Anyone else every notice that there is an inverse correlation between the strength of a poster's argument and the length of their post?
Well then your arguments must be pretty weak, since your posts have been almost as long as mine.
And has anyone else noted that shorter posts are usually filled with a dearth of sourced facts and logic, but lots of liberal handwaving and lies?
You only need to scroll up this page a bit to find a post where someone explained why CRA had little to do with the housing bubble collapse. The overwhelming majority of subprime mortgages were created by companies that were not covered by CRA.
What they showed was a red herring since the majority of subprime mortgages were not the problem. The problem was a minority (but still significant portion) of those mortgages. The ones that were made to folks who really couldn't afford them. The ones that put lender after lender in financial trouble when the recession hit. And if not most then a great many of them were made by companies covered by CRA. Or by Fannie May and Freddie Mac, who might as well have been covered.
It is simply undeniable that CRA radically changed the mortgage industry. Do you know that the number of sub-prime loans went from 1% of all mortgages to 12% within just THREE years of the Clinton Administration strenghtening the CRA law? How can CRA not have been the cause?
And it was all based on a liberal lie. There was 1993 study used by liberals at the Boston Fed to justify the strengthening of CRA by Clinton. It made the claim that minority mortgage applications were rejected at a higher rate because of racism. But an article in Forbes that same year proved that wasn't true:
http://www.vdare.com/pb/050105_hiddenclue.htm . In fact, the Boston Fed senior vice president and research director eventually had to admit to Forbes that they made a serious error in interpreting the data and that actually there was "no evidence" to support the racism charge. And the fact that Forbes completely debunked the Boston Fed's assertion didn't stop Obama and his fellow civil rights lawyers from claiming in 1995, in a court case known as Buycks-Roberson v. Citibank, that Citibank was making too few loans to black applicants due to racism. They cited the 1993 study as proof.
The liberal court swooned over the argument. Obama and his civil rights friends won the case, forcing banks to make loans that simply weren't financially sound. And once Obama helped open the flood gates, it was only a matter of time before the waters rose over the dikes. And it was only a matter of time before even non-CRA companies had *obligations* to offer credit to minorities. Obligations forced on to them via private lawsuits ... such as the one that Obama helped file. You can find many examples of such lawsuits even up into 2008 against non-CRA institutions. So not every company may have been subject to CRA, but most companies were still subject to the same sort of extortion and lies that led to CRA in first place. So to claim that CRA had nothing to do with subprime mortages is a specious argument, at best. It denies history.
The fact is that Fannie Mae was and is one of the largest mortgage lenders in the country and they issued plenty of subprimes to people who really shouldn't have been given a loan. By 1999, HALF of Fannie Mae's business consisted of loans to low and moderate-income people. And those are the loans that put Fannie Mae (and Freddie Mac) on the ropes eventually … requiring hundreds of billions in bailout money. And which even with those bailouts are still dragging Fannie and Freddie down the drain.
As far as private companies are concerned, Countrywide was the largest mortgage company in the country. It was identified by Fannie May as a role model in terms of it's commitment to CRA lending, having one of "the most flexible underwriting criteria" possible. That "flexible criteria" is why it's low income loan volume climbed from about $1 billion in 1992 to hundreds of billions by the next decade. In fact, in March of 2003, Countrywide announced that they would fund $600 billion in home loans to "previously underserved Americans through the end of the decade". That's just a euphenism for people who really shouldn't have been given a home loan.
They did this despite brewing trouble. As far back as June of 2007, almost a quarter of Countrywides' subprime loans were delinquent with 10% of them over 3 months late. And nearly half of the loans had adjustible rates, a big source of the problems. By some accounts about 70% of Countrywides' business was subprime and other marginal loans. Countrywide was literally trying to put everyone in a home … making loans that required a cash contribution of the
lessor of one percent of home sale price or $500. A recipe for disaster. All liberal driven.
And that's why Countrywide essentially went bankrupt when recession hit and had to merge with Bank Of America. Oh sure ... CRAs had nothing to do with this crisis. Nothing at all.
Of course, there is also no evidence that the number of defaults on subprime mortgages was suffiicient to cause a recession.
LOL! No evidence? Just like you folks claim there is no evidence that Bush's tax cuts improved the economy?
Quote:
To fight several wars that we didn't start.
"Several" implies more than one. Besides Afghanistan, what war did we end up in that we didn't start?
The worldwide WOT? Iraq? Yes, even Iraq. Contrary to liberal thinking, the Iraq war never ended. A cease fire was negotiated based on an agreement that Saddam broke over and over and over for more than a decade. And Iraq was definitely part of the WOT problem. Am I to assume by your response that you wouldn't have invaded Iraq? And what do you think would have been the result today? Isn't it likely (the ISG concluded it was) that Iraq would right now be armed with intermediate range missiles and WMD had we not invaded? Isn't it likely they still be cooperating with terrorists (including al-Qaeda) as they were clearly doing in the years before the invasion? Isn't it likely they'd still be sponsoring terrorism as they clearly did in the years before the invasion. And do you honestly think the cost of dealing with that would have been less than what it cost to invade? Because I can cite three economics professors in Chicago who would disagree with you. And a bunch of other reasons. Indeed I have … many times. But all I seem to get back when I do is {crickets}. Would you be any different?
Quote:
No matter what he did, we were unlikely to see revenues as a percent of GDP go above 18 or 19 percent, which they did anyway. That's what 65 years of history tells us. All that increasing taxes at that point would have done is LOWER GDP, so even if he'd managed with higher taxes to get revenue as a percent of GDP to climb to the historic average (unlikely), the net take would have been LOWER. A bigger deficit than what we had. This isn't rocket science or anything but 3rd grade math and basic logic. I don't see why this is so difficult for leftists to understand?
Because it lacks any theoretical basis.
LOL! You liberals and your ivory towers. Periodically you come down from those towers (like Romer and a half dozen of Obama's top economic advisors … all now departed back to the ivory towers … did) and try to impliment your theories. And you fail …
every single time. Liberals, it seems, are just incapable of learning from history. And you know what they say about those who can't learn from history?
Because it involves circular reasoning.
I'm not using circular reasoning. Circular reasoning is supporting a premise with a premise. I'm supporting the premise with hard evidence … the history of what revenues as a percent of GDP have actually done over the past 65 years despite wild fluxuations in tax rates.
If Reagan and Bush hadn't cut taxes, would the 65 year average have been higher?
And you want to guess what your fallacy is? Perhaps circular reasoning? Afterall, you are supporting a statement by simply repeating the statement without offering any data to support the statement. Heck, maybe if Bush and Reagon hadn't cut taxes we would ALL now be millionaires?
Tax rates have been changed to steer revenues towards certain levels.
Steered? Prove it. I bet you can't.
Is 18.4% a "natural" level
As I said earlier on these threads, it may be an indication that there is some natural level of taxation above which people react to keep it from going higher … by reallocating resources. At some point, people consider taxation stealing and will even stop working to keep from having that next dollar too heavily taxed. Perhaps it's their own sense of what their own TIME is worth?
or have various presidents worked to steer the average towards that level?
Tut Tut. More circular reasoning. Sorry, but you haven't provided ANY evidence that there has been an effort to "steer" the average to 18%. None whatsoever. It just seems to "naturally" go there.
Quote:
If what you claim is true, why didn't Obama's Stimulus work? It was predicated on the belief that a dollar in stimulus spending would create more than a dollar in GDP. It hasn't happened. Didn't even come close. Don't you socialists EVER learn from history … even the history you make?
OK. I concede that you are correct and the overwhelming majority of economists are wrong.
You haven't proven that the overwhelming majority of economists say the stimulus worked … that it increased GDP by more than the amount of stimulus. Go ahead, try. And don't use any circular reasoning to do it.
The theory that Romer and company used to justify the stimulus stated that real GDP would increase for each dollar spent as stimulus by that dollar times a multiplier … which they said was 1.6. The increase to that level was gradual but according to Romer, by fourth quarter of 2010, the full multiplier would be in effect. But that didn't happen. All told, the stimulus was over a trillion dollars so Real GDP should now be AT LEAST $1.6 trillion higher. Yet, here we almost 3 years later and real GDP (
http://voteview.spia.uga.edu/images/Real_GDP_Federal_Debt_2011.jpg from
http://voteview.spia.uga.edu/blog/?p=1419 ) only went up from the recession low about $300-400 billion at most. THAT'S A FAIL. It proves your economists' theories wrong. Plain and simple. And for that reason, the stimulus did not control unemployment like it was predicted to do by your theoriticians. Here is a source you might want to read on that topic:
http://www.heritage.org/research/re...imulate-economic-growth-answering-the-critics
Furthermore, there are reasons to suspect that whatever sources you might cite to support your claim have a political bias that makes their conclusions suspect. Go ahead … offer your sources and let's see?
However, I would like to see your evidence that a dollar in tax cuts creates more than a dollar in GDP.
Well, if it didn't, then how do you explain government revenues repeatedly going UP after tax cuts in the past? Over and over that's happened.
Heck, let's look at the despised (by you) Bush tax cuts. What did Real GDP do during that time? From 2001 to 2007, over which time the tax cuts went into effect, Real GDP rose from a little over $11 trillion to a little over $13 trillion … an increase of $2 trillion. And that happened during a time when there were significant drags on the economy. Recession. 9/11 impacts. And increases in social programs.
Yet according to this,
http://www.taxfoundation.org/news/show/26314.html , it *cost* (if a reduction in government revenue can actually be called a cost) about $1.6 trillion over the 10 years from 2001 to 2010. Here's a Washington Post source that puts the 10 year cost of the Bush Tax cuts as $1.3 trillion:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs...e-bush-tax-cuts/2011/05/09/AFxTFtbG_blog.html .
So clearly, TKN, there is evidence that the spending multiplier for the Bush tax cuts was above 1, in contrast to Obama's stimulus.
Quote:
I told you socialists earlier (
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php...&postcount=366 ) why 2-3.5% growth during the 2000's was actually quite good. And you basically ignored that response. So let me repeat what I said.
The 80's and 90's were periods when the US was still pre-eminent in many high-growth technologies (medical devices, electronics and then software). You heard of the internet boom, right? That might have something to do with why the average Real GDP growth during those periods was somewhat higher than in the 2000's, when the rest of the world had caught up in those technological areas. And as I noted, the problem is that we didn't move on to the next technology and dominate it … perhaps because democrat controlled schools have been pumping out community organizers, *actresses*, defense lawyers, and political science majors, rather than more conservative scientists and engineers … the folks who actually fueled the GDP growth of the 80's and 90's. Furthermore, the 90's had less events to impede GDP growth. No 9/11. And in the second half of the 90s when growth rates were a percent or two higher than under Bush, not even a recession.
Furthermore, let me add that there is a natural reduction (with occasional exceptions) in GDP growth as economies grow and mature. It's not unusual for small economies to sustain double digit GDP growth for many years. But as an economy grows, growth rates start to drop. The US has the largest economy in the world. So why would you expect GDP to climb much above 3% unless we come up with some new technology the rest of the world needs? Perhaps your expection shows you don't have a "cursory understanding of economics"? So let me help you. Here is a chart (from
http://www.house.gov/jec/growth/govtsize/govtsize.htm ) that you might find interesting … if you bother to study it carefully:
http://www.house.gov/jec/growth/govtsize/fig-2.gif
It shows how 10 year GDP growth has fallen in the US since 1799. You can see that when we were a young, immature nation, we saw 10 year growth rates of 70% (an average of 7% a year). And as our country has aged and our economy grown that percentage has quite steadily dropped. By 1900 the average rate was down to about 5% a year. By the 1980s and 1990s, it was down to about 3% a year. So did you really expect Bush to beat that by much? Seriously? LEARN FROM HISTORY.
The true growth rate during the pre-recession period of the Bush Administration was only a little over 1 percent. The majority of the GDP growth was generated by the housing bubble.
Ah … I see all we are going to get from you is more non-sequiturs, more handwaving and more circular logic. Sigh.
Most small business owners aren't in the top few percent of wage earners.
But the majority of those who would be taxed more under Obama and the democrat's wishlist do appear to be small business owners … and by small business I'm talking about owners of companies employing from 20 to 250 people. Congressional staff reported there is 2007 Treasury Department report which estimates that about 75 percent of the taxpayers in the top two tax brackets "are flow-through business owners" who report "net ordinary income from sole proprietorships, S corporations, and partnerships plus net long-term and short-term gains from partnerships, S corporations, estates and trusts." Of that group, according to two liberal think tanks (
http://www.foxnews.com/on-air/special-report/transcript/obamas-tax-plan-and-small-businesses ), 27 percent have a majority small business income. These are the people that Obama's "rich" tax will impact. The mid size companies owned by these members of Obama's "rich" are the majority employers in the country:
http://whittakerassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/WA-Company-Size-Distribution.jpg . Do you rationally think that if you raise taxes on them that unemployment is going down? If so, you need to leave your ivory tower.
Quote:
It's simple math and clear logic. Think about it.
Yeah, reducing the tax rate raises more tax revenue. Let's reduce the rate to zero and the govt. will have more money than it knows what to do with. Is this your idea of "clear logic"?
Nice strawman. I never suggested any such thing. And if you believe in that sort of logic, then you must also believe that since Romer's spending multipliers said that unemployment was going to produce x number of jobs, we could have spent a few times more and totally eliminated unemployment? But of course, that's equally ridiculous.
No one on my side of the aisle is suggesting we pay no taxes. And there obviously is a point of diminishing returns in tax cuts. At some point, you can't fund the necessary services. And I don't exactly know where that point is. But I do know that even with the much lower tax rates that existed at the beginning of the Bush Jr era, cutting taxes generated more GDP growth and higher total revenues. So obviously we aren't at the level yet of no return on cutting taxes further. But FIRST, we have to get a grip on spending. And that's the problem you liberals haven't yet squarely faced. You are still under the illusion you can keep on spending and spending regardless of debt or anything else. Because most of you think money grows on trees.
Quote:
The S&L debacle … which Reagan dealt with without a massive bailout and stimulus.
150 billion dollars was a pretty large amount at the time.
That's the amount that FSLIC (the forerunner to the FDIC) shelled out to insured institutions at the time. That wasn't something that Reagan had anything to do with … not like TARP.
Quote:
For example, the Bush tax cuts didn't actually cost us anything. Federal Tax revenues climbed back to historical levels as a percentage of GDP and remained there until democrats took over Congress. And GDP increased markedly for quarter after quarter after quarter after those tax cuts.
You keep making this claim without having offered a single bit of evidence to support it.
LIAR. Go back on this and all the other recent threads and you will find that I absolutely did prove that the GDP increased quarter after quarter after quarter after those tax cuts. And I did prove that federal tax revenues as a percent of GDP climbed back to historical average levels and remained there until democrats took over Congress in late 2006. Or are you as incapable of reading a graph as RF apparently was?
Quote:
In constrast, Obama's stimulus accomplished next to nothing. GDP growth has remained less than lackluster … far less than even Bush achieved . And the stimulus will cost us trillions of dollars to finance. And revenues as a percent of GDP have NOT returned to the historic average.
Other than saving millions of jobs
That's not proven. The analyses that concluded that merely took the CBO's earlier model and plugged in the same spending multipliers that earlier predicted those savings, and concluded it happened. As I've noted repeatedly, the former CBO director said
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2010/08/25/stimulus-figures-questioned-amid-economic-team-firings/
Aug 25, 2010
… snip …
Douglas Holtz-Eakin, former CBO director, said the CBO analysis cannot be taken "at face value."
The CBO report not only gives a wide range for stimulus impact in the second quarter of 2010 -- saying between 1.4 million and 3.3 million jobs were created or saved and economic growth was somewhere between 1.7 percent and 4.5 percent -- the models used are designed to spit out positive figures, he said.
"This is repackaging previous analysis at the request of Democrats in Congress," he told Fox News. "This is based on a computer model, and with computer models you get out what you put in, and the kinds of models that the CBO uses is one where the stimulus can't fail to work."
It's Garbage in, Garbage out. MEANINGLESS. But I guess liberals are too partisan to see it.
Bush inherited a budget surplus
LIAR. I have proven on this forum many times that's not true. There was no surplus during the Clinton years since the National Debt increased every single year of Clinton's term. All they did was juggle numbers to make it look like there was a surplus. They lied to the American public and this demonstrably true. I suggest you go back and study this post of mine:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7453800&postcount=366
LIAR. I have proven on this forum many times that's not true. The NBER's own data shows that we were already in recession in the last quarter of Clinton's term. They lied to the public to make Clinton look good and Bush bad. I suggest you go back and study this post of mine:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7433782&postcount=72
and an unemployment rate of 4.2%
It is true that the unemployment rate was 4.2% at the beginning of Bush's Presidency. And during the 2000-2002 recesson it climbed to about 6%. It's also true that starting in 2003, about the time the 2003 tax cuts began to impact the economy, unemployment dropped so that by the time democrats took over Congress at the end of 2006 it was back down to 4.5% … despite the recession, 9/11 and the US not having a technological lead in much of anything anymore. But then look what happened. It immediately started going back up. Ahhhhhh democrats.
and had to deal with a small downturn.
But at least he didn't make it worse like Obama and company have done.
Obama inherited a budget with a trillion dollar deficit (the Bush Administration projected a trillion dollar deficit in their budget for FY2009)
LIAR. The Bush administration in July of 2008 projected a deficit for FY 2009 of $407 billion. And that included projected spending on the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and a $170 billion bipartisan stimulus that was passed earlier that year.
a financial system on the verge of collapse
Thanks mostly to the policies of democrats the previous decade.
and an unemployment rate of 7.8%
Thanks to those same policies and the fact that democrats controlled Congress over the entire time it rose from 4.5% to 7.8% during Bush's second term.
To claim that Bush accomplished more is simply hilarious.
Not half as hilarious as watching you put your head in the sand.
Quote:
That's why you never mentioned that he started the recession with a massive tax cut. That's why you only mentioned his later tax increase and made it sound like it occurred early in the recession.
Nope, I never claimed that Reagan's tax cut caused the recession.
Another falsehood. Reagan's tax cut didn't cause the recession. The recession started BEFORE the tax cut. You REALLY need to learn a little history.

Or stop LYING.
Or maybe it's that you aren't intelligent enough to understand.
LOL! It's clear from our discussion which of us is having trouble understanding.
