"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

No, I have a ridiculous poster problem.

What an amazing coincidence! So do I. We have so much in common !


Post number ? Hell, in each case it was the post I made right before the one you were replying to. Perhaps reading what I write would help.

No, but you're just being stupid.

Isn't that nice. It can insult us.

But since you've just admitted that saying that "the price of everything went up" if the price of a single item went up, why, oh why, don't you apply that to, say, apples and fruit ? In fact, how do you determine how to "average" the price for any group of items ? Where do you stop and how do you determine when it's ridiculous or useless to say so and when it ain't ? And remember that groupings of items are arbitrary.

To talk about some land as apples and the rest as fruit in general is a stretch enough as it is

You mean it's like comparing apples to land ? :D

You'd rather retreat to absurdities, so here we are.

Absurdities ? I was bringing your argument to its logical conclusion. In order to counter that you'd need to tell me why we should stop at all fruits, or all lands, rather than consider everything else. Of course, in the end any line you draw will be arbitrary. Also, since, as we've hinted at before, everything is connected, one way or another, the price of one thing has the potential to affect everything else, in theory.

But since that's not very useful we're usually looking for more direct consequences. So, as far as I'm concerned, if the price of apples goes up and it has no discernable on the price of other fruits, then it is false, not just imprecise, to say that the price of all fruit went up.

Now, land isn't fruit, but lands can be broken up into several types of lands, each with their own market and their own potential buyers. So just because one type of land has a price increase doesn't necessarily mean that you can claim that the price of lands went up. The price of some lands went up.

Same goes for Ford Focuses and Audis.

No, that's false. You made a stupidly false claim, and I demolished it. Period.

Well, that's nice, but you don't get to decide what I said. You built a ridiculous strawman and claimed victory by hacking it to pieces. How convincing.

You're evidently unable to determine what a circular argument is.

Well, neither are you, it seems, since you can't even tell you're using one.

Oh, and retract this claim.

How about not ?

Nope. Land prices will only drop if demand drops. Period.
The value of land is due to three factors: the materials nature provides, the opportunities and amenities the community provides, and the services and infrastructure government provides.
No, it cannot, by definition. It can vary by what's allowed to be put on it, however. And how often are homes built in areas where land has very little or no value? Pretty much never.

You don't seem to leave much interpretation, there. Nope, period, never, etc.

No, it proves that location is of primary importance, and house value comes second.

In most cases, yes.

This is a very exceptional circumstance, and you know it.

Yes. Yes, I do.

No, that's false.

The price of land can't increase based on the building that's ON it ? But I'm sure you agree that the price of land can increase based on the building right next to it, right ? So why not its own building ?
 
Post number ? Hell, in each case it was the post I made right before the one you were replying to. Perhaps reading what I write would help.
So in other words, no, that's not what you were saying.

Isn't that nice. It can insult us.

But since you've just admitted that saying that "the price of everything went up" if the price of a single item went up, why, oh why, don't you apply that to, say, apples and fruit ?
I'm not admitting any such thing. You've now taken to lying in every post.

In fact, how do you determine how to "average" the price for any group of items ? Where do you stop and how do you determine when it's ridiculous or useless to say so and when it ain't ? And remember that groupings of items are arbitrary.
Are you seriously asking that question? I mean, seriously?

Absurdities ? I was bringing your argument to its logical conclusion.
No, you weren't. You were creating a strawman. It's just obvious to anyone who's not a total retard that if the price of apples goes up, the price of fruit goes up. You know it, but you're trying to find ways to avoid knowing it, because it proves your point false.

In order to counter that you'd need to tell me why we should stop at all fruits, or all lands, rather than consider everything else.
Duh, because we group things according to what we're trying to understand.

Of course, in the end any line you draw will be arbitrary. Also, since, as we've hinted at before, everything is connected, one way or another, the price of one thing has the potential to affect everything else, in theory.
Inanity.

What does any of this have to do with my original point? Nothing whatever. But you love it, because it allows you to look busy while avoiding the point.

But since that's not very useful we're usually looking for more direct consequences. So, as far as I'm concerned, if the price of apples goes up and it has no discernable on the price of other fruits, then it is false, not just imprecise, to say that the price of all fruit went up.
But that's a strawman. I didn't say "all fruit." I said "fruit," a group of which apples are a member.

Now, land isn't fruit, but lands can be broken up into several types of lands, each with their own market and their own potential buyers. So just because one type of land has a price increase doesn't necessarily mean that you can claim that the price of lands went up. The price of some lands went up.
?? Where did I ever say the price of "lands" went up? This is just another lie. I said the price of land went up, and it indisputably did. I never said all land went up in price, and certainly never used the word "lands."

Same goes for Ford Focuses and Audis.
But, again, if we're talking about cars, the increase in price of either is an increase in price.

Well, that's nice, but you don't get to decide what I said. You built a ridiculous strawman and claimed victory by hacking it to pieces. How convincing.
What strawman is that? Direct quotes please.

Well, neither are you, it seems, since you can't even tell you're using one.
I'm not using one. "I can say the sky is blue because the sky is blue" is not a circular argument. In fact, it's not even an argument.

How about not ?
Nice job, snipping what I wrote out, so it's not obvious you lied about what I wrote. I'll bring it back:

"No, I specifically said virtually no one. Stop outright lying about what I wrote."

You said I said no one. But I specifically said virtually no one. Now man up and admit your dishonesty.

You don't seem to leave much interpretation, there. Nope, period, never, etc.
Is this supposed to be some kind of point?

The price of land can't increase based on the building that's ON it ? But I'm sure you agree that the price of land can increase based on the building right next to it, right ? So why not its own building ?
?? Because the building excludes other uses of the land.
 
Relevance: 0.

It doesn't surprise me that you find no relevance.

?? Are you seriously trying to be this dishonest? Obviously, if there's some government intrusion blocking the use of the land, it won't have value. Duh.

If that's all you got, you're very, very destroyed.

A last ditch effort on your part, a random accusation of dishonesty. Exactly what I would expect from a cornered troll. Well done.
 
Freethinkr and Belz... can you oth summarise your opposing points in less than 200 words? I want to know how this started without reading 10 pages of arguments, also I think it might help you guy to get a grip on your opposing strands of thought...
 
So in other words, no, that's not what you were saying.

Let me get this straight... the fact that I insist that that's what I meant is proof to you that it wasn't ? If that's the way you reach conclusions based on premises then it's no wonder we're having problems communicating.

I'm not admitting any such thing. You've now taken to lying in every post.

I never lie, so no. Missing in my sentence was "is ridiculous". So, again, if you can't say it for "everything", why should you for "fruit" ?

Are you seriously asking that question? I mean, seriously?

Dodge noted.

No, you weren't. You were creating a strawman. It's just obvious to anyone who's not a total retard that if the price of apples goes up, the price of fruit goes up. You know it, but you're trying to find ways to avoid knowing it, because it proves your point false.

So, in other words, the price of everything ALSO goes up, right ?

What does any of this have to do with my original point? Nothing whatever. But you love it, because it allows you to look busy while avoiding the point.

You know, instead of saying "sigh" and "inanity" and "stupid" and "destroyed" and whatever, you might actually want to answer my points, now. Otherwise it seems as though you're just trying to bore me, not debate me.

But that's a strawman. I didn't say "all fruit." I said "fruit," a group of which apples are a member.

Sounds like a useless distinction. "Fruit", by definition, includes all fruit. If you mean "some fruit", then fine.

?? Where did I ever say the price of "lands" went up? This is just another lie. I said the price of land went up, and it indisputably did. I never said all land went up in price, and certainly never used the word "lands."

This is getting eerie.

But, again, if we're talking about cars, the increase in price of either is an increase in price.

The original argument, if you remember, was that a decrease in the availability of the Focus will, or not, affect the price of Audis.

What strawman is that? Direct quotes please.

Did you just learn the term "strawman" ? Because now that I've highlighted one of yours you've mentioned the term thrice in the same post.

I'm not using one. "I can say the sky is blue because the sky is blue" is not a circular argument. In fact, it's not even an argument.

Well, yeah. It's a conclusion based on a premise. In this case both are the same, ergo the term "circular".

Nice job, snipping what I wrote out, so it's not obvious you lied about what I wrote. I'll bring it back:

"No, I specifically said virtually no one. Stop outright lying about what I wrote."

Where did you say "virtually" ? You keep saying that but I don't see a quote, either. Are you denying that you said what I quoted ?

You said I said no one. But I specifically said virtually no one. Now man up and admit your dishonesty.

My dishonesty ? You're the one making up what you said as you go along.

?? Because the building excludes other uses of the land.

No, it doesn't. You can have multiple uses for the same land.
 
Freethinkr and Belz... can you oth summarise your opposing points in less than 200 words?

Yes, I can.

My point is that free "thinkr" is simplifying things by saying that "land is land", while clearly there are different types of land and one type is not necessarily affected by what happens to another type.

Of course, the whole argument's been lost in accusations of dishonesty, evasion and about-faces.
 
Let me get this straight... the fact that I insist that that's what I meant is proof to you that it wasn't ? If that's the way you reach conclusions based on premises then it's no wonder we're having problems communicating.
The fact that you refuse to show where you said that proves you never did.

God knows what you supposedly meant.

I never lie, so no. Missing in my sentence was "is ridiculous". So, again, if you can't say it for "everything", why should you for "fruit" ?
Sigh. It's just incredible that you don't understand that the term everything means, literally, everything.

Dodge noted.
It's not a dodge. If you seriously don't understand this point, you're just incapable of understanding even the simplest of concepts. There's just no hope of meaningful discussion with someone who asks such a question.

So, in other words, the price of everything ALSO goes up, right ?
No. It would be accurate to say the price of "things" went up, though. But as I keep pointing out, and you keep refusing to know, everything means every thing.

You know, instead of saying "sigh" and "inanity" and "stupid" and "destroyed" and whatever, you might actually want to answer my points, now. Otherwise it seems as though you're just trying to bore me, not debate me.
You don't have points. That's the point. All you have is inanity. Just look at this reply: it has nothing to do with anything even tangentially related to the topic, or even economics generally. You've managed to retreat into utter absurdities, and have managed to derail this thread into a pointless discussion of god-knows-what.

Are you a lawyer, by chance?

Sounds like a useless distinction. "Fruit", by definition, includes all fruit. If you mean "some fruit", then fine.
Fruit includes all fruit, but if you say fruit increased in price, it doesn't follow that all fruit increased in price.

Did you just learn the term "strawman" ? Because now that I've highlighted one of yours you've mentioned the term thrice in the same post.
Al Bundy would be proud of that Dodge.

Well, yeah. It's a conclusion based on a premise. In this case both are the same, ergo the term "circular".
No, it's not a conclusion based on a premise.

Where did you say "virtually" ? You keep saying that but I don't see a quote, either. Are you denying that you said what I quoted ?
Ah, I didn't say "virtually," I said "pretty much." Here it is:

"No, it cannot, by definition. It can vary by what's allowed to be put on it, however. And how often are homes built in areas where land has very little or no value? Pretty much never."

My dishonesty ? You're the one making up what you said as you go along.
No I'm not.

No, it doesn't. You can have multiple uses for the same land.
Not if there's a building on it! Hello?
 
Yes, I can.

My point is that free "thinkr" is simplifying things by saying that "land is land", while clearly there are different types of land and one type is not necessarily affected by what happens to another type.
Which is a completely irrelevant point. Sometimes there's no need for detail; that something's a simplification is only relevant if it's over-simplified in regard to the argument at hand.

You, of course, have never shown any such thing, or even argued to that effect. Your "point," on which this entire sad derail is based, isn't a point at all. It's just a three ring circus sideshow.

Of course, the whole argument's been lost in accusations of dishonesty, evasion and about-faces.
More like a string of attempted nit-picking that invariably ends up badly for you.
 
Could one of the mods please split the discussion of land values to its own thread? Every time someone attempts to discuss the opening post they are drowned out by by this incessant squabbling.
 
The fact that you refuse to show where you said that proves you never did.

Actually, it doesn't "prove" anything. But, hey, it's your funeral, not mine:

you said:
me said:
you said:
me said:
you said:
me said:
You said:
Tell me: if the price of apples goes up, and the price of all other fruit stays the same, is it accurate to say "the price of fruit increased" or not?
I wouldn't. On average, sure. But then, why would you want to ?
Say you own a grocery store. Someone asks: "what are produce prices like now?" He answers "prices for produce are up right now." He might add "but the increase is all apples," but that's unnecessary information.
Does that mean we're in agreement ?
No, it means you're wrong. His first statement was true without the additional information.
Which is precisely why I said that. It's pointless to say it because it's always true, anyway.
That's not what you were saying.

If you look at my first reply, I said that "on average" the price went up, but that it's useless to do so. Then you go and say that the additional information is useless. Then I say that this is what I was saying, to which you immediately disagree.

Of course, then there's this:

you said:
me said:
It's like saying that, since the price of apples (or a particular type of land) went up, everything, on average, now costs more money.
[and later...]
Which comes back to what I was saying: if the price of apples goes up, and no other product on earth varies in price, then the price of everything went up, according to you.
You weren't saying that

You have a very short memory.

Sigh. It's just incredible that you don't understand that the term everything means, literally, everything.

Indeed. The price of everything would, of course, only include things that have a price, but I still don't see why you would exclude some things and not others.

It's not a dodge. If you seriously don't understand this point, you're just incapable of understanding even the simplest of concepts. There's just no hope of meaningful discussion with someone who asks such a question.

It's amazing how many insults you fling around instead of, you know, actually making a point.

No. It would be accurate to say the price of "things" went up, though.

And "things", by definition, doesn't include every "thing" ?

Let me get this straight, when you said "the price of lands went up" you meant "the price of some lands went up" ? If that's the case, then this is a silly misunderstanding between us. One, I might add, that you could've avoided by being clear.

You don't have points. That's the point. All you have is inanity. Just look at this reply: it has nothing to do with anything even tangentially related to the topic, or even economics generally. You've managed to retreat into utter absurdities, and have managed to derail this thread into a pointless discussion of god-knows-what.

Asking you to stop throwing tantrums is unrelated ?

Fruit includes all fruit, but if you say fruit increased in price, it doesn't follow that all fruit increased in price.

:boggled:

Al Bundy would be proud of that Dodge.

It's not a dodge. It's pointing out that you seem very fond of that word since I brought it up.

No, it's not a conclusion based on a premise.

Why, yes is it. The use of the word "because" pretty much shows that.

"No, it cannot, by definition. It can vary by what's allowed to be put on it, however. And how often are homes built in areas where land has very little or no value? Pretty much never."

Yes, you did say "pretty much", instead of "virtually". If I did what you do I'd acuse you of lying about it. But I know you were using the words interchangeably. However, "pretty much never", the way I understand it, implies that it either never happens or happens so rarely as to, for all intents and purposes, never happen. This is not the case.

Not if there's a building on it! Hello?

Hello what ? You've never seen someone have a house AND a farm on the same lot ? We see that quite a bit, here. Or a small commerce on the first floor and an appartment on the second. See ? Those are different uses. But I guess those examples are too complicated.

More like a string of attempted nit-picking that invariably ends up badly for you.

I do nit-pick a lot. But that's what happens when you make sweeping generalizations.
 
Actually, it doesn't "prove" anything. But, hey, it's your funeral, not mine:

...

If you look at my first reply, I said that "on average" the price went up, but that it's useless to do so.
?? "I said that [saying] that "on average" the price went up?"

Then you go and say that the additional information is useless. Then I say that this is what I was saying, to which you immediately disagree.

Of course, then there's this:

..

You have a very short memory.
Ah. You think that when I said "[n]o, it means you're wrong. His first statement was true without the additional information," that I meant that his saying the price of produce went up. The useless information would be that it was all in apples, because that's not what the hypothetical questioner asked.

Likewise, it's not necessary for me to qualify that certain areas of land increased more than others when I say the price of land went up. I was trying to point out the general relationship between the economy and land values. The specifics of the claim are irrelevant unless others accept the general position.

Indeed. The price of everything would, of course, only include things that have a price, but I still don't see why you would exclude some things and not others.
If you say the price of everything went up, you're saying the price of every thing went up. If you say the price of produce went up, you're not saying that the price of every kind of produce went up.

This is so tedious and exhausting, over such a useless and stupid quibble.

It's amazing how many insults you fling around instead of, you know, actually making a point.
I've made many points in this thread. You've made none.

And "things", by definition, doesn't include every "thing" ?
It includes every thing, but does not imply that each kind increased in price. Everything does.

Let me get this straight, when you said "the price of lands went up" you meant "the price of some lands went up" ? If that's the case, then this is a silly misunderstanding between us. One, I might add, that you could've avoided by being clear.
Yes! You've finally got it. It's a very, very silly misunderstanding we're having. But I don't see how you find me at fault. You could have just asked for clarification. Instead, you acted as though you've somehow defeated my point by showing some inconsistency.

Asking you to stop throwing tantrums is unrelated ?
I'm just trying to show you what you're doing. People can be dishonest with themselves. They can encounter an idea which they find displeasing, and find ways of avoiding knowing the facts which prove them wrong. For some, faith will do; they can deal with the honest knowledge that they're just flatly refusing to know facts which seemingly contradict their beliefs. For those incapable of that sort of faith, there's absurdities. Focus on tangential nits, and you can avoid having to deal with the displeasing argument.

If I say "people like dogs," it's understood that I don't necessarily mean that all people like dogs, even though it's understood that "people" includes all humans. That's why we have the term "every." "Everybody" or "everything" are the terms which describe all persons and all things respectively.

It's not a dodge. It's pointing out that you seem very fond of that word since I brought it up.
Right, which enables you to avoid addressing the quoted portion. If it were even an argument, it'd be a red herring.

Why, yes is it. The use of the word "because" pretty much shows that.
Sigh. You need to be willing to know the difference between a statement of fact and an argument.

Yes, you did say "pretty much", instead of "virtually". If I did what you do I'd acuse you of lying about it. But I know you were using the words interchangeably. However, "pretty much never", the way I understand it, implies that it either never happens or happens so rarely as to, for all intents and purposes, never happen. This is not the case.
It is the case. By value, the vast majority of fixed improvements are made to land with high value.

Hello what ? You've never seen someone have a house AND a farm on the same lot ? We see that quite a bit, here. Or a small commerce on the first floor and an appartment on the second. See ? Those are different uses. But I guess those examples are too complicated.
Sigh. The land's value is its highest and best use: the price people are wiling to pay for land depends on its relative economic advantage, which depends on possible uses. The buildings people put on land and the labor they perform on it do not affect land values: what affects land values is the difference between the returns to the labor they perform and the improvements they make to land, relative to marginal land.

I do nit-pick a lot. But that's what happens when you make sweeping generalizations.
See above. Probably, you're wrong a lot.
 
Last edited:
?? "I said that [saying] that "on average" the price went up?"

What was this all about ?

Ah. You think that when I said "[n]o, it means you're wrong. His first statement was true without the additional information," that I meant that his saying the price of produce went up. The useless information would be that it was all in apples, because that's not what the hypothetical questioner asked.

My bad, then. Of course, the way I thought you meant it made more sense. But of course, I wouldn't expect you to think that the more precise information is better, seeing as how you like to simplify things.

But I suppose that's one way to do it. See how communication helps ?

If you say the price of everything went up, you're saying the price of every thing went up. If you say the price of produce went up, you're not saying that the price of every kind of produce went up.

Well, yeah. Now I get what you meant by it. It's just not obvious from the words you're using until, now, you actually explain yourself.

I've made many points in this thread. You've made none.

Of course I have. Mind you, a few of them were made against a position you (seemingly now) don't hold, because of (seemingly now) a misunderstanding.

Yes! You've finally got it. It's a very, very silly misunderstanding we're having. But I don't see how you find me at fault. You could have just asked for clarification.

Now, that's a pet peeve of mine: how could I possibly ask for clarification when I thought that what you said was crystal clear ?

Instead, you acted as though you've somehow defeated my point by showing some inconsistency.

I was trying to show that it was wrong to say what I thought it was you were saying.

For those incapable of that sort of faith, there's absurdities. Focus on tangential nits, and you can avoid having to deal with the displeasing argument.

Uh-huh, but that's not what I was doing.

If I say "people like dogs," it's understood that I don't necessarily mean that all people like dogs, even though it's understood that "people" includes all humans. That's why we have the term "every." "Everybody" or "everything" are the terms which describe all persons and all things respectively.

Okay, okay. I got it, already. I the price of "things" went up, though, which is still a pretty useless statement (too vague).

It is the case. By value, the vast majority of fixed improvements are made to land with high value.

I've already agreed to that, if memory serves.


Again, you might want to get that checked out.

See above. Probably, you're wrong a lot.

Oh, quite. It happens to me quite often. You ?
 
What was this all about ?
Your sentence, as constructed, did not make sense. I added in brackets the word I thought was missing. Was that what you meant to say?

My bad, then. Of course, the way I thought you meant it made more sense. But of course, I wouldn't expect you to think that the more precise information is better, seeing as how you like to simplify things.

But I suppose that's one way to do it. See how communication helps ?
More precise information isn't necessarily better. If someone asks about the prices of produce, that's all the information necessary.

Well, yeah. Now I get what you meant by it. It's just not obvious from the words you're using until, now, you actually explain yourself.
It was obvious all along.

Of course I have. Mind you, a few of them were made against a position you (seemingly now) don't hold, because of (seemingly now) a misunderstanding.
Picking a nit isn't a point. It's a refusal to engage in a discussion.

Now, that's a pet peeve of mine: how could I possibly ask for clarification when I thought that what you said was crystal clear ?
Your interpretation was so ridiculous, a normal person would wonder how anyone could make such a claim, and ask if that's what he really meant.

Okay, okay. I got it, already. I the price of "things" went up, though, which is still a pretty useless statement (too vague).
It's useful if someone asks if the price of things has gone up.

I've already agreed to that, if memory serves.
Not really.

Oh, quite. It happens to me quite often. You ?
Yeah, that's how I got here. I initially read Progress & Poverty with the intent of finding the hole in the argument. But I found there is no hole: the problem was my lack of comprehensive understanding of the issue.
 
It was obvious all along.

Thinkr, if it was obvious, I would've understood it. Since I didn't, it wasn't, unless I've got some sort of defect that prevents me from reading sentences. And, if that were the case, I wouldn't pankake turbine the begin success knot !

... uh oh.

Picking a nit isn't a point. It's a refusal to engage in a discussion.

Well, I'm sorry about that, I just think that details are often very important, as they are, more often than you may realise, at the heart of the discussion.

Your interpretation was so ridiculous, a normal person would wonder how anyone could make such a claim, and ask if that's what he really meant.

Well, it's amazing how many people hold ridiculous beliefs, so I wouldn't have been surprised at all.
 
So, the stock market rallied 4% today. Have we hit bottom, or is this just a dead cat bounce on the way to the worst depression in US history?

That was the topic of this thread, was it not?
 
Dead cats don't bounce, gdnp.

However, I personally doubt that this one will beat the great depression. Although I live in Canada, I don't see myself eating soup with the homeless people anytime soon.
 
Dead cats don't bounce, gdnp.

Au contraire. "Even a dead cat will bounce if you drop it from high enough". If you prefer, you can call it a sucker's rally.

However, I personally doubt that this one will beat the great depression. Although I live in Canada, I don't see myself eating soup with the homeless people anytime soon.
I tend to agree. As long as BAC and his ilk are kept away from the levers of finance I don't think we will be seeing 25% unemployment.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom