Sigh. It doesn't matter
why the lot is valuable. The question is, "is the lot valuable?" If the answer is "yes," I'm right. Period.
Edit: what you're doing here (and I know, you're just following Francesca's lead) is like saying "tires don't have any value. Yes, I know people pay considerable sums of money for them, but they only buy them because they need them for cars. Really, if you think about it, that's car value, not tire value." It's just a dishonest argument.
If I had to say what the root cause was I'd go with the housing.
But that doesn't make any sense. Say I want to build a house. I hire an architect and a GC, and I have one built. I pay the people who created the house. That's a payment for housing.
But before I did any of that, I had to pay a landowner for a site on which to build a house.
That's a payment for land.
It doesn't matter what I choose to use the land for: what matters is what factor of production my money is going to. Note, also, that when I paid the GC and architect to design and build my house, I was trading the product of my labor for the product of their labor, whereas when I paid the landowner for use of the land, I was simply paying the ransom he demanded so that I could use the land that existed without any help from anyone.
I undestand what you are saying FT, but at the end of the day, the price of "land" remained fairly steady while the price of a "lot" increased.
?? Land is parceled out in lots. If the price of "lots" increased, that literally means the price of land increased. What you're saying is like someone who owned a lot which appreciated in value over the run-up and sold it for a large gain telling his friends that he made a killing selling "housing."
But obviously he wouldn't tell his friends he made a killing selling housing, because he manifestly sold land.
The only way the "land" increased in value was buy putting a house on it. To me that means the house is the key factor.
No, that's false. It was worth more
before the house was put on it, and irrespective of whether the house, once built, remained or burnt down. Land values are the premium paid to use land in areas where people wish to live and work.