USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

So what happens after the mathematical end of progressive socialism, that being based on endless supplies of printed money?
Same thing that happens when Jesus comes to usher in Armageddon.
 
with his tax cut evangelism and unpaid-for religious wars it is the Bush administration that pushed us over the cliff.

Utter and complete garbage. As I've proven previously on recent thread, debt as a percentage of GDP (http://libertyworks.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/Debt-percentage-GDP.gif ) was about 60% when Bush entered office. And despite two recessions, 9/11 and three wars (Iraq, Afghanistan and a world wide WOT) to cause it to rise, it was clearly leveling off at 69% near the end of his term, thanks to the effects of his tax cuts and his admittedly sometimes spotty control of spending. But it was stable at the 69% figure.

Only when everyone began jumping up and down saying the sky was falling, and Bush did the stupid thing and went along with democrats in trying to control things with massive government intervention to "save the banks", did it go up ... when we also entered a recession which drove GDP down. Then the ratio of debt to GDP jumped to about 78% (by the end of his term).

But even then, things were still salvageable had we acted responsibly ... in the style of the first 7 years of Bush's term. But under Obama, all responsibility died. He and democrats spent and spent and spent. And threats of taxes kept the economy from recovering. So the ratio climbed to 84%, then 94%, and is now over 100% of GDP. You can't blame most of that increase on Bush. That's just intellectually dishonest.
 
Tax breaks can sometimes stimulate the economy, but not generally enough to overcome the decrease in revenue. Specifically, the Bush tax cuts contributed largely to the deficit we're currently facing.

LIAR. As I proved in a post above, during the time of Bush's tax cuts, Real GDP grew by $2 trillion from 2001 to 2007. And government revenues as a percent of GDP went UP during that timeframe. And various sources, including the Washington Post, put the cost of those cuts in the same timeframe on the order of only $1.3-$1.6 trillion, most of which the NYTimes just admitted went to people that are NOT in Bush's "rich" group of taxpayers. So clearly Bush increased GDP more than the tax cuts which made that possible cost and government revenues went up. I'm really tired of you leftists lying on this thread. Over and over. You are debating with the tactics of 9/11 truthers.
 
Please to explain how and/or demonstrate that the Bush tax cuts increased revenue? By how much and for what periods? Please to adjust for inflation?

You are either a fool or liar, RF. And you don't even know it because you've stopped even listening. For anyone who has missed this sorry saga, I've already provided RF with source after source proving that Real GDP (which is adjusted for inflation ... a fact that he STILL doesn't comprehend) went up year after year under Bush after his tax cuts. I also provided charts which prove that revenues as a percent of GDP went up under Bush as well. So simple math tells ANYONE with half a brain that revenues went up after Bush cut taxes. And stayed up until democrats regained control of the both Houses of Congress in late 2006. All I can do is keep pointing out that RF is wrong and that anyone who believes what he says is either gullible or a fool too. :D
 

Sure, anyone you disagree with is automatically a liar.

http://www.factcheck.org/taxes/supply-side_spin.html

In fact, the last half-dozen years have shown us that we can't have both lower taxes and fatter government coffers. The Congressional Budget Office, the Treasury Department, the Joint Committee on Taxation, the White House’s Council of Economic Advisers and a former Bush administration economist all say that tax cuts lead to revenues that are lower than they otherwise would have been – even if they spur some economic growth. And federal revenues actually declined at the beginning of this decade before rebounding.

...

“Federal revenue is lower today than it would have been without the tax cuts,” Alan D. Viard of the conservative American Enterprise Institute told the Washington Post last October. Viard, who worked in the Treasury Department’s Office of Tax Analysis and the White House’s Council of Economic Advisers under President Bush, told FactCheck.org that “nobody can absolutely prove that.” Proof would require time travel and a reversal of tax policy. “But among economists, there’s no dispute.”

Tax cuts can be a sound economic move that spurs growth, says Viard. “But it doesn’t mean that [the cuts] gained revenue."​

-Bri
 
Last edited:
you are either a fool or liar, rf. And you don't even know it because you've stopped even listening. For anyone who has missed this sorry saga, i've already provided rf with source after source proving that real gdp (which is adjusted for inflation ... A fact that he still doesn't comprehend) went up year after year under bush after his tax cuts. I also provided charts which prove that revenues as a percent of gdp went up under bush as well. So simple math tells anyone with half a brain that revenues went up after bush cut taxes. And stayed up until democrats regained control of the both houses of congress in late 2006. All i can do is keep pointing out that rf is wrong and that anyone who believes what he says is either gullible or a fool too. :d

damn that clinton11!!!
 
Unfortunately, I'll be away from my computer for the next week or so, so I won't be able to provide my usual detailed, fact-filled posts to counteract the GARBAGE that Obamaphiles are posting.

Perhaps I will have a short comment or two, though don't expect even that.

Some of you may be see my absence as cause for joy. I completely understand.

If I were debating like a truther, I'd be happy to see the debunker of my nonsense leave too.

But don't get too excited. Because I will return and when I do ... :D
 
What the hell does Democrats taking control of congress have to do with anything? Either tax cuts spur the economy or they don't. That's a bald face lie. And the increases were pathetic no matter which numbers you use. I'm the only one that posted numbers. And those numbers have been checked by other posters. My numbers stand.
 
Don't let anyone give you BS about posting numbers when--

  • They only posted graphs.
  • They never posted numbers or provided context for those numbers.
  • They never provided answers for why the numbers should go down after democrats are elected to congress.

I don't understand how you arrived at this number.

I reprocessed the table in Open Office and corrected small errors in the table.
Note: The errors do not change the results in any significant way.

Year | Nominal GDP | Real GDP | Deflator | Population | Nominal/Capita | Real/Capita
2001 | 10286200 | 11347200 | 90.650 | 285335 | 36049.56 | 39767.99
2002 | 10642300 | 11543100 | 92.196 | 288133 | 36935.37 | 40061.71
2003 | 11142200 | 11836400 | 94.135 | 290845 | 38309.75 | 40696.59
2004 | 11853300 | 12246900 | 96.786 | 293502 | 40385.76 | 41726.80
2005 | 12623000 | 12623000 | 100.000 | 296229 | 42612.30 | 42612.30
2006 | 13377200 | 12958500 | 103.231 | 299052 | 44732.02 | 43331.93
2007 | 14028700 | 13206400 | 106.227 | 302025 | 46448.80 | 43726.18
2008 | 14369100 | 13161900 | 109.172 | 304831 | 47137.92 | 43177.70
2009 | 13939000 | 12703100 | 109.729 | 307483 | 45332.59 | 41313.18
| | | | | |
Factors | 1.355 | 1.119 | 1.210 | 1.078 | 1.258 | 1.039
If you take Nominal GDP from the years 2009 and 2001 you get a Nominal Growth of about 35.55 percent increase over the eight year time period or an annual increase of 3.87 percent. Likewise, the Real GDP calculates out to 11.95 percent increase over the eight year time period or an annual increase of 1.42 percent.

From a per capita basis I find some really interesting results.

The Nominal GDP divided by population has a growth rate of 25.75 percent over the eight year period or an annual increase of 2.91 percent in Nominal Income. The Real GDP divided by population has a growth rate of 3.89 percent over the eight year period or an annual increase of 0.48 percent in Real Income. (Wow! That's low.)

So where does this 0.75 number come from? I simply cannot recreate your calculation. Could you show me how you did it?
 
So step up Republicans. Please explain how the correlation of Dems being elected to Congress has ANYTHING to do with the GDP going into the can?

Correlation does not imply causation

So, if you can't provide an explanation and you demand that correlation implies causation then you are LYING!

One more thing, why is 2001 and 2002 NOT Bush's responsibility? Funny how that is just erased from history even when he raised taxes in 2001.

You can't honestly deduct those years from the ledger. So, look at those numbers again and please, please give us your explanation.
 
S&P manager confirms that Tea Party rhetoric prompted the downgrade:

S&P: Debt default skeptics fueled ratings downgrade

A Standard & Poor’s director said for the first time Thursday that one reason the United States lost its triple-A credit rating was that several lawmakers expressed skepticism about the serious consequences of a credit default — a position put forth by some Republicans.

Without specifically mentioning Republicans, S&P senior director Joydeep Mukherji said the stability and effectiveness of American political institutions were undermined by the fact that “people in the political arena were even talking about a potential default,” Mukherji said.

“That a country even has such voices, albeit a minority, is something notable,” he added. “This kind of rhetoric is not common amongst AAA sovereigns.”

The statement seems likely to bolster one Democratic line of attack, that it was tea party intransigence — not a shortcoming of leadership by President Barack Obama — that is to blame for the U.S. downgrade, from AAA to AA+. Obama himself called on Republicans to “put country ahead of party” Thursday — a dig at conservatives in Congress who are blocking his agenda.
 
I think it's clear that the Republican strategy is to destroy Obama. The rating, economic fall out and impact to the rest of us are is simply collateral damage.
 
What the hell does Democrats taking control of congress have to do with anything? Either tax cuts spur the economy or they don't. That's a bald face lie. And the increases were pathetic no matter which numbers you use. I'm the only one that posted numbers. And those numbers have been checked by other posters. My numbers stand.
Your house of cards cannot stand a detailed look, and it's premises are made of unsolidified and sagging bull manure.

Otherwise, you could have taken my references and challenges regarding the capital gains tax, and the CBO link, and done something with it.

But you could not.
 
Your house of cards cannot stand a detailed look, and it's premises are made of unsolidified and sagging bull manure.
Rhetoric.

Show me where my numbers are wrong.

Otherwise, you could have taken my references and challenges regarding the capital gains tax, and the CBO link, and done something with it.
I did. Go back and check.

But that's beside the point. Your link could support the premise that we need drastic cuts to spending and that WOULDN'T obviate the fact of my numbers. I didn't post the numbers to prove that we DON'T need spending cuts.

My numbers stand. PERIOD. You can't dispute them and a cute little argument about cutting spending does not disprove them.
 
Rhetoric.

Show me where my numbers are wrong.

I did. Go back and check......
Now where is that?

Keep in mind I can easily produce a similar detailed argument for other major categories of taxes. These as this first one do not negate your argument from generalization, which on a logical basis is a falsehood. But what they do show nicely is that such generalizations don't yield the certain results that the sloganeers promise.

But any accountant or finance guy knows that.
 
Now where is that?
In your link. You responded to my post. I included a chart.

Keep in mind I can easily produce a similar detailed argument for other major categories of taxes. These as this first one do not negate your argument from generalization, which on a logical basis is a falsehood. But what they do show nicely is that such generalizations don't yield the certain results that the sloganeers promise.

But any accountant or finance guy knows that.
I've no idea what any of this means.

The point of my numbers are this.

  1. The Bush Tax Cuts of 2001 and 2003 had no demonstrable, positive effect on the economy for the period of time Bush was in office.
  2. Though tax rates are still the same the economy is still in the toilet.
Do you dispute either proposition?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom