USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

No, we have not started doing that. Saying it does not make it true. And we may not do it, or we may try and not succeed. Talk is cheap.
Does lowering tax rates work or not? Yes or no?
 
When will Republicans accept accountability for the USA losing its prized AAA credit-rating?
 
No, obviously Obama didn't say that they had a deal. He said that he wanted more revenue increases than the Republicans initially offered, and Boehner walked out.

As I noted, the very leftist MSNBC Lawrence O'Donnell stated that "Obama has backed away from the original agreement with Cantor and Boehner for an $800 BILLION increase in tax revenue."

And there are more leftist sources that indicate there was indeed a deal which Obama broke at the last minute. Here's what the LA Times reported:

http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-obama-boehner-20110723,0,3014755.story

By Peter Nicholas and Lisa Mascaro, Washington Bureau

July 22, 2011

… snip …

The Republicans made an offer: between $3 trillion and $3.5 trillion in spending reductions, and nearly $800 billion in revenue increases over 10 years through overhauling the tax code. Geithner and Daley took it back to the White House.

On Sunday, Boehner and Cantor were invited to the White House for a private, unannounced meeting with Geithner, Daley and Jacob Lew, the director of the White House Office of Management and Budget. Obama, who was at church that morning, popped in a couple of times.

The White House was agreeable to parts of the deal — notably, the proposal for nearly $800 billion in added tax revenue.

So sure, technically you are right. Until they publically stated agreement, there was no agreement. But behind the scenes it appears that there was an agreement, that Obama then backed out of … which was the last straw in Boehner's and Cantor's attempts to negotiate with this difficult, arrogan, wishy washy, socialist President.

Quote:
And why you think Obama was serious about deficit and debt reform in the first place, given his past behavior, is hard to see.

I think Obama definitely wants to reduce the deficit and debt

Non sequitur. I asked you why? What past evidence can you offer that Obama is serious about deficit and debt reform. He could say anything right now and renege on that too, if history is any guide.

but understands that cutting spending right now would kill jobs and isn't good for the economy.

Then Obama is Stuck On Stupid. Because neither he or you have presented ANY evidence that cutting government spending would be bad for the economy. Or even that it will kill job growth. If history is any guide, just the opposite is true. The last stimulus proved that for every dollar government takes and spends, GDP grows less than it would have had the private sector allocated that dollar. You have just shown yourself to be an ideologue who is unable to learn from history. Just like Obama. So I hold no hope that, until Obama is gone and republicans have enough control of congress to get an agenda through over any objections of democrats and RINOs, anything will improve. Government spending is the problem and until democrats can admit that, there will be no recovery and things will only get worse, unless they are driven from power. You are good example of why I think that is now necessary, Bri.
 
Does lowering tax rates work or not? Yes or no?
Now you are practicing sloganeering. WTF you talking about dude?

Cap gains, income, FICA, estate, excise, fuel, Medicare, unemployment, custom duties, AMT, user fees, licensing fees, booze taxes, tobacco taxes, import tariffs?

Those just scratch the surface of the takings going on, and each has different effects on various segments of consumer and industry.

Let's take just one. What do you think the economic effect of raising or lowering the capital gains tax is? Assume for discussion that it is raised 1% or lowered 1%.

Here is a CBO reference on the subject from 1988.

http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/84xx/doc8449/88-CBO-007.pdf

I suggest that if you can't with reasonable certainty predict the economic consequences of a tax item, then you can't for revenue purposes propose a modification of that tax item.

For political reasons you certainly can.

Sloganeering.

Whip that mob up!

Let's do it!

"Make'em pay their fair share"

:rolleyes:
 
Now you are practicing sloganeering. WTF you talking about dude?
No, I'm asking a question. A simple question. Republicans have been saying for sometime that lower tax rates will spur the economy.

So, let's try that again, will lower tax rates improve the economy or not?

I suggest that if you can't with reasonable certainty predict the economic consequences of a tax item, then you can't for revenue purposes propose a modification of that tax item.
Then why where the rates lowered?
 
Last edited:
No, I'm asking a question. A simple question. Republicans have been saying for sometime that lower tax rates will spur the economy.

So, let's try that again, will lower tax rates improve the economy or not?

Then why where the rates lowered?
I don't have any interest in your sloganneering, which is why I reduced the problem to one specific issue and challenged you to voice an opinion about it.

"Faulty generalizations" is not one logical error, but an entire category of them.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fallacies

You've got the reference above on the cap gains issue, go with it and show you can do some actual independent thinking with reasoned conclusions. If you like.
 
I don't have any interest in your sloganneering...
It's not slogannering, on the contrary, it's combating sloganneering. The BS about lowering taxes is hurting our economy. This "no new taxes" crap is to refuse to negotiate and work to solve a problem.

That's a fact.

But that's fine. The inability to justify your position is just what I expect. You have no basis to tell us what the tax rates should be. So you demand they not be raised and you can't tell us why and to cover that up you look in the mirror and find something inside of yourself to accuse me with.
 
As I noted, the very leftist MSNBC Lawrence O'Donnell stated that "Obama has backed away from the original agreement with Cantor and Boehner for an $800 BILLION increase in tax revenue."

And there are more leftist sources that indicate there was indeed a deal which Obama broke at the last minute. Here's what the LA Times reported:

http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-obama-boehner-20110723,0,3014755.story



So sure, technically you are right. Until they publically stated agreement, there was no agreement. But behind the scenes it appears that there was an agreement, that Obama then backed out of … which was the last straw in Boehner's and Cantor's attempts to negotiate with this difficult, arrogan, wishy washy, socialist President.

You might have missed this point, since it was close to the end of the article:

Further, Obama sensed that Boehner was losing GOP support — "bleeding members left and right," said the senior aide.

To compensate, Obama hoped to reel in more votes from Democrats. Securing another $400 billion or so in additional revenue would help solidify Democratic support.

That number was negotiable, as the White House saw it. If Boehner wouldn't agree to that sum, maybe he would settle for less, and they'd make up the difference some other way.

Boehner apparently couldn't supply enough Republican votes to pass his own proposal.


Then Obama is Stuck On Stupid. Because neither he or you have presented ANY evidence that cutting government spending would be bad for the economy. Or even that it will kill job growth. If history is any guide, just the opposite is true. The last stimulus proved that for every dollar government takes and spends, GDP grows less than it would have had the private sector allocated that dollar. You have just shown yourself to be an ideologue who is unable to learn from history. Just like Obama. So I hold no hope that, until Obama is gone and republicans have enough control of congress to get an agenda through over any objections of democrats and RINOs, anything will improve. Government spending is the problem and until democrats can admit that, there will be no recovery and things will only get worse, unless they are driven from power. You are good example of why I think that is now necessary, Bri.

That budget cuts will cause short-term economic problems isn't subject to debate. When the govt. cuts its budget, it cuts back on the number of people it employs. That means more unemployed workers. DUH!!! Cutting the budget will also increase income inequality, which is already a serious problem ("It is hard to shrink the size of government right now without exacerbating inequality" - Harvard economist Ken Rogoff).

By the way, have you figured out why if cutting tax rates INCREASES tax revenues the Democrats aren't pushing for tax rate cuts? And if cutting tax rates INCREASES tax revenues why the Bush tax cuts have led to the lowest tax revenue rates in 60 years?
 
...

No, we have not started doing that [dig ourselves out of this mess]. Saying it does not make it true. And we may not do it, or we may try and not succeed. Talk is cheap.

I agree with this to some extent. The first step is for the government to move to sustainable governance. That is the government needs to move significantly towards lowering and eliminating deficits.

The Obama administration and at least some economists thought that by continuing and even increasing the deficit spending of the Bush administration that the effects of the recession and the various economic crises that faced the incoming Obama administration could be mitigated. And perhaps given the size of the economic problems some continuation of the deficit spending was justified.

However, massive deficit spending is clearly unsustainable and at least some of the Obama deficit spending served to just delay and probably exacerbate the day of reckoning. The so-called stimulus package that distributed one time financial boosts for various purposes doesn't seem to have produced enough long term benefit to justify the costs.

Cutting government spending and benefits is going to have the very real effect of seeming to make things worse for awhile. Lots of government workers, defense workers, and people that profit indirectly from government programs will be harmed. For awhile, a lot of people will be in denial and they will use unemployment insurance to hold off facing the reality that they will probably need to work for less money than they were making when they worked for industries effected by government cut backs.

In the long term the economy will adjust to the new reality of less government spending and it will be better than it was before. But this is going to be a long process.

I disagreed a bit with the comprehensiveness of your comment in that I think there are signs that we are beginning to dig ourselves out of this mess. The housing bubble caused bubbles in many industries and the collapse has harmed those industries significantly, but people are moving on. People are finding jobs in other industries, new opportunities are being created, the industries that survived the crash are struggling to find new ways to sustain themselves. Some neighborhoods are beginning to recover from the foreclosure induced disasters.

Of course, we can't begin to say that we are really digging ourselves out of this mess until we stop digging ourselves deeper into the mess so I mostly agreed with the sentiment of your comment.
 
Last edited:
And we are following precisely in Canada's footprints. We are facing serious budget deficit and national debt issues. Our credit rating has been downgraded. Now we are going to start digging our way out of the mess.

Just to prove that anything Canada can do, the U.S. can copy on a much larger scale.:D


Copying the problems is easy. Copying the solutions, that's the challenge. :D
 
I agree with this to some extent. The first step is for the government to move to sustainable governance.
I disagree. The #1 problem we have is a jobs crises, not a deficit crisis. Consumers (70% of the US economy) are not spending and business is sitting on a pile of cash waiting for demand to increase. Only Uncle Sam can provide that in the short run.

In the long run (5-10 years?)? Then I agree with you. Go after the debt.

Cutting government spending and benefits is going to have the very real effect of seeming to make things worse for awhile.
Odd wording. I can't figure out if I agree with you (the downward effect will be real) or disagree (it will only seem to hurt).
 
It's not slogannering, on the contrary, it's combating sloganneering. The BS about lowering taxes is hurting our economy. This "no new taxes" crap is to refuse to negotiate and work to solve a problem.

That's a fact.

But that's fine. The inability to justify your position is just what I expect. You have no basis to tell us what the tax rates should be. So you demand they not be raised and you can't tell us why and to cover that up you look in the mirror and find something inside of yourself to accuse me with.
IF you engage in the logical error of false generalizations don't use as a defense that you are combating other people who are doing the same. You are simply engaging in a logical error. I've pointed that out. If you persist in seeking an answer to a question with a logical error that has already been pointed out, that's sort of weird or crazy. Certainly it's denial of the fact of the very question being erroneous.

So the problem's not mine. I reframed the question to create a fully answerable, precise question about specific taxes. And provided authoritative references.

Which you seem to be ignoring.

Whatever.

However the meme "don't raise taxes in a recession" goes way back in standard economics theory perspectives. So to answer your politically-laced abomination of thought, it certainly didn't start with the US Republicans. You can go back to John Keynes or ever further back for that theory.
 
Last edited:
As I noted, the very leftist MSNBC Lawrence O'Donnell stated that "Obama has backed away from the original agreement with Cantor and Boehner for an $800 BILLION increase in tax revenue."

Since when did you start taking Lawrence O'Donnell's opinion as fact?

Incidentally, I Googled that quote and couldn't find any reference to it other than a far-right web site that didn't cite its source. I couldn't even find it in the transcripts of O'Donnell's show on the MSNBC web site. Can you please post a reference so that we can see the context?

And there are more leftist sources that indicate there was indeed a deal which Obama broke at the last minute. Here's what the LA Times reported:

http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-obama-boehner-20110723,0,3014755.story

Except the quote that you posted doesn't support your claim. Even the part you bolded and colored in red:

The White House was agreeable to parts of the deal — notably, the proposal for nearly $800 billion in added tax revenue.​

The word "agreeable" doesn't mean "agreed." The fact that the White House "was agreeable to parts of the deal" was never in question.

So sure, technically you are right. Until they publically stated agreement, there was no agreement.

That's correct. There was no agreement.

But behind the scenes it appears that there was an agreement, that Obama then backed out of … which was the last straw in Boehner's and Cantor's attempts to negotiate with this difficult, arrogan, wishy washy, socialist President.

Even Boehner didn't characterize it that way, so I assume you just made that up.

Non sequitur. I asked you why?

Actually, you didn't ask me anything. You made a statement:

And why you think Obama was serious about deficit and debt reform in the first place, given his past behavior, is hard to see.​

And I gave two reasons why I think that Obama wants to reduce the deficit (although probably would prefer to wait until the economy has recovered). First, he's stated publicly on multiple occasions that he wants to reduce the deficit through a balanced approach of spending cuts and revenue increases. Second, I don't give him as much credit as you do for coming up with some ingenious plan to trick the Republicans into not balancing the budget. But if he did, it worked beautifully and the Republicans fell right into his hands.

Because neither he or you have presented ANY evidence that cutting government spending would be bad for the economy. Or even that it will kill job growth.

Only countless experts whose opinions I value far more than yours.

-Bri
 
However the meme "don't raise taxes in a recession" goes way back in standard economics theory perspectives.
Thank you for your answer. Of course, Reagan tried it and it didn't work so he then raised taxes, in a recession, the economy improved.

So to answer your politically-laced abomination of thought, it certainly didn't start with the US Republicans. You can go back to John Keynes or ever further back for that theory.
I like Keynes. He's hated by most Conservatives. He's not god and he's not a prophet. Lowering taxes hasn't worked. But you did answer my question so I'll leave you be. Thank you. BTW: Sorry to answer a question with a question but it does answer yours. We need to raise taxes and cut spending. It's the only way to get off of stupid.
 
I agree with this to some extent. The first step is for the government to move to sustainable governance. That is the government needs to move significantly towards lowering and eliminating deficits.

The Obama administration and at least some economists thought that by continuing and even increasing the deficit spending of the Bush administration that the effects of the recession and the various economic crises that faced the incoming Obama administration could be mitigated. And perhaps given the size of the economic problems some continuation of the deficit spending was justified.

However, massive deficit spending is clearly unsustainable and at least some of the Obama deficit spending served to just delay and probably exacerbate the day of reckoning. The so-called stimulus package that distributed one time financial boosts for various purposes doesn't seem to have produced enough long term benefit to justify the costs.

Cutting government spending and benefits is going to have the very real effect of seeming to make things worse for awhile. Lots of government workers, defense workers, and people that profit indirectly from government programs will be harmed. For awhile, a lot of people will be in denial and they will use unemployment insurance to hold off facing the reality that they will probably need to work for less money than they were making when they worked for industries effected by government cut backs.

In the long term the economy will adjust to the new reality of less government spending and it will be better than it was before. But this is going to be a long process.

I disagreed a bit with the comprehensiveness of your comment in that I think there are signs that we are beginning to dig ourselves out of this mess. The housing bubble caused bubbles in many industries and the collapse has harmed those industries significantly, but people are moving on. People are finding jobs in other industries, new opportunities are being created, the industries that survived the crash are struggling to find new ways to sustain themselves. Some neighborhoods are beginning to recover from the foreclosure induced disasters.

Of course, we can't begin to say that we are really digging ourselves out of this mess until we stop digging ourselves deeper into the mess so I mostly agreed with the sentiment of your comment.
Good post. So long as we stop doing what doesn't work. Cut spending. Raise taxes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom