USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

In your link. You responded to my post. I included a chart.

I've no idea what any of this means.

The point of my numbers are this.

  1. The Bush Tax Cuts of 2001 and 2003 had no demonstrable, positive effect on the economy for the period of time Bush was in office.
  2. Though tax rates are still the same the economy is still in the toilet.
Do you dispute either proposition?

I dispute the following

1. A and B had uncertain effects because they were 2 variables in a mix of 100 (E), and we measure the net aggregate E.
2. A and B are still present, and we still do not know their effect on E.
​
From which you assert without reason.

3. Remove A and B which will CERTAINLY HAVE POSITIVE EFFECT on E.
​
If the effect of A, B is uncertain, that is true for the presence of A, B partially or completely, or for the absence of A, B. You can't have your cake and eat it too.

If, on the other hand, A, B had certain effects, then you could possibly make a point. However, as I noted with the case of capital gains taxes (One of the Bush tax cuts is in fact a capital gains tax) the CBO cautions about the clear uncertainty in net revenue when moving a capital gains tax EITHER up or down.
 
Last edited:
I dispute the following
1. A and B had uncertain effects because they were 2 variables in a mix of 100 (E), and we measure the net aggregate E.
2. A and B are still present, and we still do not know their effect on E.
​
From which you assert without reason.
3. Remove A and B which will CERTAINLY HAVE POSITIVE EFFECT on E.
​
If the effect of A, B is uncertain, that is true for the presence of A, B partially or completely, or for the absence of A, B. You can't have your cake and eat it too.

If, on the other hand, A, B had certain effects, then you could possibly make a point. However, as I noted with the case of capital gains taxes (One of the Bush tax cuts is in fact a capital gains tax) the CBO cautions about the clear uncertainty in net revenue when moving a capital gains tax EITHER up or down.
Wait, WHAT?

We don't need all this BS. It's really simple. Can you cite anything to show that the economy grew significantly as a result of the Bush Tax Cuts? Yes or no?

...we still do not know their effect...
Well hell son, we don't know the effect of Bush's spending either. We don't know the effect of Obama's spending either. For all we know at any moment the spending will turn the economy around and we will see the fastest growing economy we've ever seen because of the spending. Hell, if we increase tax rates the increased revenue from the tax increases coupled with the increase in taxes as a result of economic growth might pay off the deficits in a year. If we are going to dream let's do it big.

If we are going to play that game then all bets are off. Again, you need to focus on consistency.
 
1. A and B had uncertain effects because they were 2 variables in a mix of 100 (E), and we measure the net aggregate E.

...which never stopped your and yours from claiming that A and B very definitely had the opposite effect of what RandFan claimed.

Make up your minds already.
 
Chaos, that I point out what appears to be an error in Randfan's reliance on uncertainty in his argument, does not mean that I share his perpexity regarding certainty (of beneficial effects of tax cuts) coupled with uncertainty, when it there appears that uncertainty benefits the prior argument.

Just thought it was worth pointing out.
 
Chaos, that I point out what appears to be an error in Randfan's reliance on uncertainty in his argument, does not mean that I share his perpexity regarding certainty (of beneficial effects of tax cuts) coupled with uncertainty, when it there appears that uncertainty benefits the prior argument.

Just thought it was worth pointing out.
:) Oh, yeah. Slip sliding away.
 
So, what have we got?

In 8 year under Bush's tax cuts:
Jobs: Sucked.
Housing Market: Sucked.
Stock Market: Sucked.
GDP: Sucked.

2 years under Obama with the same tax rates (taxes are actually, demonstrably lower).
Jobs: Sucked.
Housing Market: Sucked.
Stock Market: Sucked.
GDP: Sucked.

America? Stuck on stupid. But, RandFan, someday, maybe just someday those tax cuts will pay off huge. Maybe in 2060. You DON'T KNOW.

Define insanity? (or just click the link)
 
Last edited:
Chaos, that I point out what appears to be an error in Randfan's reliance on uncertainty in his argument, does not mean that I share his perpexity regarding certainty (of beneficial effects of tax cuts) coupled with uncertainty, when it there appears that uncertainty benefits the prior argument.

Just thought it was worth pointing out.

In other words, uncertain data is certain proof that your claims are correct, but certain data can never be proof that your claims are wrong.
 
In other words, uncertain data is certain proof that your claims are correct, but certain data can never be proof that your claims are wrong.

which makes it difficult to reason with these religious zealouts.
 
In other words, uncertain data is certain proof that your claims are correct, but certain data can never be proof that your claims are wrong.
Not if it is the same data, to what "uncertain" is used when it suits your case, and "certain" is similarly used when it helps, without regard for any science.

I can think of ways to address this question scientifically, but that'd be disregarded in a political sense. There is also a robust literature in economics on the effects of tax cuts- I linked to one from the CBO.

But it seems also, that must be disregarded in pursuit of what fits the narrative.
 
Last edited:
Take a look here, folks, and we shall see that perhaps we can have a somewhat more clear idea about the economy under Bush and under Obama, except for "Jobs sucked in both."

Bush started his tenure with a sharp rise in unemployment (due to 9/11 and the crashing of the internet bubble) -- from 5% to 6.5%. It peaked there during his first term. Not too good! But nevertheless, not horrible.

In his second term, things got consistently better -- unemployment steadily going down back to about 5% -- until the very end, when the worldwide crisis sent unemployment to 8%+. Generally speaking Bush's "good" years were as good as Clinton's "average" years, in terms of unemployment, and Clinton was very good from the point of view of the economy. Again -- this is not great (Clinton did better) but, apart from the tail-end of his presidency, pretty good, as much as Bush is worthy of criticism (e.g., increasing the debt) in other economic matters.

Now let's look at Obama.

Unemployment went up almost another 2% -- to almost 10%. What's far worse, he spent almost a trillion dollars (OK, $850 billion or so) on a "stimulus" bill that was supposed to help the economy, in fact save it -- a bill that did absolutely nothing. Money down the drain. Wasted. Kaput. For nothing.

Who's better here? Bush, of course. The "idiot" Bush's "evil" tax cuts of 2003 had at the very least not hurt the economy, esp. not the unemployment rates, which continued to improve, and Americans had more of their money left to them. The "genius" Obama's "saving" stimulus bill did absolutely nothing -- except stick the public with the bill of a trillion bucks.

Compared to Obama, Bush is a downright economic genius -- which, of course, isn't saying very much.
 
Take a look here, folks, and we shall see that perhaps we can have a somewhat more clear idea about the economy under Bush and under Obama, except for "Jobs sucked in both."
In short, Bush got 8 years and we have to throw out most years to craft a somewhat pleasant picture. Otherwise it sucked really bad.

Obama? 2 years only. That's it.

Yeah, THAT'S fair and honest.

BTW: What was the unemployment rate Bush inherited? What was the unemployment rate Obama inherited?
 
Last edited:
The "idiot" Bush's "evil" tax cuts of 2003 had at the very least not hurt the economy, esp. not the unemployment rates, which continued to improve, and Americans had more of their money left to them.


  • Yep, throw away the first two years of Bush. They don't count.
  • Next, ignore all of the other years that sucked.
  • Don't give Bush responsibility for the Banking scandal and crash. The trillions of dollars in pensions and savings that were wiped out. The houses that lost their value. Just ignore it.
Odd how turning your head to the side, squinting and ignoring most of the data looks, well, sorta good.
 
Considering the fact that in these 2.5 years Obama increased the debt at a rate of two trillion per years with absolutely nothing to show for it; intends to continue to borrow at that rate in a second term; blew a trillion on a "stimulus" plan that did absolutely nothing; suggested a budget plan so absurd and unrealistic the senate rejected it 97-0 (did something like this ever happen before in US history?); passed an enormously expensive healthcare bill that is barely constitutional -- if that; and so on...

...I, for one, don't think the USA can afford to wait another five and a half years to see what his full 8-year would look like.

I mean, the man is obviously an economic idiot. If you see someone running around with gasoline randomly setting fires, to you wait patiently until he finishes whatever he is doing, so as to not "unfairly" condemn him?
 
"Yep, throw away the first two years of Bush. They don't count."

Didn't say they don't count. I specifically said they did. In his first two years unemployment averaged about 6.5%. What's Obama's unemployment average in his first two years? 8.5%? 9%? 9.5%?

I wasn't considering them when I was writing that becaue I was specifically referring to Bush's major economic bill -- the 2003 tax cuts -- and what happened after them. Well, whether due to the the bill, or partially due to it, or without any connection to it, unemployment went down to about 5%. And Americans had more money in their pockets.

Now, as for Obama's major economic bill -- the so-called "stimulus" -- has been an unmitigated failure. Unemployment went up to almost 10%. For every American out of work two years after Bush's major economic bill, there are two Americans out of work two years after Obama's major economic bill. And it cost the taxpayer $850 billion.

Which of these two bills showed more economic sense and succeeded more? Obama's or Bush's?
 
Last edited:
What do we learn here? In the bizarro universe "Skeptic" inhabits, the financial crisis and its consequences ruin Bush´s track record, but have nothing to do with Obama´s track record. Any and all effects of the world-wide financial crisis ended on January 20th, 2009.
 
...I, for one, don't think the USA can afford to wait another five and a half years to see what his full 8-year would look like.
Agreed. And considering the hell the tax cuts have wrought I don't see how we can wait another day without raising them.
 
Didn't say they don't count. I specifically said they did. In his first two years unemployment averaged about 6.5%. What's Obama's unemployment average in his first two years? 8.5%? 9%? 9.5%?
See, you didn't answer my question. What was the unemployment rate that Obama inherited from Bush?

I wasn't considering them when I was writing that becaue I was specifically referring to Bush's major economic bill -- the 2003 tax cuts -- and what happened after them. Well, whether due to the the bill, or partially due to it, or without any connection to it, unemployment went down to about 5%. And Americans had more money in their pockets.
And over the 8 years Jobs were stagnant, housing crashed, GDP was little better than flat and the DJIA languished.

Sucks. Big time.

It's time we raise those rates. We just can't afford them anymore. It's such an awful result. It's done us very poorly. Get rid of them.
 
The problem is Obama's economic record is so bad, he is worse than Bush even when his policies are taken in isolation.

1). If his economic policies were A-OK, the absolute best there could be, and he had failed to deal with the financial crisis and improve the situation by 2011 -- the yardstick that he himself asked people to judge him back in 2008 -- he would still have been a failure compared to Bush, or at least no better than him (both having failed to deal with the crisis), even though, in this case, more due to a force major than to his own fault. But presidents don't get passing grades for effort.

2). If he had succeeded in reducing unemployment to Bush-era levels (say, 6%) but at the price of borrowing two trillion a year and the plan of continuing to do so, he would still have been an economic failure, as it is pointless to reduce unemployment if the price is getting the USA near bankrupcy. Here, too, while Bush was indeed bad, Obama is far worse, borrowing at 3.5 times Bush's rate, which was scary enough.

3). If he had reduced unemployment, weathered the economic crisis, AND not borrowed and spent like a maniac, but still passed a "stimulus" bill that (for some reason) was recognized as a total failure and cost nearly a trillion dollars, that, alone, would have made him an economic failure since it would have marked his major economic bill as the most espensively useless economic bill in the history of the USA -- however good he would had done in any other economic field. Bush's main economic bill -- the 2003 tax cuts -- at worst didn't hurt the economy, at most helped it, and cost nothing -- in fact gave Americans back some more of their money. Here, too, Bush wins, hand down.

Obama managed to do (1), (2), and (3). At once. All in 2.5 years. A triple catastrophic economic failure in half (or a quarter) of the time most presidents have to screw up.

Quite impressive, in a way.
 
  1. Bush managed to take us from relatively low unemployment to sky unemployment.
  2. Bush managed to wipe out the housing market.
  3. Bush managed to keep the stock market stagnant.
  4. Bush managed to keep GDP at a pathetic low rate.
Fault Obama but don't BS what Bush has done.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom