"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

Well, I think I have to agree.

I mean it's getting bogged down in semantics, but the argument is simple.

A house isn't a bottle of fine wine. It doesn't appreciate. If it goes up in value because of a school being built across the street, then the land went up in value, not the home. It's still a depreciating asset.

I disagree.

There is vacant plot of land near me, its price hasn't changed, the value of my house has, it's currently down from the peak but still has shown an increase. According to your theory the land should be going up and the net value of my bricks and mortar (overall value less land value) should be going down as it depreciates, it isn't. No doubt there is yet another special case to explain this but theories that rely on special cases aren't theories,they're just bending of the facts.

Steve
 
I disagree.

There is vacant plot of land near me, its price hasn't changed, the value of my house has, it's currently down from the peak but still has shown an increase. According to your theory the land should be going up and the net value of my bricks and mortar (overall value less land value) should be going down as it depreciates, it isn't. No doubt there is yet another special case to explain this but theories that rely on special cases aren't theories,they're just bending of the facts.

Steve
Assuming your information is accurate (unlikely), it's the special case. Anyone can observe this for himself by checking with a Realtor.

Edit: by the way, are you claiming that your house, which is not only decaying, but is also becoming obsolete, is actually increasing in value?
 
Last edited:
no, really I have to say, it would be the land that is going up in value, not the property itself. unless i suppose there is a dramatic short term increase in property in the area, or if the house has some historical value.
 
This is wrong also. The land market is dynamic, and the areas which are in demand change in unpredictable ways. If you can get a hold of BC appraisal data, however, you'll have in your hands some of the best land value data in the world, and will see some interesting facts such as the fact that land comprises nearly half of total property values, and that land values did in fact increase rapidly over the last decade, just as I've said.

Um, no, it's right. I know, I live here, I've been assessed. That's the way it works kiddo.

Now you're just being silly.
 
You're wrong that assessments wouldn't be necessary.

Oh, well maybe you're right. In retrospect, Revenue Canada doesn't set the value of either.

As some people have noted, the value of the house has little to do with the price of the land. Houses routinely sell for $1 just so they can be removed from lots. It would suggest the "land" they are on is what has value.

I'm not buying it though. To me this point to the housing getting so ridiculously over inflated people will pay anything for the "lot" they sit on. The land has no value, the "lot" does. Once again we arrive at the housing boom inflating the price of land, not the other way around.

I lived in Vancouver for a few years. I can tell you for certain housing has driven up the price of land there. You can buy the most scenic lots in the mountains for pennies. The fact is land doesn't sell if you can't build on it in BC (or get to it) I'm not sure what land value data you are referencing?
 
'Beginning Now: The Panic Phase of the Collapse'

by Martin D. Weiss, Ph.D.

"...And precisely when the government has raised hopes for a recovery in 2010 …

The panic phase of this collapse is about to begin.

The panic phase is an acceleration in the economic decline … a chain reaction of debt explosions … a free-fall in the financial markets … and a series of rude awakenings that will accelerate the decline even further:

Rude Awakening #1

In a Collapse, Washington’s Economic
Forecasting Models Are Worthless.

Rude Awakening #2

The Economy Is Sinking Three to
Five Times Faster Than Expected.

Rude Awakening #3

The Dangerous, Unintended Consequences of the
Government’s Rescue Efforts Can Only Deepen,
Broaden and Prolong the Economic Decline.

Rude Awakening #4

Investors Who Fail to Take Protective
Action Could Lose as Much as 90 Percent
In Virtually Every Asset Imaginable."

http://www.moneyandmarkets.com/beginning-now-the-panic-phase-of-the-collapse-29932
 
I'm not buying it though. To me this point to the housing getting so ridiculously over inflated people will pay anything for the "lot" they sit on.
Once again, a "lot" is a parcel of land. It's a distinct location on the surface of the earth.

The land has no value, the "lot" does. Once again we arrive at the housing boom inflating the price of land, not the other way around.
Actually, it was an economic boom, and housing is just one of the first things people spend money on. But to get housing, you must necessarily purchase land; and due to the spacial aspect of reality, you generally must purchase land within a certain proximity of where you work. Thus, the rent of land in such areas increases rapidly.

I lived in Vancouver for a few years. I can tell you for certain housing has driven up the price of land there. You can buy the most scenic lots in the mountains for pennies.
The value of land comes from three factors:

1. the materials provided by nature
2. the opportunities and amenities provided by the community
3. the services and infrastructure provided by government

In the first place, though the land you speak of may be scenic, that's not to say we should predict much value via #1: perhaps the land is very difficult to utilize, beautiful though it may be. But more importantly, such locations give you virtually nothing from #2 or #3.

It's not that housing gives land value: it's that the community and government give land value, and thus people wish to build housing in the areas benefited by them. People want to have city water; they want to be located near good schools; they want access to a wide array of retailers and entertainment options. But if land is made into property, the owners of land in areas which have these things are enabled to internalize the benefit: they say to the community "if you wish to have access to these things, you must pay us for the privilege."

The fact is land doesn't sell if you can't build on it in BC (or get to it) I'm not sure what land value data you are referencing?
BC prints (or at least used to) annual data on property values, and breaks them down into land and improvement value. I've found it before on the web, but for whatever reason I can't now. It's one of the few places that uses the accurate, improvement-residual method, and the appraisals are generally precise to within 3% of the sale prices.
 
'Beginning Now: The Panic Phase of the Collapse'

by Martin D. Weiss, Ph.D.

"...And precisely when the government has raised hopes for a recovery in 2010 …

The panic phase of this collapse is about to begin.

The panic phase is an acceleration in the economic decline … a chain reaction of debt explosions … a free-fall in the financial markets … and a series of rude awakenings that will accelerate the decline even further:

Rude Awakening #1

In a Collapse, Washington’s Economic
Forecasting Models Are Worthless.

Rude Awakening #2

The Economy Is Sinking Three to
Five Times Faster Than Expected.

Rude Awakening #3

The Dangerous, Unintended Consequences of the
Government’s Rescue Efforts Can Only Deepen,
Broaden and Prolong the Economic Decline.

Rude Awakening #4

Investors Who Fail to Take Protective
Action Could Lose as Much as 90 Percent
In Virtually Every Asset Imaginable."

http://www.moneyandmarkets.com/beginning-now-the-panic-phase-of-the-collapse-29932

:faint:

Give me a break. The markets are up and "this is the best time in the world" the markets are down and "we are all going to die, get your bomb shelter ready."

This is a hit piece / gloom and doom prediction based 100% on the writers bias (either political or financial or both).

For instance, the last thing we should worry about in this economy is the debt of the government. Yes, it's going to be high, yes we are going to pay for it down the road (for many years in fact)....

BUT

We ARE going to get out of this mess and we are not going to go live in a cave any time soon.

The only way to dig out of this hole is to have a large infusion of cash, something that the average company or citizen can't do. And to me that is the POINT of a government, it should be there to do things for the collective whole that private individuals or corporations can't (or won't) do... go to the moon, protect our boarders and yes, stimulate the economy.

What a bunch of crap. Of course if enough people pass around articles like this one they can create even more fear, a manifest destiny.

Stop talking like it's the end of the world, stop spreading fear and the "not great" economy will not ever get to "really really bad."
 
But to get housing, you must necessarily purchase land; and due to the spacial aspect of reality, you generally must purchase land within a certain proximity of where you work. Thus, the rent of land in such areas increases rapidly.

Yes, the rent on land follows the need for housing. I'm glad you've finally seen this.

You need not purchase land, and in fact a majority of people in places like Vancouver don't. I'm not sure of the technical term, whether it is an "easement" or a "right of way", but people are allowed access to the property their dwelling is on.
 
Yes, the rent on land follows the need for housing. I'm glad you've finally seen this.
No, housing is located in areas where there's greater benefit. A house in the middle of the Sahara desert is worth jack ****.

You need not purchase land, and in fact a majority of people in places like Vancouver don't. I'm not sure of the technical term, whether it is an "easement" or a "right of way", but people are allowed access to the property their dwelling is on.
No, they're not giving locations away for free: someone's definitely getting paid for the land.
 
No, housing is located in areas where there's greater benefit. A house in the middle of the Sahara desert is worth jack ****.

lol, until there's a housing boom for whatever reasons.

What's with the flip flop? You clearly said people buy houses where they need to then the land increases rapidly?

The price of the house is measured in square feet, the land gets incorporated into that price. The square footage of the house increases the price of that land. Smaller house on the same square footage of land in the city will almost always sell for less, all things being equal. I realize the lot prices rose, but again, it's incidental to the need for lots to build on.

The value of land comes from three factors:

1. the materials provided by nature
2. the opportunities and amenities provided by the community
3. the services and infrastructure provided by government


As you've pointed out, 1. is only relevant when 2. and 3. are already implemented.

2.and 3. arise as a result of the need for housing. They sure as heck don't service or build roads to random pieces of land without establishing a need for housing.

Nice try, but you've got it backwards for whatever reasons. They are very closely tied to one another so I can see how you could get confused.
 
lol, until there's a housing boom for whatever reasons.
No, there was a housing boom, and land in the Sahara didn't boom.

What's with the flip flop? You clearly said people buy houses where they need to then the land increases rapidly?
No, they build houses in areas which benefit from the community and the government: in other words, they build in areas where land has value.

The price of the house is measured in square feet,
No, it's measured in dollars.

the land gets incorporated into that price. The square footage of the house increases the price of that land. Smaller house on the same square footage of land in the city will almost always sell for less, all things being equal. I realize the lot prices rose, but again, it's incidental to the need for lots to build on.
No, smaller houses are worth less, while the land is worth the same, so the property as a whole is worth less. Hello?

As you've pointed out, 1. is only relevant when 2. and 3. are already implemented.
That's false. Two people on a single island could argue over who gets to use the only arable land thereon.

2.and 3. arise as a result of the need for housing. They sure as heck don't service or build roads to random pieces of land without establishing a need for housing.
Sigh. Are you being serious here? The government roads and services and the communal amenities and opportunities are there for human beings. So too are the houses.

Why is housing located where it is? Because that's where people want to locate. It's not the other way around. This is not "Field of Dreams." It's not build it and they will come. On the contrary, people wish to locate in certain areas, so housing is built to accommodate them.

Do you think it's just a coincidence that the vast majority of large cities are located on some body of water?

Nice try, but you've got it backwards for whatever reasons. They are very closely tied to one another so I can see how you could get confused.
No, you've clearly got it backwards. Land doesn't have value because housing is located there: housing is located there because the land has value. It has value because of the three factors I've repeatedly identified.
 
No, you've clearly got it backwards. Land doesn't have value because housing is located there: housing is located there because the land has value.

This is the silliest thing I have ever heard. Residential land encroaches on cheaper farm land contiually. As the need for housing increases people move out towards the cheaper farm land and drive up the prices as they go. The price of land does not go up until such time as that. You can't even get farmland rezoned residential without demonstrating a need.
 
Free Thinkr said:
No, you've clearly got it backwards. Land doesn't have value because housing is located there: housing is located there because the land has value.
This is the silliest thing I have ever heard. Residential land encroaches on cheaper farm land contiually. As the need for housing increases people move out towards the cheaper farm land and drive up the prices as they go. The price of land does not go up until such time as that. You can't even get farmland rezoned residential without demonstrating a need.
Not just residential. Residential, industrial, and commercial. As the population grows, more land needs to be used in a more dense manner. But you prove me right: the need (demand) precedes the housing.
 
Not just residential. Residential, industrial, and commercial. As the population grows, more land needs to be used in a more dense manner. But you prove me right: the need (demand) precedes the housing.

Of course. Which precedes the increase in the value of land.

Ok, let's leave it at that. We agree to disagree. Just promise me you won't become a Developer, you'll go broke ;)
 
Free Thinkr said:
Not just residential. Residential, industrial, and commercial. As the population grows, more land needs to be used in a more dense manner. But you prove me right: the need (demand) precedes the housing.
Of course. Which precedes the increase in the value of land.
No, when demand increases, land values increase. Land values are merely a reflection of demand for land.

Ok, let's leave it at that. We agree to disagree. Just promise me you won't become a Developer, you'll go broke ;)
No, because I, unlike you, understand the difference between improvement value, and land value.

I think you realize you're wrong, but simply don't want to admit it. You've acknowledged that it's actually land value, but have simply tried to claim that the land value is a result of housing value (prior to there even being houses). That claim, of course, is nonsensical. The sad part is, you've willingly chosen to remain ignorant. Due to this tragic decision, you will forever be unable to understand how the economy works.
 
I want to know,

Well with so many losing their jobs and homes I want to know if the government plans to make more homeless shelters and job opportunities?
 
No, when demand increases, land values increase. Land values are merely a reflection of demand for land.

FAIL.

Where does the demand for land come from?

Housing.

Why you seem to stop short of this key piece of information boggles the mind.

No demand for housing, no demand for land, no increase in price of land. What's so hard to understand here?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom