complete disappearance of the Jewish community in Egypt; less than a hundred or so remain today. Most Egyptian Jews fled to Israel (35,000), Brazil (15,000), France (10,000), the US (9,000) and Argentina (9,000).[citation needed] Today, anti-Jewish feelings run high in Egypt, and is common in the media. The last Jewish wedding in Egypt took place in 1984.
I'm sure anti-semitism had nothing to do with any of that! Nor the fact that Jews were denied citizenship in Egypt for hundreds of years prior. I'm sure there's a legitimate reason for that, I just can't think of one right now. Maybe DC or a_u_p or Thunder can find a reason for that which has nothing to do with anti-semitism?
 
The deep roots of anti-Semitism in the Arab World made hatred of Israel a key unifying element in Arab politics of the period, and so it was that the preparations for launching a joint war of extermination against the Jewish state became the cause around which the Arab countries rallied in the 1960s. In 1966-1967, the constant stream of anti-Semitic propaganda and of declarations that the Jews of Israel must be wiped out backfired on the Arab leaders, who found themselves unable to walk away from their own hype, and war became inevitable.
http://www.fighthatred.com/anti-sem...oons/603-nasser-kicking-the-jews-into-the-sea

I can't believe there's actually people here arguing that anti-semitism wasn't a major force behind the Arab states wars against Israel.
 
Last edited:
No anti-semitism here...
In a letter filed yesterday in federal court, opposing a motion filed by the Egyptian Jews whose property, now occupied by Coca-Cola, was confiscated by the Egyptian government in 1962, Coca-Cola asserted that what was done to Egypt's Jews in the early 1960's "was not targeted at a particular religious community" but was a "steady plan to nationalize Egypt's agrarian, commercial, financial, and industrial economy."

The Egyptian government has acknowledged that the property was seized illegally and rightfully belongs to the Bigio family, which has brought suit against Coca-Cola. The seizure was part of what scholars and historians generally agree was persecution of the Jewish population under the leadership of Gamal Abdel Nasser between 1952 and 1965.

...Nathan Lewin, one of the Bigio family's attorneys, said, "We were shocked at Coca-Cola's total insensitivity to the horrible experiences of Egyptian Jewish victims of Nasser's persecution. Senator Thomas Dodd contemporaneously called it 'the most malevolent international hate campaign against the Jews as Jews since the Hitler years.' In order to avoid compensating for its exploitation of property that it knew Nasser had confiscated from a Jewish family, Coca-Cola has joined the ranks of anti-Semites who pervert history and deny the worst persecutions of the Jewish people."
I'm sure it was just coincidence that it was Jewish property which was confiscated.
 
You think?

I'm sure anti-semitism had nothing to do with any of that! Nor the fact that Jews were denied citizenship in Egypt for hundreds of years prior. I'm sure there's a legitimate reason for that, I just can't think of one right now. Maybe DC or a_u_p or Thunder can find a reason for that which has nothing to do with anti-semitism?

and your evidence that when non Jews had taken over that part of land that they would not have cared at all?
 
Wildcat, is it your anti-native Americanism that you do not support the independence of the Republic of Lakotah?
 
and your evidence that when non Jews had taken over that part of land that they would not have cared at all?
Because historically the Arab states don't give a damn about human rights. Where were the protests from the Arab world when Syria shelled Hama? When Saddam gassed the Kurds? When the janjaweed started their atrocities in Sudan that continue to this day?

But heaven forbid if the Jews deny a shipment of cheese doodles to Gaza, that's an outrage!
 
and Israel confiscated a butt-load of Muslim property after the 1948 War. does that make Israel anti-Muslim?

I guess soo huh.
Was Egypt engaged in a civil war when they confiscated Jewish property and sent the Jews packing under Nasser? Compare/contrast the number of Muslims living in Israel to the number of Jews living in Arab states, then try to say with a straight face that the situations are even comparable.

It would be like if the US confiscated the property of all US Muslims after 9/11, and then deported them. No one would defend such an obviously bigoted act, but when it happens in the Arab world there's no shortage of people who make excuses for it, and blame the Jews/Zionists/Israelis, like you just did here.
 
Because historically the Arab states don't give a damn about human rights. Where were the protests from the Arab world when Syria shelled Hama? When Saddam gassed the Kurds? When the janjaweed started their atrocities in Sudan that continue to this day?

But heaven forbid if the Jews deny a shipment of cheese doodles to Gaza, that's an outrage!

:rolleyes: that's your evidence? wow that is pretty laughable.
 
Was Egypt engaged in a civil war when they confiscated Jewish property and sent the Jews packing under Nasser? Compare/contrast the number of Muslims living in Israel to the number of Jews living in Arab states, then try to say with a straight face that the situations are even comparable.

It would be like if the US confiscated the property of all US Muslims after 9/11, and then deported them. No one would defend such an obviously bigoted act, but when it happens in the Arab world there's no shortage of people who make excuses for it, and blame the Jews/Zionists/Israelis, like you just did here.

800,000 Arabs were sent packing from Israel during the 1948 War. None of them have been allowed to return or receive compensation for their lost property. Israel THEN sent another 30,000 Arabs packing after 1949, even though the conflict was over. They too have not been allowed to return or get compensation for lost property.

But its ok to steal land and exile minorities, when Jews do it....right Wildcat?

;)
 
:rolleyes: that's your evidence? wow that is pretty laughable.
Go ahead, find me a single example of an Arab state going to war over human rights abuses in another Arab state.

I can show you 3 wars they fought with Israel, allegedly because the rights of Palestinians were being infringed upon. But the reality is they only cared because there were Jews involved. Jews are supposed to be Dhimmi "under the wing of Islam". But then they got uppity and have the nerve to call themselves a Jewish state!

And don't overlook the role Jewish imigration played in the Palestinian independence movement beginning after WWI. The Arabs were outraged at the Jewish immigration, and the reason for the outrage was anti-semitism. No Arab property was being confiscated, no Arabs forced from their homes, they were pissed off that Jews were coming to live there. The British tried to appease them by limiting Jewish immigration to palestine, but that wasn't good enough for the Arab leaders. One of the most influential Palestinian leaders during this time was Amin al-Husayni, a raging anti-semite who allies with the Nazis during WWII and even recruited Arab soldiers for the SS.

When the Arab League was formed in 1945 one of its first acts was to put in place a boycott of all Jewish goods. Go ahead, try to blame that on the actions of a country that wouldn't even exist for 3 more years.

And wikipedia has an article on anti-semitism in the Arab world.

Go ahead DC, lol! It's crazy funny.
 
Last edited:
800,000 Arabs were sent packing from Israel during the 1948 War. None of them have been allowed to return or receive compensation for their lost property. Israel THEN sent another 30,000 Arabs packing after 1949, even though the conflict was over. They too have not been allowed to return or get compensation for lost property.

But its ok to steal land and exile minorities, when Jews do it....right Wildcat?

;)
Why do you think the Arab states went to war in 1948 Thunder? In 1967? In 1972?

Note to all: Thunder will run away from this question. Probably just post a smilie in response.
 
I can show you 3 wars they fought with Israel, allegedly because the rights of Palestinians were being infringed upon. But the reality is they only cared because there were Jews involved.

source?

The Arabs were outraged at the Jewish immigration, and the reason for the outrage was anti-semitism. No Arab property was being confiscated, no Arabs forced from their homes, they were pissed off that Jews were coming to live there.

source?

....I'm sure the fact that the Zionists were seeking to create an independent Jewish state in Palestine with millions of more Jes from around the world, had nothing to do with their anger and objection to mass Jewish immigration and settlement.

;)
 
Why do you think the Arab states went to war in 1948 Thunder? In 1967? In 1972?

Note to all: Thunder will run away from this question. Probably just post a smilie in response.


why did they go to war in 1948? because they felt the creation of a Jewish state in Palestine encompasing 60% of the land while Jews made up only 40% of the population, was incredibly unfair and put the burden of the Holocaust and 2,000 years of Jewish persecution upon people who had NOTHING to do with any of it.


blaiming all of this on anti-Semitism, doesn't require much thought or analysis. and its a great card to use when its the only card ya got.
 
Last edited:
why did they go to war in 1948? because they felt the creation of a Jewish state in Palestine encompasing 60% of the land while Jews made up only 40% of the population, was incredibly unfair and put the burden of the Holocaust and 2,000 years of Jewish persecution upon people who had NOTHING to do with any of it.


blaiming all of this on anti-Semitism, doesn't require much thought or analysis. and its a great card to use when its the only card ya got.
(citation needed)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom