"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

Anyone have any comments on this? I just want to know what you think, is he full of it or is he pretty accurate like usual?

well anyone who gets the sequence of things wrong when he is waffling merely so that he can make things seem worse to fit his "pattern" doesn't get much cred in the prognostication department.

as for the "pretty accurate" did oyu have anything approaching statistical analysis to back up the claim or is this just the "usual BS"?
 
Sigh. It doesn't matter why the lot is valuable. The question is, "is the lot valuable?" If the answer is "yes," I'm right. Period.

This is the equivilent of explaining colour to someone who's colour blind. You see the brown earth of the land as the reason for it's value, I see what is on (or may be on) the land as the reason for it's value. 5 acres of tidal mudflats or cliff faces has no value because nothing can be done with it. 5 acres of flat, well drained land in a city centre has value but only because you can build something on it. The value will then depend on what you are allowed (or can afford) to build on it. It is still only 5 acres of land but it is land that can be used. It is the use that gives it value, not the fact that it is land.

Now if all land is equal, I'll take my five acres in the city centre and you can have the tidal mudflats. Why not, it's all God given land?

Steve
 
You should go back there. Because every argument you have made here has been utterly demolished. I know I have personally destroyed you on every point.
Well, that's clearly false, as you've never made any point at all in responses to what I wrote.

Frensesca and Drkitten have done the same.
Also false. I've comprehensively demolished most of their arguments.

Maybe you are the brightest poster on Paul Birch's (whoever that is) forum (highly unlikely), but I suspect they don't exactly have geniuses posting there.
Well, that's true, but irrelevant. The point is, people who have no other arguments generally follow the same pattern. People such as yourself.

Like I've said before, a year from now, long after you have left in total humiliation, I'll still be here. You'll be long gone, and the subject of one of those "Whatever happened to..." threads.
Like I said before, you ought to retire from the prediction game.

And we still won't have a definition of "popped bubble".
Of course, because no one defines phrases such as "popped bubble." The meaning is obvious if you know the definition of "bubble."
 
Last edited:
This is the equivilent of explaining colour to someone who's colour blind. You see the brown earth of the land as the reason for it's value, I see what is on (or may be on) the land as the reason for it's value.
The bolded portion is false. I have already explained, several times with perfect clarity, that the value of land arises from three things. I'll do so yet again, just because I'm such a nice guy:

1. the materials provided by nature
2. the opportunities and amenities provided by the community
3. the infrastructure and services provided by government

To the extent land has value, it is due to one of these three factors. That said, the source of the value is irrelevant. The point is that it's the land, or the site, NOT JUST HOUSES that has value.

5 acres of tidal mudflats or cliff faces has no value because nothing can be done with it.
Unless the cliff faces are composed of materials that are useful, yes. The community doesn't provide any opportunities or amenities to cliff faces, and the government doesn't service them.

5 acres of flat, well drained land in a city centre has value but only because you can build something on it.
You can build on land in the desert, but it has no value. The difference is that the land in the city center gives its owner the economic advantage of access to the opportunities and amenities provided by the community, and the infrastructure and services provided by the government.

The value will then depend on what you are allowed (or can afford) to build on it. It is still only 5 acres of land but it is land that can be used. It is the use that gives it value, not the fact that it is land.
?? Yes, but you're not arguing whether land has value, you're arguing over why it has value.

You've essentially conceded the argument, while trying to change what the argument is all about and pretend you haven't conceded the point. But even your alternate point is wrong, because land doesn't have value based on what can be built on it, but has value based on the factors I identified.

Now if all land is equal, I'll take my five acres in the city centre and you can have the tidal mudflats. Why not, it's all God given land?

Steve
Yes, but no one has any exclusive right to either (or, to put it another way, everyone has equal right to all land). If someone wishes to use the mud flats, he's not depriving anyone else of what they'd otherwise have: the fact that the land has no value shows that no one else wants to use it. But the person who gets use of the land in the center of a city is depriving others of what they'd otherwise have: the fact that the land has great value proves that others would like to use the land; their opportunity to use that land has been extinguished without compensation by the government issuance of land titles.
 
Chicken or egg.

If I had to say what the root cause was I'd go with the housing. I understand what you are saying FT, but at the end of the day, the price of "land" remained fairly steady while the price of a "lot" increased. The only way the "land" increased in value was buy putting a house on it. To me that means the house is the key factor.


No, the problem was not housing or even mortgages. It was with the fraudulent representation of the underlying risk, which was given with the imprimatur of the US government.
 
Not wishing to beat a dead horse, but the housing situation is not unlike Chemistry. With every chemical reaction there will be a rate determining step and a limiting reagent. The same goes for housing.

To build new houses requires land, labor, capital, and materials. In a place where land is scarce and labor and materials are plentiful, The price of a lot will determine most of the final cost. If land is plentiful but there are few contractors, the contractors will raise the rates and reap most of the profits. If there is a shortage of building supplies, but lots of land and underutilized labor, then building supply prices will rise. If there is lots of land, lots of supplies, lots of willing workers, but no one willing to lend money, then the price of borrowing will come into play: you can afford a much larger loan at 4% than at 8%. It all depends on local conditions: elasticity of supply of labor, capital, land, and materials.
 
Not wishing to beat a dead horse, but the housing situation is not unlike Chemistry. With every chemical reaction there will be a rate determining step and a limiting reagent. The same goes for housing.

To build new houses requires land, labor, capital, and materials. In a place where land is scarce and labor and materials are plentiful, The price of a lot will determine most of the final cost. If land is plentiful but there are few contractors, the contractors will raise the rates and reap most of the profits. If there is a shortage of building supplies, but lots of land and underutilized labor, then building supply prices will rise. If there is lots of land, lots of supplies, lots of willing workers, but no one willing to lend money, then the price of borrowing will come into play: you can afford a much larger loan at 4% than at 8%. It all depends on local conditions: elasticity of supply of labor, capital, land, and materials.
This is all true of any specific time and place, but in the aggregate, over long periods of time, the market tends toward certain equilibria.

George largely came to write Progress & Poverty because he noticed an interesting phenomenon: he noticed wages and interest (profits) were higher in the newly-settled West than they were in the more-thoroughly settled East; likewise, he noted that wages were higher in the comparatively less built-up US than it was in the comparatively more built-up Britain. Finally, he noted that, as San Francisco grew, and land values increase, wages and interest decreased correspondingly. The fact is, once the free land runs out, all producers are competing with one another for use of land. This can have no other result than skimming the synergistic value of society off the top.

Interestingly, in certain instances the relationship between landowners and laborers became practically as bad as the relationship between slave-owners and slaves, and arguably worse:

We have abolished negro slavery in the United States. But how small is the real benefit to the slave. George M. Jackson writes me from St. Louis, under date of August 15, 1883:​
During the war I served in a Kentucky regiment in the Federal army. When the war broke out, my father owned sixty slaves. I had not been back to my old Kentucky home for years until a short time ago, when I was met by one of my father's old negroes, who said to me: "Mas George, you say you sot us free; but 'fore God, I'm wus off than when I belonged to your father." The planters, on the other hand, are contented with the change. They say: "How foolish it was in us to go to war for slavery. We get labor cheaper now than when we owned the slaves." How do they get it cheaper? Why, in the shape of rents they take more of the labor of the negro than they could under slavery, for then they were compelled to return him sufficient food, clothing and medical attendance to keep him well, and were compelled by conscience and public opinion, as well as by law, to keep him when he could no longer work. Now their interest and responsibility cease when they have got all the work out of him they can.​

--Henry George, Social Problems, Ch. 15​

Our modern banking system changed the equilibrium. Now the financial sector works with the RE sector and the Insurance sector (together, "FIRE") to change the rules in their favor, allowing them to collect ever-greater rents from the economy. I really think everyone should take a look at this link; printed quite a while ago, but undeniably relevant now. The rules of our society are such that the economy tends toward an equilibrium which is both inherently unstable, and acts to transfer wealth from the lowest classes to the highest classes.
 
Oh, it was worth saying once.

Unless you think that the market for Ford Focuses is the same as the market for Audis.

Well, as someone who could afford and Audi and drives a Ford Focus, I would say that the markets, if not the same, at least substantially overlap.

ETA: I was, ironically, having this discussion with a friend yesterday. Her husband wants to buy a Lexus SUV for $79,000, which they can afford. I am, literally, driving a 2000 Ford Focus that cost me $14,000. I do not find the marginal benefit to me of the Lexus SUV worth $65,000, even taking into account the higher resale value vs. higher insurance, maintenance, and fuel costs over the life of the car. So I continue with my focus, and spend my money on other things that bring me more pleasure. Quite frankly, I'd rather donate the money to charity than pay $79,000 for a car when there are perfectly good alternatives for a fraction of the cost.
 
Last edited:
Well, as someone who could afford and Audi and drives a Ford Focus, I would say that the markets, if not the same, at least substantially overlap.

ETA: I was, ironically, having this discussion with a friend yesterday. Her husband wants to buy a Lexus SUV for $79,000, which they can afford. I am, literally, driving a 2000 Ford Focus that cost me $14,000. I do not find the marginal benefit to me of the Lexus SUV worth $65,000, even taking into account the higher resale value vs. higher insurance, maintenance, and fuel costs over the life of the car. So I continue with my focus, and spend my money on other things that bring me more pleasure. Quite frankly, I'd rather donate the money to charity than pay $79,000 for a car when there are perfectly good alternatives for a fraction of the cost.

That's very practical of you and damned un-American.:p

Heck I've seen ladies turn guys down simply because they didn't drive a luxury import. To be fair the guys were probably only asking her out because she had implants and of course out here in California that kind of shallowness, for both genders, is par for the course.

Weren't we supposed to be talking about some Depression or something?
 
That's very practical of you and damned un-American.:p

Heck I've seen ladies turn guys down simply because they didn't drive a luxury import.
Another advantage of the focus. I'm not interested in such women anyway. ;)

Weren't we supposed to be talking about some Depression or something?
I suppose.

Spoil sport. :blush:
 
Well, as someone who could afford and Audi and drives a Ford Focus, I would say that the markets, if not the same, at least substantially overlap.

Oh, absolutely.

But my point was that fewer Focuses doesn't mean that Audis will sell more or that their price will increase. Same goes for land. One land and another may simply not be part of the same market. Therefore the lack of one doesn't mean the price of the other will necesarily go up.
 
Oh, absolutely.

But my point was that fewer Focuses doesn't mean that Audis will sell more or that their price will increase. Same goes for land. One land and another may simply not be part of the same market. Therefore the lack of one doesn't mean the price of the other will necesarily go up.
But your point is irrelevant, because we're not talking about any specific area of land, but land as a whole. For land as a whole, increased demand means increased prices, even though the distribution of those increases isn't equal.
 
And that's why I talked about oversimplification, which went over your head, apparently.
?? For it to be an oversimplification, it must be overly simple in reference to some point. You haven't provided any such reference point. Obviously, when you're looking at the big picture, you don't go over every minute detail.
 
?? For it to be an oversimplification, it must be overly simple in reference to some point. You haven't provided any such reference point. Obviously, when you're looking at the big picture, you don't go over every minute detail.

And if the big picture is wrong????

Steve
 
And if the big picture is wrong????

Steve
But it's not. In the aggregate, prices will tend toward an equilibrium determined by supply and demand. Land is fixed in supply, so when aggregate demand increases, so too do aggregate land prices. Evidence bears this out.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom