mhaze
Banned
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2007
- Messages
- 15,718
In your link. You responded to my post. I included a chart.
I've no idea what any of this means.
The point of my numbers are this.
Do you dispute either proposition?
- The Bush Tax Cuts of 2001 and 2003 had no demonstrable, positive effect on the economy for the period of time Bush was in office.
- Though tax rates are still the same the economy is still in the toilet.
I dispute the following
1. A and B had uncertain effects because they were 2 variables in a mix of 100 (E), and we measure the net aggregate E.
2. A and B are still present, and we still do not know their effect on E.
From which you assert without reason.2. A and B are still present, and we still do not know their effect on E.
3. Remove A and B which will CERTAINLY HAVE POSITIVE EFFECT on E.
If the effect of A, B is uncertain, that is true for the presence of A, B partially or completely, or for the absence of A, B. You can't have your cake and eat it too.
If, on the other hand, A, B had certain effects, then you could possibly make a point. However, as I noted with the case of capital gains taxes (One of the Bush tax cuts is in fact a capital gains tax) the CBO cautions about the clear uncertainty in net revenue when moving a capital gains tax EITHER up or down.
Last edited: