"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

I feel the need to spit this stuff out:

"Just so you have a short list of what's at stake if Washington DC doesn't change policy here and now (which means before the collapse in equities comes, which could start as soon as today, if the indicators I watch have any validity at all. For what its worth, those indicators are painting a picture of the Apocalypse that I simply can't believe, and they're showing it as an imminent event - like perhaps today imminent.)

...You may be reading this too late for it to matter.
"

- 'What's Dead (Short Answer: All Of It)'

Karl Denninger, The Market Ticker

March 5. 2009

http://market-ticker.denninger.net/authors/2-Karl-Denninger
 
No, the problem was not housing or even mortgages. It was with the fraudulent representation of the underlying risk, which was given with the imprimatur of the US government.

You took my quote out of context. I don't entirely disagree with what you are saying. Although in this case I don't blame the Government. It probably should have been regulated in hindsight.
 
You took my quote out of context. I don't entirely disagree with what you are saying. Although in this case I don't blame the Government. It probably should have been regulated in hindsight.


Yes, I knew that. But I wanted to get my point in. ;)
 
Oh a russian news station? How funny. Looks like Russia is also seeing the depression.
 
This guy truly is in one of those fields where you can reasonably ask "If you're so smart, how come you're not rich?" If this guy's predictions are as accurate as he claims, he should have made himself incredibly wealthy during the last 25.

So, how much has he increased his net worth through investment/speculation since the mid-80s or so?


His not smart but russian oligarchs like Oleg Deripaska are. I read that Deripaska made his first billions when he was only 22 years old now that is smart and simply amazing. How does a person become so rich in so quick and so young? :confused:
Maybe he bribed people? ;)
 
?? For it to be an oversimplification, it must be overly simple in reference to some point. You haven't provided any such reference point. Obviously, when you're looking at the big picture, you don't go over every minute detail.

The "big picture"... where have I heard that before ? Oh, yes. 9/11 CTers...

Minutiae IS important.

If you say "land is land" and "a car's a car", and ignore the obvious differences between several types of them, then why not just say "money is money", and use an average or all types of currency in the world to find the "value of world money" ?

Or imagine this situation:

Wife: "Honey would you mind getting me some apples from the store ?"
[Later]
Wife: "These are raspberries, honey. I asked for apples."
Husband: "A fruit's a fruit, baby."
 
The "big picture"... where have I heard that before ? Oh, yes. 9/11 CTers...
?? Or, from anyone who was talking about the grand scheme of things.

Know who else frequently mentions the big picture? People arguing with creationists. I've done so many times myself. Creationists, to avoid knowing the facts that prove beyond reasonable doubt that life shares common descent, will frequently try to focus on very specific situations which are difficult for evolution to explain; but if they'd just look at the big picture, it's not hard to see that over large scales of time, many small changes to the gene pool add up to big changes and speciation.

Minutiae IS important.
Important, yes. Relevant to all discussions, no.

If you say "land is land" and "a car's a car", and ignore the obvious differences between several types of them, then why not just say "money is money", and use an average or all types of currency in the world to find the "value of world money" ?
Because I'm not interested in doing so. But if you're talking about all money in the world, theoretically, there should indeed be some average value, don't you think?

Or imagine this situation:

Wife: "Honey would you mind getting me some apples from the store ?"
[Later]
Wife: "These are raspberries, honey. I asked for apples."
Husband: "A fruit's a fruit, baby."
?? The wife asked for apples, not fruit. This is the second time this exact mistake has been made. Incredible.
 
I'm sorry you missed it. Apples ARE fruit. So in asking for apples, she DID ask for fruit. And since a fruit's a fruit...
Sigh.

I was talking about land. drkitten then tried to shift the focus some particular areas of land.

In your example, the wife was asking for some particular kind of fruit, and the husband tried to shift focus to fruit in general.
 
In your example, the wife was asking for some particular kind of fruit, and the husband tried to shift focus to fruit in general.

Then why are you saying the price of "land" or "fruit" went up when only "apples" or "building lots" (ie. a particular kind of fruit or land) went up (due to unfounded speculation on ever increasing value/continuous growth.)

You've backed yourself into a hole on this FT ;) This analogy could even extend to the land the apples are grown on. Just because the price of apples goes up doesn't mean the land on fruit farms will go up.
 
Then why are you saying the price of "land" or "fruit" went up when only "apples" or "building lots" (ie. a particular kind of fruit or land) went up (due to unfounded speculation on ever increasing value/continuous growth.)
Tell me: if the price of apples goes up, and the price of all other fruit stays the same, is it accurate to say "the price of fruit increased" or not?

Furthermore, it's not "building lots" that increased in value, it's locations where people wished to build. Just the ability, by itself, guarantees no increase. It's true that restrictions on usage can limit the value, or increase in value, but that's an intrusion into the market, and must be considered as a complication to the underlying theory.

You've backed yourself into a hole on this FT ;)
No, you're just having issues with basic logic.

This analogy could even extend to the land the apples are grown on. Just because the price of apples goes up doesn't mean the land on fruit farms will go up.
It does unless the value of other kinds of fruit goes down.
 
Tell me: if the price of apples goes up, and the price of all other fruit stays the same, is it accurate to say "the price of fruit increased" or not?

I wouldn't. On average, sure. But then, why would you want to ? Someone who said that the price of fruit went up when only apples did would not be completely honest about the whole deal.

It's like saying that, since the price of apples (or a particular type of land) went up, everything, on average, now costs more money. How, exactly, do you manage to find a common denominator to average all these "things" together is anybody's guess.
 
Tell me: if the price of apples goes up, and the price of all other fruit stays the same, is it accurate to say "the price of fruit increased" or not?

Yes, but to go to my neighbour and say "Well I guess our home values are going up" based on the increase in San Fransico, I'd be dead wrong.

The tax collected on all land, as represented by the fair market value, did not increase across the board. Farming/Agricultural, Crown and in my area even Commercial, did not increase in value as much as resdential. Had it been as broad based as you are suggesting this wouldn't be the case.

It's you logic that fails you FT. It's not the increase in land value at all, it's the housing market that increased, carrying with it residential lots.

Lastly, I'm not sure what country you are from but here in Canada the tax paid on land lags the increase in property value by at least a year. It's called "assessment". The government "predicts" a standard rate increase and assesses your property based on the previous assessment (or purchase price). This is subject to appraisal. If you were in fact correct, there would be no need for assessment.

Game, set and match ;)
(somehow I doubt it)
 
I wouldn't. On average, sure. But then, why would you want to ? Someone who said that the price of fruit went up when only apples did would not be completely honest about the whole deal.
Not really. It depends on your perspective.

Say you own a grocery store. Someone asks: "what are produce prices like now?" He answers "prices for produce are up right now." He might add "but the increase is all apples," but that's unnecessary information.

It's like saying that, since the price of apples (or a particular type of land) went up, everything, on average, now costs more money. How, exactly, do you manage to find a common denominator to average all these "things" together is anybody's guess.
The returns to land come out of the returns to labor and capital.
 
Yes, but to go to my neighbour and say "Well I guess our home values are going up" based on the increase in San Fransico, I'd be dead wrong.

The tax collected on all land, as represented by the fair market value, did not increase across the board. Farming/Agricultural, Crown and in my area even Commercial, did not increase in value as much as resdential. Had it been as broad based as you are suggesting this wouldn't be the case.
Not true. Each market is different, but in the aggregate, land prices rose.

It's you logic that fails you FT. It's not the increase in land value at all, it's the housing market that increased, carrying with it residential lots.
No, that's nonsensical. There can't be a market for something which doesn't exist. What you're saying is that nonexistent houses rose in value, somehow making the land that'd theoretically be under them rise in value. But that's obviously false and stupid.

What happened is that land in areas where people wished to live and work rose in value, and for the same reason people were able to buy so much housing: there was lots of easy credit, and the economy was strong, which meant people had money to spend.

Lastly, I'm not sure what country you are from but here in Canada the tax paid on land lags the increase in property value by at least a year. It's called "assessment". The government "predicts" a standard rate increase and assesses your property based on the previous assessment (or purchase price). This is subject to appraisal. If you were in fact correct, there would be no need for assessment.
This is wrong also. The land market is dynamic, and the areas which are in demand change in unpredictable ways. If you can get a hold of BC appraisal data, however, you'll have in your hands some of the best land value data in the world, and will see some interesting facts such as the fact that land comprises nearly half of total property values, and that land values did in fact increase rapidly over the last decade, just as I've said.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the main argument here seems to be:

FreeThinkr is saying that Land value appreciates. The objects that are erected on the land depreciate. The [seemingly increasing] value of the physical home is merely a reflection of the continued issuance of more debt for more homes. It's the land that's scarce, not the physical dwelling.

Is this what you're saying?
 
Last edited:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the main argument here seems to be:

FreeThinkr is saying that Land value appreciates. The objects that are erected on the land depreciate. The [seemingly increasing] value of the physical home is merely a reflection of the continued issuance of more debt for more homes. It's the land that's scarce, not the physical dwelling.

Is this what you're saying?
Mainly. This is all actually the fallout from my initial correction of drkitten; he said that housing prices had increased, and I pointed out that, in actuality, most of that increase was land.

The one part I'd caution about what you've said is the bit about the continued issuance of debt; though this particular run-up featured that in spades, its certainly not necessary for land values to increase.
 
Well, I think I have to agree.

I mean it's getting bogged down in semantics, but the argument is simple.

A house isn't a bottle of fine wine. It doesn't appreciate. If it goes up in value because of a school being built across the street, then the land went up in value, not the home. It's still a depreciating asset.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom