Well, I think I have to agree.
I mean it's getting bogged down in semantics, but the argument is simple.
A house isn't a bottle of fine wine. It doesn't appreciate. If it goes up in value because of a school being built across the street, then the land went up in value, not the home. It's still a depreciating asset.
I disagree.
There is vacant plot of land near me, its price hasn't changed, the value of my house has, it's currently down from the peak but still has shown an increase. According to your theory the land should be going up and the net value of my bricks and mortar (overall value less land value) should be going down as it depreciates, it isn't. No doubt there is yet another special case to explain this but theories that rely on special cases aren't theories,they're just bending of the facts.
Steve
