"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

I'm sorry. All that was lost in the Italian.

Oh, no, no. Not "burst". "Popped".

Right back at you.

No, indeed. Just like apples and oranges are neither like land or like cars. For some reason, however, people keep using them in analogies. Curse them!

No, of course not. I was talking about some people's need to make things simpler in order to feel like they understand them. But, carry on.
Right. So, basically, you just had nothing of any worth to say at all. Carry on... in another thread.
 
A house with [worth?] a $10,000,000 can be built there, or just about anywhere.
I doubt that.

The value of the lot is higher because of the services and infrastructure provided by government, the opportunities and amenities provided by society, and the physical qualities provided by nature.
Agreed and this is the climb-down from it being "all about the land" that you have already conceded.

All you're saying here is "if the council slapped a ruling that said the land could not be put to its highest and best use, it'd be worth less."
Correct, and its highest and best use has rather little to do with it being land and rather a lot to do with what those highest and best uses are, which are not provided by nature.

Of course. And it won't be worth anything at all if the council slaps a ruling on it such that it can't be used at all!
I could not have made my point better myself--thanks! The fact that it is (still) land doesn't mean very much. It does not get its value by "being land". I, and others, have said this all along.

I don't understand why you continue to post as if you are making an alternative argument (still less that you have been "proved right" in it) when you have retreated comprehensively and are now saying what I and others said to begin with. There is really no sense in merely bickering for bickering's sake, as you may have noticed.
 
Last edited:
I doubt that.
Doubt all you like.

The bottom line is, if the lot is worth more, it's land value. You're just being ridiculous by trying to deny that obvious fact. You might as well say "that oil field is only valuable because you can sell it to producers of gasoline." Okay, but the oil has value: not just the gasoline.

Agreed and this is the climb-down from it being "all about the land" that you have already conceded.
Uh, no. Land is how you get access to those advantages: the landowner's role is to control access to those advantages. He either allows access, or doesn't. If he allows access, others will pay him for the value of the benefit.

Get it?

Correct, and its highest and best use has rather little to do with it being land and rather a lot to do with what those highest and best uses are, which are not provided by nature.
But the land and location are, which is the point. This is not one of the better attempts at refusing to know the facts that Georgist theory identifies.

Could not have made my point better myself. Thanks. The fact that it is (still) land doesn't mean very much. It does not get its value by "being land". I, and others, have said this all along.
I of course never said that it gets its value by being land, whatever that's supposed to mean. If that's your "point," then you haven't even comprehended what I've written.

Land, by itself, has no value. If you're the only person in the world, no matter how much you appreciate some piece of land, it will have no value. Value arises when two or more people wish to use some piece of land. Areas serviced by government with robust infrastructure and many amenities and opportunities made available by society will be economically beneficial compared with areas without such access. People are willing to pay for the difference. That's land value.

I don't understand why you continue to post as if you are making an alternative argument (still less that you have been "proved right" in it) when you have retreated comprehensively and are now saying what I and others said to begin with. There is really no sense in merely bickering for bickering's sake, as you may have noticed.
This is a flat out lie. I'll ask you to either quote me claiming what you here imply I'm claiming, or retract this and apologize.
 
I have to refer you to my previous posts, wherein your concession / climb-down is noted. Nothing further to discuss on this subject, thank you :)
 
Last edited:
I have to refer you to my previous posts, wherein your concession / climb-down is noted. Nothing further to discuss on this subject, thank you :)
No, I don't think so. You said:
Francesca said:
I could not have made my point better myself--thanks! The fact that it is (still) land doesn't mean very much. It does not get its value by "being land". I, and others, have said this all along.
I never said any such thing. Here you're just lying and claiming that I said land value came from land "being land," and that you have me running in retreat from that claim.

But I never said any such thing. You're just lying in an attempt to make it look as though you've countered my self-evident and indisputable claims. Run if you like, but unless you either quote me saying what you claim I said, or admit I haven't said any such thing and apologize, you're just a liar.
 
Here you're just lying and claiming that I said land value came from land "being land,"
Point to where I said you said that. Didn't think so. However you don't need to apologise for alleging I did or even retract it. For details of your concession / climb-down see post 223 among others.

And enjoy the last word :)
 
For anyone in doubt of who is right here, let's just consider one of Francesca's claims:
The increase in lot value was owing to houses.
I own a bare lot. Others are willing to give me $50,000 for it.

Is that land value or house value? If it's land value, I'm right and Francesca's destroyed.


Clearly, it's land value and I'm right.
 
Point to where I said you said that. Didn't think so.
Oh?
You said:
Agreed and this is the climb-down from it being "all about the land" that you have already conceded.

...

I could not have made my point better myself--thanks! The fact that it is (still) land doesn't mean very much. It does not get its value by "being land". I, and others, have said this all along.
You said that this is a "climb-down" from it being "all about land." And then you said that land doesn't get its value by "being land," and that you've been saying this all along (presumably, I've been denying that). Thus, you are claiming my former position was that it was "all about land," and that land gets its value by "being land."

You simply lied. I have now proved it.

However you don't need to apologise for alleging I did or even retract it.
I don't need to apologize because you in fact clearly did lie about what I wrote.

For details of your concession / climb-down see post 223 among others.
Oh, the post where I specifically stated where land value comes from, counter to your claim that my position was that land gets its value from "being land?"

And enjoy the last word :)
Have fun continuously lying about what I wrote and then fleeing like a thief in the night every time I demolish your arguments and point out your dishonesty.

Because it's going to happen a lot, until you're willing to admit error.
 
Chicken or egg.

If I had to say what the root cause was I'd go with the housing. I undestand what you are saying FT, but at the end of the day, the price of "land" remained fairly steady while the price of a "lot" increased. The only way the "land" increased in value was buy putting a house on it. To me that means the house is the key factor.
 
Chicken or egg.
Sigh. It doesn't matter why the lot is valuable. The question is, "is the lot valuable?" If the answer is "yes," I'm right. Period.

Edit: what you're doing here (and I know, you're just following Francesca's lead) is like saying "tires don't have any value. Yes, I know people pay considerable sums of money for them, but they only buy them because they need them for cars. Really, if you think about it, that's car value, not tire value." It's just a dishonest argument.

If I had to say what the root cause was I'd go with the housing.
But that doesn't make any sense. Say I want to build a house. I hire an architect and a GC, and I have one built. I pay the people who created the house. That's a payment for housing.

But before I did any of that, I had to pay a landowner for a site on which to build a house. That's a payment for land.


It doesn't matter what I choose to use the land for: what matters is what factor of production my money is going to. Note, also, that when I paid the GC and architect to design and build my house, I was trading the product of my labor for the product of their labor, whereas when I paid the landowner for use of the land, I was simply paying the ransom he demanded so that I could use the land that existed without any help from anyone.

I undestand what you are saying FT, but at the end of the day, the price of "land" remained fairly steady while the price of a "lot" increased.
?? Land is parceled out in lots. If the price of "lots" increased, that literally means the price of land increased. What you're saying is like someone who owned a lot which appreciated in value over the run-up and sold it for a large gain telling his friends that he made a killing selling "housing."

But obviously he wouldn't tell his friends he made a killing selling housing, because he manifestly sold land.

The only way the "land" increased in value was buy putting a house on it. To me that means the house is the key factor.
No, that's false. It was worth more before the house was put on it, and irrespective of whether the house, once built, remained or burnt down. Land values are the premium paid to use land in areas where people wish to live and work.
 
Last edited:
But I still haven't had my definition of a popped bubble !!!
I provided the definition of a bubble. If you're unable to see what a popped bubble is based on that definition, I can't help you.

It also seems like you didn't get any of my points. Somehow, I'm not surprised.
You shouldn't be, because you had no points.
 
But I still haven't had my definition of a popped bubble !!!

It also seems like you didn't get any of my points. Somehow, I'm not surprised.

You never will. Because he doesn't have one.



Par for the course.

You can't be this thick, can you?

He already gave you a definition of a financial bubble. One of the features of a bubble is that when the speculative frenzy reaches its peak the bubble bursts or pops, and there is a rapid, catastrophic fall in prices. Like the bursting of a bubble. Oil drops to 30% of its former value. Housing prices drop 50%. Internet stocks lose 80% of their value.

Now what was your point? Do you have one?
 
You can't be this thick, can you?
No, of course not. When someone very much invested in not being wrong realizes he is wrong, he must come up with some tactic to avoid discussing the issue.

Believe it or not, I've actually encountered this exact tack before. On Paul Birch's forum, I and several other posters utterly demolished every argument contained in his ridiculous "Critique of Georgism." His answer was to demand I provide a definition of "amount of land." Literally, he wanted a definition, not for land, but for amount of land. Demanding a definition for a "popped bubble" is much the same thing. It's an obvious attempt to just demand the impossible so as to avoid being demolished on substantive points.
 
Believe it or not, I've actually encountered this exact tack before. On Paul Birch's forum, I and several other posters utterly demolished every argument contained in his ridiculous "Critique of Georgism." His answer was to demand I provide a definition of "amount of land." Literally, he wanted a definition, not for land, but for amount of land. Demanding a definition for a "popped bubble" is much the same thing. It's an obvious attempt to just demand the impossible so as to avoid being demolished on substantive points.

You should go back there. Because every argument you have made here has been utterly demolished. I know I have personally destroyed you on every point. Frensesca and Drkitten have done the same. Maybe you are the brightest poster on Paul Birch's (whoever that is) forum (highly unlikely), but I suspect they don't exactly have geniuses posting there.

Like I've said before, a year from now, long after you have left in total humiliation, I'll still be here. You'll be long gone, and the subject of one of those "Whatever happened to..." threads.

And we still won't have a definition of "popped bubble".
 
Oh, I can be VERY thick when I want to get a point across.
Well, you have clearly demonstrated that you can be very thick when you want to get a point across. What you have not demonstrated is whether you can stop. ;)

Why, I do. Of course, since I already made it...

My mistake for assuming you were trying to communicate. Carry on. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom