USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

Many loan schemes were found to be outright fraud on the part of the loan company, and people wound up with documents they never agreed to or signed modifying the loans they DID agree to.

I have a friend who applied for the money given to the banks by the feds to save his house. He kept calling BofA and they kept telling him not to worry that everything was fine. He asked if he could send payments and they said no. Finally after 6 months they told him they lost his app and that he would have to reapply. He went to BofA and reapplied. 6 months later they closed on his home. I understand BofA can apply to the fund to make up the back payments and substantial fees and sell his home at auction. Nice.

Whose bright idea was it to give the money to the banks? Did they really believe the banks wouldn't figure out a way to double dip?
 
Yeah and if that lender doesn't ask for proof of income or employment and promises 100% financing you're being taken just like in a Nigerian 419 scam. No one to blame but yourself.
Very interesting analogy. Tell me, are 419 scams illegal? Thank you. Now, in your analogy, who is legally culpable for a scam loan?
 
Very interesting analogy. Tell me, are 419 scams illegal? Thank you. Now, in your analogy, who is legally culpable for a scam loan?

Interesting note, they're call '419' scams because 419 is the section of the Nigerian criminal code they violate. Nigerian has never prosecuted a case for it if I remember correctly though.
 
8 years of Bush, lower taxes and deregulation lead to bank melt down, housing crash, pathetic GDP stock market growth, staggering deficit. Will people really just ignore that?
Fannie and Freddy and Dem social engineering policy against economic reality and all the Bush you want... Bush sucks. Add to the list. Obama sucks.

No Bush is running this time either again (although you'd never know that listening to Dems still trying to milk the Bush hate) and I hope it stays that way.

you are blaming the sub-prime mortgage debacle on the democrats?
wow.
you should get a job with the tea party, revising history texts.

You are Orwellian.

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=aSKSoiNbnQY0
http://biglizards.net/blog/archives/2008/09/subprime_mccain.html
http://spectator.org/archives/2009/02/06/the-true-origins-of-this-finan
http://hotair.com/archives/2008/09/16/whose-policies-led-to-the-credit-crisis/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franklin_Raines

but whatever you do,
never hold Democrats accountable for anything,
and blame Republicans for everything.
 
Last edited:
No Bush is running this time either again (although you'd never know that listening to Dems still trying to milk the Bush hate) and I hope it stays that way.
I will gladly stand on my record of attacking Democrats. I've been very critical of Obama (see my Obama moves to the right thread).
 
Anyone else every notice that there is an inverse correlation between the strength of a poster's argument and the length of their post? Maybe lengthy posts are a case of the poster trying to convince themself.

LOL! Yeah, blame it all on Bush.

Never mind the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), started by a democrat (Jimmy Carter), which eventually allowed ACORN and *community-minded* democrats like Obama to delay and halt the efforts of banks to merge or expand until they had agreed to lower their credit standards … to provide mortgages to people who couldn't really afford them.

Never mind the role of the Clinton Administration in expanding the CRA's powers in 1995 … giving ACORN and those *community organizers* even more leverage to force banks to ignore long established and sound financial traditions and make unsound loans … especially unsound if there were any downturn in the economy.

You only need to scroll up this page a bit to find a post where someone explained why CRA had little to do with the housing bubble collapse. The overwhelming majority of subprime mortgages were created by companies that were not covered by CRA. Of course, there is also no evidence that the number of defaults on subprime mortgages was suffiicient to cause a recession. But a better explanation can be found here:
http://dallasfed.org/ca/bcp/2009/bcp0901.cfm

In addition, there was a commercial real estate bubble at the same time. Commercial mortgages were not at all involved with CRA.

To fight several wars that we didn't start.
"Several" implies more than one. Besides Afghanistan, what war did we end up in that we didn't start?

No matter what he did, we were unlikely to see revenues as a percent of GDP go above 18 or 19 percent, which they did anyway. That's what 65 years of history tells us. All that increasing taxes at that point would have done is LOWER GDP, so even if he'd managed with higher taxes to get revenue as a percent of GDP to climb to the historic average (unlikely), the net take would have been LOWER. A bigger deficit than what we had. This isn't rocket science or anything but 3rd grade math and basic logic. I don't see why this is so difficult for leftists to understand?
Because it lacks any theoretical basis. Because it involves circular reasoning. If Reagan and Bush hadn't cut taxes, would the 65 year average have been higher? Tax rates have been changed to steer revenues towards certain levels. Is 18.4% a "natural" level or have various presidents worked to steer the average towards that level?

LOL! I thinks it's clear who has LESS than a cursory understanding of economics here. If what you claim is true, why didn't Obama's Stimulus work? It was predicated on the belief that a dollar in stimulus spending would create more than a dollar in GDP. It hasn't happened. Didn't even come close. Don't you socialists EVER learn from history … even the history you make?
OK. I concede that you are correct and the overwhelming majority of economists are wrong. However, I would like to see your evidence that a dollar in tax cuts creates more than a dollar in GDP.

I told you socialists earlier (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7453800&postcount=366 ) why 2-3.5% growth during the 2000's was actually quite good. And you basically ignored that response. So let me repeat what I said.

The 80's and 90's were periods when the US was still pre-eminent in many high-growth technologies (medical devices, electronics and then software). You heard of the internet boom, right? That might have something to do with why the average Real GDP growth during those periods was somewhat higher than in the 2000's, when the rest of the world had caught up in those technological areas. And as I noted, the problem is that we didn't move on to the next technology and dominate it … perhaps because democrat controlled schools have been pumping out community organizers, *actresses*, defense lawyers, and political science majors, rather than more conservative scientists and engineers … the folks who actually fueled the GDP growth of the 80's and 90's. Furthermore, the 90's had less events to impede GDP growth. No 9/11. And in the second half of the 90s when growth rates were a percent or two higher than under Bush, not even a recession.

Furthermore, let me add that there is a natural reduction (with occasional exceptions) in GDP growth as economies grow and mature. It's not unusual for small economies to sustain double digit GDP growth for many years. But as an economy grows, growth rates start to drop. The US has the largest economy in the world. So why would you expect GDP to climb much above 3% unless we come up with some new technology the rest of the world needs? Perhaps your expection shows you don't have a "cursory understanding of economics"? So let me help you. Here is a chart (from http://www.house.gov/jec/growth/govtsize/govtsize.htm ) that you might find interesting … if you bother to study it carefully:

http://www.house.gov/jec/growth/govtsize/fig-2.gif

It shows how 10 year GDP growth has fallen in the US since 1799. You can see that when we were a young, immature nation, we saw 10 year growth rates of 70% (an average of 7% a year). And as our country has aged and our economy grown that percentage has quite steadily dropped. By 1900 the average rate was down to about 5% a year. By the 1980s and 1990s, it was down to about 3% a year. So did you really expect Bush to beat that by much? Seriously? LEARN FROM HISTORY.
The true growth rate during the pre-recession period of the Bush Administration was only a little over 1 percent. The majority of the GDP growth was generated by the housing bubble.


Sigh. As to your first point, don't you understand that the backbone of our economy are the small businesses which employ the vast majority of workers. And their taxes are primarily paid for as individuals and as payroll taxes. Revenue from corporations is only a small part of total revenues. They account for only 9% of total federal revenues (http://www.heritage.org/budgetchartbook/federal-revenue-sources and http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2009/10/20/business/economy/revenues.jpg ). And many of those corporations are tiny (with just a few or no employees) … effectively small businesses who will be hurt if government increases taxes.
Yawn. Most small business owners aren't in the top few percent of wage earners.

It's simple math and clear logic. Think about it.
Yeah, reducing the tax rate raises more tax revenue. Let's reduce the rate to zero and the govt. will have more money than it knows what to do with. Is this your idea of "clear logic"?

The S&L debacle … which Reagan dealt with without a massive bailout and stimulus.

150 billion dollars was a pretty large amount at the time.

For example, the Bush tax cuts didn't actually cost us anything. Federal Tax revenues climbed back to historical levels as a percentage of GDP and remained there until democrats took over Congress. And GDP increased markedly for quarter after quarter after quarter after those tax cuts.
You keep making this claim without having offered a single bit of evidence to support it. No, repeating it over and over does not make it true. If increasing the tax rate decreases revenue, why aren't the people who want to downsize the govt. in favor of raising the tax rate? If decreasing the tax rate increases revenue, why aren't the people who want to expand govt. programs pushing for lower tax rates? Is almost everyone acting against their own interests?

In constrast, Obama's stimulus accomplished next to nothing. GDP growth has remained less than lackluster … far less than even Bush achieved . And the stimulus will cost us trillions of dollars to finance. And revenues as a percent of GDP have NOT returned to the historic average.
Other than saving millions of jobs and perhaps preventing the recession from getting even worse. Bush inherited a budget surplus, a growing economy, and an unemployment rate of 4.2% and falling, and had to deal with a small downturn. Obama inherited a budget with a trillion dollar deficit (the Bush Administration projected a trillion dollar deficit in their budget for FY2009), a financial system on the verge of collapse, and an unemployment rate of 7.8% and rising rapidly. To claim that Bush accomplished more is simply hilarious.

That's why you never mentioned that he started the recession with a massive tax cut. That's why you only mentioned his later tax increase and made it sound like it occurred early in the recession.
Nope, I never claimed that Reagan's tax cut caused the recession. I merely mentioned that Reagan raised taxes several times, once when the recession was ending, without either slowing the economy or decreasing tax revenue. Just to show that tax rate increases don't necessarily slow growth or decrease revenue. Just one of many of examples of how you've twisted my comments to mean something that they obviously didn't mean. Or maybe it's that you aren't intelligent enough to understand.
 
Last edited:

The last article concludes that Fannie and Freddie had little to do with the housing bubble collapse or the Great Recession (
Multiple analyses have debunked the theory that the GSEs either caused or greatly contributed to the financial crisis of 2008.
), despite all of BeAChooser's bloviation. What point were you trying to make?
 
Last edited:
never hold Democrats accountable for anything,
and blame Republicans for everything.
Fair enough. Though it was formulated by Republicans (or rather the banking lobbyists that financed Phil Gramm's campaigns), both parties were complicit in repealing Glass-Steagall and it was signed into law by Bill Clinton. That action more than any other contributed to the invention of mortgage-backed securities and other strange derivatives, and the balloon of subprime mortgages. It was a foul action, one for which our children will be paying the price, and for which the bankers' grandchildren for many generations will never have to dirty their fingernails.

We were headed toward ruin when Bush got into office. But with his tax cut evangelism and unpaid-for religious wars it is the Bush administration that pushed us over the cliff.
 
Johnson. Carter. Obama.

Progressive idealism meets reality.

Reality wins, while causing enormous damage to the USA's foreign and domestic and economic interests.

They explain it's all the evil conservatives' fault.

Nobody believes them.

So, what is Obama? A poor man's Carter, a midget Hoover?

Or is that unfair to Carter and Hoover, and he should be consider instead a latter-day Buchanan -- doing nothing effective as the country falls to pieces around him?

That might be going too far, I know, but still, one sometimes feels that way.
 
To Americans, in regards to the last three to four years of the housing market and financial system travails the U.S. has suffered, I would respectfully suggest you take a close look at the differences between the American and Canadian financial systems and how each one has performed. Canada avoided both the housing subprime mortgage disaster and the financial/banking system bailout/failure fiascoes.

In addition, in the early 1990s Canada was facing a serious budget deficit and national debt issues. The nation's credit rating was downgraded in 1993 as a consequence. But we dug ourselves out of that mess and put our fiscal house in order.

There are perhaps lessons to be learned from the experience of your neighbours to the north. :)
 
Of course, the "raise the taxes on the rich" is a red herring. First of all Bush's tax cuts actually increased revenues (or at least contributed to that) -- because low taxes does NOT necessarily mean lower revenues, of course.

Second, Obama's spending had been so mind-spinningly huge and ineffective that, even if raising taxes would have no depressive economic effect on an already-lousy economy, the additional revenues would be negligible compared to the size of the debt he accumulated.
 
Of course, the "raise the taxes on the rich" is a red herring. First of all Bush's tax cuts actually increased revenues (or at least contributed to that) -- because low taxes does NOT necessarily mean lower revenues, of course.

It looks like some of the major fact-checking sites disagree with you:

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-m...pence-says-raising-taxes-lowers-tax-revenues/
http://www.factcheck.org/taxes/supply-side_spin.html

You can read the articles and the sources cited and decide for yourself. Tax breaks can sometimes stimulate the economy, but not generally enough to overcome the decrease in revenue. Specifically, the Bush tax cuts contributed largely to the deficit we're currently facing.

Second, Obama's spending had been so mind-spinningly huge and ineffective that, even if raising taxes would have no depressive economic effect on an already-lousy economy, the additional revenues would be negligible compared to the size of the debt he accumulated.

Most experts (including conservative ones) agree that it's necessary to cut spending and raise taxes in order to reduce the deficit. However, Democrats who believe that we can get by with only raising taxes on the rich are probably wrong -- taxes will likely have to be raised across the board (at the very least allowing the Bush tax cuts to expire).

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Of course, the "raise the taxes on the rich" is a red herring. First of all Bush's tax cuts actually increased revenues (or at least contributed to that) -- because low taxes does NOT necessarily mean lower revenues, of course.

Second, Obama's spending had been so mind-spinningly huge and ineffective that, even if raising taxes would have no depressive economic effect on an already-lousy economy, the additional revenues would be negligible compared to the size of the debt he accumulated.
Please to explain how and/or demonstrate that the Bush tax cuts increased revenue? By how much and for what periods? Please to adjust for inflation?

Low taxes does not necessarily mean lower revenues. Nor does it necessarily mean higher revenue or an improved economy. The economy under Bush was one of the worst economies in a long time.

FACTS:

Please don't just come here and make statements without supporting them.
 
Second, Obama's spending had been so mind-spinningly huge and ineffective that, even if raising taxes would have no depressive economic effect on an already-lousy economy, the additional revenues would be negligible compared to the size of the debt he accumulated.

How are you defining "Obama's spending"? Does this include all govt. spending since Obama took office (more than 90 percent of which was the continuation of existing programs)? Or just the stimulus spending? If it is the latter, do you have any idea of how much spending ARRA entailed?
 
To Americans, in regards to the last three to four years of the housing market and financial system travails the U.S. has suffered, I would respectfully suggest you take a close look at the differences between the American and Canadian financial systems and how each one has performed. Canada avoided both the housing subprime mortgage disaster and the financial/banking system bailout/failure fiascoes.

In addition, in the early 1990s Canada was facing a serious budget deficit and national debt issues. The nation's credit rating was downgraded in 1993 as a consequence. But we dug ourselves out of that mess and put our fiscal house in order.

There are perhaps lessons to be learned from the experience of your neighbours to the north. :)

And we are following precisely in Canada's footprints. We are facing serious budget deficit and national debt issues. Our credit rating has been downgraded. Now we are going to start digging our way out of the mess.

Just to prove that anything Canada can do, the U.S. can copy on a much larger scale.:D
 
The true growth rate during the pre-recession period of the Bush Administration was only a little over 1 percent. The majority of the GDP growth was generated by the housing bubble.

Yeah the housing bubble and the deficit. Fun fact, the "true growth rate" currently is staggeringly negative.
 
Yeah the housing bubble and the deficit. Fun fact, the "true growth rate" currently is staggeringly negative.
perceptive.

From a business point of view, what we are seeing is contingent liabilities or unrealized liabilities being written off. But there are still fourteen boatloads of them waiting to be handled before we're clear and free. Usually these bad things are grouped and written off in "a bad year", then the company can have "several good years".

I had to laugh at the prior poster's saying "now we are digging ourselves out of the mess".

No, we have not started doing that. Saying it does not make it true. And we may not do it, or we may try and not succeed. Talk is cheap.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom