Split Thread War in Afghanistan

I wonder if you have the self awareness to understand how revealing it is that you excuse the war crimes you "understand". And the ones you understand are invariably the ones committed by enemies of the U.S.

Utter bollocks again - I agreed that ISIS and Taliban are committing war crimes. ISIS are not freedom fighters in the way that Hamas could be seen to be.

I just happen to focus on the US ones because USA is the country that holds itself as above the law because they're the good guys. It is interesting that you see it that way, though. Not reading what I've actually typed is legion around here.

You already tried this fallacy and failed the first time. You're welcome to continue failing. I am not giving ISIS or Taliban a free pass, but so far, they haven't quite committed anything as atrocious as the Kunduz MSF attack.

Are you a Poe, out to waste our time with silly little head games?

No, I'm making sure there is a balance between the apologists for atrocity and those who still have sufficient humanity left in the to be disgusted by the attack.
 
Yeah, I saw that. Have to wonder if he's not a Poe, but I don't read enough of him to judge.

Once I would have said; gotta be a poe. But it's the Internet. .. lots of strangeness around.
 
I am not giving ISIS or Taliban a free pass, but so far, they haven't quite committed anything as atrocious as the Kunduz MSF attack.
Savagely beating, raping and killing women, setting prisoners in cages on fire in cages, torturing children, none of this is worse than mistakenly bombing a hospital?

No, I'm making sure there is a balance between the apologists for atrocity and those who still have sufficient humanity left in the to be disgusted by the attack.
An atrocity is "extremely wicked or cruel act" and the only evidence for such a thing here is in your head. Posturing as the one protecting humanity is a joke. You're the one who says we should just leave Afghanistan for the Taliban to take over as they will anyway, isn't that right? :covereyes
 
Savagely beating, raping and killing women, setting prisoners in cages on fire in cages, torturing children, none of this is worse than mistakenly bombing a hospital?

An atrocity is "extremely wicked or cruel act" and the only evidence for such a thing here is in your head. Posturing as the one protecting humanity is a joke. You're the one who says we should just leave Afghanistan for the Taliban to take over as they will anyway, isn't that right? :covereyes

Beheading children for not being Islamic enough. Credit where it's due!
 
Savagely beating, raping and killing women, setting prisoners in cages on fire in cages, torturing children, none of this is worse than mistakenly bombing a hospital?

En masse, probably, but in single instances, I can't think of any at the level of a sustained attack and machine-gunning people running away from a burning hospital.

An atrocity is "extremely wicked or cruel act"...

This is why I suspect you struggle with English, because that describes perfectly what happened at the MSF hospital.

Let me take it slowly for you.

The full description of atrocity - you only gave half of it - is:

An extremely wicked or cruel act, typically one involving physical violence or injury: war atrocities

No question it was cruel, no question it involved violence and injury.

You do know what "or" means don't you? Maybe you're struggling with "cruel". An ocean can be cruel - intent is not necessary, although the level of intent is presently unknown.

Here is one of the descriptions of cruel, from the same dictionary you used:

Causing pain or suffering.

Plain as it could be, The correct word has been used: atrocity.

You're the one who says we should just leave Afghanistan for the Taliban to take over as they will anyway, isn't that right?

Yes it is, and it's notable that the Taliban didn't attack the hospital.

The US are the good guys, though.
 
You don't just get to make up your own definitions for words as you go along trying to create emotional effect...

It's notable the Taliban didn't attack the hospital? Do you think the Taliban has never attacked a hospital before? Really?

There's no evidence that the people who pulled the trigger, let alone anyone in command, knew they were blowing up a Doctor's Without Borders hospital, you merely state you believe it, and then go on ranting about how evil it was, and how we're blind apologists... blah blah blah... :words:

It's worse than My Lai, you haven't even proved it was done on purpose buddy, no one cares about your moral posturing. Or what you imagined happened and how horrible it seems to you.
 
You don't just get to make up your own definitions for words as you go along trying to create emotional effect...

That's about as dishonest as it could be. I used the dictionary you took the meaning from to show you in extremely simple terms why your "reasoning" was incorrect.

You made an error, no point trying to get defensive about it.

It's notable the Taliban didn't attack the hospital?

Correct!

They came and went away without seeing the need to fry the people in it.

USA: not so much.

There's no evidence that the people who pulled the trigger, let alone anyone in command, knew they were blowing up a Doctor's Without Borders hospital,...

So, an official statement by a US Army General doesn't convince you.

Sounds good to me - I wouldn't trust them a millimetre.
 
The attack on the hospital is a war crime.



Nominate a better suggestion - I'm open to them.

All you need to come up with a single instance that matches the MSF hospital attack in immorality. The best I can come up with is My Lai, and I think this surpasses it, so over to you.

Albigensian Crusade
 
You also invent interpretations from things a person didn't actually say, the Americans didn't admit to blowing it up on purpose, no one said that, you completely made that up, just like everything else.

You're actually saying the Taliban were more moral than the Americans for not blowing up the hospital, despite the fact that they have a history of attacking hospitals quite on purpose.
 
Albigensian Crusade

I presume you mean the massacre of the people of Beziers rather than the entire 20-year crusade.

A bagatelle compared to Kunduz - the papists gave the people a chance to surrender at Beziers! I don't see that option in the timeline of the MSF report.
 
Every military in the world has it's own history of friendly fire and accidental targeting of noncombatants. This isn't the first time an AC-130 gunship has fired on the wrong target, soldiers have died. Every military is going to have incidents eventually. It's not acceptable, but neither is waging no war at all because of the risks.
I was reacting to your comment about "...Everyone but you realizes that the fact that they were given the coordinates doesn't mean that the party who decided on the attack knew what they were shooting at. ...", not making a generalised point, JM.

If a military organisation allows somebody to plan an attack when that person (or group) does not know what they are attacking, then that is gross dereliction of duty.

I would be intrigued to hear just WHAT the US Army thought it WAS attacking. After all, the attack was VERY precise.
 
I presume you mean the massacre of the people of Beziers rather than the entire 20-year crusade.

A bagatelle compared to Kunduz - the papists gave the people a chance to surrender at Beziers! I don't see that option in the timeline of the MSF report.
This No True Scotsman of massacres seals it. The Atheist is either a Poe, a gamer/troll, or a rabid ideologue without the slightest capacity for objectivity.
 
Utter bollocks again...

Yeah. Here it comes...

I just happen to focus on the US ones because USA is the country that holds itself as above the law because they're the good guys...

Yeah. That's about as "utter bollocks" as you can get. But thanks for the warning anyway. Not that we needed it. Your pattern has been clear for some time now.

Right. I get it. As long as the Taliban, for example, does not hold itself up as the "good guys" while committing war crimes and crimes against humanity, you will continue to "focus" on the U.S., which, unlike your ilk, has spent blood and treasure trying to tamp down the Taliban.

Except the Taliban does hold itself up as the good guys. That's how they justify beheading children, for example.

You can't even come up with a feeble excuse for your bollocks that isn't bass ackwards. And to make your bollocks more completely odious, you hold yourself up as the righteous accuser and judge.
 
The Atheist also thinks we should have given in to the Nazis to prevent human suffering.
And he thinks the Maori were happy to give New Zealand to the nice British men with guns because they thought they were so awesome, or enamored with the beauty and grace of Queen Victoria, or something.
 
Last edited:
This No True Scotsman of massacres seals it. The Atheist is either a Poe, a gamer/troll, or a rabid ideologue without the slightest capacity for objectivity.
There's another possibility, but bringing it up is against forum rules.
 
Don't forget the attack was not an isolated event.
There was a fierce battle going on for control of a town. Buildings snd streets change hands, there is no front line.
If you are tasked with close support then you shoot at the target that your FOO gives to you and you do it as quickly as you can. Fighting in built up areas is a difficult, dirty and confused business.

My uncle Harold was part of ajoint RN, RAF FOO in Normandy.
His unit was in armoured cars alongside the Infantry and tanks.
They got requests from the infantry and passed it to the Battleships (until they were 20 miles or so off the beaches) or the RAF Typhoons in the 'cab rank' It took about 5 minutes from a request to the fire coming in from the ships and as little as a minute for the Typhoons.
Sometimes things went wrong and the fire landed in tbe wrong place or a target was misidentified. It happens, it always will in a confusing, dynamic situation. It's sad when it does but it's war, it's nasty and tragic.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm...

So what you are basicly suggesting, Joey McGee, is that the US Military command structure is dangerously incompetent, to the point of criminality ?

You're implying that the worlds largest, most expensive, and most technologically sophisticated Military organisation has a command-and-control system equivelent to a banana republic ?

A multi-trillion dollar organisation has "gaps" that result in "the party who decided on the attack (didn't) know who they where shooting at" ?

In that scenario, the "party" in question - and their commanding officers - should, under the USA Uniform Code of Military Justice - be SHOT ! (or at least, be subject to either the Electric Chair, or a Lethal Injection; I'm not sure how the military handle the death penalty these days).

Moreover, the Chief of the General Staff responsible for the branch in question should be cashiered, and the Commander in Chief required to attend Congress to answer questions relating to dereliction of duty, in that the armed forces under his pervue had been demonstrated to be unfit for purpose.

THAT is what should happen if "...the party who decided on the attack (didn't) know what they where shooting at".

Are you SURE you wan't to continue with that proposal ?

Totally rule of So.
 
And he thinks the Maori were happy to give New Zealand to the nice British men with guns because they thought they were so awesome, or enamored with the beauty and grace of Queen Victoria, or something.

Chalk up another thing you have absolutely no idea about - New Zealand history.

1 Maori didn't give land away.
2 They fought the British to a stalemate, so were in no danger of defeat.
3 They chose to enter into an agreement with the Crown that still applies today.
 
Chalk up another thing you have absolutely no idea about - New Zealand history.

1 Maori didn't give land away.
2 They fought the British to a stalemate, so were in no danger of defeat.
3 They chose to enter into an agreement with the Crown that still applies today.

Shouldn't they have just surrendered according to your philosophy?
 
Last edited:
Shouldn't they have just surrendered according to your philosophy?

No, you've got it wrong. He's being perfectly consistent with his philosophy. If you're a westerner, you should never fight for your values because your values are evil. If you're not a westerner, it's OK to fight for your values.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom