"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

:faint:

Give me a break. The markets are up and "this is the best time in the world" the markets are down and "we are all going to die, get your bomb shelter ready."

This is a hit piece / gloom and doom prediction based 100% on the writers bias (either political or financial or both).

For instance, the last thing we should worry about in this economy is the debt of the government. Yes, it's going to be high, yes we are going to pay for it down the road (for many years in fact)....

BUT

We ARE going to get out of this mess and we are not going to go live in a cave any time soon.

The only way to dig out of this hole is to have a large infusion of cash, something that the average company or citizen can't do. And to me that is the POINT of a government, it should be there to do things for the collective whole that private individuals or corporations can't (or won't) do... go to the moon, protect our boarders and yes, stimulate the economy.

What a bunch of crap. Of course if enough people pass around articles like this one they can create even more fear, a manifest destiny.

Stop talking like it's the end of the world, stop spreading fear and the "not great" economy will not ever get to "really really bad."

They have already put 2 trillion into the system, more cash won't do anything.

There is several times the world GDP in debt right now. It cannot be paid off no matter how much money they throw out there.

They are going to have to reset the economic system to solve this problem because pumping money into a system with massive debt will just make things worse.

People can't spend money anyway because they have so much debt, and the same goes for corporations.

We are going to see a second great depression, whether you want to believe it or not.

You can choose not to prepare for it, but I would rather be safe than sorry in this case.

When you have mainstream articles talking about $5000 an ounce gold (Bloomberg.com), as well as riots then you know things are really bad.
 
FAIL.

Where does the demand for land come from?
Want of places to live and work.

Two points:

First of all, it's not just housing. As the community grows, there's more demand for housing and there's also more demand for commerce and industry.

Secondly: again, you're not arguing that land doesn't have value, but why it has value. If all land were the same, when one purchased housing, he'd only be paying for the cost of building housing. But that's not the case: it's not the case because people also pay for locations. You're simply wrong as a matter of objective fact.

Why you seem to stop short of this key piece of information boggles the mind.

No demand for housing, no demand for land, no increase in price of land. What's so hard to understand here?
?? Other than it's flat false? In many places, there was no demand for housing, but there was a demand for land: take many CBD's for example. You're just flat wrong. You're trying to turn demand for land into demand for housing, but clearly they are not the same thing.

Why do you refuse to know facts that prove your beliefs false?
 
Not really. It depends on your perspective.

Say you own a grocery store. Someone asks: "what are produce prices like now?" He answers "prices for produce are up right now." He might add "but the increase is all apples," but that's unnecessary information.

Emphasis mine.

Does that mean we're in agreement ?

The returns to land come out of the returns to labor and capital.

Sure. I can agree to that. But then so does everything else. Which comes back to what I was saying: if the price of apples goes up, and no other product on earth varies in price, then the price of everything went up, according to you.
 
Assuming your information is accurate (unlikely), it's the special case. Anyone can observe this for himself by checking with a Realtor.

Well I work in a field related to real-estate and assessment of property, and from what I know house value is not necessarily related to land value. So much in fact that I disagree that it's a "special" case.
 
No, you've clearly got it backwards. Land doesn't have value because housing is located there: housing is located there because the land has value.

No, no, and no. You are dead wrong about this. Land can definitely vary in value because of what's on it.

Question: when you buy a house, do you look primarily at the land, or the building ?
 
Emphasis mine.

Does that mean we're in agreement ?
No, it means you're wrong. His first statement was true without the additional information.

Sure. I can agree to that. But then so does everything else.
?? What else? Everything else is returns to labor or capital. There's three factors of production: land labor and capital. Everything is a return to one of the three.

Which comes back to what I was saying: if the price of apples goes up, and no other product on earth varies in price, then the price of everything went up, according to you.
You weren't saying that, and that's not true according to me. But if apples increased in price, and nothing else, it would still be true that fruit increased in price.

Well I work in a field related to real-estate and assessment of property, and from what I know house value is not necessarily related to land value. So much in fact that I disagree that it's a "special" case.
Hm. Let's just check that claim against reality. Let's just imagine two identical houses: 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, built in 2000. One's located in Orange County, California, the other's located in La Porte County, Indiana.

Now, I don't work in a field related to real-estate and assessment of property, but I say with the utmost of confidence that the former house will be more expensive than the latter. I can say that, because you're obviously wrong. Improvement (house) value is the property value minus the land (site) value.

No, you've clearly got it backwards. Land doesn't have value because housing is located there: housing is located there because the land has value.
No, no, and no. You are dead wrong about this. Land can definitely vary in value because of what's on it.
No, it cannot, by definition. It can vary by what's allowed to be put on it, however. And how often are homes built in areas where land has very little or no value? Pretty much never.

Question: when you buy a house, do you look primarily at the land, or the building ?
The thing of utmost importance to me is where the house is located. The perfect house, located in Nebraska, is of no use to me whatever. In fact, I wouldn't purchase a house located any more than 30 miles from the central square of Crown Point, Indiana. I know I'll pay a premium to live here compared to houses in, say, Newton County, but I'll pay it, because proximity is important.

So in fact, to me, just as to professional Realtors, it's primarily about location, location, location.
 
The thing of utmost importance to me is where the house is located. The perfect house, located in Nebraska, is of no use to me whatever. In fact, I wouldn't purchase a house located any more than 30 miles from the central square of Crown Point, Indiana. I know I'll pay a premium to live here compared to houses in, say, Newton County, but I'll pay it, because proximity is important.

The main factor determining value of land and housing is proximity to jobs. Houses in Crown Point are expensive only because there are good paying jobs in or near Crown Point. If that job market dries up, real estate values will plummet.
 
The main factor determining value of land and housing is proximity to jobs.
Pretty true, but the main factor determining whether there's jobs is government protection of property rights, and investment in infrastructure. There's not much in the way of jobs in, say, Somalia.

Houses in Crown Point are expensive only because there are good paying jobs in or near Crown Point. If that job market dries up, real estate values will plummet.
Right. But again, the question isn't over why land has value, but whether it does. You, unlike others, seem to understand that it does, but somewhat wrongly argue that the majority of land value comes from proximity to jobs; that's true as far as it goes, but it's a partial truth that doesn't enable a comprehensive understanding of the matter.
 
?? What else? Everything else is returns to labor or capital. There's three factors of production: land labor and capital. Everything is a return to one of the three.

Which is precisely why I said that. It's pointless to say it because it's always true, anyway.

Belz... said:
Which comes back to what I was saying: if the price of apples goes up, and no other product on earth varies in price, then the price of everything went up, according to you.

You weren't saying that

Yes. Yes, I was.

and that's not true according to me. But if apples increased in price, and nothing else, it would still be true that fruit increased in price.

Those statements are contradictory. You just said that, if the price of apples, and ONLY apples, goes up, then the price of fruit increased. A single sentence before you say you disagree with what I said: if the price of apples, and ONLY apples, goes up, then the price of everything increased.

Hm. Let's just check that claim against reality. Let's just imagine two identical houses: 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, built in 2000. One's located in Orange County, California, the other's located in La Porte County, Indiana.

Yes, in that case the houses will not be priced the same. But I notice you made the houses identical. So, obviously the only difference, assuming identical buyers, is the land.

I can say that, because you're obviously wrong.

You can say I'm wrong because I'm wrong ? Sounds circular, to me.

No, it cannot, by definition. It can vary by what's allowed to be put on it, however. And how often are homes built in areas where land has very little or no value? Pretty much never.

That's a funny thing to say. Plenty of people build things precisely because the land under it is cheap.

The thing of utmost importance to me is where the house is located.

It's of some importance, but it's not always crucial. Very often you're looking also for some things specific to the actual building.
 
Which is precisely why I said that. It's pointless to say it because it's always true, anyway.
Sigh. That's not what you were saying.

Yes. Yes, I was.
Post #?

Those statements are contradictory. You just said that, if the price of apples, and ONLY apples, goes up, then the price of fruit increased. A single sentence before you say you disagree with what I said: if the price of apples, and ONLY apples, goes up, then the price of everything increased.
Because everything means every thing. If only the price of apples goes up, it's accurate to say that prices have increased.

Yes, in that case the houses will not be priced the same. But I notice you made the houses identical. So, obviously the only difference, assuming identical buyers, is the land.
Right. Which utterly demolishes your claim that "house value is not necessarily related to land value." Obviously, house value is necessarily related to land value.

You can say I'm wrong because I'm wrong ? Sounds circular, to me.
Well, then you have issues with logic.

That's a funny thing to say. Plenty of people build things precisely because the land under it is cheap.
Some do perhaps, but the vast majority don't.

It's of some importance, but it's not always crucial. Very often you're looking also for some things specific to the actual building.
Of course. But location is of primary importance. The best house in the world would be worthless in Antarctica.
 
There's a little bit of 'chicken and the egg' going on here, if you know what I mean.


The reason land is valuable is because of gravity and scarcity. Otherwise, we could just build mobile skyhomes. And then, housing prices[edit] would not increase, only go down[edit].

Likewise, if I put a newspaper bodega on a plot of land in the middle of nowhere, it doesn't increase in value, until the land increases in value, which it eventually, inevitably will, unless we all die of disease or something.
 
Last edited:
There's a little bit of 'chicken and the egg' going on here, if you know what I mean.


The reason land is valuable is because of gravity and scarcity. Otherwise, we could just build mobile skyhomes. And then, housing prices[edit] would not increase, only go down.[edit]
No, that too is wrong. Because there's still the matter of proximity. A skyhome above Chicago would be worth more than a skyhome above Omaha. And the higher up you go, the less valuable the space would be.

The reason land is valuable is the scarcity of resources and the spacial context of existence.

Likewise, if I put a newspaper bodega on a plot of land in the middle of nowhere, it doesn't increase in value, until the land increases in value, which it eventually, inevitably will, unless we all die of disease or something.
Some places will likely never have any value, such as the aforementioned
Antarctica.
 
No, that too is wrong. Because there's still the matter of proximity. A skyhome above Chicago would be worth more than a skyhome above Omaha. And the higher up you go, the less valuable the space would be.

The reason land is valuable is the scarcity of resources and the spacial context of existence.

Some places will likely never have any value, such as the aforementioned
Antarctica.

Well, I think the land in Antarctica will become valuable before the Moon or an asteroid, or Mars. Also, isn't there a possibly a lot of oil there? On Antarctica, that is, not the moon.
 
Well, I think the land in Antarctica will become valuable before the Moon or an asteroid, or Mars.
Probably, none of those places will ever have any value.

Also, isn't there a possibly a lot of oil there? On Antarctica, that is, not the moon.
That's a good point. Maybe there is oil, in which case the land would have value, assuming it's feasible to extract it.
 
In many places, there was no demand for housing, but there was a demand for land: take many CBD's for example. You're just flat wrong. You're trying to turn demand for land into demand for housing, but clearly they are not the same thing.

lol, I don't know where you live but there has never been a run on green space around here.

Your reasoning is flawed and numerous examples of why have been given. Just in case you don't get it, I'll offer another.

Suppose you buy a chunk of "land", a nice piece of land with a river running through it, good drainage, access to the highway, even city water and sewers running close by. And just suppose I start to break ground and discover a nest of rare endangered speckled burrowing owls. Constrcution stops and the city decides I can't build on that land anymore. Do you think I'll get my money back on that piece of property if I put it back on the market?
 
lol, I don't know where you live but there has never been a run on green space around here.
Relevance: 0.

Your reasoning is flawed and numerous examples of why have been given. Just in case you don't get it, I'll offer another.

Suppose you buy a chunk of "land", a nice piece of land with a river running through it, good drainage, access to the highway, even city water and sewers running close by. And just suppose I start to break ground and discover a nest of rare endangered speckled burrowing owls. Constrcution stops and the city decides I can't build on that land anymore. Do you think I'll get my money back on that piece of property if I put it back on the market?
?? Are you seriously trying to be this dishonest? Obviously, if there's some government intrusion blocking the use of the land, it won't have value. Duh.

If that's all you got, you're very, very destroyed.
 

You seem to have a respiratory problem. You might want to get that checked out.

That's not what you were saying.

Why, yes. Yes I was.

Because everything means every thing. If only the price of apples goes up, it's accurate to say that prices have increased.

It's accurate to say that the average price of everything increased. It's also accurate to say that if the price of any item, anywhere in the world, has increased. Does that sound like a useful statement to you ?

Right. Which utterly demolishes your claim that "house value is not necessarily related to land value." Obviously, house value is necessarily related to land value.

Er... no. My point was -- and if you were actually following the conversation you'd tell -- that you constructed an example that was not at all what I was arguing. In short, it was a strawman.

Well, then you have issues with logic.

Only if you think circular arguments are good.

Some do perhaps, but the vast majority don't.

That's not the issue, you implied that NO ONE does this. It is clearly false. Therefore your claim was wrong.

Of course. But location is of primary importance. The best house in the world would be worthless in Antarctica.

Yes, yes it will, but then again that's another ridiculous example that proves nothing.

The fact is, some people buy lands that are next to worthless and built virtual castles on them. When someone else buys the place from them, it's the house they're buying, not the land. The land, that they have to buy with the house, of course, had probably increased in value because the house is on it. It's a minority of cases, I agree, but my whole point was, it does happen, as opposed to your claim.
 
You seem to have a respiratory problem. You might want to get that checked out.
No, I have a ridiculous poster problem.

Why, yes. Yes I was.
Post #?

It's accurate to say that the average price of everything increased. It's also accurate to say that if the price of any item, anywhere in the world, has increased. Does that sound like a useful statement to you ?
No, but you're just being stupid. To go back to the point, I was talking about land. To talk about some land as apples and the rest as fruit in general is a stretch enough as it is, but to make the analogy of some land being a single item and the rest being all possible items is stupid.

You'd rather retreat to absurdities, so here we are.

Er... no. My point was -- and if you were actually following the conversation you'd tell -- that you constructed an example that was not at all what I was arguing. In short, it was a strawman.
No, that's false. You made a stupidly false claim, and I demolished it. Period.

Only if you think circular arguments are good.
You're evidently unable to determine what a circular argument is.

That's not the issue, you implied that NO ONE does this. It is clearly false. Therefore your claim was wrong.
No, I specifically said virtually no one. Stop outright lying about what I wrote.

Oh, and retract this claim.

Yes, yes it will, but then again that's another ridiculous example that proves nothing.
No, it proves that location is of primary importance, and house value comes second.

The fact is, some people buy lands that are next to worthless and built virtual castles on them. When someone else buys the place from them, it's the house they're buying, not the land.
This is a very exceptional circumstance, and you know it.

The land, that they have to buy with the house, of course, had probably increased in value because the house is on it.
No, that's false.

It's a minority of cases, I agree, but my whole point was, it does happen, as opposed to your claim.
In-context, verbatim quote? Of course not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom