What the Palestinians Really Want

Of course, if Parky were correct, Israel would be perfectly justified in kicking out all Israeli Arabs, foreign workers, etc., etc.

THEN, once it finished the ethnic cleansing a la the Arab world's ethnic cleansing of Jews and Christians, it would finally achieve the coveted status of being a "real" nationality.

So why is Parky so opposed to Kahane, let alone Liberman (if Liberman were what he wrongly says he is)?

That's what was bugging me so much about Thunder's statements. I just couldn't figure out how to articulate it.
 
They ended decades ago, and decades-old wars are not justifications for current expansion of borders. While it is interesting that you have no respect for international law, you are yet to provide a satisfactory explanation as to why israels expansion of its borders is a form of self-defence.
Odd, I could have sworn that Hamas was still at war with Israel. And Iran was still arming, training, and funding Hamas and Hizbullah. And the "moderate" PA still hasn't got around to amending their Charter or recognizing Israel's right to exist. Hasn't there been an uptick of rockets from Gaza the last few days?

I'm sure you'll post links showing I'm in error, because you seem so much more informed than I am...
 
The 1967 border.
International law.
Since when was the 1967 border so special? How'd that work out in 1967?

What does international law say about firing rockets and mortars at other countries civilian population?
 
You are so full of it.

The "guilt by association" fallacy has nothing to do with who you literally associate with, but I think you know that and this is deliberate obfuscation.

Whatever you want to tell yourself. At the end of the day, it remains a pathetic, dishonest attempt at character assassination.

But let's be honest, the ISM is connected with Palestinian "resistance" in all it's forms. Its connections to Hamas are a lot stronger than just belonging to the same myspace group as another person who used the Hamas logo as his avatar. To try to distance yourself from that after all the effort put into making the connections in the first place is just disingenuous.
What the hell does ISM have to do with this? :confused:
 
Odd, I could have sworn that Hamas was still at war with Israel. And Iran was still arming, training, and funding Hamas and Hizbullah. And the "moderate" PA still hasn't got around to amending their Charter or recognizing Israel's right to exist. Hasn't there been an uptick of rockets from Gaza the last few days?

I'm sure you'll post links showing I'm in error, because you seem so much more informed than I am...

Well, you're wrong. If hamas were at war with israel, they would be trying to invade it with armies, and vice versa. What we're seeing are border skirmishes, not war.

But regardless of whether you believe rocket attacks are war, there is a clear difference between the positions of the two sides. Hamas can claim that rocket attacks are a resistance against israeli expansion, but israel cannot claim that israeli expansion is resistance against rocket attacks.

So, once again, how do you justify israel expanding its borders into palestine? Do you think the palestinians should be exterminated over time?
 
Their 1988 charter, yes. Well, the jews in israel/palestine, not around the world. But their 2010 statement was that if the 1967 borders are recognized, they get right of return, and east jerusalem, then they will stop armed hostilities against israel.

http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE64T2AM20100530

sounds fair to me.
and it should be fair to israel too, or they would not have agreed to it in 1967.
(contrary to popular belief, treaties are not made to be broken.)
 
My old professor disagrees with you.

And I trust him a lot more than I trust you.

there are believers among them, but the greater part of them are transgressors

Um...I thought Hamas wants to kill ALL Jews?

[FONT=arial, helvetica, sans-serif]In calling for Jihad, Hamas brands Jews as war criminals on the model of the Nazis. [/FONT]

I like the above comment, especially cause' Hamas, Hezbollah, Al Qaeda, and Fatah are often compared to the Nazis. :)
 
Of course the "right of return" means the "Return" of millions of "refugees" to Israel to destroy it demographically. So what Hamas is saying is that if it gets to kick every last Jew out of the West Bank and east Jerusalem AND destroy Israel through the "right of return" then it MIGHT "sign a peace agreement". Naturally what this means is simply "if Israel is destroyed we will no longer want to destroy it".

I don't doubt this "sounds fair" or somehow "not the same" as wanting to destroy Israel to certain people on this forum, which shows how much they know about the reality of this conflict. Of course literally two days ago the head of Hamas repeated the real choice: Jews have only the option of "death of leaving".
 
And what is their standing in this conflict?

oh, you can blow off the entire planet Earth, if you like.

but don't go whining about anti-Semitism when they then tell Israel to go **** off, and cut off all aid, diplomatic relations, and trade.
 
oh, you can blow off the entire planet Earth, if you like.

but don't go whining about anti-Semitism when they then tell Israel to go **** off, and cut off all aid, diplomatic relations, and trade.
Who is "they"?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom