Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

http://www.spiegel.de/politik/ausland/0,1518,742362,00.html

[15.13 Uhr] Der einflussreiche Geistliche Qaradawi hat sich zu Wort gemeldet. "Dies ist das Ende des Mubarak-Regimes", wird er zitiert. Außerdem fordert er laut al-Dschasira die Demonstranten zum Gewaltverzicht auf.

More bad news for Hosni: an influential cleric has said that Mubaraks days are over.

Some more people who want to gamble when Mubarak will leave the country?

I say monday.
 
Not Good

I know their current leader is a dictator type due but this "power vacuum" happening in Middle East is not good. They are ticked off about the US armaments just like the Palestinians were when Israel used USA stuffs on them.

If Egypt falls they will have no where else to vent their anger at except the West. With Israel and Europe the closest next targets.

Their 2 main reasons is corruption and poverty.

Honestly though, anyone that can show me 1 country in this world without poverty and corruption is a liar.

So, if those two reasons suggest sound terms to start a revolution then God help us all.

All the cheer leading going on in this thread about these recent events is making me feel like I have to throw up and it makes my scar where my head was almost cut off itch.
 
I know their current leader is a dictator type due but this "power vacuum" happening in Middle East is not good. They are ticked off about the US armaments just like the Palestinians were when Israel used USA stuffs on them.

If Egypt falls they will have no where else to vent their anger at except the West. With Israel and Europe the closest next targets.

Their 2 main reasons is corruption and poverty.

Honestly though, anyone that can show me 1 country in this world without poverty and corruption is a liar.

So, if those two reasons suggest sound terms to start a revolution then God help us all.

All the cheer leading going on in this thread about these recent events is making me feel like I have to throw up and it makes my scar where my head was almost cut off itch.

Finally some sane words from the US; as an aside I always had a preference for the South, which will come as no surprise to my opponents.

There is nothing indeed to cheer about, for Israel much less then Europe, for the moment. In the end we might even have to fear the Islamic bomb spreading to countries like Egypt. It looks like Europe needs to be very viril again in the coming years.
Where is Erwin Rommel when you need him? :cool:
Maybe we Europeans will buy half of the American fleet for a soft price.

The Roman Empire lasted 4 centuries or so. I doubt the American empire will exist in a few years time. We are entering a very instable multipolar world. Enjoy your warm shower, your central heating, your espresso machine, your Beamer... it is not going to last.
 
Last edited:
I suggest they bring in El Baradei as the new temporary president.

and make Egypt a true representative democracy.
 
Watching protests by the the Egyptian people on television brings a smile to my face, I'll wait to see who fills the vacuum before breaking into a big grin.
 
interesting announcement by an army guy just on Aljazeera
 
deja vu:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/9380534.stm

1601 Hosni Mubarak's two sons, Alaa and Gamal, have arrived in London, the BBC Arabic Service is told.

[...] 1633 Egyptian TV denies the flight of President Mubarak's sons to London. "There is no truth to what has been broadcast by some channels on the travel of Alaa and Gamal Mubarak to London," state-owned TV channel al-Misriyah says.

BBC told by whom? And you'd think the BBC could confirm this themselves from sources in airports and whatnot.

This is annoying!
 
http://www.elsevier.nl/web/Opinie/Afshin-Ellian/287952/Krijgt-Egypte-zijn-eigen-Sjahmoment.htm

(my excuses for the untranslated Dutch; I will comment each part so you get the gist)

In Holland we have an influential commentator, Afshin Ellian, who fled the Khomeiny regime and now has a parttime career here in warning against islamic fundamentalism (I would not be surprised if he has partial Jewish roots).

Krijgt Egypte zijn eigen Sjah-moment?
Does Egypt gets it's own Shah-moment?

zaterdag 29 januari 2011 17:31

De Egyptische opstand is de opstand der verschoppelingen. Nu vraagt de wereld aan Hosni Mubarak om economische hervormingen in te voeren. Pardon, economische hervormingen? Welke hervormingen? Egypte heeft geen economie: geen gas, geen olie, geen industrie. De Egyptenaren leven voornamelijk van de Amerikaanse hulp.

Voor de rest zijn ze afhankelijk van wat ze zelf produceren en toerisme. Egypte is arm en zal arm blijven. De bestrijding van corruptie zal slechts leiden tot de eerlijke verdeling van armoede.

Geen verlichting
Waarom heeft Egypte zich economisch niet kunnen ontwikkelen? Omdat de Egyptenaren geen vrije, verlichte, mondige, wetsgetrouwe mensen zijn. Wat Zuid-Koreanen hebben bereikt, kunnen de Egyptenaren niet. Immers, de voorwaarde voor de industriële en technologische ontwikkeling is een vrije, moderne en verlichte cultuur.

Ellian: the revolution will change nothing to the situation of the average Egyptian. He makes the comparisson with South-Korea and explains why the latter could ascend to European level and why the Egyptians will not. He uses terms like 'enlightenment, law obedience, frankness' (911I: the real reason he does not mention, namely that Egypt has an average IQ of 83, where Korea has 106, even more than Europeans). But he is right, Mubarak is not stopping Egyptians from developing, it is the Egyptian themselves.

Desondanks groeide het aantal inwoners van Egypte in de afgelopen decennia. In het Arabische land wonen te veel mensen. Dankzij de islamitische propaganda aangaande de voortplanting van de moslims kwamen in de afgelopen tientallen jaren er miljoenen Egyptenaren bij. Zijn er nog banen voor die miljoenen mensen? Is er voldoende voedsel? Nee.

Egypt is over-populated, o.a. thanks to muslim propaganda. There is no economy, no industry, nothing, except for some tourism. There will not be enough food.

Is deze opstand der verschoppelingen een democratische revolutie zoals de Groene Beweging in Iran of elders? Helaas niet. Er bestaat daar geen elite van democraten of een middenklasse die het volk naar de democratie zal leiden.

The democratic revolution will fail by lack of a democratic elite or middle class. It is a uprising of Les Miserables.

Bij eenmalige vrije verkiezingen zullen waarschijnlijk de islamisten een meerderheid kunnen vormen. De vraag is dus of Egypte in handen van de Moslimbroederschap valt. En ElBaradei? Daarover zijn er twee meningen: de ene groep vertrouwt ElBaradei niet omdat hij te dichtbij Iran staat. En de andere groep ziet in hem een onnozelaar die door de moslimsfundamentalisten kan worden gebruikt.

Ik weet het niet. Wat ik wel weet is dat ruim dertig jaar geleden de Iraanse onnozelaars zich lieten misbruiken door de fundamentalisten om Sjah ten val te brengen. Daarna werden zij letterlijk eruit gegooid. Hier in Amerika noemt men de toestand in Egypte als ‘het Sjah-moment’ .

De Moslimbroeders opereerden slim en afwachtend. Toen de Moslimbroederschap de woedende jongeren zag, gaf de organisatie bij monde van zijn vertegenwoordiger een verklaring op de Iraanse staatszender Press TV (Engelstalig) en de Arabische zender van Iran.

Ellian exects that a one time election wil bring Islamists to power. He praises the behavior of the Muslim Brotherhood as smart and restraintfull.

Angstaanjagend
De Moslimbroeders zijn goed bevriend met Iran. Wat er kan, met nadruk zeg ik ‘kan’ gebeuren in Egypte, is werkelijk angstaanjagend: een islamitische revolutie. Niet voor niets vroegen de Moslimbroeders het Egyptische volk om na vrijdaggebed de straat op te gaan. Zij willen de beweging islamiseren.

Ellian is very afraid of the connection between the MB and Iran and the possibility of Islamification of the revolution.

Islamisering!? Wat gaat dan gebeuren? De Moslimbroeders zullen een conflict ontketenen met Israël. Gaza is de plek waar zich het gewapende conflict met Israël zou kunnen afspelen. Libanon is nu in handen van Hezbollah. Jemen begint te wankelen. Irak is in de handen van de vrienden van Iran.

Ellian is always very concerned about Israel (that is why I think he could be partial Jewish). Ellian predicts that the MB will start a conflict with Israel. Lebanon is in the hands of the Hezbollah; Yemen is starting to stumble, Iraq is in the hands of friends of Iran (911I: thanks to a blundering US and their Clean Break idiocy).

Jordanië, de andere vriend van Israël en Amerika zal tijdens een Arabische islamitische revolutie gaan wankelen. In dit geval zal de bedreiging van burgeroorlogen en een regionale oorlog alleen maar toenemen. Olie zal duurder worden. En dat zal het economische herstel in het westen tegenwerken.

Ellian predicts that Jordan could be toppled as well.
 
Last edited:
Ellian: the revolution will change nothing to the situation of the average Egyptian. He makes the comparisson with South-Korea and explains why the latter could ascend to European level and why the Egyptians will not. He uses terms like 'enlightenment, law obedience, frankness' (911I: the real reason he does not mention, namely that Egypt has an average IQ of 83, where Korea has 106, even more than Europeans). But he is right, Mubarak is not stopping Egyptians from developing, it is the Egyptian themselves.
The comparison with South Korea is a canard. Until 10 years ago or so, South Korea was also an authoritarian oppressive regime - and still it came to economic development. Singapore ditto.

I don't know where your IQ numbers come from, but you do realize that education plays a large factor in that? When you're illiterate, you won't score high in IQ tests. Education is key not only to high IQ tests, but also to economic development, especially in this information age. And that's indeed a point for the government to provide the infrastructure and that everyone receives a K12 education.
 
I don't know where your IQ numbers come from, but you do realize that education plays a large factor in that? When you're illiterate, you won't score high in IQ tests. Education is key not only to high IQ tests, but also to economic development, especially in this information age. And that's indeed a point for the government to provide the infrastructure and that everyone receives a K12 education.
Unfortunately, in much of thr Middle East an "education" consists of going to a madrassa to memorize the Koran and interpret it according to the teachings of the fundy cleric in charge.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom